This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
This is where people (and probably our scouting department) are getting it wrong. It’s gonna sound a bit silly, but Meyer only played in the holding position last season. He didn’t actually play as a traditional holding midfielder. Not one that could be likened to any holding role we have in our team anyway. He was a “deep lying playmaker” for Schalke last year, and what his strengths were in the holding position are still entirely different to anything Cabaye did for us. And what Roy would require as part of the 2 defensive midfielders he seems to always play with. His job last season was essentially to knit the play together from a deeper position, think Pirlo or Jorginho. But it wasn’t at all to be a tireless or tenacious defensive midfielder (a bit like Cabaye was for us), and actually you’d see the likes of Bentaleb & Goretzka doing a lot more of the defensive work in midfield. He is not a like for like replacement for Cabaye in any sense of the word. They are 2 different players. And that goes without mentioning, despite the fact Cabaye is a huge miss for us and was a key player. I actually think we would’ve still got more out of him had he played higher up more often. Meyers most promising years were as a number 10. That’s when he was forecasted to be one of the very best in the world. And for the way Roy plays, with the personnel we’ve got, we need to have him as the creative force in the side. That will mean being the closest midfielder to Wilf. A bit like we saw when he came on at Watford. As I said previously. I think we have a ready made solution for the “striker problem”. Get Meyer in for RLC and closer to Wilf and things will happen. Agree with this. All the time I've seen him play, not sure I've seen him make a tackle. I'd play him left with kayoute and Luka as defensive midfielders and townsend right...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mr Fenandes
Out of interest, why do you think that? I don't like to judge a player too early but I haven't seen anything in his game which looks like he'll make it at this level. I'm getting a Patrick Bamford vibe about him, and he looks less hard-working now than his first game, which is worrying. Way, way too casual. They both look like they know a good hair dressing salon when they see one. I'm sure that is why they were signed.
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” |
|
|
Originally posted by Mr Fenandes
Out of interest, why do you think that? I don't like to judge a player too early but I haven't seen anything in his game which looks like he'll make it at this level. I'm getting a Patrick Bamford vibe about him, and he looks less hard-working now than his first game, which is worrying. Way, way too casual.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
This is where people (and probably our scouting department) are getting it wrong. It’s gonna sound a bit silly, but Meyer only played in the holding position last season. He didn’t actually play as a traditional holding midfielder. Not one that could be likened to any holding role we have in our team anyway. He was a “deep lying playmaker” for Schalke last year, and what his strengths were in the holding position are still entirely different to anything Cabaye did for us. And what Roy would require as part of the 2 defensive midfielders he seems to always play with. His job last season was essentially to knit the play together from a deeper position, think Pirlo or Jorginho. But it wasn’t at all to be a tireless or tenacious defensive midfielder (a bit like Cabaye was for us), and actually you’d see the likes of Bentaleb & Goretzka doing a lot more of the defensive work in midfield. He is not a like for like replacement for Cabaye in any sense of the word. They are 2 different players. And that goes without mentioning, despite the fact Cabaye is a huge miss for us and was a key player. I actually think we would’ve still got more out of him had he played higher up more often. Meyers most promising years were as a number 10. That’s when he was forecasted to be one of the very best in the world. And for the way Roy plays, with the personnel we’ve got, we need to have him as the creative force in the side. That will mean being the closest midfielder to Wilf. A bit like we saw when he came on at Watford. As I said previously. I think we have a ready made solution for the “striker problem”. Get Meyer in for RLC and closer to Wilf and things will happen. Interesting debate mate. I don’t follow German football closely but didn’t Meyer’s career as a no 10 kinda stall? You’re maybe right in that he was more Pirlo style playmaker but that’s what we’re desperately missing - from what I see in our current set up since Cabaye left. How many sideways passes in the Wolves game? No two players are the same so perhaps we’d need a fresh midfield shape for it to work but I see lots of potential in Meyer when he’s had a chance. He should be the first receiver of the ball from defence. Who knows with 2 holding next to him he could the float forward as well. But he can’t do anything on the bench.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Aray
Maybe we're talking about different things. I was addressing your point saying we haven't got anyone to replace Cabaye. We do his name is Meyer. I only mentioned formation as a passing point. The lack of quality up front is not a new thing. RLC hardly scored a boatload did he?
