This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Elpis
I think the 4 points is probably fair given the reasons around the Johnson transfer . What I don't like about it is the appeal process . Appeal must be lodged a week before the end of the season which means if they are safe they do nothing but if they need the points back to stay up they appeal . I think so too. Everton pulled together after their deduction, pretty sure they won 4 in a row. Suspect this will make the Forrest game a fair bit harder. They will be looking to claw most of those points back at the first chance.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
I can see a time when we end up with a kind of fixed price menu for profit & sustainability indiscretions - then we will see clubs gambling on how many potential match winning points its worth in the effected period if the buy player(s) x or x & y as opposed to points deducted / the penalty imposed. This.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
I can see a time when we end up with a kind of fixed price menu for profit & sustainability indiscretions - then we will see clubs gambling on how many potential match winning points its worth in the effected period if the buy player(s) x or x & y as opposed to points deducted / the penalty imposed. We’re already there. Don’t tell me Forest & Everton didn’t know exactly what they were doing. That’s why 4 or 6 point deductions aren’t a deterrent. Automatic relegation or maybe a 20 point deduction would stop this.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Davepalace707
We’re already there. Don’t tell me Forest & Everton didn’t know exactly what they were doing. That’s why 4 or 6 point deductions aren’t a deterrent. Automatic relegation or maybe a 20 point deduction would stop this. Agreed
|
|
|
Certainly by the time we get to the end of the season with the publicity & media coverage / explanations as to who did what & how the outcome was reached for Everton (twice) & Forest everyone involved will be a lot more clued up on the mechanics of it -
Originally posted by Davepalace707
We’re already there. Don’t tell me Forest & Everton didn’t know exactly what they were doing. That’s why 4 or 6 point deductions aren’t a deterrent. Automatic relegation or maybe a 20 point deduction would stop this.
|
|
|
Originally posted by FernsideEagle
Just to clear up one thing, any appeal by Forest has to be submitted within 7 days from today ie by 25th March, not 7 days before the end of the season. Ah yes I slightly miss heard what they were saying on the radio . Though your right that the appeal must be submitted within 7 days the leagues rules do state the appeals process must be completed by the 24th May , 5 days after the last game of the season . So my point stands ,if Forest appeal teams will not know what points they need to be safe and could get relegated in the close season .
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
You know, I have been as self righteous and self serving as the rest on here in condemning those who voted for rules and then broke them. However, if only to be Devil's advocate, some balance. Forest came up with a team worth £12M (I know!) and were expected to compete on equal terms with teams worth £billions. It just isn't fair. They sought to "stretch" the rules to stand a chance; and they only just scraped it. And now, the vested interests who profit from this unfairness are punishing them for their nerve of seeking to eat at the High Table and are sending them back to the lower, impoverished obscurity where they belong. As an aside, makes you proud to be Palace. Sustainable and rule compliant, we should be heading into our 12th season. That said, the gap is now much bigger than 11 years ago. I am pretty sure we would not have survived. No-one can expect to compete On equal terms when promoted to the Prem, and the do not. Look at the 3 promoted teams this year; Luton and Sheffield haven't gone Out and spent the world, Burnley have spent more(I think) but apparently not outside their means. 3 clubs which can be classed as 'small->medium' sized, who knew their limits, and accepted that unless you are a club that bounces straight back up, you have no chance of having the financial clout to compete, but still have a chance to stay in the division.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by Davepalace707
We’re already there. Don’t tell me Forest & Everton didn’t know exactly what they were doing. That’s why 4 or 6 point deductions aren’t a deterrent. Automatic relegation or maybe a 20 point deduction would stop this. Agreed and throw in a transfer ban for good measure
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
You know, I have been as self righteous and self serving as the rest on here in condemning those who voted for rules and then broke them. However, if only to be Devil's advocate, some balance. Forest came up with a team worth £12M (I know!) and were expected to compete on equal terms with teams worth £billions. It just isn't fair. They sought to "stretch" the rules to stand a chance; and they only just scraped it. And now, the vested interests who profit from this unfairness are punishing them for their nerve of seeking to eat at the High Table and are sending them back to the lower, impoverished obscurity where they belong. As an aside, makes you proud to be Palace. Sustainable and rule compliant, we should be heading into our 12th season. That said, the gap is now much bigger than 11 years ago. I am pretty sure we would not have survived. I take your point but they are continuing to overspend. It’s a two fingere salute to the PL from their owner imo
|
|
|
The summary from the hearing makes an interesting read (even if it is 50 pages) from going through it I got the overall impression that Forest were fortunate in the ruling of a 4 points deduction because they knew they were going to be in breach of PSR & did nothing to improve their situation within deadlines that they were fully aware of & because all of their golden mitigation arguments were slapped down an appeal would likely be fruitless. Originally posted by Spiderman
I take your point but they are continuing to overspend. It’s a two fingere salute to the PL from their owner imo
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
The summary from the hearing makes an interesting read (even if it is 50 pages) from going through it I got the overall impression that Forest were fortunate in the ruling of a 4 points deduction because they knew they were going to be in breach of PSR & did nothing to improve their situation within deadlines that they were fully aware of & because all of their golden mitigation arguments were slapped down an appeal would likely be fruitless.
IMO, therefore, they got off lightly. One way to deal with appeals is to adopt the PL approach to red card appeals, where the appeal is seen as spurious. If the club lose the appeal they should get docked an extra point or two. Edited by doombear (19 Mar 2024 1.59pm) Edited by doombear (19 Mar 2024 1.59pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.