This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
It wasn't 'My' midfielder problem. It was the club's midfielder problem from January 2016 to September 2016, added to by selling Jedi, not scouting Rincon or anyone properly, and ending up with flaming Flamini. It was ignored, or not given enough attention because of Benteke. We then get idiots like rikz telling us we don't understand contracts, and net spend means nothing, even though it was a pitiful £10 million. It takes time to sign 2 players? We didn't sign another left back for over a year or another defender all summer yet in January 2017 we signed 2 left backs in 2 weeks and whacked the money down for a top class centre half because we'd driven ourselves into the sh1t by not doing what we should've done in the 1st place, albeit just 1 left back. Rudi so your blaming Parish here by the sounds of it.
Palace 13th 2017/18. |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Man Utd played a few youngsters against us at the end of last season and they basically tore us a new AH. We have youngsters that are good and there are plenty of others in the lower divisions just begging to be discovered. So why is it that a player in the modern game is no good unless we are paying £30m for him? I know players at the premier level already are proven but I think I would rather be buying low and selling high than competing with the squillionaires for players we can't afford and ultimately ending up with their cast offs who last one season and are then ready for the scrap heap. Time to get some decent scouts and someone with balls who is willing to give players a go. So you prescribe to the Holloway method, buying loads of cheap players hoping some will come good. Didn't work last time, why do you think it will now?
|
|
|
Originally posted by alaneagle1
Rudi so your blaming Parish here by the sounds of it. I'm not outright blaming Parish for this summer because the window isn't over. But too long was spent on RDB, if it's true Frank wanted it agreed sooner. Or did we actually want Pellegrino? I think that could be true. You just know from from previous history that we won't sign what's required, there'll be some injuries, and we'll, or some, like the 'how could anyone know Souare would have a car crash' excusers will claim we've been unlucky. Always amused by the 'who would you bring in?' retorts. I'm not in the inner sanctum to see what should be a solid list of quite a few per position, and not just in the five ish positions we need to add to but the whole team, in case Benteke or Townsend or Cabaye or anyone leaves now or in January. Those few people should have scouts, agents and resources having possibilities looked at and ready to have serious approaches made when needed, but not, after a big signing is made, a big panic and a crock coming in, or nobody in the case of 2 defenders last summer. See my point? Edited by Rudi Hedman (12 Jul 2017 9.21am)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
So you prescribe to the Holloway method, buying loads of cheap players hoping some will come good. Didn't work last time, why do you think it will now? I think his point is more around better scouting, which we haven't ever been blessed with. We've spent good money but I'm sure go the prices we've paid for some players we could've easily attracted better and with the right scouting network players equally as good for less. This is the reason we have such a thin squad in my opinion because we've never identified cheaper options who can compete with the first XI. It all comes down to the quality of our scouting and one would hope we can start identifying more efficient targets with a more continental manager.
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Love the sign loads of sh1t vs really expensive players like there's nobody priced in between.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I'm not outright blaming Parish for this summer because the window isn't over. But too long was spent on RDB, if it's true Frank wanted it agreed sooner. Or did we actually want Pellegrino? I think that could be true. You just know from from previous history that we won't sign what's required, there'll be some injuries, and we'll, or some, like the 'how could anyone know Souare would have a car crash' excusers will claim we've been unlucky. Always amused by the 'who would you bring in?' retorts. I'm not in the inner sanctum to see what should be a solid list of quite a few per position, and not just in the five ish positions we need to add to but the whole team, in case Benteke or Townsend or Cabaye or anyone leaves now or in January. Those few people should have scouts, agents and resources having possibilities looked at and ready to have serious approaches made when needed, but not, after a big signing is made, a big panic and a crock coming in, or nobody in the case of 2 defenders last summer. See my point? Edited by Rudi Hedman (12 Jul 2017 9.21am) Not really.
Palace 13th 2017/18. |
|
|
Originally posted by alaneagle1
Not really. Knew you wouldn't. Not surprised. 'Sakho plus one maybe two?' Have you ever read the bench? Are injuries not going to happen at CPFC next season? No wonder you don't get it. Oh and Mariappa and Hangeland left before Tomkins came in, so again down 1. And who scouted Tomkins? Bl00dy Hangeland. Best to give up here.
COYP |
|
|
This exactly sums up why youth does not get a chance. And Milo failed at Anderlecht and was in the obscure Greek league to just state an obvious example of you being wrong. If a youngster is good he is good, the average attitude in the PL is just unbelievable cowardly in not giving youth any chance at all. Originally posted by Painter
So you prescribe to the Holloway method, buying loads of cheap players hoping some will come good. Didn't work last time, why do you think it will now?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle
Let's not let the manager evaluate the squad before deciding what he needs. Lets go balls deep scatter gunning like Holloway. Five years we've been up. Why do you think that is? As a club we spend big money. We also negotiate as good value for money as we can. But let's buy sh*te so we can announce a signing. I agree. We don't want to see panic and ill-informed purchases such as Florian Marange, Elliot Grandin, Jimmy Kebe and the great promise Jose Campana to name a few Edited by AdelaideEagle (12 Jul 2017 10.30am)
True Blue Red 'n' Blue !!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Love the sign loads of sh1t vs really expensive players like there's nobody priced in between. That seems to be the HOL way along with not spending more that tuppence ha'penny on a player as we don't want to go into Administration again
|
|
| ParchmoreEagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle
How long did it take BS to sign Sahko, PVA, Schlupp and Mili? How long? Were they aweful signings? Did quick equal rubbish? Who is the only PL team that hasn't made a signing yet? Did anyone see the CPFC website video of FDB seriously coaching the players at training? I'm a teacher, and you plan a lesson from start to finish and there's nothing more frustrating than when students enter class at various times through the lesson - they'll miss something. Is FBD expected to repeat himself to the new signings when they arrive? Point is, time in pre-season is important for players to gel as a team. Ours is rapisly disappearing. And it doesn't have to take ages to sign the right people as BS and his 4 signings clearly evidenced. Oh, and we should have gone down, and all we want this season is to avoid that same position. And... FDB came to us as proper coach/manager, and now I'm thinking, is he starting to get p1ssed off like the others? Why, because he wears the mantle of being a very good manager, and now with only a few weeks to go to the start of the season, he still hasn't got his full team to manage! Poor b****** is going to have a bunch of new players to iject into the team with insufficient time to prepare them with the team, then HE WILL GET BLAMED NO DOUBT FOR BEING A SH1T MANAGER! P1ssed off? I think so.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Why was that the most important signing as he was already contracted to us for another two years so wasn't going anywhere unless we wanted him to. On a short term contract with (relatively) low wages Wilf was a prime target for another club. If a top 6 had come knocking with a decent offer & a good package for Wilf do you honestly think we'd have been able to keep him? Why do you think the club felt it was the right time to get him signed up again? Not rocket science is it.
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
|
Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle
FDB came to us as proper coach/manager, and now I'm thinking, is he starting to get p1ssed off like the others? Why, because he wears the mantle of being a very good manager, and now with only a few weeks to go to the start of the season, he still hasn't got his full team to manage! It was FdB himself that said he wanted a good look at all of our players before deciding where we need to strengthen and he can only be in that position now.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
As a matter of interest who has suggested that's what we should be doing? There's a lot of comment about our lack of signings compared with those in our financial field or the newly promoted clubs. The fact that a majority fall into the categories I mentioned seems irrelevant to many. There have been a few astute signings but the rest would not enhance our team. If I wanted to make my car faster on a budget I'd never t buy lots of small/cheap parts but spend the money on those that would make the most difference.
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Nice post, Nobbybm but you can put your house on us having signed about 40% of what we need 2 days before the season starts. I'm not bed wetting myself. I just know it will happen. You will see a gradual growth of serious concern and more supporters concerned we've signed 2 players before Huddersfield. Probably, but I'd rather get it right than throw money at anyone who will come. Reckon there'll be a few loans this season though - let's hope they're decent & we get options on em.
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nobbybm
There's a lot of comment about our lack of signings compared with those in our financial field or the newly promoted clubs. The fact that a majority fall into the categories I mentioned seems irrelevant to many. The comment that I had read most of all was that we were the only club in the Premier League not to have made any signings at all - nothing to do with those in our financial field or newly promoted clubs
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.