|
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Striking Options' by Midlands Eagle He could be, yes. Or not. But hopefully. Merrrrrrge.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
You know what, I'll hold my hands up. I completely forgot we played the two of them together at the end of the season. I was thinking of October/November 2017 when aside from the Chelsea result it didn't really work. In fact Tekkers return to the team saw us get a win at Stoke (he came on at h/t when it was 0-0) and scored in the 3-0 win away to Leicester after we reverted to a normal striker. Maybe dementia is setting in early? Perhaps you ought to be in charge of substitutions :-)
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by jjsperling
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Striking Options' by Midlands Eagle Could Connor Wickham be the solution to give us an edge going forward. Or should we stick with Ayew, or the Zaha-Townsend partnership? A fit Connor Wickham up front would be preferable to any other striker options we have at the moment. For a while though I think we will all be holding our breath every time he breaks into a run.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Pete53
A fit Connor Wickham up front would be preferable to any other striker options we have at the moment. For a while though I think we will all be holding our breath every time he breaks into a run. .........or a sweat for that matter !!
Pro USA & Israel |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I was in conversation yesterday with an A.Villa supporter who simply cannot believe what has happened to Benteke.He said that he was brilliant for A.Villa and was keeping Lukaku out of the Belgium team.He is unrecognisable from the player at that club. In actual fact, a couple of years ago, I saw Gordon 'Sid' Cowans in a pub in Lichfield.Cowans was coach at A.Villa when Benteke was there.I intended to speak to 'Sid' about Benteke but never got to speak to him. Edited by Willo (24 Oct 2018 1.34pm) It happens, look at Fernando Torres. It’s a combination of factors spearheaded by a mental problem and lack of confidence. Benteke is possibly the best header of a ball in the league, or he was at least, but we have never exploited that properly. He was a different player at Villa for sure. Sad reality is he may never get back there after misfiring for so long.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha. |
|
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
It happens, look at Fernando Torres. It’s a combination of factors spearheaded by a mental problem and lack of confidence. Benteke is possibly the best header of a ball in the league, or he was at least, but we have never exploited that properly. He was a different player at Villa for sure. Sad reality is he may never get back there after misfiring for so long. I actually think Benteke has been playing injured for the best part of 2 years. It's clear we have had no other options at the club and the operation he's had now was a last resort after continuous attempts to patch him up and get him out for the next game. My main annoyance is that the club should probably have made him have an op right at the end of the last season with a view to having him back for the start of this one. We've seen how often Zaha is pushed back early when he should be out for a few weeks and his form has suffered for it. It may be wishful thinking, but I genuinely think if he comes back in January fully fit, we'll see a completely different Benteke to the one we've seen the last 18 months. We saw enough in his first season to know he's got it in him.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JohnB
I actually think Benteke has been playing injured for the best part of 2 years. It's clear we have had no other options at the club and the operation he's had now was a last resort after continuous attempts to patch him up and get him out for the next game. My main annoyance is that the club should probably have made him have an op right at the end of the last season with a view to having him back for the start of this one. We've seen how often Zaha is pushed back early when he should be out for a few weeks and his form has suffered for it. It may be wishful thinking, but I genuinely think if he comes back in January fully fit, we'll see a completely different Benteke to the one we've seen the last 18 months. We saw enough in his first season to know he's got it in him. My thoughts have been along these lines . there is no way we have the player that Liverpool signed from Villa so something has gone wrong somewhere . An ongoing injury could be the problem and the op and the rest could do Christian the world of good. I did think he was not 100% last season and nothing changed at the start of this so maybe it was the club delaying for the sake of having him in squad and finally deciding they had made the wrong call . COYP , CO Christian .
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wilbraham413
Glenn Murray now has more goals than our entire team. I don't see how we can keep going like this.
|
|
|
We need midfielders who create chances - Meyer should start ahead of any others barring Zaha
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.