You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 8.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 46 of 71 < 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 19 Nov 18 7.35pm

I had a response from Paul McGowan this evening

It simply said come and see seats in rows 1 to 6

It did not respond at all to the points I raised

I said the following:

I am not interested in seeing another seat Paul, I shall stay in my current seat and sing. I have already told you this twice but it feels like I am talking and emailing into a black hole.

This is my final response to you. Either you start talking to me or I shall find another outlet for my views.

The whole process has been a debacle. Please let me know the following, I am asking for the third time:

1. What are the terms and conditions of my season ticket, which is pre-paid for next year
2. How you intend to allocate the tickets in E Block for next season
3. What equal opportunities analysis have you undertaken.

To be clear, I wish to stay in my seat. There are multiple reasons why I consider this a reasonable request and I have no intentions of accepting an alternative solution.

Please feel free to call me

Thank you


I also copied Steve Parish and Phil Alexander, I don't know if I got their email addresses correct.

I am now deeply losing my sense of humour.

Edited by Mapletree (19 Nov 2018 7.36pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Nov 18 7.40pm

Originally posted by rach_cpfc

Piss-up in a brewery...…

Have you had a reply now?

You’re right there.

 


COYP

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 19 Nov 18 7.41pm

.

Edited by Dean_CPFC (19 Nov 2018 7.41pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Nov 18 7.42pm

Originally posted by rach_cpfc

Piss-up in a brewery...…

Have you had a reply now?

You’re right there. And people have been defending the club on this thread, questioning how I can say that CPFC, with whichever year after it, has a history of incompetence or poor service. Tickets, season tickets, kits, you name it.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Nov 18 7.55pm

Originally posted by premier fan

berk = c**t
blimey, never knew that, I had to google it... all those years my Dad called me a berk. If I'd had told my mum she'd have gone berserk LOL!!

You learn something everyday on here...

Berk is an idiot. Cvnt on its own is a nasty, horrible person. He may have got confused with ‘’you stupid cvnt’, thinking it’s the same as berk.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (19 Nov 2018 8.05pm)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Nov 18 7.58pm

Originally posted by est1905

They're not tired arguments. They just seem tired because he repeats himself. The reason he finds himself having to repeat himself is that you and people like you on here wont debatte his points because you know he has some very valid and fair ones.
And like a child does when losing an argument you simply ignore his points and dismiss them as 'tired old arguments'

Puncture repair man doesn’t debate valid points. He froths at the mouth over it happening, daily. That’s been the case for weeks and adds nothing. The situation and negotiations have all moved onto other considerations.

 


COYP

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 19 Nov 18 8.33pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Berk is an idiot. Cvnt on its own is a nasty, horrible person. He may have got confused with ‘’you stupid cvnt’, thinking it’s the same as berk.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (19 Nov 2018 8.05pm)

A little off topic, I’ve always known a berk to be cockney slang for a Berkshire Hunt ... c**t.

Anyway, as you were.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 19 Nov 18 8.54pm

Berkeley Hunt

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Nov 18 9.08pm

It seems the meaning of the terms have changed. I’ve never known Cvnt to mean stupid. When fans had a go at Salah, ‘’They didn’t sung ‘’Salah you’re a cvnt’’ because they thought he’s stupid but they believed he was out of order and doing them over.

062E0504-2B81-4A5B-8DB0-12E530BD97FF.jpeg Attachment: 062E0504-2B81-4A5B-8DB0-12E530BD97FF.jpeg (98.78Kb)

 


COYP

dreamwaverider Flag London 19 Nov 18 10.46pm

Originally posted by becky

It has been mentioned before. That move was made to separate away fans from the most vocal home fans, and reduce the possibility of it all kicking off between the two sets ( rare, but not entirely unknown). This then meant that the internal security could be undertaken by club stewards, rather than having to pay the massive costs for policing inside the ground as well as outside.

As I recall things, the HF adopted block B To be next to

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 19 Nov 18 11.09pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

As I recall things, the HF adopted block B To be next to

I’ll try again........
The HF adopted block B to be next to the away fans to taunt them. They were sandwiched between the HF and the singing section of the AW. When they were moved to the other end of the AW , the AW singing section spread down towards the Homesdale.
The singing section at Selhurst was originally on the half way line in the old Park Road stand. When the AW got built a section emerged behind the goal on the Homesdale but with no cover, the noise was lost except for really big days.
Then the AW re emerged in the standing section on the halfway line. So we had two singing sections. By default, the two groups kind of merged when the away fans were moved in the AW.
The AW has always been louder because firstly it’s better covered and secondly loads more sing in there. For the Homesdale to get loud it needs the top tier to sing which happens on occasions and then it’s noisy.
The HF became like a song leader in block B which the AW seemed to follow. This season the HF spat its dummy out and vaporised.
They have literally disappeared without trace..
I see two issues moving forward. Firstly there is no guarantee that they will re emerge behind the goal. Secondly there is no certainty they will harmonise from there with the AW choir due to the distance.
And the finally there is clearly a lot of bad blood being generated which is really bad news all round.
Where the HF have gone is anyone’s guess. To be honest I am really disappointed at their approach to this and the club’s. Although I admire the noise they make I am amazed by their disappearing act.
Personally I sit in block X of the AW but hell I would be just as happy to be back in the Homesdale rather than absent.
My love of attending Selhurst is far greater than some dispute about where I am in the ground. Over the years I have watched from all parts of all sides.
I don’t have a solution to what is becoming a very messy affair, but I hope this history lesson may add some thoughts to the situation.

 

bicycle repair man 19 Nov 18 11.33pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I’ll try again........
The HF adopted block B to be next to the away fans to taunt them. They were sandwiched between the HF and the singing section of the AW. When they were moved to the other end of the AW , the AW singing section spread down towards the Homesdale.
The singing section at Selhurst was originally on the half way line in the old Park Road stand. When the AW got built a section emerged behind the goal on the Homesdale but with no cover, the noise was lost except for really big days.
Then the AW re emerged in the standing section on the halfway line. So we had two singing sections. By default, the two groups kind of merged when the away fans were moved in the AW.
The AW has always been louder because firstly it’s better covered and secondly loads more sing in there. For the Homesdale to get loud it needs the top tier to sing which happens on occasions and then it’s noisy.
The HF became like a song leader in block B which the AW seemed to follow. This season the HF spat its dummy out and vaporised.
They have literally disappeared without trace..
I see two issues moving forward. Firstly there is no guarantee that they will re emerge behind the goal. Secondly there is no certainty they will harmonise from there with the AW choir due to the distance.
And the finally there is clearly a lot of bad blood being generated which is really bad news all round.
Where the HF have gone is anyone’s guess. To be honest I am really disappointed at their approach to this and the club’s. Although I admire the noise they make I am amazed by their disappearing act.
Personally I sit in block X of the AW but hell I would be just as happy to be back in the Homesdale rather than absent.
My love of attending Selhurst is far greater than some dispute about where I am in the ground. Over the years I have watched from all parts of all sides.
I don’t have a solution to what is becoming a very messy affair, but I hope this history lesson may add some thoughts to the situation.

A rarity,a well thought out,nicely composed,intelligent post.


Edited by bicycle repair man (19 Nov 2018 11.34pm)

 

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 19 Nov 18 11.36pm

Originally posted by premier fan

berk = c**t
blimey, never knew that, I had to google it... all those years my Dad called me a berk. If I'd had told my mum she'd have gone berserk LOL!!

You learn something everyday on here...

Berkenhead hunt..... Never been but apparently it's a hunt in Berkenhead... Funny that &#128514;

Hunt .. well we know what that is
Berk ... That's the Cockney bit

So to call someone a Berk is calling them a C....T


As for this singing section.... Load of Berks &#128514;&#128514;

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 20 Nov 18 8.15am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I’ll try again........
The HF adopted block B to be next to the away fans to taunt them. They were sandwiched between the HF and the singing section of the AW. When they were moved to the other end of the AW , the AW singing section spread down towards the Homesdale.
The singing section at Selhurst was originally on the half way line in the old Park Road stand. When the AW got built a section emerged behind the goal on the Homesdale but with no cover, the noise was lost except for really big days.
Then the AW re emerged in the standing section on the halfway line. So we had two singing sections. By default, the two groups kind of merged when the away fans were moved in the AW.
The AW has always been louder because firstly it’s better covered and secondly loads more sing in there. For the Homesdale to get loud it needs the top tier to sing which happens on occasions and then it’s noisy.
The HF became like a song leader in block B which the AW seemed to follow. This season the HF spat its dummy out and vaporised.
They have literally disappeared without trace..
I see two issues moving forward. Firstly there is no guarantee that they will re emerge behind the goal. Secondly there is no certainty they will harmonise from there with the AW choir due to the distance.
And the finally there is clearly a lot of bad blood being generated which is really bad news all round.
Where the HF have gone is anyone’s guess. To be honest I am really disappointed at their approach to this and the club’s. Although I admire the noise they make I am amazed by their disappearing act.
Personally I sit in block X of the AW but hell I would be just as happy to be back in the Homesdale rather than absent.
My love of attending Selhurst is far greater than some dispute about where I am in the ground. Over the years I have watched from all parts of all sides.
I don’t have a solution to what is becoming a very messy affair, but I hope this history lesson may add some thoughts to the situation.

Top post. A hundred noisy berks have the say over the whole club? Parish, hang your head in shame.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Nov 18 8.24am

We must remember to call opposition players berks seeing as it means the same as Cvnt. Somehow I think not. The meaning or intention of calling someone a Cvnt is not what it was.

 


COYP

beagle Flag pom tiddly om pom pom 20 Nov 18 8.31am

Originally posted by aquickgame2

Berkenhead hunt..... Never been but apparently it's a hunt in Berkenhead... Funny that &#128514;

Hunt .. well we know what that is
Berk ... That's the Cockney bit

So to call someone a Berk is calling them a C....T


As for this singing section.... Load of Berks &#128514;&#128514;

Dont think its the Berkenhead (sp Birkenhead?) Hunt - More likely to be the Berkeley hunt, which, Im told, is one of the oldest.

 


When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep.
Not screaming and terrified.
Like his passengers.

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 20 Nov 18 3.01pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

A rarity,a well thought out,nicely composed,intelligent post.


Edited by bicycle repair man (19 Nov 2018 11.34pm)

You should try it some time.

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 20 Nov 18 3.07pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Top post. A hundred noisy berks have the say over the whole club? Parish, hang your head in shame.

The whole Club ??? more like a few hundred people who will have to move seats. Whole club ??? honestly the amount of exaggeration and self interest over atmosphere is astounding.

Parish is doing what he thinks is best for the club and I'm not alone in thinking that overall (as long as the elderly and vulnerable are looked after) he has made the right choice. he was never going to please everyone, so he chose to go with the fans that make the most noise etc etc.

Well Done SP. Hopefully the same thought process will leach into his transfer dealings and we stop signing shyte and vent Freedman.

Hang your head in shame ?! good grief

 

bicycle repair man 20 Nov 18 3.35pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

You should try it some time.


Hee,hee,I can hardly type for laughing !
That's brilliant coming from someone who's debating skills consist of hurling insults and name calling.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 20 Nov 18 3.45pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

The whole Club ??? more like a few hundred people who will have to move seats. Whole club ??? honestly the amount of exaggeration and self interest over atmosphere is astounding.

Parish is doing what he thinks is best for the club and I'm not alone in thinking that overall (as long as the elderly and vulnerable are looked after) he has made the right choice. he was never going to please everyone, so he chose to go with the fans that make the most noise etc etc.

Well Done SP. Hopefully the same thought process will leach into his transfer dealings and we stop signing shyte and vent Freedman.

Hang your head in shame ?! good grief

Parish has made the only choice he could. He has to try to maintain the atmosphere in the ground and the unique elements the HF bring. Its a business.

"Well done SP"? More like medium rare. I wont go praising Parish just yet, he showed once again, how not to handle a situation. Took way too long, kept people in the dark, made a half hearted decision then went back on it at the first sign of trouble.

If thats the way you want him to run transfers, you already have your wish! See Niasse, Oumar.........

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Page 46 of 71 < 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic