You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
October 30 2026 6.59am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Brexit Thread (LOCKED)


Page 44 of 1552 < 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 >
JohnyBoy Flag 08 May 16 10.55am

Originally posted by davenotamonkey

“There’s absolutely no connection between the peace process and the European Union ... I think this is just scaremongering.”

“Well, nobody’s actually spelt out [the alleged threat to peace] – they go around saying it would cause a problem, but they haven’t said how it would cause a problem.

“I do not see that there is a problem, and I’d love to see people pointing out just what the difficulty is.

“I think it’s just grabbing at anything they can find to try and make an argument.”

-- Lord David Trimble, former First Minister of Northern Ireland, Chairman of the Good Friday Agreement, recipient of the Nobel peace prize for his important role in the GFA negotiations.

I think these quotes epitomise the Remain campaign in a nutshell: non-specific threats and scaremongering, fear of what "might" happen based on either clear misinformation or selective reporting of events (as was very evident in the taxpayer-funded "leaflet".

With respect, and i do have respect for Lord Trimble because of his deklerk moment in securing the peace, but your claim would have considerably more weight had it come from a nationalist source let alone the more hardline republicans.....but surely we can all see that if the EHRA is replaced with a BRITISH bill of rights this may cause issues and whilst its easy to say to republicans "tough luck we are still British" it just will not be acceptable.....and so all the sh@t starts again....this just seems naive to me

 

Hoof Hearted 08 May 16 11.16am

Originally posted by JohnyBoy

With respect, and i do have respect for Lord Trimble because of his deklerk moment in securing the peace, but your claim would have considerably more weight had it come from a nationalist source let alone the more hardline republicans.....but surely we can all see that if the EHRA is replaced with a BRITISH bill of rights this may cause issues and whilst its easy to say to republicans "tough luck we are still British" it just will not be acceptable.....and so all the sh@t starts again....this just seems naive to me

Johnny and Dave...

The Good Friday agreement and NI must be one of the most obscure arguments hanging on the result of the EU referendum for most on here.... obviously those from NI or with relatives may be interested.

Why are you both wasting so much time on it?

Leif is complaining about "Muppets" not taking much onto account to decide out or in, but you two are discussing irrelevant minutiae FFS

 

JohnyBoy Flag 08 May 16 11.21am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Johnny and Dave...

The Good Friday agreement and NI must be one of the most obscure arguments hanging on the result of the EU referendum for most on here.... obviously those from NI or with relatives may be interested.

Why are you both wasting so much time on it?

Leif is complaining about "Muppets" not taking much onto account to decide out or in, but you two are discussing irrelevant minutiae FFS

You know what Hoof, you are right, its all too irrelevant and tiresome for a sunday morning....i'm off to enjoy the sunshine and suggest you all do the same

 

Hoof Hearted 08 May 16 11.29am

Originally posted by JohnyBoy

You know what Hoof, you are right, its all too irrelevant and tiresome for a sunday morning....i'm off to enjoy the sunshine and suggest you all do the same

I'm out of here right now Johnny!

Enjoy your day mate!

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 09 May 16 9.32am

Has there ever been a more blatant piece of scaremongering by David buffoon this morning, he's going on about if we pull out of the EU, there is a real prospect of war !!! They must getting worried that the out campaign is gaining momentum to resort to mentioning the battle of Britain as a reason to stay in the EU.

Cameron you utter long piece.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 May 16 10.04am

Originally posted by dannyh

Has there ever been a more blatant piece of scaremongering by David buffoon this morning, he's going on about if we pull out of the EU, there is a real prospect of war !!! They must getting worried that the out campaign is gaining momentum to resort to mentioning the battle of Britain as a reason to stay in the EU.

Cameron you utter long piece.

Indeed, this kind of political fear mongering is a disgrace to the idea of democracy. Nothing is sadder than watching highly educated and capable individuals stoop to base oratory. Next it'll be justification through rhetorical arguments and so on.

In fact arguably, I don't believe that the political parties and media should even be commenting on the in or out vote, or trying to sway opinion, in an referendum as its a vote of the people themselves, and not decided by their representatives.

Personally, I'm more inclined to an out, primarily because it gives the UK several options in terms of changing society to societies benefit and because ultimately it also delivers the best option for entirely redefining the idea of a 'European Union' in the future.

I don't think that the idea of the EU is necessarily fundamentally bad across the board; only it needs to be defined, in my opinion, not as a means of directing European countries towards corporate agendas, but delivering shared needs from a union that could benefit countries as a whole; rather than exploiting them for the benefit of a minority of another.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 May 16 10.15am

Originally posted by leifandersonshair

Those stupid and ill informed enough to not even know when a crucial vote is suggests they have no clue about the arguments- they've probably made up their minds because they 'don't want any more foreigners here' and will ignore any facts, on both sides.

I'm not saying you're wrong, merely that it's depressing such muppets could make a difference!

This is what makes democracy works, no one decides who can and cannot have a say (well more or less, as Prisoners and members of the Lords make up the core can't vote - for the most part even the mentally ill get to vote).

Because its the only way to ensure that the people are represented in a democracy, to give every citizen the vote.

The only problem now, is that the system is rigged to make some votes count less than others, based on where you live. But that's a different question.

Proportional representation, and were about as close to democratic ideals as you can get without having a referendum on every subject (which technologically speaking is viable).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 09 May 16 10.40am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Personally, I'm more inclined to an out, primarily because it gives the UK several options in terms of changing society to societies benefit and because ultimately it also delivers the best option for entirely redefining the idea of a 'European Union' in the future.

I think if the out vote wins... the rest of the EU will wake up and realise what is going on.

A vote to stay in will only make the EU worse... a sort of "Mandate" for them to take things further and get us to pay!

I would be all for the EU if it was reformed and fair.

At the moment we are paying far more than every other member nation in % terms (and will continue to do so whilst our economy does better than the EU). Also we cannot sustain immigration levels at the rate they are arriving. Geographically there is a limit on space and infrastructure that has probably been exceeded already.

The idea of the EU doesn't faze me at all, but the experience is not acceptable and we must vote out to reshape our future.

 

johnfirewall Flag 09 May 16 11.34am

The security argument is back out again.

Yes the intelligence has likely stopped a few potential terrorists entering but apparently offered us no visibility of Lithunian criminal records, not that we'd be able to deny entry to convicted murderers anyway.

 

johnfirewall Flag 09 May 16 12.02pm

The European Convention on Human Rights does mean we can't can't talk about Hugh bonneville, though.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 May 16 12.12pm

Originally posted by johnfirewall

The security argument is back out again.

Yes the intelligence has likely stopped a few potential terrorists entering but apparently offered us no visibility of Lithunian criminal records, not that we'd be able to deny entry to convicted murderers anyway.

Neither is true, because the EU doesn't have its own intelligence agency, that connects the national agencies of each country. Which it really should, possibly along with a 'federal' agency for law enforcement (for crimes with cross national or multi-national jurisdictions).

Problems like human trafficking can't really be resolved nationally and internationally at present without a great endeavour and running into different legal requirements in different countries (and different priorities in those countries).

These probably are two real functions that the EU requires, effectively a law enforcement arm and intelligence services. The current relationship between intelligence services is pretty poor in terms of national intelligence, but good in terms of foreign intelligence.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 May 16 12.23pm

Originally posted by johnfirewall

The security argument is back out again.

Yes the intelligence has likely stopped a few potential terrorists entering but apparently offered us no visibility of Lithunian criminal records, not that we'd be able to deny entry to convicted murderers anyway.

The truth is a bit more complicated. The UK collects data on criminal records internationally, but the existing system of passport control was not sufficiently robust to maintain an index, largely due to the failure of the e-borders project meaning that the UK passport control system, in 2014, was the same system due to be replaced in 1996 (in fact it couldn't handle searches on whole names.

The UK as such, had problems when it came to Free movement, because it was possible to find details of undesirables on visa applications, this wasn't possible with the technology in service for border control.

Of course obtaining the data on criminal records and then translating them into a warning index to run on border and passport control is itself as difficult as the source in which the data is made available (as it has to be sanitised, translated and then migrated into the format for the system).

I know this, because I helped rescue a project that effectively made the new system viable within the updated home office systems. Of course the problem now is that you have to obtain, translate, sanitise and migrate the criminal records of each EU member state going back at least 25 years. Which is an expensive undertaking (bear in mind some of these may well be entirely manual systems).

Where the EU would have been more astute, would have been implementing a project for the rationalisation of the its member states into a single solution defined for and shared by member countries; which included internal border controls and monitoring.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 09 May 16 1.06pm

I've been undecided but having heard Cameron say that to vote out risks a war has made my mind up. I've long thought that a good war is the only way to sort the whole mess out and we can all go back and start again, so I'm voting out.

Bit like pressing Ctrl Alt Del on your computer.

