You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Great Academy or a neglected one
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Great Academy or a neglected one


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Dan89 Flag Se25 27 Jun 17 11.10am

There's a lot of talk that , FDB appointment is great news for the academy products. However are the likes of Kai Kai good enough or is that there not being given an opportunity. While previous managers have joined the club, with survival as their only mission. These players have hardly flourished in the U23 game or when out on loan in the football league. Im all for giving youth a chance but they have to be good enough. Didn't the academy get graded as category B. How can we improve this. Is Gary Issot the problem.

What's your thoughts on the academy and why has it been 7 to 8 years. Since Zaha burst onto he scene.

Edited by Dan89 (27 Jun 2017 11.26am)

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 27 Jun 17 11.21am

I think it's the way football is going with academy's being neglected.

Chelsea have lots of their academy players loaned out and hardly bring any of them through.

I like the way Frank is going to address this.

The likes of Joniesta and Kai Kai are good enough and will hopefully get their chance under FDB.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Jun 17 11.23am

Originally posted by black eagle.

I think it's the way football is going with academy's being neglected.

Chelsea have lots of their academy players loaned out and hardly bring any of them through.

I like the way Frank is going to address this.

The likes of Joniesta and Kai Kai are good enough and will hopefully get their chance under FDB.

Not so sure that 'Williams' will ever be effective in the PL.
'Kai Kai' hasn't done enough, when loaned out, to suggest he will be a positive influence.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 27 Jun 17 11.25am

Originally posted by black eagle.

I think it's the way football is going with academy's being neglected.

Chelsea have lots of their academy players loaned out and hardly bring any of them through.

I like the way Frank is going to address this.

The likes of Joniesta and Kai Kai are good enough and will hopefully get their chance under FDB.

Hope your right because when ever I've seen Williams. I personally think he's too lightweight. Let's remember he's played 12 prem games. Mostly subs. Yes he's injury prone but I feel that it would be better for his career to leave, for a championship club. (I know he signed a new deal)

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 27 Jun 17 11.26am

I think the impact FdB will make on the academy will be in its organization and recruitment. We will probably not see the results for a number of years. As long as survival in the Prem is Job #1 we will have to rely on the transfer market. As a start, let's see what Williams, KaiKai and Boateng bring to the table and go from there.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Dan89 Flag Se25 27 Jun 17 11.36am

Originally posted by kenbarr

I think the impact FdB will make on the academy will be in its organization and recruitment. We will probably not see the results for a number of years. As long as survival in the Prem is Job #1 we will have to rely on the transfer market. As a start, let's see what Williams, KaiKai and Boateng bring to the table and go from there.

Are the likes of Kai Kai and boateng good enough. There no wilfried Zaha or Clyne. Does our whole academy set up. Need a restructuring. Maybe bring in some new youth coaches. Gary Issot been at palace for years. Is he the problem.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

HerneBayPalace Flag Herne Bay 27 Jun 17 11.42am

De Boer coming in will not suddenly make our youth players world beaters.

A few people have already said that it will take a few years to develop anyone, which is correct. We haven't been able to give them a chance due to being in and around the bottom nearly every season and tried and trusted players were used with experienced managers.

What he will bring is a new understanding of the game which may mean the current U23 team and below may well pick up on this and develop their 'football brain'. This could have an impact on their thought process and therefore seemingly improve their ability whilst on the pitch. He can be the missing link from apply the ability into using it in the correct situations.

I personally couldn't understand why any of our youth team left backs were not in with a shout over Martin Kelly under Pardew, that was an opportunity as it couldn't have got much worse.

Time will tell but I think he will be using the transfer market for his first season or if we are safe by April he may think about it.

 

HerneBayPalace Flag Herne Bay 27 Jun 17 11.43am

Originally posted by HerneBayPalace

De Boer coming in will not suddenly make our youth players world beaters.

A few people have already said that it will take a few years to develop anyone, which is correct. We haven't been able to give them a chance due to being in and around the bottom nearly every season and tried and trusted players were used with experienced managers.

What he will bring is a new understanding of the game which may mean the current U23 team and below may well pick up on this and develop their 'football brain'. This could have an impact on their thought process and therefore seemingly improve their ability whilst on the pitch. He can be the missing link from applying the ability into using it in the correct situations.

I personally couldn't understand why any of our youth team left backs were not in with a shout over Martin Kelly under Pardew, that was an opportunity as it couldn't have got much worse.

Time will tell but I think he will be using the transfer market for his first season or if we are safe by April he may think about it.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 27 Jun 17 11.44am

Originally posted by kenbarr

I think the impact FdB will make on the academy will be in its organization and recruitment. We will probably not see the results for a number of years. As long as survival in the Prem is Job #1 we will have to rely on the transfer market. As a start, let's see what Williams, KaiKai and Boateng bring to the table and go from there.

I agree Ken,however previous management have deemed the three lads you name not good enough.
Albeit Williams (lovely lad) is injury prone.
But there is nothing better than a youngster coming through for the Palace.
It's easy to tell if good enough,I remember seeing Zaha at Dorchester and Clyne given a start by Neil.

Edited by alaneagle1 (27 Jun 2017 11.45am)

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Dan89 Flag Se25 27 Jun 17 11.44am

Originally posted by HerneBayPalace

Originally posted by HerneBayPalace

De Boer coming in will not suddenly make our youth players world beaters.

A few people have already said that it will take a few years to develop anyone, which is correct. We haven't been able to give them a chance due to being in and around the bottom nearly every season and tried and trusted players were used with experienced managers.

What he will bring is a new understanding of the game which may mean the current U23 team and below may well pick up on this and develop their 'football brain'. This could have an impact on their thought process and therefore seemingly improve their ability whilst on the pitch. He can be the missing link from applying the ability into using it in the correct situations.

I personally couldn't understand why any of our youth team left backs were not in with a shout over Martin Kelly under Pardew, that was an opportunity as it couldn't have got much worse.

Time will tell but I think he will be using the transfer market for his first season or if we are safe by April he may think about it.

You say that again lol

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

manosdedios Flag 27 Jun 17 11.48am

Originally posted by Dan89

Are the likes of Kai Kai and boateng good enough. There no wilfried Zaha or Clyne. Does our whole academy set up. Need a restructuring. Maybe bring in some new youth coaches. Gary Issot been at palace for years. Is he the problem.

When Clyne was coming through the academy he was considered as not good enough and was behind Michael Abnett (currently plying his trade at Merstham) in the pecking order. Give the lads a chance to see what they can do.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 27 Jun 17 11.54am

Originally posted by manosdedios

When Clyne was coming through the academy he was considered as not good enough and was behind Michael Abnett (currently plying his trade at Merstham) in the pecking order. Give the lads a chance to see what they can do.

They need to earn that chance. Take Williams for example. He had numerous pre season with palace to impress. With most managers opting out of place him in the 25 man squad. With the financial reward to stay in this league. You have to be assured that they can cope. With Clyne, we was in the championship. Also as someone mentioned above that when we went through a left back crisis. No U23 left back was given a chance. The u23 haven't been very successful this year.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 28 Jun 17 1.51pm

The benefit of what FDB said won't be seen for years and not with the current crop of players. However if youngsters believe that they will have a better chance of early recognition at Palace then their advisers/parents and associated leeches will tend to direct them towards us, so long as we maintain the facilities and coaching staff. That's the real benefit.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Midlands Eagle Flag 28 Jun 17 1.57pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Take Williams for example. He had numerous pre season with palace to impress. With most managers opting out of place him in the 25 man squad.

I think that you will find that "most managers" didn't have to put him in the squad of 25 as he was under the age limit

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 28 Jun 17 2.00pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I think that you will find that "most managers" didn't have to put him in the squad of 25 as he was under the age limit

The last 2 seasons. He could of been named wasn't. Because FDB arrived let's not pretend, we have the greatest academy. Improving academy will take 2 to 3 years minimum.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 28 Jun 17 4.14pm

Originally posted by manosdedios

When Clyne was coming through the academy he was considered as not good enough and was behind Michael Abnett (currently plying his trade at Merstham) in the pecking order. Give the lads a chance to see what they can do.

Very much agree with this. If we get put some distance between us and the drop zone. FdB should be the perfect coach to want to blood players he feels might be good enough and maybe we'll all be surprised at who makes it.

 

PaddyMcPaddy Flag 28 Jun 17 4.45pm

Originally posted by manosdedios

When Clyne was coming through the academy he was considered as not good enough and was behind Michael Abnett (currently plying his trade at Merstham) in the pecking order. Give the lads a chance to see what they can do.

Spot on, that is the only way to work it. Fight or flight. Some players thrive on the opportunity. You never know until you play them.
Unfortunately it is too risky. Ultimately Zaha and Clyne only got in the team due to the financially situation we were in not because they were ready to play first team football.

 

Johnny Byrne Flag Pinner 28 Jun 17 5.03pm

Be interesting to see if our youngsters make the first team squad.

Joniesta
Anderson
Ladapo
KaiKai
Boateng
Wan-Bissaka
Flanagan
Kirby
Dreher

Interesting pre season looms.

 


1 June 2010 - saved from oblivion by CPFC 2010
27 May 2013 - promoted to Premier League
2013-14 - 11th in PL
2014-15 - 10th in PL
2015-16 - 15th in PL
2016-17 - 14th in PL (and grateful for that!)

est1905 Flag 28 Jun 17 5.07pm

Originally posted by Dan89

There's a lot of talk that , FDB appointment is great news for the academy products. However are the likes of Kai Kai good enough or is that there not being given an opportunity. While previous managers have joined the club, with survival as their only mission. These players have hardly flourished in the U23 game or when out on loan in the football league. Im all for giving youth a chance but they have to be good enough. Didn't the academy get graded as category B. How can we improve this. Is Gary Issot the problem.

What's your thoughts on the academy and why has it been 7 to 8 years. Since Zaha burst onto he scene.

Edited by Dan89 (27 Jun 2017 11.26am)

Our lack of youngsters coming through more or less coincides with our promotion to the Premiership. The pressure on all clubs to win is enormous. Playing an untried youngster is a massive risk. Kaikai has done very well on loan but is he ready to make the step up to the Prem? On sub appearances I would say its a difficult one to call but probably not.
I'm sure I am right in saying our academy gets more investment now than it ever has year on year. Problem is those youngsters have to be so much better than when we were in the Championship in order to get a chance. Under Frank I cannot see too much changing too soon. Yes he wants to bring kids through but his brief is to keep us well away from the relegation zone. Blooding youngsters when you need points and are under pressure to win is not smart.

 

jeeagles Flag 28 Jun 17 6.12pm

As people have said. It's pretty difficult to give youngsters time during religated battles.

Currently our back up to Puncheon is Lee. I would prefer to give Williams a go.

I'd also like Kaikai to be given preference over Sako.

With Lesley gone maybe Boateng will get a chance.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Great Academy or a neglected one