You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Lost our identity, thanks to parish
November 16 2026 8.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Lost our identity, thanks to parish


Page 5 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 27 Aug 17 2.33pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Cast your minds back when last December, when big Sam was appointed and the words that Steve parish used was the player need a system their comfortable in and it's time to turn back the dial. My question is did he see Dann, Kelly and others struggle to adapt to a possession based game under pardew. Our DNA has always been hard to beat, good counter attacking side. When you appoint a manager that been schooled in the academy of Ajax and Barcelona, what style did you think we are gonna play. Unless there's a considerable budget, should appoint a 40 pts manager and not gamble with our prem status.

Is parish to blame for our lack of identity?

1. In answer to your question No. As Chairman he makes decisions that are for the good of our club, right or wrong. Try picking out the good ones.
2. I would be very concerned if SP left, hopefully you and other detractors of his agree?

 


Bring back Brolin

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 27 Aug 17 2.34pm

Originally posted by bodge

We had the same last season even under SA we had lost our identity then we won a few games and all of a sudden we were back to the old Palace lol. We are a small club with no right to win or sign £30m players if FDB can keep us up get us playing better football with a set style and give youth a chance then great he needs time and support from SP and us fans.

Nail on head Bodge!

 


Bring back Brolin

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 27 Aug 17 2.36pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

Lost our identity, oh please how f***ing precious are we?
It's not a problem changing your approach, ask Arsenal, Southampton, Swansea etc, many have changed over the years. Problem is trying to do it in 4 pre season games with the same squad as last season. It has to be gradual with a few new faces already familiar with said style. I have no problem not being associated with kick and run, park the bus football, but I have a problem with changing in a half arsed fashion which will inevitably end in disaster.
FdB needs the players and SP has to provide them or all our hard work will have been in vain. What both men are thinking is beyond me, cos we all know this squad can't be changed that drastically in such a short space of time.
Parish wants a more attractive team and for that I don't blame him, but you have to fully commit or it's pointless (as we currently are).
Oh yeah one last thing. Losing yesterday didn't relegate us, just as winning wouldn't have kept us up. Still a long way to go.

Edited by Dangermouse (27 Aug 2017 10.59am)

Common sense posting at last!

 


Bring back Brolin

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 27 Aug 17 2.41pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Parish saved the club,fact.
He is also responsible for FDB appointment which was questioned by many pundits,who sadly,have been proven correct.
Question remains,how do we get out of this mess immediately, take stock and play to our strengths.
Getting Sam back or similar,a manager who understands the Premiership would be a step in the right direction.
To think, it took SP some 6 weeks to make the wrong appointment for the club.

And why after 3 games is it the wrong appointment?

SP didn't just pick his nose for 6 weeks, so on that basis I will for now stick with his Judgment and review it further down the line!

 


Bring back Brolin

Midlands Eagle Flag 27 Aug 17 3.31pm

Originally posted by bodge

We had the same last season even under SA we had lost our identity

I keep hearing that we lost our identity but what identity was that?

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 27 Aug 17 3.34pm

Our identity was relegation fodder, make up the numbers, yo-yo club. What's changed?

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Dan89 Flag Se25 27 Aug 17 3.58pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I keep hearing that we lost our identity but what identity was that?

The identity of the team for me is fighting until the end, giving 100% and fast counter attacking style. Hard to beat ethos.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Painter Flag Croydon 27 Aug 17 4.05pm

Originally posted by Dan89

The identity of the team for me is fighting until the end, giving 100% and fast counter attacking style. Hard to beat ethos.

I only remember your description under Pulis, not Holloway, Warnock, Millen, Pardew or Allardyce. So how is it Parish's fault. Don't say he employed them, as they were given a job to do and were supported with purchases.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 27 Aug 17 4.11pm

Originally posted by Painter

I only remember your description under Pulis, not Holloway, Warnock, Millen, Pardew or Allardyce. So how is it Parish's fault. Don't say he employed them, as they were given a job to do and were supported with purchases.

You answered you own question, you can't change a style on 8m. We got away with Pardew trying an expansive style had to wind back the dial- parish words. Appointed big Sam rescued us. Then it seem he hasn't learnt from the Pardew appointment. That's why I blame parish. Most fans knew we didn't have the players for a FDB philosophy. Whether it's our DNA or identity it's the only successful way we survived in this league. With hindsight dyche was by far the better option but many fans on here were turning their nose up.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 27 Aug 17 6.40pm

Aye

Originally posted by Dangermouse

Our identity was relegation fodder, make up the numbers, yo-yo club. What's changed?

 

majorkaios Flag Trowbridge, Wilts 28 Aug 17 2.46am

Originally posted by Tom R

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Champagne football lemonade lifestyle ' by Guntrisoft

Another thread but spot on. Parish says he wants something but won't back it up in the transfer market. He treats supporters like idiots but some of us can see through his inept rubbish

That may well be because some supporters judging by the comments on HOL seem to think June 30th is the 31st of August. Things may well have been different but Klops antics put a stop to the start of that.

 


School, SN.Juniors, SN High, Selhurst. 1st match 1972 CP 2 N. Utd 1. Thank you, John Jackson and Vince Hilair for brightening our darkest days. I moved to the west country in 1983. Always Proud and 'Glad All Over' to be a Palace Fan. ))

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 28 Aug 17 6.39am

Every fan should be questioning what the f*** has gone on with the board's decision making and why our starts seasons are so s***. SP can't hide forever behind "he saved the club"

 

majorkaios Flag Trowbridge, Wilts 28 Aug 17 7.47am

Originally posted by iheartcpfc

Every fan should be questioning what the f*** has gone on with the board's decision making and why our starts seasons are so s***. SP can't hide forever behind "he saved the club"

Genuinely sorry it is not working out on the pitch, it's a new tack. It may take the whole season before we get it right. Also so sorry there is no one on the HOL
from the CPFC2010 board to answer YOU directly here, maybe the mods can help.

Based on the above, in my opinion, FDB has every right to experiment and to try all the worst possible options and in so doing lose all games until the end of the window. Unfortunately, we did, its whats called a learning curve. However, days before the match, Frank did say. "It depends on who on the day is more hungry to win the game." That is down to the way the players played on the day. The games were lost on player errors. Kindly prove the formational errors that were more responsible than the player errors THAT DIRECTLY LED TO GOALS.

Still, I don't disrespect your opinion, it's valid in the short term. I feel strongly that the best opportunity for Frank to experiment to his heart's content was until the end of the window and the final Squad. I won't add Frank to the same learning curve as the players until the end of November, personally.

So we're down to whether we should play direct football till we get the points then worry about learning Total football.

I don't know maybe that is what will happen after the International break. Maybe not, but clearly it depends on who we end up with. I've not lost sleep over it, I work nights


COYP!

 


School, SN.Juniors, SN High, Selhurst. 1st match 1972 CP 2 N. Utd 1. Thank you, John Jackson and Vince Hilair for brightening our darkest days. I moved to the west country in 1983. Always Proud and 'Glad All Over' to be a Palace Fan. ))

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 28 Aug 17 8.13am

Originally posted by majorkaios

Genuinely sorry it is not working out on the pitch, it's a new tack. It may take the whole season before we get it right. Also so sorry there is no one on the HOL
from the CPFC2010 board to answer YOU directly here, maybe the mods can help.

Based on the above, in my opinion, FDB has every right to experiment and to try all the worst possible options and in so doing lose all games until the end of the window. Unfortunately, we did, its whats called a learning curve. However, days before the match, Frank did say. "It depends on who on the day is more hungry to win the game." That is down to the way the players played on the day. The games were lost on player errors. Kindly prove the formational errors that were more responsible than the player errors THAT DIRECTLY LED TO GOALS.

Still, I don't disrespect your opinion, it's valid in the short term. I feel strongly that the best opportunity for Frank to experiment to his heart's content was until the end of the window and the final Squad. I won't add Frank to the same learning curve as the players until the end of November, personally.

So we're down to whether we should play direct football till we get the points then worry about learning Total football.

I don't know maybe that is what will happen after the International break. Maybe not, but clearly it depends on who we end up with. I've not lost sleep over it, I work nights


COYP!

ignoring the sarcastic patronising of me

The fatal error so far this season is the inability to defend crosses. This is basic stuff we're talking about, losing a man in the box and not pressuring the crosser. In the Hudds game Mooy (and Ince) had the freedom of SP to cross as our 3 atb system and high line was exploited by one long ball (which Schalke used again and again) into the space. Riedewald was partly to blame as well for losing Mounie. Even in the first few mins v Swans they nearly scored from a cross to Abraham.

Another thing is the absymal movement of the team in possession. No one presents themselves as options for the pass, no one creates space for themselves in the 3-4-3 system as I suspect they barely understand where they should be. With Wilf there are no runners in the team and the wing backs have half a mind on not being caught up the pitch. As a result our build up play is easy to defend against. No surprise when Andros ran at their defence (going with his instinct as a direct player) we looked like we'd threaten them. Unless the movement is there then we will create f*** all.

Thirdly, the system has completely negated Luka's presence by forcing him to push up instead of screening the CB's. He is a defensive midfielder, end of and should be in a midfield 3. He must take some blame for his poor performances but the system is not right for him. With 2 CB's and him in front he can drop in between them to collect the ball and distribute to Cabaye and RLC (the ideal partners for him) then stay in our half but he has too much to do now. He is a very effective player in the right system but FdB is using him poorly.

Edited by iheartcpfc (28 Aug 2017 8.14am)

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 28 Aug 17 8.19am

Originally posted by Dangermouse

It's not a problem changing your approach, ask Arsenal...

Yes, let's do ask Arsenal

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Den1923 Flag 28 Aug 17 10.06am

Originally posted by iheartcpfc

ignoring the sarcastic patronising of me

The fatal error so far this season is the inability to defend crosses. This is basic stuff we're talking about, losing a man in the box and not pressuring the crosser. In the Hudds game Mooy (and Ince) had the freedom of SP to cross as our 3 atb system and high line was exploited by one long ball (which Schalke used again and again) into the space. Riedewald was partly to blame as well for losing Mounie. Even in the first few mins v Swans they nearly scored from a cross to Abraham.

Another thing is the absymal movement of the team in possession. No one presents themselves as options for the pass, no one creates space for themselves in the 3-4-3 system as I suspect they barely understand where they should be. With Wilf there are no runners in the team and the wing backs have half a mind on not being caught up the pitch. As a result our build up play is easy to defend against. No surprise when Andros ran at their defence (going with his instinct as a direct player) we looked like we'd threaten them. Unless the movement is there then we will create f*** all.

Thirdly, the system has completely negated Luka's presence by forcing him to push up instead of screening the CB's. He is a defensive midfielder, end of and should be in a midfield 3. He must take some blame for his poor performances but the system is not right for him. With 2 CB's and him in front he can drop in between them to collect the ball and distribute to Cabaye and RLC (the ideal partners for him) then stay in our half but he has too much to do now. He is a very effective player in the right system but FdB is using him poorly.

Edited by iheartcpfc (28 Aug 2017 8.14am)

and add to that FdB was recruited by SP and then given a couple of loan signings who wanted more PL game time to increase their experience and and unproven player who cost 8mil, hardly enough to change a system. What we need to learn first of all is how to stop teams scoring at least we will get a point even if we do not score ourselves. The defensive errors were there for all to see on Saturday when Ward was responsible for the two goals conceded either side of HT. SP has to be to blame for the number of Managers who have come and left orhave been fired over the last four and bit seasons and the dismal records of having only won less than a third of our home games over the same period. What SP did in the past with the other Directors is history, he reputation will be in tatters if we are relegated as he would have overseen the biggest loss in revenue in the clubs history!

