You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Whiteley a spy, says Tomlinson
November 22 2026 12.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Whiteley a spy, says Tomlinson


Page 5 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 07 Mar 17 3.12pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Any policy that gives advantage based on ethnicity is just plain wrong. I doubt many sensible black football professionals want to be seen as being given a hand up either. You get a job because you deserve it.
The idea that there are not enough black managers is absurd anyway. They are roughly in with with the population. The greater truth is that black footballers are highly disproportionate to the population. Why should that equate to management? It makes no sense at all. You are either good enough or not and you either want to manage or not.

With regards to managers I agree with you. If you exclude the Asian population who have tended to be less interested in football then black/mixed race population is around 5% so there would be around five or six. Given that black players are "over-represented (for want of a better word) perhaps 25% why don't those numbers flow through to management? There would appear to be no prejudice against players - which makes sense. What manager isn't going to pick their best players but something is happening between ending playing and going into management.

The answer isn't quotas or giving anyone an advantage but it is interesting that in the NFL the Rooney rule which purely required teams to interview minority candidates immediately transformed the number of appointments.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 07 Mar 17 3.13pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

I rather suspect that most of the people you are referring to - the sort of tossers that go through public school, into the professions and to the top of society - what generally gets called the "Establishment" are many things; but Liberals they aint.

That is a separate problem and one that cannot be easily solved in a capitalist society. I can't see that denying people their inheritance is an option even if that advantage was originally based on some skullduggery of the past. Some people do go to Oxbridge on merit of course.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 07 Mar 17 3.18pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

With regards to managers I agree with you. If you exclude the Asian population who have tended to be less interested in football then black/mixed race population is around 5% so there would be around five or six. Given that black players are "over-represented (for want of a better word) perhaps 25% why don't those numbers flow through to management? There would appear to be no prejudice against players - which makes sense. What manager isn't going to pick their best players but something is happening between ending playing and going into management.

The answer isn't quotas or giving anyone an advantage but it is interesting that in the NFL the Rooney rule which purely required teams to interview minority candidates immediately transformed the number of appointments.

Is there an unspoken pressure?
Commerce relies on having the biggest markets and that include minorities. My suspicion is that sponsors want more diversity because it's good for business and this drives what is seen as the liberal agenda in large part.

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 07 Mar 17 3.25pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

That is a separate problem and one that cannot be easily solved in a capitalist society. I can't see that denying people their inheritance is an option even if that advantage was originally based on some skullduggery of the past. Some people do go to Oxbridge on merit of course.

Having spent thirty years in the Liberal Party and the Liberal Democrats - and I owe the by-election in Croydon for that - until I resigned over the coalition it feels very much part of the same problem. Where you see a Liberal elite I see a complete absence of liberals though doubtless many of them are well-meaning enough. What I object to is people buying advantage for themselves and their family regardless of talent. Let people achieve based upon merit and abilities not because they were given a head start in life.

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 07 Mar 17 3.25pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe


Is the fact that Trump is stifling free debate by banning parts of the press from his press conferences and also trying to intimidate them by tweeting that they are the "enemy of the people" proof that Trump is part of the "liberal left"?

What has the President of the USA got to do with our discussion of the intolerant and authoritarian nature of the liberal left leadership of British institutions?

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 07 Mar 17 3.34pm

Originally posted by hedgehog50

What has the President of the USA got to do with our discussion of the intolerant and authoritarian nature of the liberal left leadership of British institutions?

We were discussing the stifling of free debate and who does it - which is ironic given your post.

Edited by Sedlescombe (07 Mar 2017 3.34pm)

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 07 Mar 17 3.40pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

We were discussing the stifling of free debate and who does it - which is ironic given your post.

Edited by Sedlescombe (07 Mar 2017 3.34pm)

We were discussing the stifling of free debate in the UK due to the intolerant and authoritarian nature of the liberal left establishment. You are trying to divert the discussion to Trump.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 07 Mar 17 3.46pm

Originally posted by hedgehog50

We were discussing the stifling of free debate in the UK due to the intolerant and authoritarian nature of the liberal left establishment. You are trying to divert the discussion to Trump.

