You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 21 2026 10.43pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 5 of 44 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
wearegoingup Flag 02 Dec 16 11.34am

Originally posted by 7mins

The one thing I will say. This is driven by DfT. A senior DfT employee went rogue at a meeting and let slip that he wanted to crush the union. My old boss went mental. They didn't want the unions warned. The changes will make the railway less safe... how much do is subjective. Passenger numbers have doubled and cutting safety staff by 50% at the same time was a big ask. For us the RSSB was the big problem, but they seemed to have sorted it.


My opinion. Guards and drivers are right... the company know it. Anything that makes the railway less safe is going to be a hard sell. Southern will try dirty tricks, they will tell managers to go "hard" on staff. Southern will try to use media to water down changes. I've sat in meetings where I've heard top managers tell middle management to target union reps. I don't think the guards will win. This is coming from the DfT... it's almost ideological. If drivers go out, it may change things... they hold power, and management fvcking hate them because of it.

They aren't cutting safety staff by 50% though are they, Govia guaranteed they'd keep the same numbe of staff on trains until the end of the franchise, they're just changing their roles so they don't close the doors. This is how countless trains and operators already run so if it's unsafe, why are they allowed to do it?

In my opinion, it's got very little to do with safety and a lot to do with conductors, and their unions, having significantly less power and influence under the DOO system.

I also think Southern are also a a shambles by the way but its unacceptable how we, the commuters, are caught in the middle of this and are having our lives severely disrupted because of it. We are a captive audience who have no choice but to use their services, unless we change jobs which is not something people should have to consider simply because there's an argument over who closes the bloody train doors.

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 02 Dec 16 11.36am

It's right.

 


@sxp55555

7mins Flag In the bush 02 Dec 16 11.43am

Originally posted by wearegoingup

They aren't cutting safety staff by 50% though are they, Govia guaranteed they'd keep the same numbe of staff on trains until the end of the franchise, they're just changing their roles so they don't close the doors. This is how countless trains and operators already run so if it's unsafe, why are they allowed to do it?

In my opinion, it's got very little to do with safety and a lot to do with conductors, and their unions, having significantly less power and influence under the DOO system.

I also think Southern are also a a shambles by the way but its unacceptable how we, the commuters, are caught in the middle of this and are having our lives severely disrupted because of it. We are a captive audience who have no choice but to use their services, unless we change jobs which is not something people should have to consider simply because there's an argument over who closes the bloody train doors.


You're wrong. The whole point of getting rid of the guards safety training was to run trains without guards. Southern will not guarantee a 2nd member of staff on board. If you don't believe me, contact them and ask them.
It's the thin end of the wedge... TOCs want to be able to run with only the driver.., the long term plan is to get rid of guards and OBS's and move towards a small mobile team of revenue protection staff.


^
Not a guess

 

7mins Flag In the bush 02 Dec 16 11.46am

Guards are trained in loads of safety procedures
OBS's won't have any safety training.
They will not be on all trains.
Soon they will be on hardly any trains. Like FCC, Gat Ex

 

npn Flag Crowborough 02 Dec 16 12.02pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Guards are trained in loads of safety procedures
OBS's won't have any safety training.
They will not be on all trains.
Soon they will be on hardly any trains. Like FCC, Gat Ex

Thanks for your input, as someone 'in the know'. It's interesting and informative.

As a commuter who suffers regularly because of this, I would ask, however, what is different about Southern from all of the current services which are driver only (trams, tubes, and I believe some train lines, for instance)?

We all know that companies will say whatever it takes to get a cost saving through, but is there really a safety implication? On my line, literally all the guard does is to open the doors and carry a ticket machine to sell tickets when your station office is closed. It's very frustrating, from this side, when the guards gets stuck on another service, and your train is cancelled when you are completely aware that the train could run perfectly OK without them.

The fact that this is step one to getting rid of them is obvious (regardless of the promise to keep them for a few years), but how long can you fight against the advance of technology (I'm sure plenty of stokers were laid off when trains went electric, for instance).

 

7mins Flag In the bush 02 Dec 16 12.20pm

Originally posted by npn

Thanks for your input, as someone 'in the know'. It's interesting and informative.

As a commuter who suffers regularly because of this, I would ask, however, what is different about Southern from all of the current services which are driver only (trams, tubes, and I believe some train lines, for instance)?

We all know that companies will say whatever it takes to get a cost saving through, but is there really a safety implication? On my line, literally all the guard does is to open the doors and carry a ticket machine to sell tickets when your station office is closed. It's very frustrating, from this side, when the guards gets stuck on another service, and your train is cancelled when you are completely aware that the train could run perfectly OK without them.

The fact that this is step one to getting rid of them is obvious (regardless of the promise to keep them for a few years), but how long can you fight against the advance of technology (I'm sure plenty of stokers were laid off when trains went electric, for instance).

The problems we encountered were more to do with 12 car trains...there was a ratio of 1400:1 in terms of passengers to staff... Any evacuation would be impossible... The safety peeps didn't like them numbers. Also any technical fault means the drivers had to leave the train to fix it or do what's called "protection" this is a procedure where the driver leaves the train to go meet another train that will tow the busted train away... The safety bods didn't like passengers being left alone on a train with no member of staff.
We also had issues with elderly/blind/wheelchairs... No guard and trains became unaccessible for them.
The technology was also flawed....CCTV was jerky, if rain got on the cameras the driver couldn't use them. Also a 12 car train has 24 doors....RSSB had concerns about drivers being able to see 12 mini CCTV screens at the same time.

The problem we had, was guards had this safety training.... We needed to get rid of that and then we could get rid of guards

 

7mins Flag In the bush 02 Dec 16 12.25pm

Trams are smaller and the DfT have always treated them as more akin to busses....something called line of sight driving.
Tubes have better cameras...no issues with rain or sunlight...also had more staff.

As I said...I think guards will lose...they're fighting a Tory government, with little public sympathy.

I also think they are right.. We should have more staff on our railways, not less. Passenger numbers have gone through the roof.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 02 Dec 16 2.40pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Trams are smaller and the DfT have always treated them as more akin to busses....something called line of sight driving.
Tubes have better cameras...no issues with rain or sunlight...also had more staff.

As I said...I think guards will lose...they're fighting a Tory government, with little public sympathy.

I also think they are right.. We should have more staff on our railways, not less. Passenger numbers have gone through the roof.

You weren't doing too bad until then. You've let your "guard" slip.

As npn said, we all know it's about eventually reducing staff levels. Making the public suffer, while telling them they're striking for something else, is foolhardy.

 


Optimistic as ever

7mins Flag In the bush 02 Dec 16 3.27pm

Originally posted by Stuk

You weren't doing too bad until then. You've let your "guard" slip.

As npn said, we all know it's about eventually reducing staff levels. Making the public suffer, while telling them they're striking for something else, is foolhardy.

The Southern franchise is a only A management contract. Southern get paid to carry out the mandate of DfT.
It's the only franchise agreement like it in the country. DFT took away the financial risk because they knew changes being made would result in industrial action. See wilkinson speech at Fairfield halls.

Do you disagree with any of that?

 

Stuk Flag Top half 02 Dec 16 3.53pm

Originally posted by 7mins

The Southern franchise is a only A management contract. Southern get paid to carry out the mandate of DfT.
It's the only franchise agreement like it in the country. DFT took away the financial risk because they knew changes being made would result in industrial action. See wilkinson speech at Fairfield halls.

Do you disagree with any of that?

GTR get paid to run the Southern franchise.

We didn't have a tory government when they set out what was being bid for. And they weren't the only bidders.

 


Optimistic as ever

7mins Flag In the bush 02 Dec 16 5.06pm

Originally posted by Stuk

GTR get paid to run the Southern franchise.

We didn't have a tory government when they set out what was being bid for. And they weren't the only bidders.

What are you talking about?
I worked in HR for years for these TOCs.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 02 Dec 16 5.11pm

Originally posted by 7mins

What are you talking about?
I worked in HR for years for these TOCs.

Trains, same as you.

 


Optimistic as ever

steph_eagle Flag Thornton Heath 02 Dec 16 5.38pm

[Link]

Not sure if anyone's posted this but we'll get compensation of around a months costs, not that that helps when people can't even get to work.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 02 Dec 16 8.14pm

I think going on strike is akin to holding someone to ransom. It's playing on the survival of someone. In this case the MD. It is immoral.

I have no problem with unions, in fact I think they are needed more now than in the last 30 odd years. Negotiation between workers and management is at 1930's levels. But striking just piles on misery to countless innocents who have nothing to do with the perceived problem.

In this day and age, companies should be allowed to sack anyone who strikes, as there are plenty of other deserving workers who are desperate to earn their wages. I understand that this sounds Victorian, but workers rights have been established. Striking to merely increase wages (same as less hours, same wages) or to keep unnecessary jobs is downright idiotic. Negotiating pay rises, genuine H&S issues (which are already almost non-existant, bar stupidity) fine. But refuse to work to get that, P45! Work to rule, go slow, constant union pressure on the management (meetings every day) are legitimate methods of getting results.

Striking is only acceptable if pay or conditions are adverse to a workers well being. Those conditions are illegal. As is blackmail, which is how I view unions calling strikes over spurious matters.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (02 Dec 2016 8.16pm)

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 02 Dec 16 9.02pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3087922]

I think going on strike is akin to holding someone to ransom. It's playing on the survival of someone. In this case the MD. It is immoral.

I have no problem with unions, in fact I think they are needed more now than in the last 30 odd years. Negotiation between workers and management is at 1930's levels. But striking just piles on misery to countless innocents who have nothing to do with the perceived problem.

In this day and age, companies should be allowed to sack anyone who strikes, as there are plenty of other deserving workers who are desperate to earn their wages. I understand that this sounds Victorian, but workers rights have been established. Striking to merely increase wages (same as less hours, same wages) or to keep unnecessary jobs is downright idiotic. Negotiating pay rises, genuine H&S issues (which are already almost non-existant, bar stupidity) fine. But refuse to work to get that, P45! Work to rule, go slow, constant union pressure on the management (meetings every day) are legitimate methods of getting results.

Striking is only acceptable if pay or conditions are adverse to a workers well being. Those conditions are illegal. As is blackmail, which is how I view unions calling strikes over spurious matters.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (02 Dec 2016 8.16pm)

How and why do you think that health and safety conditions have got better.

What southern are proposing would mean a staff member to passenger ratio of 1:1400

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 02 Dec 16 9.24pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

How and why do you think that health and safety conditions have got better.

What southern are proposing would mean a staff member to passenger ratio of 1:1400

I work in the construction industry Nick. H&S have been the bane of my life since 1985ish. They reached an acceptable standard of H&S then. Since then, they just make up rules to cover completely ridiculous situations.

A bit like who closes the doors. How many deaths occurred when we had to close our own doors as opposed to automatic closing? It works fine elsewhere. If the cameras fail, upgrade them, don't revert to redundant methods.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

johnfirewall Flag 02 Dec 16 9.37pm

If they dropped the 'safety' angle the public could actually decide whether they're behind them and we might see support for something which protects staff without preventing progress.

70% of trains already being operated in the proposed fashion with only the driver but 30% held back by dinosaurs has seen them lose the contract.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 02 Dec 16 9.47pm

Originally posted by johnfirewall

If they dropped the 'safety' angle the public could actually decide whether they're behind them and we might see support for something which protects staff without preventing progress.

70% of trains already being operated in the proposed fashion with only the driver but 30% held back by dinosaurs has seen them lose the contract.


I may be wrong, but I'm sure I heard/read that most of the 70% of trains are a lot shorter than the 12+ carriage trains on some southern routes.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 02 Dec 16 10.43pm

Originally posted by nickgusset


I may be wrong, but I'm sure I heard/read that most of the 70% of trains are a lot shorter than the 12+ carriage trains on some southern routes.

Not all platforms can accommodate 12 carriages, let alone more. You could have more carriages, and get passengers to get on the train where appropriate. You are then putting the rail company in the position of explaining to customers which carriages they can use if the wish to alight at various different stations. It's even confusing trying to word it correctly, so getting Joe Moron/Public to comply is futile. Increasing platform length is not possible in many cases. Even if it was, it's quite expensive.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

johnfirewall Flag 02 Dec 16 11.06pm

Originally posted by nickgusset


I may be wrong, but I'm sure I heard/read that most of the 70% of trains are a lot shorter than the 12+ carriage trains on some southern routes.

I'm not aware that there is such a thing as >12 here and I can't see the difference when the carriages are monitored by the driver on CCTV screens but if we're talking technical capabilities it's common across the world to have 4 carriages running driverless. The sort of thing that wouldn't really occur to Londonders aside from in this debate.

 

Page 5 of 44 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong