You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Alcohol Minimum Unit Pricing
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Alcohol Minimum Unit Pricing


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Mstrobez Flag 15 Nov 17 6.23pm

[Link]

Law just passed in Scotland to have minimum prices on Alcohol according to units.

Personally don't have much time for this as I think detterants are often used as an excuse to make more money, if someone has a problem with alcohol or addiction in any form, making the source more expensive will only make them poorer. The cycle of such example can only be a counter productive one.

However I do think it shines the light on the perceptions of alcohol and the fact that essentially it is a drug. It's quite ironic that this is such a perverse concept to some yet legalising a substance such as cannabis is considered as crazy to the same people.

Edited by Mstrobez (15 Nov 2017 6.24pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

dorking Flag 15 Nov 17 7.17pm

If someone is buying lots, just drive to Berwick on Tweed or Carlisle (over the border) and get it cheap with all the offers.

If they ever do it in England, it will just resurrect all the booze cruises to Calais!

All this does is make life even harder for alcoholics, their diet will worsen as they spend even more on booze

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 15 Nov 17 7.20pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

[Link]

Law just passed in Scotland to have minimum prices on Alcohol according to units.

Personally don't have much time for this as I think detterants are often used as an excuse to make more money, if someone has a problem with alcohol or addiction in any form, making the source more expensive will only make them poorer. The cycle of such example can only be a counter productive one.

However I do think it shines the light on the perceptions of alcohol and the fact that essentially it is a drug. It's quite ironic that this is such a perverse concept to some yet legalising a substance such as cannabis is considered as crazy to the same people.

Edited by Mstrobez (15 Nov 2017 6.24pm)

The makers of Buckfast & Frosty Jack must be doing their crunch however manufacturers of meths and alcohol hand gel must be ecstatic.

 

YT Flag Oxford 15 Nov 17 7.53pm

Ridiculous and ill-considered (Scottish) government interference.

What next; minimum pricing on chips?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Pussay Patrol Flag 15 Nov 17 8.34pm

I think a large proportion of smokers give up because of the cost.

Saying that though alcohol is generally more expensive than in Europe and we have a big drinking culture here

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 16 Nov 17 12.57am

i love to drink. yet i think minimum pricing is a good thing. Good for society, road safety, NHS bills, health, crime statistics. teenagers, the homeless,


if nothing else, it may postpone wino's getting smashed for a few hours every day.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Nov 17 5.49am

Originally posted by YT

Ridiculous and ill-considered (Scottish) government interference.

What next; minimum pricing on chips?

Good god no......I'd starve!

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Nov 17 5.51am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

i love to drink. yet i think minimum pricing is a good thing. Good for society, road safety, NHS bills, health, crime statistics. teenagers, the homeless,


if nothing else, it may postpone wino's getting smashed for a few hours every day.

So if you have money you can continue to get smashed.

But if you are poor....the government says 'fcuk you'.

I instinctively dislike that.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Nov 17 6.29am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Personally don't have much time for this as I think detterants are often used as an excuse to make more money,

Surely if the law has the desired effect it would cut the amount of money being made not increase it

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Nov 17 6.33am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

So if you have money you can continue to get smashed.

But if you are poor....the government says 'fcuk you'.

I instinctively dislike that.

The poorer members of British society don't seem to take any notice of health warnings which is one of the reasons that we are the fattest nation in Western Europe.

I think that minimum pricing is a good idea and I would like to see a large sugar tax imposed on anything with excess sugar in it too

 

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Nov 17 6.40am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The poorer members of British society don't seem to take any notice of health warnings which is one of the reasons that we are the fattest nation in Western Europe.

I think that minimum pricing is a good idea and I would like to see a large sugar tax imposed on anything with excess sugar in it too

I believe that's wrong. It's artificially restricting the choice of the individual because they have less money.

This is taking yet another thing away from them and patting them on the head telling them how they should live their lives.

While those with more money aren't seriously affected.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Nov 2017 7.58am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 16 Nov 17 6.43am

I don't get it as if the equation is SAY:
50p per % ABV per 1L
A 500ml can of 4% lager is £1 that's what it is now.
.75ml whiskey at 37% ABV is £14 app.
No change
The only ones it effects are the super strength beers in reality.
Not many social drinkers drink them anyway.
Unless the cost is way above what I worked it out on.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 16 Nov 17 6.52am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

i love to drink. yet i think minimum pricing is a good thing. Good for society, road safety, NHS bills, health, crime statistics. teenagers, the homeless,


if nothing else, it may postpone wino's getting smashed for a few hours every day.

I think it will have the opposite effect on crime. Skint alcoholics will still drink regardless. Would expect an increase in mugging, burglaries, stealing charity boxes etc.
The homeless will just eat less as a result of this, might also get more of them hooked on cheap drugs.
Also dangerous snide alcohol will become more used/ supplied. I can see why they want to cut down on unsociable behaviour, but I’d rather have a pissed bloke asleep on a bench in the middle of the day , than robbing women’s handbags so that he can get pissed and fall asleep on a bench.
Needs addressing , I don’t know how it should be, but can’t see that this is the answer.