You are stifling debate and I accuse you of being a member of the "liberal elite" though I can understand why you would want to divert attention and not face the implications of your own post

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 07 Mar 17 3.48pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

You are stifling debate and I accuse you of being a member of the "liberal elite" though I can understand why you would want to divert attention and not face the implications of your own post

So you think that having a go at Trump answers the charges against the UK liberal left?

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Username Flag Horsham 07 Mar 17 3.49pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Is there an unspoken pressure?
Commerce relies on having the biggest markets and that include minorities. My suspicion is that sponsors want more diversity because it's good for business and this drives what is seen as the liberal agenda in large part.

I don't think that really matters to be honest. Sponsors care about on field product. That's what sells, not who the head coach is. There are plenty of minority icons playing that would appease any sponsors. Besides, sponsors are far more likely to appease the richer (and whiter) portions of America. Which is part of the reason Colin Kaepernick was such a huge topic of conversation this year.

The whole point of the Rooney rule, is that it gives that person a chance to 'wow' the team owner and GM. There's no pressure to hire them, but by forcing people to listen to them they get a chance. It's not perfect, but is working.

If this legislation, forces magistrates/judges to think for a little bit longer about what sentences to hand down, maybe that will have a similar effect.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 07 Mar 17 4.06pm

Originally posted by Username

I don't think that really matters to be honest. Sponsors care about on field product. That's what sells, not who the head coach is. There are plenty of minority icons playing that would appease any sponsors. Besides, sponsors are far more likely to appease the richer (and whiter) portions of America. Which is part of the reason Colin Kaepernick was such a huge topic of conversation this year.

The whole point of the Rooney rule, is that it gives that person a chance to 'wow' the team owner and GM. There's no pressure to hire them, but by forcing people to listen to them they get a chance. It's not perfect, but is working.

If this legislation, forces magistrates/judges to think for a little bit longer about what sentences to hand down, maybe that will have a similar effect.

I don't think it is all necessarily about selling directly to minorities but appearing to associated with progressive policies that appeal to a large chunk of liberal white people.
As far as sentencing is concerned. If minorities are receiving tougher sentences then surely a policy of lighter sentencing would not in fact be positive discrimination but just establishing parity. So we need to be clear. Are minorities set to get lighter sentences than white people or are sentences being equalised? There is a key and important difference.

 

Username Flag Horsham 07 Mar 17 4.10pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I don't think it is all necessarily about selling directly to minorities but appearing to associated with progressive policies that appeal to a large chunk of liberal white people.
As far as sentencing is concerned. If minorities are receiving tougher sentences then surely a policy of lighter sentencing would not in fact be positive discrimination but just establishing parity. So we need to be clear. Are minorities set to get lighter sentences than white people or are sentences being equalised? There is a key and important difference.

In America, and particularly the NFL, that can be very counter productive.

The NFL and College football both still have massive conservative fanbases.

Your second point is valid and I agree. I would assume and hope that it's about getting parity. However, I would argue that a publication such as the Daily Mail will always choose the more incendiary language in this sort of area.

Edited by Username (07 Mar 2017 4.12pm)

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 07 Mar 17 4.19pm

Originally posted by Username

In America, and particularly the NFL, that can be very counter productive.

The NFL and College football both still have massive conservative fanbases.

Your second point is valid and I agree. I would assume and hope that it's about getting parity. However, I would argue that a publication such as the Daily Mail will always choose the more incendiary language in this sort of area.

Edited by Username (07 Mar 2017 4.12pm)

Well I don't know about that. Are you saying that liberals don't watch football?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Mar 17 4.22pm

Originally posted by hedgehog50

What has the President of the USA got to do with our discussion of the intolerant and authoritarian nature of the liberal left leadership of British institutions?

Although it should be pointed out that the intolerance and authoritarian nature of the so called Liberal Left is reserved for those who are intolerant.

Is it really intolerant to not be accepting of homophobia, sexism, racial prejudice etc.

Now I agree that some people are too quick to play the instant 'racism' card, and overlook the argument being made and engage in it properly (such as race and crime), but they're f**ktards and every side of the argument has its fair share.

Personally, I'm fairly intolerant of racism, sexism, homophobia, religious justifications, transpobia etc and I can live with that paradox.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Mar 17 4.28pm

Originally posted by Username

In America, and particularly the NFL, that can be very counter productive.

The NFL and College football both still have massive conservative fanbases.