 

ger20 Flag London 28 Aug 17 10.41am

Three games is too soon to be thinking of sacking the manager, but having said that there are several areas of concern that do not bode well for the future. De Boors inability to be flexible, lack of charisma and rush to judgment of his players, calling them cowards in public is a big deal and it may be an indication that he is willing to walk out if things don't improve. De Boor was a living legend as a player and expects the players to be up to the standards set by him. He now realises that half the team are championship standard at best. He just doesn't have to tools to succeed. Palace are a kick and rush counter attacking team but it is clear De Boor does not want to play that way. Parish has a clear choice bring in four or five high quality players (unlikely given the time frame and budget constraints) or sack the manager or wait until he walks.

 

Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 28 Aug 17 10.42am

Originally posted by Den1923

and add to that FdB was recruited by SP and then given a couple of loan signings who wanted more PL game time to increase their experience and and unproven player who cost 8mil, hardly enough to change a system. What we need to learn first of all is how to stop teams scoring at least we will get a point even if we do not score ourselves. The defensive errors were there for all to see on Saturday when Ward was responsible for the two goals conceded either side of HT. SP has to be to blame for the number of Managers who have come and left orhave been fired over the last four and bit seasons and the dismal records of having only won less than a third of our home games over the same period. What SP did in the past with the other Directors is history, he reputation will be in tatters if we are relegated as he would have overseen the biggest loss in revenue in the clubs history!

To be honest I agree that Parish and his merry band saved the club, that's great but it's history now. But surely the buck stops with him, He has been the one who made every single management decision. Frustratingly enough we are no further forward as a club on all fronts, than we were when promoted. Relegation possibilities every single season. If he was in most other Industries he would of been forced to stand down, He can't go on blaming the Managers as I have said before he is responsible, I wish he would stand down.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 28 Aug 17 10.45am

Originally posted by Bangell

The formation doesn't work. But you're acting as if Parish has somehow pissed away everything that's good about this club, when FDB could simply switch to a back 4 after the break, just like he did in the 2nd half today?

He should have started with four at the back but can't you blame him to much for hoping and trying his system against Swansea. It didn't work and he rightly changed it.

Performance immediately improved and if Kelly's effort had gone in it'd been 1-1 with us playing the better football.

He's no had his chances trying to implement his system and its so far failed. We now need points on the board and an Sakho injection to give confidence back.

I personally don't want Frank sacked but he does need in the short term to play to our strengthens. If he doesn't I believe Parish will axe him and he'll never work in the Prem again.

If he does suck it up and change for the short to medium term I can still see him being a success.

Two great signings and one question mark signing. Maybe Reidiweld had a bad day at the office maybe he needs longer to adjust. Maybe he's not good enough, time will tell. Preseason he looked solid but yes this isn't preseason. He's been taken out the firing line which is a good thing and either an injury or the sign of good management.

In franks defence the Liverpool game wasn't bad and he's changed the formation at half time each time we've looked piss poor.

The boo boys... 0-0 and we're booing, best fans in the league? No chance. Shameful.

We're to good to go down? No way not if we have such a lack of confidence. The manager needs to build the players up in a system they're comfortable in. He has changed it mid game and hopefully that's a small hope he can in the future.

I want him to stay as holistically I think he'll be great for the club, kids, development and club progress. He needs to get the players and fans on side and get points on the board. He needs a few transfer windows with the club backing him. But in those circumstances he could be a success.

Hopefully Swansea and Huddersfield have taught him just how slow the change needs to be. I hope he's up for the challenge and can adapt.

 

Jacey Flag 28 Aug 17 10.46am

Originally posted by ger20

Three games is too soon to be thinking of sacking the manager, but having said that there are several areas of concern that do not bode well for the future. De Boors inability to be flexible, lack of charisma and rush to judgment of his players, calling them cowards in public is a big deal and it may be an indication that he is willing to walk out if things don't improve. De Boor was a living legend as a player and expects the players to be up to the standards set by him. He now realises that half the team are championship standard at best. He just doesn't have to tools to succeed. Palace are a kick and rush counter attacking team but it is clear De Boor does not want to play that way. Parish has a clear choice bring in four or five high quality players (unlikely given the time frame and budget constraints) or sack the manager or wait until he walks.

What a depressing state after just 3 games we find ourselves in.
One thing for sure,we need some quality signings in the next few days to arrest this slide.

 

Page 5 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Lost our identity, thanks to parish