You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 8.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 40 of 71 < 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 >
Nobbybm Flag Dartford 15 Nov 18 8.35am

Originally posted by stanzerman


The main point you miss is the safety aspect of moving a couple of hundred uncontrollable,boisterous fans who consistently ignore stadium and safety regulations, into the middle of a group of normal fans, including families, who are there to just watch football and support their team. I just hope that no one gets seriously hurt.

Much like away games? Not aware of any issues from those & never seen any 'dangerous' behaviour.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 15 Nov 18 8.39am

Originally posted by Mapletree

I get the feeling they are just going to try to talk us into taking other - already available - seats . I expect very little ‘consultation ‘.

This came up in a pub discussion the other week. It's been widely reported that the HF are still attending games but have their ST's elsewhere. I presume they're not all sat as individuals so, in theory, there's a load of seats in small groups that would be 'available' as it were.

Does anyone actually know where any groups of them are, because there's just a few pairs of them in the main stand G & H?

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Nov 18 8.43am

Originally posted by Nobbybm

This came up in a pub discussion the other week. It's been widely reported that the HF are still attending games but have their ST's elsewhere. I presume they're not all sat as individuals so, in theory, there's a load of seats in small groups that would be 'available' as it were.

Does anyone actually know where any groups of them are, because there's just a few pairs of them in the main stand G & H?

You would think they’d present these as available at these meetings next week, but this is Palace, so I expect it’ll be underprepared and they’ll be lucky if they’re offered any more than the block next to the away fans or any chunk of 400 seats in the Arfur.

 


COYP

eritheagle Flag Erith 15 Nov 18 12.54pm

Originally posted by eritheagle

I received an email last Friday (9th Nov) from the club regarding the "open day" being held next Tuesday (20th Nov).
As I'm unable attend due to being away I rang Paul McGowan on Monday around lunchtime to see if I could arrange another day to go to the ground.
He wasn't in the office so I left my details with a lady. I explained that due to problems with my eyes I don't use a computer or check emails often so would prefer a phone call.
She said she would pass on the info to Paul and he would be in contact.

Wednesday afternoon and I'm yet to hear back from Paul!

Feeling less valued as a supporter by the day!

Edited by eritheagle (14 Nov 2018 1.19pm)

I received my phone call from one of Paul McGowan's staff this morning.
Basically he asked where my new seating preference would be and if any special conditions need to be considered.
I told him where I'd like to sit if/when moved and he made a note of it.

I WAS asked if I'd like to apply for the new singing area but I declined and I pointed out to him that I just doubt that it will be a nice atmosphere in amongst them all and that I foresee trouble ahead.

I am lucky in that I am just looking for one ticket on it's own and I have the upmost sympathy for all my fellow E blockers especially those wanting to find multiple seats together.

I did point out that where I wish to move to is more expensive then my current seat and it may be an issue in the seasons after next season (after the discount). I will have to review if I can afford to or want to still attend after that.

I'm glad that they did get back to me and I am hopeful of getting a good seat but please don't think that this in anyway means I am still not very disappointed about moving away from the seat I have loved sitting in for the past 21 years and the people I enjoy sitting next to every game.

And I am still angry with how the club and especially Parrish have handled the situation!

 

bicycle repair man 15 Nov 18 1.38pm

Originally posted by eritheagle

I received my phone call from one of Paul McGowan's staff this morning.
Basically he asked where my new seating preference would be and if any special conditions need to be considered.
I told him where I'd like to sit if/when moved and he made a note of it.

I WAS asked if I'd like to apply for the new singing area but I declined and I pointed out to him that I just doubt that it will be a nice atmosphere in amongst them all and that I foresee trouble ahead.

I am lucky in that I am just looking for one ticket on it's own and I have the upmost sympathy for all my fellow E blockers especially those wanting to find multiple seats together.

I did point out that where I wish to move to is more expensive then my current seat and it may be an issue in the seasons after next season (after the discount). I will have to review if I can afford to or want to still attend after that.

I'm glad that they did get back to me and I am hopeful of getting a good seat but please don't think that this in anyway means I am still not very disappointed about moving away from the seat I have loved sitting in for the past 21 years and the people I enjoy sitting next to every game.

And I am still angry with how the club and especially Parrish have handled the situation!

You have every right to feel angry.
It's a disgrace that you feel you have to move,and Parish & Co should hang their head's in shame.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 15 Nov 18 1.52pm

How are they going to enforce the "singing" section? Will those who take up the offer be monitored by CCTV and if not seen to be singing will they have their seats taken away? What level of "singing" is acceptable for the "singing" section"?
So many questions...

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Nov 18 2.10pm

Originally posted by eritheagle

I received my phone call from one of Paul McGowan's staff this morning.
Basically he asked where my new seating preference would be and if any special conditions need to be considered.
I told him where I'd like to sit if/when moved and he made a note of it.

I WAS asked if I'd like to apply for the new singing area but I declined and I pointed out to him that I just doubt that it will be a nice atmosphere in amongst them all and that I foresee trouble ahead.

