You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Eddie Howe - Staying at AFC Bournemouth - or is he?
November 19 2026 7.09pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Eddie Howe - Staying at AFC Bournemouth - or is he?


Page 43 of 141 < 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 >
sydtheeagle Flag England 09 Jan 11 12.58am

Quote scififan2001 at 09 Jan 2011 12.42am

He wont be coming to Palace. I'm normally right.

I think you may be right. To be honest, if I put my rose-tinted Palace spectacles to one side, if I was Howe I would take the club I truly loved up this year and then leave for a considerably better opportunity than ours in the summer. I have little doubt that a better-funded, "bigger" team will come calling if he has further success over the balance of this season. And really, if he's been offered the Palace job already but spent Saturday managing Bournemouth while we were simultaneously going out of the FA Cup, that tells me all I need to know about which way he's leaning.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

jaxon Flag London 09 Jan 11 1.00am

Quote sydtheeagle at 09 Jan 2011 12.58am

Quote scififan2001 at 09 Jan 2011 12.42am

He wont be coming to Palace. I'm normally right.

I think you may be right. To be honest, if I put my rose-tinted Palace spectacles to one side, if I was Howe I would take the club I truly loved up this year and then leave for a considerably better opportunity than ours in the summer. I have little doubt that a better-funded, "bigger" team will come calling if he has further success over the balance of this season. And really, if he's been offered the Palace job already but spent Saturday managing Bournemouth while we were simultaneously going out of the FA Cup, that tells me all I need to know about which way he's leaning.

Well lets hope hope on this occasion, scififan, you're wrong.

 

Buzzcock Flag In an underground lair near Bright... 09 Jan 11 1.03am

I once got offered the position of Senior Recreation attendant (Park keeper) while still a mere Recreation attendant at Bromley council.
I spent the whole weekend thinking about it.
I took the job after much soul searching and spouting my love of my former position.

 


In the woods there grew a tree. And a fine fine tree was he.

SpikeyMatt Flag Fishing for condiments 09 Jan 11 1.04am

Quote sydtheeagle at 09 Jan 2011 12.58am

Quote scififan2001 at 09 Jan 2011 12.42am

He wont be coming to Palace. I'm normally right.

I think you may be right. To be honest, if I put my rose-tinted Palace spectacles to one side, if I was Howe I would take the club I truly loved up this year and then leave for a considerably better opportunity than ours in the summer. I have little doubt that a better-funded, "bigger" team will come calling if he has further success over the balance of this season. And really, if he's been offered the Palace job already but spent Saturday managing Bournemouth while we were simultaneously going out of the FA Cup, that tells me all I need to know about which way he's leaning.

I think it's been cleverly stage managed by CPFC2010, Howe and his employers - allowing him one last game whilst we have the relative unimportance (compared to the league) of the FA Cup to deal with. But then I might just be being a tad simplistic and naive.

Getting him would be a coup. Our owners know that and I think may well pull it off, they negotiated with multiple administrators to buy a club and ground; convincing a manager to join our club must be walk in the park compared to that!

Canny.

 


Twitter!

Justin Bieber: the singing amoeba

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Jan 11 1.10am

Quote Buzzcock at 09 Jan 2011 12.55am

Hard man Seth.
Playing devil's advocate - if our imaginary young, successful,loyal manager was torn between staying with us and moving to Wigan you'd expect some sort of media discourse or just for him to just say - F you Palace, stepping stone, here's the big time?


It's happened to us enough times, I'm used to it. It's football. They pay their dues then move on to bigger and better things.

There are exceptions of course and if Howe is one of them, good luck to him. I just hope he knows his own mind very well because if he takes this job he's going to have to give it everything he's got or it'll be more tears all round.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Jan 11 1.11am

Quote SpikeyMatt at 09 Jan 2011 1.04am

Quote sydtheeagle at 09 Jan 2011 12.58am

Quote scififan2001 at 09 Jan 2011 12.42am

He wont be coming to Palace. I'm normally right.

I think you may be right. To be honest, if I put my rose-tinted Palace spectacles to one side, if I was Howe I would take the club I truly loved up this year and then leave for a considerably better opportunity than ours in the summer. I have little doubt that a better-funded, "bigger" team will come calling if he has further success over the balance of this season. And really, if he's been offered the Palace job already but spent Saturday managing Bournemouth while we were simultaneously going out of the FA Cup, that tells me all I need to know about which way he's leaning.

I think it's been cleverly stage managed by CPFC2010, Howe and his employers - allowing him one last game whilst we have the relative unimportance (compared to the league) of the FA Cup to deal with. But then I might just be being a tad simplistic and naive.

