You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Gaza Massacre
November 21 2026 10.43pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Gaza Massacre


Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 17 May 18 11.08pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle


In terms of Gaza Israel's actions are clearly shameful. Their actions in recent weeks have been deliberately inflammatory and their response to protest has been unacceptably heavy handed to say the least. Tit for tat is not an excuse to murder 60-odd people. Approaching a fence does not warrant being executed. These actions should be a last resort not a first one.


Have you been watching Jon Snow on Channel 4? Totally wrong on every point as the previous comment has detailed.

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 18 May 18 7.40am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Man oh man, this purity spiraling.

Tell me a nation outside of the Anglosphere that you think is ok to trade with?

I would stop the arms trade. For the income generated, no way is it worth the tragedy and devastation it produces.

If worrying about our role in human rights abuses is purity spiralling then call me Mother bloomin Theresa.

To my mind, you can’t really moan about Islamic terrorism and condone our arms sales. There is a very clear link.

Edited by serial thriller (18 May 2018 7.41am)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 18 May 18 7.59am

Originally posted by serial thriller

I would stop the arms trade. For the income generated, no way is it worth the tragedy and devastation it produces.

If worrying about our role in human rights abuses is purity spiralling then call me Mother bloomin Theresa.

To my mind, you can’t really moan about Islamic terrorism and condone our arms sales. There is a very clear link.

Edited by serial thriller (18 May 2018 7.41am)

Quoted for truth.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 18 May 18 9.10am

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

Quoted for truth.

Surely Islamic terrorism came (Bin Laden) from Saudi Arabia.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 18 May 18 9.34am

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

What utter nonsense. Inflammatory? How so? Israel just existing is inflammatory to Hamas. They organise these days of rages all the time. 'Shameful' because Israel are trying to protect their border from terrorists trying to get through the fence and kill their own citizens? Tell me what Hamas' intentions would be should they breach the border?

Are you that ignorant? It's not just "approaching a fence". The people of Gaza were told to not go within 300 metres of the border or face the consequences. Everyone knows that Israel don't take s***, so why go to the border?

Had people breached the border into Israel, then hundreds would have been killed! Is that what you prefer?

Hamas paid civilians to be there. Over 50 of the 60 killed were Hamas terrorists and warrant being murdered. Should the IDF come out and give them hugs? Why are you defending terrorists??

Edited by Penge Eagle (17 May 2018 11.16pm)

Huge pomp and ceremony over new US embassy in Jerusalem has been deliberately inflammatory. They could have just done it with minimum fuss.

There is no evidence that any of the people murdered were terrorists.

Shooting people for going near a fence even if you say you will do it isn't justifiable. Would it be reasonable for me to say if you walk down my road I will shoot you? Should I be immune from prosecution were I to do so?

Plenty of things Hamas does are also indefensible, but that doesn't give Israel a free pass to act like barbarians.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 18 May 18 9.40am

Originally posted by Jamesey


Have you been watching Jon Snow on Channel 4? Totally wrong on every point as the previous comment has detailed.

Remind me how many Israelis were killed?

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 18 May 18 10.00am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Huge pomp and ceremony over new US embassy in Jerusalem has been deliberately inflammatory. They could have just done it with minimum fuss.

There is no evidence that any of the people murdered were terrorists.

Shooting people for going near a fence even if you say you will do it isn't justifiable. Would it be reasonable for me to say if you walk down my road I will shoot you? Should I be immune from prosecution were I to do so?

Plenty of things Hamas does are also indefensible, but that doesn't give Israel a free pass to act like barbarians.

Not True:

Salah al-Bardawil, one of the Islamist group’s leaders, told Palestinian Radio on Wednesday: “In the last round of confrontations 62 people were martyred, 50 of them were Hamas.”

I agree that Israel have the means to show more restraint, but then I don't have to live in fear of being attacked every day

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 18 May 18 10.00am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Huge pomp and ceremony over new US embassy in Jerusalem has been deliberately inflammatory. They could have just done it with minimum fuss.

There is no evidence that any of the people murdered were terrorists.

Shooting people for going near a fence even if you say you will do it isn't justifiable. Would it be reasonable for me to say if you walk down my road I will shoot you? Should I be immune from prosecution were I to do so?

Plenty of things Hamas does are also indefensible, but that doesn't give Israel a free pass to act like barbarians.

The opening of the embassy is a BIG deal for Israel. If you can't see how that doesn't deserve huge fuss, then... So what's the excuse for all the other times Hamas causes violence and attempts to kill Israeli citizens then?

'Hamas Leader Says 50 Members Killed in Gaza Protests'
[Link] This story has been reported a lot but not in the left wing outlets you read.

Walking down the road is not comparable to trying to breach a national border which you consider a hated enemy and are also warned of the dangers. It's not like they were crossing the French-Belgian border. Are you actually using that as a sensible comparison??

Protecting your citizens is not acting like barbarians. Hamas wanted to breach the border fence and kill Israelis. If a terrorist intends to kill, then they deserved to be killed. But you'd let them over the fence and give them a hug, wouldn't you.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 18 May 18 10.10am

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

The opening of the embassy is a BIG deal for Israel. If you can't see how that doesn't deserve huge fuss, then... So what's the excuse for all the other times Hamas causes violence and attempts to kill Israeli citizens then?

'Hamas Leader Says 50 Members Killed in Gaza Protests'
[Link] This story has been reported a lot but not in the left wing outlets you read.

Walking down the road is not comparable to trying to breach a national border which you consider a hated enemy and are also warned of the dangers. It's not like they were crossing the French-Belgian border. Are you actually using that as a sensible comparison??

Protecting your citizens is not acting like barbarians. Hamas wanted to breach the border fence and kill Israelis. If a terrorist intends to kill, then they deserved to be killed. But you'd let them over the fence and give them a hug, wouldn't you.

Remind me how many Israelis were killed during the protests.

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 18 May 18 10.11am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Remind me how many Israelis were killed during the protests.

I don't understand your point?

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 18 May 18 10.13am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Not True:

Salah al-Bardawil, one of the Islamist group’s leaders, told Palestinian Radio on Wednesday: “In the last round of confrontations 62 people were martyred, 50 of them were Hamas.”

I agree that Israel have the means to show more restraint, but then I don't have to live in fear of being attacked every day

Where is the evidence that they were going to commit any sort of terrorist act?

The killings were one sided and the actions of Israel totally disproportionate, for which they should be condemned at the very least.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 18 May 18 10.14am

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

I don't understand your point?


Understanding the toll on the Israelis side will help understand how reasonable their actions were and whether their actions constituted defence or aggression.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 18 May 18 10.15am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Huge pomp and ceremony over new US embassy in Jerusalem has been deliberately inflammatory. They could have just done it with minimum fuss.

There is no evidence that any of the people murdered were terrorists.

Shooting people for going near a fence even if you say you will do it isn't justifiable. Would it be reasonable for me to say if you walk down my road I will shoot you? Should I be immune from prosecution were I to do so?

The Trump media describe this as 'involved in clashes'.

Time to re-think our alliances, adopt a neutral position not automatically involved in a coalition, seemingly without thinking.

Not Trump but the rest of the World, I find Russia and China and the EU more reasoned stable places.

Trump would not keep to a deal struck as Iran shows, so why bother, we are still close to the American people and he will be gone one day sooner the better.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 May 18 10.27am

Originally posted by steeleye20

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Huge pomp and ceremony over new US embassy in Jerusalem has been deliberately inflammatory. They could have just done it with minimum fuss.

There is no evidence that any of the people murdered were terrorists.

Shooting people for going near a fence even if you say you will do it isn't justifiable. Would it be reasonable for me to say if you walk down my road I will shoot you? Should I be immune from prosecution were I to do so?

The Trump media describe this as 'involved in clashes'.

Time to re-think our alliances, adopt a neutral position not automatically involved in a coalition, seemingly without thinking.

Not Trump but the rest of the World, I find Russia and China and the EU more reasoned stable places.

Trump would not keep to a deal struck as Iran shows, so why bother, we are still close to the American people and he will be gone one day sooner the better.

Well what a shock.

I think you will find that America has still got our six. A bit dumb to bite the hand that has it's finger on the trigger of a big pile of nukes pointed at your enemies.
We have more influence over them as friends than enemies, which is still not much.

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 18 May 18 10.29am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle


Understanding the toll on the Israelis side will help understand how reasonable their actions were and whether their actions constituted defence or aggression.

So I take it you would have been happier had it been an even death count?

Do you understand the death toll of ordinary Israelis under attack by Palastinians. There were three killed in March.

Israel's actions stopped more Hamas deaths and ensured it was zero Israeli deaths. That is a good thing.

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 18 May 18 10.32am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Where is the evidence that they were going to commit any sort of terrorist act?

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 18 May 18 10.48am

Gunning down over 50 civilians whatever the reason, is not an occasion for laughter.

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 18 May 18 10.52am

Originally posted by steeleye20

Gunning down over 50 civilians whatever the reason, is not an occasion for laughter.

Aren't you reading the thread? They were Hamas terrorists!

Also, read the particular point I was laughing at. Please don't misquote me.

Edited by Penge Eagle (18 May 2018 10.56am)

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 18 May 18 12.51pm

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

Aren't you reading the thread? They were Hamas terrorists!

Also, read the particular point I was laughing at. Please don't misquote me.

Edited by Penge Eagle (18 May 2018 10.56am)

Devil's Advocate calling once again: does being a member of Hamas instantly turn you into an Ak-47 wielding terrorist just waiting for the chance to shoot an Israeli civvy? "Jihad, dirka dirka" comes to mind.

Hamas is a large movement with many, many followers in Gaza. Are they all gun-toting threats to Israeli life? I'm sure that some of them are - however I'd bet that there are members of the IDF who fit a similar profile.

Hamas shouldn't get a free pass, but then neither does the so-called civilised, western-style democratic and law-abiding Israeli state. That's why I (and maybe others) are angry about this.

It really is one rule for Israel and one rule for pretty much everyone else. Feel free to show me how I'm wrong and highlight all the sanctions and punitive actions taken against Israel when it's killed large numbers of people either in Gaza, the West Bank or Lebanon?

When states actively kill civilians, it's unacceptable. It doesn't matter which state it is.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Islington Eagle Flag North of the River 18 May 18 1.08pm

Few Points:

The fence is not a border. The people of Gaza are under the occupying control of Israel since the 1967 war. How is it a border? Remeber there is no country of Palestine - so this is not a border.

As the occupying power the government of Israel has a responsibility to the inhabintants of Gaza. However since the Democratic election of Hamas in free and fair elections Israel has imposed illegal collective punishment on the 2 million people of Gaza (for exercising their democratic right - the result of which Israel didn't like).
This collective punishment has meant that Gaza has become an open prison where Water and Power have been rationed. The economy has been destroyed by a blockade and 2 wars. Everyday items are prevented from entering Gaza on the pretence that they could be used as weapons. In response to this Gazans built tunnels to sneak in items. Fisherman are regularly shot and killed by the Israeli navy. Farmers are shot and killed in the fields near the fence. Regular incursions over the fence by Israel are used to bulldoze houses, olive groves and crops. The Israeli airforce overfly the City "sonic booming" the residents nightly.
This is a living hell for the residents where Israel controls nearly every aspect of their daily lives.
It has also not dislodged Hamas - Whose govenment is one of the only employers of anyone in the city where 50% are unemployed.
Hamas are not nice people, and have a horrible charter that seeks the destruction of Israel; but characterising people in desperate situations all as terrorists is incorrect. Gaza contains all sorts of men women and children with all sorts of views, all sorts of dreams and aspirations. They are like any other city - but put yourself in their situation - what would you do? You can only poke people with a stick so much.
Israel does not seek any peace. they are happy with the status quo where their creeping colonialisation of the west bank continues, and where the Palestinians are marginalised economically and physically into Bantustans. This is the very definition of Apartheid. It is on the basis of this that we as individuals, organisations and governements should be boycotting Israel until it changes its policies and engages in genuine peace negotiations.

By the way there are far two many people on this thread conflating Jews and Israel. Just saying.

 


Palace Fan

Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Gaza Massacre