I am lucky in that I am just looking for one ticket on it's own and I have the upmost sympathy for all my fellow E blockers especially those wanting to find multiple seats together.

I did point out that where I wish to move to is more expensive then my current seat and it may be an issue in the seasons after next season (after the discount). I will have to review if I can afford to or want to still attend after that.

I'm glad that they did get back to me and I am hopeful of getting a good seat but please don't think that this in anyway means I am still not very disappointed about moving away from the seat I have loved sitting in for the past 21 years and the people I enjoy sitting next to every game.

And I am still angry with how the club and especially Parrish have handled the situation!

Your feeling should be the worst or the most disappointed, well it would be if the club could organise a p1ss up in a brewery. They can find multiple seats together of people who travel together for the match, but probably not 20 acquaintances packed together. There will no doubt be more available after this p1ss poor league campaign or relegation.

What I agree and object to is the financial ‘compensation’ in Parish’s words, coming to the E400. If the 50% ST discount money has been eaten up before the new stand is built then they’re obviously worse off, and that’ll only take 3-4 seasons, with the new stand possibly not due to finish in 2-3 years time as some of the objectors argued but possibly 10 or who knows how many years. And in that new stand they should be offered first choice after no doubt the very expensive areas and the complimentary seats.

Usually at football grounds you get different types of supporters in different stands, or in different parts of the stand, and would be the case possibly with a big new stand. But the club can’t organise or promise things with regards to the HF and first choice promises to the E400 perhaps mean so little when that new stand could be whoever knows how long. Half a generation? Once the old 1924 stand is finally condemned?

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Nov 18 2.12pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

You have every right to feel angry.
It's a disgrace that you feel you have to move,and Parish & Co should hang their head's in shame.

Please, can you add to the discussion on what’s maybe happening or not happening, not what you want to moan about that is happening.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Nov 18 2.17pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

How are they going to enforce the "singing" section? Will those who take up the offer be monitored by CCTV and if not seen to be singing will they have their seats taken away? What level of "singing" is acceptable for the "singing" section"?
So many questions...

This is the issue with not having a full reset or reset of E,D,C,B,A. A seat swap will probably solve it so Parish doesn’t have to, you still may have silent standers unwilling to move out of D but at least the singing may travel and join up between E and B.

However, if you intend to sit in E then you’ll have few decent seats to choose from elsewhere in the stadium once you get the hump after 2-3 League games (the performances are so sh1t then that you may put up with it).

Edited by Rudi Hedman (15 Nov 2018 4.29pm)

 


COYP

bicycle repair man 15 Nov 18 2.27pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Please, can you add to the discussion on what’s maybe happening or not happening, not what you want to moan about that is happening.


Have you not heard of free speech ?
It's very popular in this country.
I have the right to post what I like,as long as I remain within the rules.
And you have the right not to read what I post,use your right.

 

becky Flag over the moon 15 Nov 18 2.42pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Your feeling should be the worst or the most disappointed, well it would be if the club could organise a p1ss up in a brewery. They can find multiple seats together of people who travel together for the match, but probably not 20 acquaintances packed together. There will no doubt be more available after this p1ss poor league campaign or relegation.

What I agree and object to is the financial ‘compensation’ in Parish’s words, coming to the E400. If the 50% ST discount money has been eaten up before the new stand is built then they’re obviously worse off, and that’ll only take 3-4 seasons, with the new stand possibly not due to finish in 2-3 years time as some of the objectors argued but possibly 10 or who knows how many years. And in that new stand they should be offered first choice after no doubt the very expensive areas and the complimentary seats.

Usually at football grounds you get different types of supporters in different stands, or in different parts of the stand, and would be the case possibly with a big new stand. But the club can’t organise or promise things with regards to the HF and first choice promises to the E400 perhaps mean so little when that new stand could be whoever knows how long. Half a generation? Once the old 1924 stand is finally condemned?

One of the factors here is whether or not people who love to sit behind the goal actually want a side-on view of the match, which is, obviously, very different from end-on.

Personally, after years of standing behind the goal on the old Holmesdale terracing, I hated it when I had to go and sit in the Arthur whilst the new stand was built, and was never more pleased than when I went back to a seat in the LH, more or less where we used to stand (and back with the family group too).

From behind the goal you get a great view of the pattern of the game from end to end - not the best when they are up the far end, but still able to see what's happening(goals confirmed by the Sainsbury's end rising to their feet!). You just don't get that view of the passing pattern and the spread of the game from side-on.

No idea how many others actually involved will feel the same, but I'd put money on not being alone in this preference.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Mapletree Flag Croydon 15 Nov 18 2.53pm

Originally posted by becky

One of the factors here is whether or not people who love to sit behind the goal actually want a side-on view of the match, which is, obviously, very different from end-on.

Personally, after years of standing behind the goal on the old Holmesdale terracing, I hated it when I had to go and sit in the Arthur whilst the new stand was built, and was never more pleased than when I went back to a seat in the LH, more or less where we used to stand (and back with the family group too).

From behind the goal you get a great view of the pattern of the game from end to end - not the best when they are up the far end, but still able to see what's happening(goals confirmed by the Sainsbury's end rising to their feet!). You just don't get that view of the passing pattern and the spread of the game from side-on.

No idea how many others actually involved will feel the same, but I'd put money on not being alone in this preference.

I have been on every side of the ground

The best view was from the Old Stand with my dad but I moved for the best atmosphere to the Holmesdale as a wee nipper. We then moved to standing in the Arthur and managed to create quite a bit of noise. For some reason we went to the wilderness of the Whitehorse Lane end for a while, did get a good view of Richard Shaw goading Cantona into going mental.

Then back to the LH 23 years ago.

I have grown used to the end view and like it but the LH for me is really about the atmosphere. Mind you I am bang in the middle, bang in the middle. Best seats in the house. And I AIN'T MOVING!

 

Terry Ven Flag 15 Nov 18 3.55pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

wasnt you at the away seaweed game last season?? I was barged out my seat by them lot in hoodies and nearly sh4t myslef when that first firework went off behind me...

Much like away games? Not aware of any issues from those & never seen any 'dangerous' behaviour.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Nov 18 4.33pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I have been on every side of the ground

The best view was from the Old Stand with my dad but I moved for the best atmosphere to the Holmesdale as a wee nipper. We then moved to standing in the Arthur and managed to create quite a bit of noise. For some reason we went to the wilderness of the Whitehorse Lane end for a while, did get a good view of Richard Shaw goading Cantona into going mental.

Then back to the LH 23 years ago.

I have grown used to the end view and like it but the LH for me is really about the atmosphere. Mind you I am bang in the middle, bang in the middle. Best seats in the house. And I AIN'T MOVING!

Are you buying the club? I hope you actually build the new stand.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Nov 18 4.46pm

Originally posted by becky

One of the factors here is whether or not people who love to sit behind the goal actually want a side-on view of the match, which is, obviously, very different from end-on.

Personally, after years of standing behind the goal on the old Holmesdale terracing, I hated it when I had to go and sit in the Arthur whilst the new stand was built, and was never more pleased than when I went back to a seat in the LH, more or less where we used to stand (and back with the family group too).

From behind the goal you get a great view of the pattern of the game from end to end - not the best when they are up the far end, but still able to see what's happening(goals confirmed by the Sainsbury's end rising to their feet!). You just don't get that view of the passing pattern and the spread of the game from side-on.

No idea how many others actually involved will feel the same, but I'd put money on not being alone in this preference.

You could call it a personal preference. I’ve never seen any managers sit in the home end upper or lower tier to watch the first half, all main stands are along the side of the pitch, and prices are nearly always cheaper behind the goal.

I hear what you mean about seeing the pattern of passes, whereas I would call it the layout of both teams and the positioning at any moment, although you get used to this side on, so much so that you can see where the player receiving the ball can pass to once he’s able to pass.

Players should be able to know where their teammates are also. Wayne Rooney may be a Neanderthal but it’s well known he has a great picture in his head of where people are and angles of people and passes. He doesn’t need to face from a certain angle and neither do the managers. You’ll get used to it, as long as it’s not too near the front. Actually from behind the goal you can sometimes not appreciate when a sprint or ball in front of a player is beyond them whereas you can with a side on view. You also can’t see clever forward moves as well behind the goal vs a side on view.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (15 Nov 2018 4.47pm)

 


COYP

Mapletree Flag Croydon 15 Nov 18 5.29pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Are you buying the club? I hope you actually build the new stand.

What do you mean?

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 15 Nov 18 6.27pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

What do you mean?

he's being sarcastic.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 15 Nov 18 7.24pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

he's being sarcastic.

Really?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 15 Nov 18 7.28pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Are you buying the club? I hope you actually build the new stand.

I am sorry. You seem to be under some kind of misapprehension. If I gave you the impression by saying that I ain't moving that I actually live at the ground, or intend to do so, I apologise. I feel that the mortgage on such a property may be slightly beyond my means.

I have in fact merely purchased the leasehold of my seat, in advance, for another year. Should anyone try to renege on that arrangement I intend to release the Hounds of Hell. Sorry, I didn't mean to give you an impression that I take a dog to the match. I know you can take things a little literally. This was merely a metaphor.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Nov 18 7.42pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I am sorry. You seem to be under some kind of misapprehension. If I gave you the impression by saying that I ain't moving that I actually live at the ground, or intend to do so, I apologise. I feel that the mortgage on such a property may be slightly beyond my means.

I have in fact merely purchased the leasehold of my seat, in advance, for another year. Should anyone try to renege on that arrangement I intend to release the Hounds of Hell. Sorry, I didn't mean to give you an impression that I take a dog to the match. I know you can take things a little literally. This was merely a metaphor.

Do you hold a 25 year ‘season ticket’, not a lease or ownership of that part of the ground?

I hope the E400 get a good deal out of this, but if you’re required to
move then you will be moving (not given that seat next season). 2010 didn’t have to honour those long term season tickets that Jordan shouldn’t have sold anyway.

 


COYP

Page 40 of 71 < 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic