Quote Bubbs at 09 Jan 2011 6.40am
I've got alarm bells ringing in my head over this whole situation. (maybe I need to see a psychiatrist? or is this just a symptom of following Palace for over 30 years?)
Of course it would be a great coup for the club to get such a promising young manager, but all this 'should I/shouldn't I' pondering doesn't bode well for me.
What happens if he does take the job at Palace and, as expected, we continue to struggle early on? You know what it is like taking a new job: it is very easy to look back at what you had before with rose tinted glasses, especially if you're struggling to settle in at your new place, and the pressures are tenfold what you had previously - which they most undoubtedly will be.
Do we really need someone in charge who will carry around some residue of regret of what he's left behind in the midst of a massive relegation battle? Especially if Bournemouth continue to look like they'll gain promotion.
Just watched his post match interview, and to me it looks like he has made up his mind to come to us, mainly due to not getting on with Bournemouth's owners and probably feeling more in tune with Parish, but he is obviously finding it severley painful to wrench himself away from what he's built.
This has all the hallmarks of the Dave Bassett debacle back in 1984. We had just sacked Mullery and Bassett was the rising star very much like David Howe: taking 4th division Wimbledon all the way to the 2nd tier in 3 seasons. He had a similar battle with heart and head; took the Palace job; 4 days later realised he'd made a massive mistake and ran back to Wimbledon. Thankfully as it happens, as Ron Noades turned to Coppell.
Ironically, my gut feeling is that this is what we should be doing now: turning to Coppell. After all the upheavel of the last year, the main task has to be to steady the ship; get us sitting comfortably in mid-table and then, and only then, start taking risks with young, promising lower league managers.
People underestimate the impact administration can have on a club. I felt this when we exited admin in July, and that is why I wanted the safe and knowing hands of Coppell back then, just to cradle us through to calmer waters. This is something Coppell himself realised when we came out of administration the first time back in 2000, and the reason Simon Jordan thought he was far too negative to take Palace forward. I think our last gasp survival that following season bore out Coppell's fears.
Don't get me wrong: i'm as excited as everyone to be linked with such an up and coming managerial prospect as Howe. Unfortunately, I just don't think it is good to start a new job with a heavy heart.
As a Palace fan, i'm packing his bags for him; as a friend I would be telling him to stay put.
Edited by Bubbs (09 Jan 2011 6.57am)
Excellent post...I remember those Bassett days...he had barely drunk his first cup of tea at Mitcham Training Ground on his first day when he decided he'd had enough.
All I would say is he has to look at this possible new position as a long term project. If he is able to bring success in keeping us up it will see him firmly established as one of the countrys brightest young managers (which he already is) but at a potentially bigger Club who in my unbiased view have all the attributes to push for promotion in the next season or two. I think when you leave somewhere after being there for a long time you will always miss it to an extent but there comes a time when you must look forward for your own career and take the next step. My only concern would be his lack of knowledge of the Championship although GB had that by the bucketload and look where that has left us so maybe not such a bad thing. As for his age, remember Steve Coppell was two months short of 29 when he took over for the first time. In the light of this, I would love to have Steve as a Technical Director to mentor Eddie..that would be a management dream team!
We love you,we love you,we love you and where you play we follow,we follow,we follow, cos we support the Palace, the Palace,the Palace and thats the way we like it,we like,we like it...WOAH,WOAH,WOAH!!!
A winner is a dreamer who never gives up...