You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Ban Smoking
November 19 2026 5.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ban Smoking


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
johnno42000 Flag 01 Jan 05 11.30am

As I have posted before smoking brings in 7 billion pounds. Smoking costs the NHS 1.5 billion. You work it out. I will be glad when the non-smokers have to start paying more in income tax to cover this deficit. Do all non-smokers think that this persecution will stop with smoking? First hunting, then smoking, what next alcohol, cars in city centres then on country roads, then on motorways?

This Government has it in mind to make this country into a state where freedom for people to enjoy what they want to enjoy is banned. Think of the jobs and income that have been lost in New York and Dublin due to the bans.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

HorshamEagle Flag under the union jack 01 Jan 05 6.48pm

Quote premier fan at 01 Jan 2005 10:49am

Smokers will suffer most. If they had more respect for non smokers then there would be no need to ban it from most places. Smoking will be banned from all or most public places before too long. I am longing for that day. If smokers could just be more considerate at football and hold out for 45 mins Im sure most non smokers would respect them for this too. We all have vices but this one clearly affects people directly. I want CPFC fans to bring more children to the game and if banning smoking helps then all the better. Im sure smoking is now a minority habit in our daily lives (apart from silly young teenage girls). So lets all have a thought for each other and respect our health. As for moving stands its not possible for me to as other places are full and I dont want to sit in the back corner somewhere,

If you feel like that, then perhaps football is the wrong sport for you. I hope you shall be lobbying a ban on swearing at football aswell.

 


Do you know where hell is?

premier fan Flag BR4 02 Jan 05 10.09am

How can football be the wrong sport for me because Im a non smoker? confused!!

Im just discusing the possibility of banning smoking during the game, thats all. As Ive said before it means smokers only have to hold out for 45mins max.

Why cant you compromise a little bit?

 

HorshamEagle Flag under the union jack 02 Jan 05 10.18am

Because we're already being limited in the parts of the ground we can smoke....thats the compromise. Football is a game which attracts a large male following, a following who smoke, drink and swear, it's been like this for years and all of a sudden people want this changed. You have your areas of the ground you can sit smoke free, if you don't like that you have to put up with the smoke, if you don't like that then tough.

Just out of interest, if we were to delay our smoking till half time, where would we go and smoke?

 


Do you know where hell is?

premier fan Flag BR4 03 Jan 05 2.10am

I disagree. Most people these days don`t smoke/swear or drink in excess thats why smokings becoming restricted (obvious observation I would have thought). Football crowds have increased greatly since the days of anti social behaviour such as fighting/excessive swearing and drinking which is restricted to bar areas. So its obviuos these measures work and are helping the game. If you must smoke why not hold out till HT. One question, How do you cope on long fights/train journeys etc...?
Democracy is for the benefit of the majority of the people. if smoking is not acceptable in a public place to the majority of people then that request should be observed. Lets keep football crowds coming and make the atmosphere at Palace an even better place to come to.

 

HorshamEagle Flag under the union jack 03 Jan 05 10.34am

But as you can see from this thread you are in the minority who really has a problem with it. In your view should smokers get a vote aswell?

I can see your point, i'm not totally unreasonable, thats why i restrict my smoking to smoking areas of the ground, maybe i could hold out until half time, but i don't want to. I sit in an area where i have the choice to smoke when i like, watching Palace can be particually stressful, so i will smoke when i can.

Smokers arn't scum, we're people with an addiction slowly killing ourselves. We're not killing you, or anyone else around us because that is not how passive smoking takes effect, the smoke inhaled whilst sitting next to a smoker outside is so small, that is does not make a difference. If your uncomfortable with the smell, then that is unfortunate but unavoidable. When i gave up smoking, people smoking around me didn't bother me, i thought to myself just because i;d given up it doesn't mean the whole world has to aswell. I know people have habits that annoy me, but you have to live with them, in a tolerant society as we are(or maybe as we used to be) people do things that we dislike, but you can't stop someone from doing something unless it's illegal.

 


Do you know where hell is?

Nuno Flag have no idea.... 03 Jan 05 10.39am

Having never smoked I am not bothered if it gets banned or not. I think some smokers attitude to smoking is wrong thinking they have the right to light up anywhere they want. It’s all about common decency. If you are sitting in a restaurant and have just finished your meal don’t light up if the table next to you have just started theirs.

 


AKA Bacon

HorshamEagle Flag under the union jack 03 Jan 05 10.40am

E, having been out with me and other on numerous occasions, you know i am a considerate smoker. I always ask if it's ok with everyone that i smoke at the Table, and will never do it if someone is eating.

 


Do you know where hell is?

Nuno Flag have no idea.... 03 Jan 05 10.43am

Quote HorshamEagle at 03 Jan 2005 10:40am

E, having been out with me and other on numerous occasions, you know i am a considerate smoker. I always ask if it's ok with everyone that i smoke at the Table, and will never do it if someone is eating.

i know mate thats why i said some and made it bold.

you have the decency to ask and always have respect when we ask you to smoke in the garden.

 


AKA Bacon

premier fan Flag BR4 04 Jan 05 12.16am

Its all about respect and consideration for others at the end of the day. Yes, most smokers now are more considerate. At the end of the day it won`t stop me watching Palace and I understand it probably helps you relieve the stress we have to suffer!

 

HorshamEagle Flag under the union jack 04 Jan 05 12.30am

I think we have to agree to disagree premier fan. Consideration goes a long way, a bit of respect goes even further, a bit of this from both sides and there isn't a problem!

 


Do you know where hell is?

Mr Fenandes Flag 04 Jan 05 2.55am

Quote HorshamEagle at 03 Jan 2005 10:40am

E, having been out with me and other on numerous occasions, you know i am a considerate smoker. I always ask if it's ok with everyone that i smoke at the Table, and will never do it if someone is eating.

It is a pity that not all smokers share your manners in that respect. I don't suppose its fair to tar everyone with the same brush but then again its a bit unfair that some on here label all non-smokers as ignorant etc etc

 


Check out our Croydon-based football comedy series 'Road to F.A. Cup'!
All episodes available FREE here: [Link]

Lee McB Flag Van Basten's nephew... 04 Jan 05 5.55pm

Quote HorshamEagle at 30 Dec 2004 2:52pm
Madcap, you obviously have no idea on addiction, If smokers had a choice i'm sure the majority would stop smoking, but it isn't that easy.


I don't know much about addiction, having never smoked myself, but I find that a poor excuse.

Have you been brainwashed to think that you don't have a choice?! Of course you have a choice!

I imagine you've only been smoking for a few years. My grandad smoked very heavily for about 55 years despite others telling him he shouldn't. Eventually his arteries clogged up and he had to have a triple heart bypass.

That's what it took for him to finally give up, and when he tells me it was difficult to do then I believe him. But if you've only been smoking for a few years, then I think think it's a cop out to say you are addicted as the reason you can't quit.

To counter the missing "addiction" my grandad grew a beard. Funny, you might think, but it's given him something to concentrate on rather than smoking.

 


I am running the 2011 Virgin London Marathon in aid of The Children's Trust: [Link]

Pete the Eagle is on twitter:

Pete and Alice are on Facebook: [Link]

Lee McB Flag Van Basten's nephew... 04 Jan 05 5.59pm

Quote HorshamEagle at 30 Dec 2004 2:56pm
ASH would have you believe differently, however if you read their comments about us being a drain on the NHS then i think you will see what a bunch of idiots they are. Surely achoholism and even the consumption of fatty foods is of equal drain to the NHS but they quietly skirt over that issue.


But ASH is an organisation set up to prevent smoking, isn't it? I'm sure that if they were set up to prevent alcoholism or the consumption of fatty foods then they would discuss those issues instead.

 


I am running the 2011 Virgin London Marathon in aid of The Children's Trust: [Link]

Pete the Eagle is on twitter:

Pete and Alice are on Facebook: [Link]

Lee McB Flag Van Basten's nephew... 04 Jan 05 6.05pm

Quote johnno42000 at 01 Jan 2005 11:30am
As I have posted before smoking brings in 7 billion pounds. Smoking costs the NHS 1.5 billion. You work it out.


But what's that got to do with smoking at a football match? Or in public places?

If smoking is, as HorshamEagle says, an addiction then surely if it is banned from public places it will not stop smokers from smoking. They will just have to do it in their own homes or something.

However, there will be less "smoking costs" for the NHS because you won't get non-smokers being admitted to hospital for smoking-related illnesses.

If smoking was banned in public places, I think we'd soon see just how addictive people find it.

 


I am running the 2011 Virgin London Marathon in aid of The Children's Trust: [Link]

Pete the Eagle is on twitter:

Pete and Alice are on Facebook: [Link]

Lee McB Flag Van Basten's nephew... 04 Jan 05 6.08pm

Quote HorshamEagle at 01 Jan 2005 6:48pm

Quote premier fan at 01 Jan 2005 10:49am

Smokers will suffer most. If they had more respect for non smokers then there would be no need to ban it from most places. Smoking will be banned from all or most public places before too long. I am longing for that day. If smokers could just be more considerate at football and hold out for 45 mins Im sure most non smokers would respect them for this too. We all have vices but this one clearly affects people directly. I want CPFC fans to bring more children to the game and if banning smoking helps then all the better. Im sure smoking is now a minority habit in our daily lives (apart from silly young teenage girls). So lets all have a thought for each other and respect our health. As for moving stands its not possible for me to as other places are full and I dont want to sit in the back corner somewhere,

If you feel like that, then perhaps football is the wrong sport for you. I hope you shall be lobbying a ban on swearing at football aswell.


There's no rule that states you have to smoke to be a football fan, or enjoy football...well at least last time I checked there wasn't!

 


I am running the 2011 Virgin London Marathon in aid of The Children's Trust: [Link]

Pete the Eagle is on twitter:

Pete and Alice are on Facebook: [Link]

Lee McB Flag Van Basten's nephew... 04 Jan 05 6.09pm

Quote HorshamEagle at 02 Jan 2005 10:18am
Just out of interest, if we were to delay our smoking till half time, where would we go and smoke?


Behind the bike shed?

 


I am running the 2011 Virgin London Marathon in aid of The Children's Trust: [Link]

Pete the Eagle is on twitter:

Pete and Alice are on Facebook: [Link]

Lee McB Flag Van Basten's nephew... 04 Jan 05 6.24pm

Quote HorshamEagle at 03 Jan 2005 10:34am
But as you can see from this thread you are in the minority who really has a problem with it. In your view should smokers get a vote aswell?


Seven pages on one unofficial club-specific website hardly constitutes a fair assumption on the rest of the nation though.

Quote
I can see your point, i'm not totally unreasonable, thats why i restrict my smoking to smoking areas of the ground, maybe i could hold out until half time, but i don't want to. I sit in an area where i have the choice to smoke when i like, watching Palace can be particually stressful, so i will smoke when i can.


I agree that whilst there are smoking areas, you have the right to smoke in them. I'm sure I posted earlier in this thread that I chose my season ticket seat on the basis that it was in a non-smoking area.

If there is a rule saying you can smoke somewhere then that is fine.

I personally would like to be nearer to block B because I enjoy a good atmosphere and singing all game, but I'm not prepared to inhale all that smoke, even if it is for only 90 minutes a week. That's the sacrifice I make for the compromise.

If there ever is a complete ban, I would probably look to move closer to block B. For now I am happy where I am.

Quote
Smokers arn't scum, we're people with an addiction slowly killing ourselves. We're not killing you, or anyone else around us because that is not how passive smoking takes effect, the smoke inhaled whilst sitting next to a smoker outside is so small, that is does not make a difference.


I wouldn't class you as scum. I don't think many non-smokers would. I haven't read all the posts in this thread, but from the ones I have read I've only seen yourself refer to smokers as "scum" through the supposed eyes of a non-smoker.

And inhaling smoke does make a difference. 90 minutes in an open football stadium may not seem much, but every little helps unfortunately. Granted it'd take a prolonged amount of time to be very serious, but it does still have an affect.

I remember doing a project at school once on the advantages and disadvantages of smoking, and whilst I can't remember every fact (it was a long time ago!) I recall that in cigarette smoke there are approximately 60 harmful toxic substances. So yes, it does have an effect.

 


I am running the 2011 Virgin London Marathon in aid of The Children's Trust: [Link]

Pete the Eagle is on twitter:

Pete and Alice are on Facebook: [Link]

HorshamEagle Flag under the union jack 04 Jan 05 8.12pm

But the argument here is to turn a block of seats where people smoke into a non smoking area. Tell me why is that fair? the smokers have agreed to do it away from everyone else in a confined area, so why try and and 2nd class us even more and stop it all together?

Ash is prevention of smoking, but i was commenting on their single mindess and the fact that they have come out with a statement that is incredibly obvious, but is also the tip of the iceberg with regards the NHS and it's blood suckers! They can only comment on the subject in hand, but it is a silly argument to make and one where many comparisons can be made!

Every little helps - You're totally right lee, me smoking at football does make a difference to you, but the difference is so small you will never feel the effects. If you were in a room with me and other smokers for a prolonged period of time then you would feel the effects. But the argument can be levelled at anything that lets out poisonous fumes. All vehicles are a danger to my health with their fumes, i don't drive, i don't expect others to stop driving, it's part of life which i have to accept, it's not a worry to my health because i realise the danger to my own health is minimal.

I'm not deliberately going out to hurt people, i'm partaking in a habit with which i have very little control over. Fair enough, i want to to smoke, it curves the nerves, it relaxes me, this doesn't mean i could stop smoking with a click of the fingers. With effort and willpower anyone can do anything, but why should i stop? Selfish view to take i know, but for once i'd like to to be selfish about something.

My comment about perhaps football is the wrong sport for premier fan was a silly one to make and one which was ill thought out and i apologise. Everyone is welcome at football, but this also means that smokers should be welcomed as much as the next person.

 


Do you know where hell is?

johnno42000 Flag 04 Jan 05 8.36pm

Quote Lee McB at 04 Jan 2005 6:05pm

Quote johnno42000 at 01 Jan 2005 11:30am
As I have posted before smoking brings in 7 billion pounds. Smoking costs the NHS 1.5 billion. You work it out.


But what's that got to do with smoking at a football match? Or in public places?

If smoking is, as HorshamEagle says, an addiction then surely if it is banned from public places it will not stop smokers from smoking. They will just have to do it in their own homes or something.

However, there will be less "smoking costs" for the NHS because you won't get non-smokers being admitted to hospital for smoking-related illnesses.

If smoking was banned in public places, I think we'd soon see just how addictive people find it.


Look at Ireland, New York, San Francisco etc. A certain percentage of people have been forced to give up smoking in order to keep their jobs, that is not democracy or freedom it is the strictist form of tyranny.

This WILL effect the amount of revenue raised and people WILL continue to smoke (but in fewer numbers), but as in New York and in Ireland there will be job losses in the leisure industry...pubs etc as addicted smokers are not visiting these premises and the revenue has fallen, where are the Government going to make up the shortfall when the revenue from Public Houses goes down?

What would happen if this freedom loving Government (sic!) decides to ban smoking at Football Grounds? I don't know the exact figures but I should imagine there is a fair percentage of supporters who smoke (and are probably addicted)...will they vote with their feet and not turn up? Where will the clubs make up any lost revenue?

Where will the Government turn to next to raise the loss in Revenue? If the whole country stopped smoking today, the benefit on the savings on the NHS costs would probably take many years to come through, where would they make up the shortfall...higher taxes for all. The same is true if 10% of people give up smoking...somewhere along the line you, me and everyone else will have to pay higher taxes in one form or another as there WILL be a shortfall.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Ban Smoking