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

davenotamonkey Flag 09 May 16 1.14pm

Originally posted by JohnyBoy

With respect, and i do have respect for Lord Trimble because of his deklerk moment in securing the peace, but your claim would have considerably more weight had it come from a nationalist source let alone the more hardline republicans.....but surely we can all see that if the EHRA is replaced with a BRITISH bill of rights this may cause issues and whilst its easy to say to republicans "tough luck we are still British" it just will not be acceptable.....and so all the sh@t starts again....this just seems naive to me

I make no "claim" - I am quoting verbatim the words of one of the (if not the) most instrumental players in the GFA. Feel free to disregard what he says then. What does he know, after all.

 

davenotamonkey Flag 09 May 16 1.15pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Johnny and Dave...

The Good Friday agreement and NI must be one of the most obscure arguments hanging on the result of the EU referendum for most on here.... obviously those from NI or with relatives may be interested.

Why are you both wasting so much time on it?

Leif is complaining about "Muppets" not taking much onto account to decide out or in, but you two are discussing irrelevant minutiae FFS

Indeed - it's merely one in the myriad Brexit scare-stories concocted by these pro-EU nutters. It's all irrelevant when (apparently) WW3 is coming if we leave.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 May 16 1.17pm

Originally posted by mezzer

I've been undecided but having heard Cameron say that to vote out risks a war has made my mind up. I've long thought that a good war is the only way to sort the whole mess out and we can all go back and start again, so I'm voting out.

Bit like pressing Ctrl Alt Del on your computer.

I'd argue that a war among the European nations, on the scale of WWII, would be more like using something like format c:*.* but yeah...

Also, the EU has nothing to do with the prevention of war in Europe, arguably the establishment of the lasting piece was the threat of the soviet union.

Common enemies tend to be greater forces for peace, than even mutual benefit. Its usually how mutual benefit comes about.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 May 16 1.22pm

Originally posted by davenotamonkey

Indeed - it's merely one in the myriad Brexit scare-stories concocted by these pro-EU nutters. It's all irrelevant when (apparently) WW3 is coming if we leave.

According to them, the end of the world is nigh and there will an immediate cessation of trade with the EU if we leave !!!!

 

BelfastEagle Flag 09 May 16 1.35pm

If we leave it's possible to plunge Europe into WW3 , the four horsemen will appear and it will be end of days.

 

JohnyBoy Flag 09 May 16 2.19pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

I think if the out vote wins... the rest of the EU will wake up and realise what is going on.

A vote to stay in will only make the EU worse... a sort of "Mandate" for them to take things further and get us to pay!

I would be all for the EU if it was reformed and fair.

At the moment we are paying far more than every other member nation in % terms (and will continue to do so whilst our economy does better than the EU). Also we cannot sustain immigration levels at the rate they are arriving. Geographically there is a limit on space and infrastructure that has probably been exceeded already.

The idea of the EU doesn't faze me at all, but the experience is not acceptable and we must vote out to reshape our future.

Ah it was such a splendid sunday afternoon enjoying the sunshine with Hoof. We know we are just footsoldiers for our respective causes so things could remain cordial for one day only. I explained to him that doing an economics degree wasnt entirely useless and indeed i learned some valuable life skills, like pool sharking, lighting farts and being able to drink a pint of bitter in 2.5 seconds. Hoof nodded in approval. I also commented that i didnt receive one bet for my compelling offer of 50 lap dances if any of his regiment could say that 99% of their DAY TO DAY legal stuff is not covered by uk law, but not even a single punt even from the more vocal members of the regiment including cucking, davemonkey, willo and Dannyh. "Them blo$dy english! Just cant rely on em" He hoofed. "You cant say THAT, i protested, thats bigoted" to which he replied "dont be a t*** johnyboy" er ok then but does this mean that there is a possibility you will become a Brighton supporter? Or perhaps danny, davemonkey, willo and cucking are softening towards the remain campaign? Hoof remained eerily silent.
We knew however that the sunny sunday could not last and that we had to return to our trenches the next day when talk of war would no doubt reemerge because some of us truly believe that the eu, with trade inderdependency, diplomacy and a shared economically prosperous future has led to the longest period of european peacetime - 80 YEARS! the longest of the last millenia (i accept i will be corrected on this one). As i left i understood that Hoof would be trying to get me in a half nelson, or beating seven bells of cyber stuffing out of me the next, "its all for King and country, you understand Johnyboy" hoof called out. "Yeh i understand hoof" i shrugged resigned to the knowledge that even with the impending threat of war announced by HIS prime-minister this morning, the real threat of Brexit still exists

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 May 16 2.33pm

Originally posted by JohnyBoy


perhaps danny, davemonkey, willo and cucking are softening towards the remain campaign?


Absolutely NOT.

I am firmly in the "Brexit" camp and my position is entrenched.

 

Page 44 of 1552 < 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic