You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?
November 16 2026 6.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?


Page 43 of 44 < 39 40 41 42 43 44 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Jan 19 8.25am

Originally posted by kev64

A common sense post prevails , let’s blame the board for saving the club, getting promoted and staying in the PL for six season (securing a 100 m investment) and all the other behind the scenes things that have been achieved to reverse the years of decline and under investment.

I wouldn’t claim or shout about that until it happens because it may not. So far it’s just nice pictures.

 


COYP

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 30 Jan 19 9.05am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Kane on corners is unforgivable.

I know he's our manager and of course we all want him to succeed, but the level of sycophancy on here is incredible to me. It's at the level of trying to rewrite history!

He was a disaster for England and really, nothing to write home about at club level. He suits us because as a club our board's ambition matches his ability. It's a good fit.

Yes, it is. Which is why people ( like me ) are defending Hodgson.

But getting back to the original topic, I would contend that we are 3 points from the relegation zone and points wise worse off than a year ago because of the Board and their shortcomings in the transfer market. It's a results business so Roy doesn't get off scot free. But ultimately that is where I think the majority of the responsibility is.

I asked the question many pages ago on this thread - those that want Hodgson out, who would you realistically want to bring in as a replacement ? And would you replace him now ??

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 30 Jan 19 11.24am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Yes, it is. Which is why people ( like me ) are defending Hodgson.

But getting back to the original topic, I would contend that we are 3 points from the relegation zone and points wise worse off than a year ago because of the Board and their shortcomings in the transfer market. It's a results business so Roy doesn't get off scot free. But ultimately that is where I think the majority of the responsibility is.

I asked the question many pages ago on this thread - those that want Hodgson out, who would you realistically want to bring in as a replacement ? And would you replace him now ??

I've never advocated sacking Roy Hodgson, I challenged the fawning of a few who seek to promote him as one of the best England manager of all time now that he's our manager.

I've been critical of his inflexibility in games, unclear tactcs behind substitutions and their timing.

I agree that the board is to blame and echo your surmise, although that said I'm actually encouraged by this window because for once it looks like there's a strategy: clearing out the dead wood and getting the wage bill down. The overall model appears to be to tread water which I personally think is the wrong approach long term, but I suppose that's a different debate.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 30 Jan 19 1.11pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

I've never advocated sacking Roy Hodgson, I challenged the fawning of a few who seek to promote him as one of the best England manager of all time now that he's our manager.

I've been critical of his inflexibility in games, unclear tactcs behind substitutions and their timing.

I agree that the board is to blame and echo your surmise, although that said I'm actually encouraged by this window because for once it looks like there's a strategy: clearing out the dead wood and getting the wage bill down. The overall model appears to be to tread water which I personally think is the wrong approach long term, but I suppose that's a different debate.


Although on the back foot against the big sides we do now play football don't we, we no longer hoooof ball at every opportunity..even against the big sides.

Performances wise we are and have improved apart from a few games like home Southampton ..although we still in that game had opportunities with our old keeper McCarthy motm to stop us, so I feel to say we are just treading water is unfair to the club.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 30 Jan 19 1.52pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink


Although on the back foot against the big sides we do now play football don't we, we no longer hoooof ball at every opportunity..even against the big sides.

Performances wise we are and have improved apart from a few games like home Southampton ..although we still in that game had opportunities with our old keeper McCarthy motm to stop us, so I feel to say we are just treading water is unfair to the club.

Apart from a few games?

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 30 Jan 19 6.03pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Apart from a few games?

Everyone went on about the Chelsea game didn't they, I never saw the game but apparently we allowed them to take control and we only tried in the dying minutes, but of course Chelsea on a good day ...

..or do you mean is that all?

Edited by Tickled pink (30 Jan 2019 6.06pm)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 30 Jan 19 6.14pm

Unfortunately there appears to be no ambition. A pity, because this part of the world has a lot to offer. I suspect Parish wants off. The new stand will never happen, and the fact that the playing staff is being reduced says it all.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 30 Jan 19 7.15pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Everyone went on about the Chelsea game didn't they, I never saw the game but apparently we allowed them to take control and we only tried in the dying minutes, but of course Chelsea on a good day ...

..or do you mean is that all?

Edited by Tickled pink (30 Jan 2019 6.06pm)

No, I meant: only a few?

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 31 Jan 19 3.56am

It’s a bit of both.

In Hodgsons post game comments he seemed to me to have a dig at parish and freedman over transfers. You have to wonder about someone like Meyer, he clearly isn’t fancied by the manager so why did we sign him? Parish thought, it’s a free, so no downside. What would be better would be giving the manager the players he wants to play in his side,

As for Hodgson he really is a mixed bag. He is terribly predictable and just cannot make decsisve personnel or tactical changes during games which is terribly frustrating as we lose points from winning positions time and again.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Midlands Eagle Flag 31 Jan 19 6.04am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

You have to wonder about someone like Meyer, he clearly isn’t fancied by the manager so why did we sign him? Parish thought, it’s a free, so no downside.

