You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Performance of the new government
November 21 2026 9.10pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Performance of the new government


Page 4 of 23 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
cryrst Flag The garden of England 07 Jul 24 10.48am

Originally posted by YT

Yes, you are getting into the detail there somewhat. My question was somewhat more basic towards someone who proudly stated that means-testing of the state pension is a good idea. So presumably he's thought about it and has a view on who should and who shouldn't receive the state pension. I mean surely he's not just a bitter leftie who can't abide people who are better of than he is.

Edited by YT (07 Jul 2024 9.56am)

Just testing the water really and the poster won’t answer his actual reasons for believing it because they don’t know why it’s either fair or doable.

 

YT Flag Oxford 07 Jul 24 10.53am

Originally posted by cryrst

Just testing the water really and the poster won’t answer his actual reasons for believing it because they don’t know why it’s either fair or doable.

Like most people who envy the success of others, he will be happy with means-testing provided it cuts in at a higher level than his own means.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Midlands Eagle Flag 07 Jul 24 11.03am

Originally posted by silvertop


Genuine question Willo. We have just lived through the worst government in a generation. Yet 7 million people STILL voted for those who had so negligently mismanaged. Thus...

What would it take to lose your vote?

I'm not Willo but still voted Conservative on the basis that there was no credible alternative and there was no way that I would vote for Smash the Gangs Starmer as I didn't consider him to be a credible alternative

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 07 Jul 24 11.03am

I can't see this happening. In any case a state pension is not a benefit at least not as I understand it.

You make contributions and in return receive an annuity when you retire.

Personally I would favour changing the system so that everybody has a pot of money which is their own. They can put more or less in but that is their lot.

 


One more point

YT Flag Oxford 07 Jul 24 11.06am

Originally posted by Badger11

I can't see this happening. In any case a state pension is not a benefit at least not as I understand it.

You make contributions and in return receive an annuity when you retire.

Personally I would favour changing the system so that everybody has a pot of money which is their own. They can put more or less in but that is their lot.

I can't see it happening either but, with respect, everything I've highlighted above is incorrect.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

dreamwaverider Flag London 07 Jul 24 11.19am

Glad I renewed my season ticket. Can't believe football will escape the 'G' word.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 07 Jul 24 4.24pm

Originally posted by YT

So if you were in charge, what would your means threshold be for whether you do or don't become entitled to the state pension?

And would you means-test other public sector provision? The health service for example or perhaps refuse collection?

We are only talking about state pension and that means test already exists. It's called pension credit.

Hardly the oracle but Peter stringfellow, a lifelong Conservative voter, called the DSS (as was) after he turned 65 demanding they take back his state pension! Why does a millionaire need a state benefit he asked.

If you can answer that question I will deal with any sensible points you make.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 07 Jul 24 4.31pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I can't see this happening. In any case a state pension is not a benefit at least not as I understand it.

You make contributions and in return receive an annuity when you retire.

Personally I would favour changing the system so that everybody has a pot of money which is their own. They can put more or less in but that is their lot.

No and the very definition of revisionism given the purpose of the benefits system.

Anyway back to point. No government will interfere with pensions as they will lose office. The article is made up.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 07 Jul 24 5.00pm

The state pension debate is an interesting one.

For some to view them as sacrosanct is clearly a nonsense as they had a hatchet taken to them when they raised the entitlement age and it will keep rising unless someone changes the law. So for some people they will drop down dead before they are a penny, however much they have paid in.

This change was supposedly made as are are all living longer but what we are in fact seeing is folks working far longer are suffering from ill health issues from simple 'wear and tear,' which in turn adds to NHS costs.

But another driver has to be cost. Universal state pensions cost a lot of money. Now every government has to decide what it spends it's money on and successive governments clearly see this as a cost. This government is just the same. It is looking at ways to save money.

Is what is happening now any worse than someone like me as I approach my latter years finding out suddenly that my retirement age has gone up by 7 years almost overnight?

It's all political decisions and like it or not it probably all boils down to money.

 

beak Flag croydon 07 Jul 24 5.11pm

Originally posted by silvertop

We are only talking about state pension and that means test already exists. It's called pension credit.

Hardly the oracle but Peter stringfellow, a lifelong Conservative voter, called the DSS (as was) after he turned 65 demanding they take back his state pension! Why does a millionaire need a state benefit he asked.

If you can answer that question I will deal with any sensible points you make.


This is total rubbish you do not automatically receive the State Pension , you have to put in a claim.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 07 Jul 24 5.46pm

A British driver wins the F1 Grand Prix at Silverstone.

Another success for the new Government.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 07 Jul 24 5.50pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Garbage made up tosh.

However, even if true - good and not before time!

That depends on the means.

Some ideologically obsessed lefty deciding who should get state pension?

No thanks.

Looks like 5 years in power will be all they can hope for.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 07 Jul 24 6.02pm

Originally posted by beak


This is total rubbish you do not automatically receive the State Pension , you have to put in a claim.

No it's partly rubbish. His point still stands.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 07 Jul 24 6.05pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

That depends on the means.