Your second point is valid and I agree. I would assume and hope that it's about getting parity. However, I would argue that a publication such as the Daily Mail will always choose the more incendiary language in this sort of area.

Edited by Username (07 Mar 2017 4.12pm)

We should be wary of Positive Discrimination. However, people are also very quick to see it as hypocracy, and not look in any depth.

In the NFL for example, the discrimination is only that if someone who is black, and qualified applies, you have to give them an interview. Not the job, or special treatment, just the interview.

This is actually based on research on job interview applications, which tend to show an unconscious prejudice when reducing the candidate list.

And this in return has led to a massive shift in the diversity of coaches in the NFL.

So, in this example, Positive Discrimination is actually aligned with well established social science research, and aimed directly to counter it. Its not actually discrimination, its really levelling the playing field against unconscious prejudices.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Mar 17 4.30pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I don't think it is all necessarily about selling directly to minorities but appearing to associated with progressive policies that appeal to a large chunk of liberal white people.
As far as sentencing is concerned. If minorities are receiving tougher sentences then surely a policy of lighter sentencing would not in fact be positive discrimination but just establishing parity. So we need to be clear. Are minorities set to get lighter sentences than white people or are sentences being equalised? There is a key and important difference.

There is an argument that sentencing should not be set by the Judge on the case, but by a judge who has worked the case working from a 'redacted transcript' that removes details of the offender and defendent's name, occupation, social class etc.

That way, the judges preconceptions of the defendant are removed entirely and placed instead on the argument of the case.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 07 Mar 17 4.39pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

Having spent thirty years in the Liberal Party and the Liberal Democrats - and I owe the by-election in Croydon for that - until I resigned over the coalition it feels very much part of the same problem. Where you see a Liberal elite I see a complete absence of liberals though doubtless many of them are well-meaning enough. What I object to is people buying advantage for themselves and their family regardless of talent. Let people achieve based upon merit and abilities not because they were given a head start in life.

One of the benefits of success is to pass that advantage on to one's offspring. If I were very rich, I'd ensure that my kids had everything they might need, including a private education. I don't think we can criticise people for that attitude but clearly it does present a problem for our society where potential incompetents are in top jobs and a closed shop based on old school tie cronyism develops. It is up to institutions to make policy that discourage that sort of behavior because we can't deny people the fruits of their father's or even their great great great grandfathers labour.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Mar 17 4.39pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Is there an unspoken pressure?
Commerce relies on having the biggest markets and that include minorities. My suspicion is that sponsors want more diversity because it's good for business and this drives what is seen as the liberal agenda in large part.

Research suggests that unconscious prejudices aren't significant in interviews, but more as a means by which candidate lists are reduced. This is true both of sports and jobs, and its not just on the basis of race (its much broader, its harder to get a job interview if you have an name people associate with negative issues).

However, at interview, where the interaction is face to face, you don't tend to see the same degree of prejudice (racial discrimination, even among people who are overtly racist aren't consistant, there tends to be them (the people you don't know) and the 'good ones' (the people you do know).

Prejudice is a bit bizarre like that, but it makes sense entirely when you look a research of Social Identity theory, such as Tajfal, which shows how normal people tend to discriminate against others based on perceived similarities / differences.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 07 Mar 17 4.41pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Although it should be pointed out that the intolerance and authoritarian nature of the so called Liberal Left is reserved for those who are intolerant.

Is it really intolerant to not be accepting of homophobia, sexism, racial prejudice etc.

Now I agree that some people are too quick to play the instant 'racism' card, and overlook the argument being made and engage in it properly (such as race and crime), but they're f**ktards and every side of the argument has its fair share.

Personally, I'm fairly intolerant of racism, sexism, homophobia, religious justifications, transpobia etc and I can live with that paradox.

I take it then that you are intolerant of the widely held views on these matters in the Muslim communities?

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Username Flag Horsham 07 Mar 17 4.42pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Well I don't know about that. Are you saying that liberals don't watch football?

No, but they are already football fans, and less likely to be 'turned' off by the rule not coming in, compared to conservatives being annoyed by the change.

Kaepernick's protest is a good example. Liberal football fans weren't exactly vocal about the issue before it happened, but there were plenty of conservative fanbases who were outraged when it started to happen.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Page 5 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Whiteley a spy, says Tomlinson