 

Mstrobez Flag 16 Nov 17 7.53am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Surely if the law has the desired effect it would cut the amount of money being made not increase it

But that's the point, I think it will have little effect at all. People who drink in moderation are now punished for a minority with a problem that doesn't take finance into consideration. As I think Stirling mentioned; a wealthy alcoholic carries on buying alcohol, a non wealthy alcoholic starts spending his dinner money on alcohol. Rightly or wrongly, it's just what an addict does, so the results will just completely go against the purpose the Scottish government suggest the law is intended to serve.

As for the detterant side of things, a lot of research into drug use in particular to show that these type of deterrents simply don't work, and as I said in the OP, alcohol is a drug, no matter how much we like to morally seperate it from the illegal kind.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Nov 17 8.02am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I believe that's wrong. It's artificially restricting the choice of the individual because they have less money.

This this taking yet another thing away from them and patting them on the head telling them how they should live their lives.

Perhaps a huge sector of society need to be artificially restricted as they cannot restrict themselves. I doubt whether penal pricing will deter alcoholics but it may slow down or stop others from becoming dependant on alcohol.

I'd still rather see penal pricing on sugar in products though before the NHS is brought to it's knees by fatties who can't or won't control their sugar intake

 

Mstrobez Flag 16 Nov 17 8.08am

Originally posted by Casual

I think it will have the opposite effect on crime. Skint alcoholics will still drink regardless. Would expect an increase in mugging, burglaries, stealing charity boxes etc.
The homeless will just eat less as a result of this, might also get more of them hooked on cheap drugs.
Also dangerous snide alcohol will become more used/ supplied. I can see why they want to cut down on unsociable behaviour, but I’d rather have a pissed bloke asleep on a bench in the middle of the day , than robbing women’s handbags so that he can get pissed and fall asleep on a bench.
Needs addressing , I don’t know how it should be, but can’t see that this is the answer.

Many turn to drink/drugs as a coping mechanism.

So pretty much the usual - serious reforms and funding to social care, mental health services and the NHS.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Nov 17 8.23am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Perhaps a huge sector of society need to be artificially restricted as they cannot restrict themselves. I doubt whether penal pricing will deter alcoholics but it may slow down or stop others from becoming dependant on alcohol.

I'd still rather see penal pricing on sugar in products though before the NHS is brought to it's knees by fatties who can't or won't control their sugar intake

That's selective collectivism based upon financial class ahead of individualism.

A minority will always find a way of abusing the system. They won't be stopped by this and all that will happen is the majority are punished. This might even increase crime levels.

The majority of the funding of the NHS is provided by the working class's national insurance. This is middle class hubris.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 16 Nov 17 8.52am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Perhaps a huge sector of society need to be artificially restricted as they cannot restrict themselves. I doubt whether penal pricing will deter alcoholics but it may slow down or stop others from becoming dependant on alcohol.

I'd still rather see penal pricing on sugar in products though before the NHS is brought to it's knees by fatties who can't or won't control their sugar intake

So fatties are a burden.
What exactly is the NHS for
If the money wasn't spent on 'fatties' what would it be spent on.
I reckon 90% of NHS use is for self inflicted issues.
Road accidents for example as there is no such thing as an 'accident' if you check the terminology.its in the wording.
Most people with an illness have self inflicted it in one way or another through their life. But that isn't mentioned.
The biggest burden on the NHS is people using it who don't need it at that time, they are the burden.
It's there for a reason, when is the last time you needed it midland or how frequently do you.
I would guess very infrequently the same as myself and yes you guessed I'm not a model size bloke. On the other hand I could easily say I pay 10% of my wages in so why can't I have a bit back as and if I need it.! Fat or not !!!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Nov 17 9.50am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I believe that's wrong. It's artificially restricting the choice of the individual because they have less money.

This is taking yet another thing away from them and patting them on the head telling them how they should live their lives.

While those with more money aren't seriously affected.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Nov 2017 7.58am)

Plus it fundamentally misunderstands the problem of alcoholism. It might have an impact on younger drinkers, but I doubt it. It will certainly increase the problems for alcoholics and their families.

I don't disagree with the idea that the UK may have a problematic relationship with alcohol, but in an era where its almost impossible to get an affordable rehab place (privately or for the NHS) this seems to be counter-intuitive to the problem drinking in the UK.

My father is a recovered alcoholic, 42 years and change. When he went into rehab there was virtually no waiting for a place. These days, he reckons, from talking with new AA members that you can be waiting for months to get a place on the NHS, if you can't afford to go private (which is a booming industry in the UK now).

The key with addiction is often getting people into rehab when they've hit rock bottom, and experienced the 'moment of clarity'. If they're having to keep drinking for a month or two after that, well recovery seems less likely; its led to more people going through detox at home, without proper medical supervision which is dangerous.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Nov 17 9.53am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Perhaps a huge sector of society need to be artificially restricted as they cannot restrict themselves. I doubt whether penal pricing will deter alcoholics but it may slow down or stop others from becoming dependant on alcohol.

I'd still rather see penal pricing on sugar in products though before the NHS is brought to it's knees by fatties who can't or won't control their sugar intake

Cost of insulin, vs the cost of long term elderly care? Healthy people, living longer lives are the burden on the NHS. Plus those fatties, paying for the NHS as well with their NI.

Addiction doesn't work like that. Addiction really lies in the person, not the substance.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Alcohol Minimum Unit Pricing