Parish has gone on record as saying that there isn't a downside which I assume meant that he could get a good fee for him if he didn't work out here

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 31 Jan 19 7.01am

Is there really any point in signing anyone today? Does anyone truly believe Roy will utilise them? Bloody frustrating

 

taylors lovechild Flag 31 Jan 19 8.44am

I'm not really against Parish/the board or Hodgson and think we are doing ok and but for a bit of luck would be a place or two higher; however, Hodgson in his diplomatic way has clearly alluded to the fact that the club pick the players that are signed and he increasingly seems to be distancing himself from the transfer side of things. He also seems to be showing signs of frustration that we are shipping people out but not bringing any in.

I am curious as to what the club's long-term plan is? Are we looking to sign players to fit Roy's game plan (Sako fits that bill) or are we clearing the decks with one eye on the summer and a new beginning, possibly under a new manager? At Roy's age he is not going to be building a football dynasty at Palace, so perhaps the club think we have enough to consolidate this season? If no one gets injured we probably have, but it's a risk and I feel for Roy that since coming in he has seen little investment in the squad. Apparently there are issues around broadcasting contracts which is a big reason why clubs have been less active this January, and is possibly another reason why we've been quiet.


Hopefully come 11pm both Roy and I will be surprised and happy with the day's events, but I am not holding much hope.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 31 Jan 19 8.52am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Parish has gone on record as saying that there isn't a downside which I assume meant that he could get a good fee for him if he didn't work out here

Our business decisions on players aren’t turning out to be very good ones, and that’s because the scouting or decision makers aren’t up to the job. Murray and Meyer spring to mind and a lot of this stems from ex Palace players without the experience or ability making them.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 31 Jan 19 8.56am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

It’s a bit of both.

In Hodgsons post game comments he seemed to me to have a dig at parish and freedman over transfers. You have to wonder about someone like Meyer, he clearly isn’t fancied by the manager so why did we sign him? Parish thought, it’s a free, so no downside. What would be better would be giving the manager the players he wants to play in his side,

As for Hodgson he really is a mixed bag. He is terribly predictable and just cannot make decsisve personnel or tactical changes during games which is terribly frustrating as we lose points from winning positions time and again.

I’m bored with Hodgson but it won’t be forever, or will it? Parish would love it to be.

 


COYP

Maine Eagle Flag USA 31 Jan 19 1.07pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Parish has gone on record as saying that there isn't a downside which I assume meant that he could get a good fee for him if he didn't work out here

Trying to command a nice fee for a player bereft of confidence who hasn’t played much might be harder than Parish thinks, and Meyer will do a Riedewald and reject any kind of club he doesn’t fancy.

The downside to signing players the manager doesn’t fancy is it never works out. Meyer has to hope a new manager comes in over the summer for a fresh start.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 31 Jan 19 1.10pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I’m bored with Hodgson but it won’t be forever, or will it? Parish would love it to be.

I don’t think Hodgson will be fired.

If it becomes fairly nailed on that we are going down, AND there is enough time left to make a change and actually turn it around, then it’s still only a maybe.

This would be handled more like Pardew than FDB - long drawn out affair with the sacking coming far too late.

However if Hodgson retires - not an Allardyce type retirement, but a real one, then anything is possible.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

jeeagles Flag 31 Jan 19 4.38pm

How many times after a game can he say:

"I thought we deserved 3 points today"

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 01 Feb 19 8.13am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Well said.

You would say that with your narrow view, as i said to you, there is more to international football than just tournaments,but you cam only judge him on tournaments.
I already proved to you that his OVERALL record as manager of England is the 4th best of 17, but you keep reverting back to his tournament record because you can't accept that you were proved wrong when you said "he is the worst manager England ever had"

 

Painter Flag Croydon 01 Feb 19 8.49am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I’m bored with Hodgson but it won’t be forever, or will it? Parish would love it to be.

You maybe bored with Hodgson, but the majority aren’t.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 01 Feb 19 9.35am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

You would say that with your narrow view, as i said to you, there is more to international football than just tournaments,but you cam only judge him on tournaments.
I already proved to you that his OVERALL record as manager of England is the 4th best of 17, but you keep reverting back to his tournament record because you can't accept that you were proved wrong when you said "he is the worst manager England ever had"

No you didn't. You excluded managers to manipulate the figures to support your inaccurate statement.

Even so, you could only get him to 4th, which is a big climb down from the best ever.

As for narrow views, that's a bit rich coming from someone so single minded about Hodgson being a superb manager when empirically, he isn't.

Edited by Midlands Eagle (17 Aug 2019 5.42am)

 

Page 43 of 44 < 39 40 41 42 43 44 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?