Some ideologically obsessed lefty deciding who should get state pension?

No thanks.

Looks like 5 years in power will be all they can hope for.

Wait hang on. Reducing state benefits is lefty?

 

YT Flag Oxford 07 Jul 24 6.20pm

Originally posted by silvertop

We are only talking about state pension and that means test already exists. It's called pension credit.

Hardly the oracle but Peter stringfellow, a lifelong Conservative voter, called the DSS (as was) after he turned 65 demanding they take back his state pension! Why does a millionaire need a state benefit he asked.

If you can answer that question I will deal with any sensible points you make.

You clearly haven't got a clue what you are talking about and you are now waffling to avoid answering a simple question, which I will repeat:

If you were in charge of the country, at what level of means would you say that a person should be denied the basic state pension?

And please don't try to get smart with me on this topic as I was, before my semi-retirement, a pensions professional for 40 years.

Edited by YT (07 Jul 2024 6.20pm)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 07 Jul 24 6.20pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Wait hang on. Reducing state benefits is lefty?

A pension is paid for by working and is designed to support those who have retired.

Benefit is the exact opposite for many who have hardly worked a day.

The best part is that a reduction in state pensions would probably be used to fund layabouts.

Now that is Lefty.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 07 Jul 24 8.31pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

A pension is paid for by working and is designed to support those who have retired.

Benefit is the exact opposite for many who have hardly worked a day.

The best part is that a reduction in state pensions would probably be used to fund layabouts.

Now that is Lefty.

Agreed

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 08 Jul 24 11.32am

Originally posted by YT

You clearly haven't got a clue what you are talking about and you are now waffling to avoid answering a simple question, which I will repeat:

If you were in charge of the country, at what level of means would you say that a person should be denied the basic state pension?

And please don't try to get smart with me on this topic as I was, before my semi-retirement, a pensions professional for 40 years.

Edited by YT (07 Jul 2024 6.20pm)

OK then, as the expert, educate me. How is pension credit calculated? Is it means tested? If so, at what level? That is, is it based on a line designed to ensure that those below it have the minimum dignified life that an elderly person deserves.

If so, then that is the level I would set it at. The work has been done. And, to answer your question, I would not have basic state pension at all. It wouldn't exist. There would only be this benefit. It would have as its aim the lifting of retired people of limited means out of poverty. That is, what was always intended to be its purpose.

I may be a lone voice and this view is VERY unpopular, especially on this site where many posters receive this money and believe they are entitled (your word) to it. However, I think there has been mission creep on state pensions where its role has morphed from safety net (the clue is in the words national INSURANCE) to entitlement (Badger misdescribed it as an "annuity" to a transparent electoral bribe.

In a rapidly ageing population where the disposable income of the retired passed those of the workforce some years ago and then left it well behind, is it really appropriate to pay from a diminishing tax kitty somebody who has 2 houses, no dependents, no debts, a brand new car every 3 years and a dog, other than to retain their vote?

And this time, please don't get smart and tell me that these people have this wealth as they have worked hard all their life etc. I know that. I just fail to see the fiscal justification for the workforce having to add to it.

Like I said, I'm p1ssing in the wind. Pure electoral suicide.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 08 Jul 24 11.33am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I'm not Willo but still voted Conservative on the basis that there was no credible alternative and there was no way that I would vote for Smash the Gangs Starmer as I didn't consider him to be a credible alternative

this whole thread is rather depressing - let's knock the new govt on day 1 and get a right leaning pile on against anything Labour, however, this response is just pathetic.

So after 14 years when the Tories have behaved disgracefully, all public services are now broken and we are in a cost of living crisis, yet we are paying the highest tax rates since the 2nd world war to bring this down to immigration is so sad.

'Illegal' immigration accounts for c5% of all immigrants coming into the UK and the Rwanda scheme is so costly and will account for c1% of those who do come in i'm not sure how this can be considered a deterrent. Cameron had told us he would get net migration down to the tens of thousands about 10 years ago and failed miserably as has every Tory govt since.

I think Starmer has shown more statesmanship in 2 days than we have seen from the Tories in the last 10 years.
I'm not his biggest fan, but it is clear we now have a grown up running the country. Clearly the Mail and the Telegraph will never like him, but they let the likes of Boris and Sunak literally get away with murder.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 08 Jul 24 11.38am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

A pension is paid for by working and is designed to support those who have retired.

Benefit is the exact opposite for many who have hardly worked a day.

The best part is that a reduction in state pensions would probably be used to fund layabouts.

Now that is Lefty.

Not your best argument but I can see a to and fro where we get nowhere. So, as for some reason you keep calling me a lefty (YT called me a "socialist"!!) I will say 2 areas where I am right of you and one where I think I may be right of you.

1. State pensions. Scrap 'em. Replace by means tested benefit.

2. NHS. Not sustainable as the population ages. Far more private sector involvement.

3. Free movement of EU labour. I am a free marketeer, not a protectionist, trade unionesque, crypto-Bolshevik like you!

Discuss.

 

Page 4 of 23 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Performance of the new government