Getting him would be a coup. Our owners know that and I think may well pull it off, they negotiated with multiple administrators to buy a club and ground; convincing a manager to join our club must be walk in the park compared to that!

Canny.


You could be right Matt. But then you were convinced Hughton would get the job because he was at the Millwall game

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

SpikeyMatt Flag Fishing for condiments 09 Jan 11 1.13am

Quote Seth at 09 Jan 2011 1.11am

Quote SpikeyMatt at 09 Jan 2011 1.04am

Quote sydtheeagle at 09 Jan 2011 12.58am

Quote scififan2001 at 09 Jan 2011 12.42am

He wont be coming to Palace. I'm normally right.

I think you may be right. To be honest, if I put my rose-tinted Palace spectacles to one side, if I was Howe I would take the club I truly loved up this year and then leave for a considerably better opportunity than ours in the summer. I have little doubt that a better-funded, "bigger" team will come calling if he has further success over the balance of this season. And really, if he's been offered the Palace job already but spent Saturday managing Bournemouth while we were simultaneously going out of the FA Cup, that tells me all I need to know about which way he's leaning.

I think it's been cleverly stage managed by CPFC2010, Howe and his employers - allowing him one last game whilst we have the relative unimportance (compared to the league) of the FA Cup to deal with. But then I might just be being a tad simplistic and naive.

Getting him would be a coup. Our owners know that and I think may well pull it off, they negotiated with multiple administrators to buy a club and ground; convincing a manager to join our club must be walk in the park compared to that!

Canny.


You could be right Matt. But then you were convinced Hughton would get the job because he was at the Millwall game

I'm like a kid on Christmas Eve when it comes to speculation. I explode with excitement and nonsensical bollocks.

 


Twitter!

Justin Bieber: the singing amoeba

Jonathan Flag West Hampstead 09 Jan 11 1.57am

Having just sat and listened to his interview he sounds like a thoroughly decent man who is torn between the possibility of lifting the club he loves to new heights or moving on to progress to a level he probably would be unable to take Bournemouth to.

My instinct is he'll come - and having listened to that interview I am even keener that he does take the reigns than I was previously and I have felt from the outset he is right man for the job.

 


19/12/06
i was there.

RJ19 Flag 09 Jan 11 2.01am

Quote Seth at 09 Jan 2011 12.58am

Quote SpikeyMatt at 09 Jan 2011 12.47am

Quote Seth at 09 Jan 2011 12.45am

Quote SpikeyMatt at 09 Jan 2011 12.35am

The comments to me are of a man torn between heart and head but doesn't want to believe his head is telling him the right choice. I think he'll come and hope he doesn't look back.


How could he not look back? He sounds like someone who's being asked to kill his own mother. He's going to have to man up a little bit if he's going to make it as a manager outside of Dorset.

Haha. I do enjoy it when you're on the offensive


Well I'm just bored of it now. Some of you may know that I'm a practising counsellor, so am not at all against emotional expression. Indeed it's what my career depends on.

However all this whining about how much he loves Bournemouth and how hard it is for him (poor likkle diddums) is getting tiresome. I want him here, but not if he's going to get suicidal over it and start listening to the Smiths or something.

It's just a job for chrissake. Either take it or don't, but hurry the f*ck up. Time is running out for us.

Edited by Seth (09 Jan 2011 1.02am)


I don't honestly think the real issue here is whether he can tear himself away from Bournemouth. Obviously he's got a massive loyalty but he also seems very ambitious and intelligent, and he must be aware that everyone has him down as the 'next big thing' as far as management is concerned. He's had other offers, and by this point is must be a question not of whether he'll leave but when, and where he'll go.

I think the bigger issue for him is assessing the level of risk involved here. If, lord forbid, he came to Palace and things didn't go so well for the remainder of the season, then he'd really have tarnished his golden record. Nobody had any expectations of him at Bournemouth and he's worked wonders, but now he's got to work out whether he thinks he can do the same thing at Palace, two leagues higher (from where Bournemouth were, obviously not where they are now), and picking things up halfway through the season, mid-transfer window.

The answer to that in my mind is that he definitely can - we've got a good bunch of players who were unlucky in my mind for a long time at the beginning of the season and have only recently started putting in really poor performances. Our position in the table doesn't reflect the team, it just reflects the way we've been playing and a lack of stability. What I'm basically saying is that he's probably spending this weekend getting to know a bit about the players we have at Palace, and working out what he'd do and where he thinks he could take us. I have him down as a guy who knows the game inside out so I think we need to give him a bit more credit. Love for Dorset hasn't got Bournemouth where they are! It's a gamble for him but I think it would pay off. He doesn't need to come to Palace now, he's got decades of management ahead of him and he's got a lot more to lose than he has to gain. Hence the difficult decision.

Edited by RJ19 (09 Jan 2011 2.02am)

 

Whoever Flag Forest Hill 09 Jan 11 2.25am

Listening to that interview that Howe gave after the Plymouth game sounds to me that he as already made up his mind he just wants to let the fans down gently. I have no problem is in saying that Howe is going to be our next manager. He is just sad to be leaving a club he loves

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 09 Jan 11 2.43am

Im praying we get Howe but my main concern is how long its taking to get someone in, I know you cant just panic and put any old manager in charge but nearly half of the transfer window has gone now and we pretty much need a new defence.
Pack your suitcase Eddie and get the f*** down to Beckenham NOW. Thank you.

 

carter the eagle Flag 09 Jan 11 3.41am

Quote joe_cpfc at 09 Jan 2011 2.43am

Im praying we get Howe but my main concern is how long its taking to get someone in, I know you cant just panic and put any old manager in charge but nearly half of the transfer window has gone now and we pretty much need a new defence.
Pack your suitcase Eddie and get the f*** down to Beckenham NOW. Thank you.


Its only the 9th lol

 

money4nuffin Flag croydon 09 Jan 11 4.05am

It's been about 30 pages since I last posted so thought I'd give you lucky lot my view!

Couple of points. I think he might just be coming here, my reasons

• We ARE a bigger club. AFCB are doing well, very well indeed. But that's part of the problem. If we were in their position, in our heads we are still playing below where we believe we belong. We believe that now. And we're a league above them!

• EH has a fantastic record. I can see peoples points that if he were to take over and we got relegated it would tarnish that. Granted it's a valid point. But.... IF, and it's still an IF, AFCB were to gain promotion, they would in all seriousness go down next year. They would probably go down quite badly too. EH has worked wonders there but the gulf between L1 and the championship is massive.  Football 'experts' claim the gap in quality between league 1&2 and the Championship is quite huge. Just take into consideration the players in this league. Mostly they have some prem experience. Through loans or previous teams. Is it worse to take over a team and get relegated or to go up and get spanked every odd week and go down badly? It could go the other way totally but it's an interesting thought.

• Also on potential. AFCB might go up, might not. If they did they will be looking next year to stay in the Championship. If he came here and kept us up, we're looking at a genuine push for promotion. Youngest ever prem manager maybe?

• The other thing I picked up on, and am amazed no one else has, is he said it's a question of head v heart. So he knows which is the right decision. That's decided, it's whether he can do it. But the bit I am amazed at is in his interview he says he LOVED working for this club. Now I'm no Derren Brown mind reader superstar, but I think simple logic would say your subconscious will be controlling you in an interview that's not pre scripted. Surely if you had no intention of leaving and you are staying, you would say I LOVE working for this club. Saying you loved working for this club and players etc, you're putting the club (subconsciously) in your past....

•We know EH is loved by the fans, but I can bet your bottom dollar SP has been on recently to here, maybe under a different alias, and shown EH the excitement with our fans. Maybe not made him look at the screens but taken quoted etc about how much chat there is. Would be good knowing he has the instant, and almost 100% backing of the new fans. Also a lot of AFCB fans saying although it will hurt, they won't hold it against him..

I might be totally wrong, but it's interesting.

 


For f*cks sake Murray!!

Follow me on twitter @money4nuffin and same on ps3 (without the @ of course!)

james03 Flag Bangkok 09 Jan 11 4.22am

Quote money4nuffin at 09 Jan 2011 4.05am

It's been about 30 pages since I last posted so thought I'd give you lucky lot my view!

Couple of points. I think he might just be coming here, my reasons

• We ARE a bigger club. AFCB are doing well, very well indeed. But that's part of the problem. If we were in their position, in our heads we are still playing below where we believe we belong. We believe that now. And we're a league above them!

• EH has a fantastic record. I can see peoples points that if he were to take over and we got relegated it would tarnish that. Granted it's a valid point. But.... IF, and it's still an IF, AFCB were to gain promotion, they would in all seriousness go down next year. They would probably go down quite badly too. EH has worked wonders there but the gulf between L1 and the championship is massive.  Football 'experts' claim the gap in quality between league 1&2 and the Championship is quite huge. Just take into consideration the players in this league. Mostly they have some prem experience. Through loans or previous teams. Is it worse to take over a team and get relegated or to go up and get spanked every odd week and go down badly? It could go the other way totally but it's an interesting thought.

• Also on potential. AFCB might go up, might not. If they did they will be looking next year to stay in the Championship. If he came here and kept us up, we're looking at a genuine push for promotion. Youngest ever prem manager maybe?

• The other thing I picked up on, and am amazed no one else has, is he said it's a question of head v heart. So he knows which is the right decision. That's decided, it's whether he can do it. But the bit I am amazed at is in his interview he says he LOVED working for this club. Now I'm no Derren Brown mind reader superstar, but I think simple logic would say your subconscious will be controlling you in an interview that's not pre scripted. Surely if you had no intention of leaving and you are staying, you would say I LOVE working for this club. Saying you loved working for this club and players etc, you're putting the club (subconsciously) in your past....

•We know EH is loved by the fans, but I can bet your bottom dollar SP has been on recently to here, maybe under a different alias, and shown EH the excitement with our fans. Maybe not made him look at the screens but taken quoted etc about how much chat there is. Would be good knowing he has the instant, and almost 100% backing of the new fans. Also a lot of AFCB fans saying although it will hurt, they won't hold it against him..

I might be totally wrong, but it's interesting.


Gosh money that was all a tad cerebral wasn't it. Good luck to Howe if he comes though and we should know the answer in the next day or two.

Edited by james03 (09 Jan 2011 4.23am)

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

money4nuffin Flag croydon 09 Jan 11 4.34am

Quote james03 at 09 Jan 2011 4.22am

Quote money4nuffin at 09 Jan 2011 4.05am

Gosh money that was all a tad cerebral wasn't it. Good luck to Howe if he comes though and we should know the answer in the next day or two.

Edited by james03 (09 Jan 2011 4.23am)

No point posting without giving it some thought! I do like your comments though James, haven't heard someone say "gosh" I'm a long time!!


Edited by money4nuffin (09 Jan 2011 4.34am)

 


For f*cks sake Murray!!

Follow me on twitter @money4nuffin and same on ps3 (without the @ of course!)

james03 Flag Bangkok 09 Jan 11 4.48am

Quote sydtheeagle at 09 Jan 2011 12.58am

Quote scififan2001 at 09 Jan 2011 12.42am

He wont be coming to Palace. I'm normally right.

I think you may be right. To be honest, if I put my rose-tinted Palace spectacles to one side, if I was Howe I would take the club I truly loved up this year and then leave for a considerably better opportunity than ours in the summer. I have little doubt that a better-funded, "bigger" team will come calling if he has further success over the balance of this season. And really, if he's been offered the Palace job already but spent Saturday managing Bournemouth while we were simultaneously going out of the FA Cup, that tells me all I need to know about which way he's leaning.[/quote]

Sorry Syd but I just do not get this. He was here for an interview and, if the stories are true, was offered the job on Friday. Now I guess SP would have agreed to give him the weekend to think it over but even had he said yes on the spot he would not have been managing us yesterday for the Coventry game. He would have to return to Bornemouth, resign and say his goodbyes. At best he could have sat in the stands but what would be the benefit to us of that. I think you are slightly askew on your thinking this time.

Anyway if he is going to take the job then turning up at the beginning of the week and starting to get to know the squad, talking to Doog about what areas need strengthening urgently and preparing for the Swansea game is ideal.

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

Bubbs Flag Edinburgh 09 Jan 11 6.40am

I've got alarm bells ringing in my head over this whole situation. (maybe I need to see a psychiatrist? or is this just a symptom of following Palace for over 30 years?)

Of course it would be a great coup for the club to get such a promising young manager, but all this 'should I/shouldn't I' pondering doesn't bode well for me.

What happens if he does take the job at Palace and, as expected, we continue to struggle early on? You know what it is like taking a new job: it is very easy to look back at what you had before with rose tinted glasses, especially if you're struggling to settle in at your new place, and the pressures are tenfold what you had previously - which they most undoubtedly will be.

Do we really need someone in charge who will carry around some residue of regret of what he's left behind in the midst of a massive relegation battle? Especially if Bournemouth continue to look like they'll gain promotion.

Just watched his post match interview, and to me it looks like he has made up his mind to come to us, mainly due to not getting on with Bournemouth's owners and probably feeling more in tune with Parish, but he is obviously finding it severley painful to wrench himself away from what he's built.

This has all the hallmarks of the Dave Bassett debacle back in 1984. We had just sacked Mullery and Bassett was the rising star very much like David Howe: taking 4th division Wimbledon all the way to the 2nd tier in 3 seasons. He had a similar battle with heart and head; took the Palace job; 4 days later realised he'd made a massive mistake and ran back to Wimbledon. Thankfully as it happens, as Ron Noades turned to Coppell.

Ironically, my gut feeling is that this is what we should be doing now: turning to Coppell. After all the upheavel of the last year, the main task has to be to steady the ship; get us sitting comfortably in mid-table and then, and only then, start taking risks with young, promising lower league managers.

People underestimate the impact administration can have on a club. I felt this when we exited admin in July, and that is why I wanted the safe and knowing hands of Coppell back then, just to cradle us through to calmer waters. This is something Coppell himself realised when we came out of administration the first time back in 2000, and the reason Simon Jordan thought he was far too negative to take Palace forward. I think our last gasp survival that following season bore out Coppell's fears.

Don't get me wrong: i'm as excited as everyone to be linked with such an up and coming managerial prospect as Howe. Unfortunately, I just don't think it is good to start a new job with a heavy heart.

As a Palace fan, i'm packing his bags for him; as a friend I would be telling him to stay put.

Edited by Bubbs (09 Jan 2011 6.57am)

 


'Better stop dreaming of the quiet life 'cos it's the one we'll never know'

Pymble Wizard Flag 09 Jan 11 7.05am

Apologies if this has been covered already but has anyone given any thought to what might happen to Dougie's role as and when we appoint a new manager? As we know most successful manager's are reliant on their back room team so it is likely that if we are lucky enough to secure Howe's services he will want to bring in his own assistant. If so where does that leave DF? Thoughts?

 

kentpalacegirl Flag kent 09 Jan 11 8.22am

Yeah I was thinking about The Dougie situation last night and I would have thought by the way Eddie Howe seems to be that he would want his own staff, if it is going to be a hard enough wrench to leave surely he will feel happier with his own around, but it would be such a shame for Dougie if this does happen.

 


We are Staying up !!

maxipalace Flag in a box 09 Jan 11 9.21am

Quote Bubbs at 09 Jan 2011 6.40am

I've got alarm bells ringing in my head over this whole situation. (maybe I need to see a psychiatrist? or is this just a symptom of following Palace for over 30 years?)

Of course it would be a great coup for the club to get such a promising young manager, but all this 'should I/shouldn't I' pondering doesn't bode well for me.

What happens if he does take the job at Palace and, as expected, we continue to struggle early on? You know what it is like taking a new job: it is very easy to look back at what you had before with rose tinted glasses, especially if you're struggling to settle in at your new place, and the pressures are tenfold what you had previously - which they most undoubtedly will be.

Do we really need someone in charge who will carry around some residue of regret of what he's left behind in the midst of a massive relegation battle? Especially if Bournemouth continue to look like they'll gain promotion.

Just watched his post match interview, and to me it looks like he has made up his mind to come to us, mainly due to not getting on with Bournemouth's owners and probably feeling more in tune with Parish, but he is obviously finding it severley painful to wrench himself away from what he's built.

This has all the hallmarks of the Dave Bassett debacle back in 1984. We had just sacked Mullery and Bassett was the rising star very much like David Howe: taking 4th division Wimbledon all the way to the 2nd tier in 3 seasons. He had a similar battle with heart and head; took the Palace job; 4 days later realised he'd made a massive mistake and ran back to Wimbledon. Thankfully as it happens, as Ron Noades turned to Coppell.

Ironically, my gut feeling is that this is what we should be doing now: turning to Coppell. After all the upheavel of the last year, the main task has to be to steady the ship; get us sitting comfortably in mid-table and then, and only then, start taking risks with young, promising lower league managers.

People underestimate the impact administration can have on a club. I felt this when we exited admin in July, and that is why I wanted the safe and knowing hands of Coppell back then, just to cradle us through to calmer waters. This is something Coppell himself realised when we came out of administration the first time back in 2000, and the reason Simon Jordan thought he was far too negative to take Palace forward. I think our last gasp survival that following season bore out Coppell's fears.

Don't get me wrong: i'm as excited as everyone to be linked with such an up and coming managerial prospect as Howe. Unfortunately, I just don't think it is good to start a new job with a heavy heart.

As a Palace fan, i'm packing his bags for him; as a friend I would be telling him to stay put.

Edited by Bubbs (09 Jan 2011 6.57am)


well said, bubbs

 

Page 43 of 141 < 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Eddie Howe - Staying at AFC Bournemouth - or is he?