This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by cryrst
I asked if you backed May's deal and you didnt What part of me backing it in a straight fight between deal and no deal do you not understand? because you thought brexit would be overturned. Wrong. I didn't "think" that. I hoped for it and preferred that it would be. I didn't expect it. Outside interference was by what means and by whom. The security report will reveal that but my expectations are that the Russians were behind it, aided and abetted by Cambridge Analytica with Farage's fingerprints all over it. Adverts on the net? Not adverts. Internet memes and trolling which planted fake news and spread propaganda. If you think these are unimportant then you underestimate the power of social media these days. Trump doesn't use Twitter for no reason. Give the public some credit. I do. Do you? They deserve to know what's true and what isn't. A choice was in or out end of. That's just the typical attitude of the hardline leaver. It's about as reasonable, and true, as the "we won" attitude. As the events since 2016 showed very clearly it was far from such a clearcut choice. Asking one simple question to a set of complex problems was soon shown to be a huge mistake. A mistake that ought to have been acknowledged and dealt with by Parliament. Out got more votes. Just, in 2016 after a suspect referendum. By 2019, when people understood more, it seems the balance had shifted. That was ignored and the people's understandable frustration and boredom exploited. The rest was always negotiable. Negotiations always depend on what the objectives are and then on who is handling them. We weren't exactly blessed with much skill were we?
Your choice to concentrate on Brexit. Not mine. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (16 Feb 2020 8.12pm)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Edited by Wisbech Eagle (16 Feb 2020 8.12pm) I voted to reman.
|
|
|
Then on this particular 'subject' the divisions can start to be reversed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
I voted to reman. You might not have started as a hardline leaver but the attitude you routinely espouse on here marks you out as one. I am sure that you know the old adage that "there are none so devoted as the converted". I have no idea what you are expecting after Dec 31st. I am expecting half a deal, on the easy bits, and a fudge on others with a delay disguised as something else and blamed on EU intransigence to keep the troops onside. How long will it be before you admit has all "gone south? I have heard some leavers say it will take 20 years before we manage to get back to where we would have been if we stayed in. By which time many who voted to leave will be dead! My own view is that in today's fast changing world nothing is certain for very long so we need to see an immediate improvement or it's a failure. Oh, in the very unlikely event that the UK enters a period of unrestricted growth, with a united and happy people with no defections by Scotland or Northern Ireland then I will happily admit I was wrong. Don't hold you breath though.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Typical hard line leaver. Unable to accept that other opinions exist let alone show them any respect. It's no wonder that these divisions exist and that people like me go on fighting as a result. I'm just sick to death of you repeating yours for the hundredth time. We get it. You can't accept democracy and everyone else is wrong.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cpfc_chap
Shame we didn't have the pr voting in place in 2015 as UKIP would've had large representative and Brexit would have been sorted I'd imagine also with this system the Brexit party would've had a large number of seats. You're really a brexiteer in disguise!! Regarding referendums, how would a countries and regions like scotland, N.Ireland and Barcelona vote for independence? I agree it was a shame it wasn't in place then because you are right, they would have had around 70 seats, almost all taken from the Tories. It would also have sorted Brexit out but not in the way you think. If they had the voice they deserved in Parliament the argument for a referendum would have gone up in smoke and the remain majority in Parliament would have seen them off. Exactly the same with the Brexit Party. They deserve to be represented but only at the level of their support. Scotland, N Ireland and the Catalan region ought not to be able to vote for independence. If it is to be done then it needs to be decided by the relevant Parliament. A consultative referendum of ALL the people might be sensible.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I'm just sick to death of you repeating yours for the hundredth time. We get it. You can't accept democracy and everyone else is wrong. The answer is entirely in your own hands. No-one is compelled to read what I have to say let alone respond to anything. You don't get it at all so yes you are wrong. I respect democracy. I don't believe in referendums as they are not part of our system. They are a fudge. A cop out by our elected representatives seeking to avoid taking the blame. When the system is broke then we need to change it. FPTP is really broken.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Or a mixture of the two. In this instance would it have been better for MPs to have made the decision to leave the EU on their own? Would that have been more democratic? It would have not just been more democratic. It would have just been democratic. They, of course, would not have done so as the MPs, who are more aware of all the complexities than the population at large, and less influenced by the media, were overwhelmingly in favour of remaining in the EU.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Or apparently the Supreme Court could decide what was best for us all. The Supreme Court did no such thing. It offered no opinion on the merits, or otherwise, of anything being done by the government, including Brexit. All it did was rule that the PM deciding to prorogue in the way he did was unlawful as it restricted Parliament's duty to scrutinise. It only did that because it was asked to rule. It did not bring the action itself!
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It would have not just been more democratic. It would have just been democratic. They, of course, would not have done so as the MPs, who are more aware of all the complexities than the population at large, and less influenced by the media, were overwhelmingly in favour of remaining in the EU. So 326 MPs voting to leave would have more validity in democratic terms. Sorry but I don’t buy this since some of them don’t understand the complexities of putting on a hat.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The Supreme Court did no such thing. It offered no opinion on the merits, or otherwise, of anything being done by the government, including Brexit. All it did was rule that the PM deciding to prorogue in the way he did was unlawful as it restricted Parliament's duty to scrutinise. It only did that because it was asked to rule. It did not bring the action itself! MPs are public servants - as such their only duty was to serve the will of the people. They failed miserably and got the boot at the next election. The Supreme Court and the Speaker revealed their true colours and have and will also pay the price.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
So 326 MPs voting to leave would have more validity in democratic terms. Sorry but I don’t buy this since some of them don’t understand the complexities of putting on a hat. What your, or my, opinion is of any MP is irrelevant. When we elect them they then acquire the duty of their office. Don't like it? Then elect better MPs.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
MPs are public servants - as such their only duty was to serve the will of the people. They failed miserably and got the boot at the next election. The Supreme Court and the Speaker revealed their true colours and have and will also pay the price. I will doubtless get criticised for repetition but you are yet another who doesn't understand the way our democracy actually works. MP's are not public servants. They are our elected representatives, sent to Parliament to decide things for us. Our sole task is to choose who we want to represent us. After that they make their own decisions. They don't "serve the will of the people"! They determine what the people need and not what they want. If we don't like the results then we change them for others when we get the opportunity. The Supreme Court simply did it's job. It was asked to rule on a matter of law and it did. If it had not been asked it would not have been involved in any way. The Speaker also did his job. He protected the rights of Parliament and stood up for the back benchers. That he frustrated the government was obvious but that was their own fault as they attempted to over reach themselves and tried to sideline Parliament. It is Parliament is that is sovereign and not the government. No government, or PM, can do very much unless it can carry Parliament with it. Right now, with an 80 seat majority and a new bunch of compliant Tory MPs, that's easy but the fact remains. It's Parliament, and not the government, which is the ultimate authority.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I will doubtless get criticised for repetition but you are yet another who doesn't understand the way our democracy actually works. 1 MP's are not public servants. They are our elected representatives, sent to Parliament to decide things for us. Our sole task is to choose who we want to represent us. After that they make their own decisions. They don't "serve the will of the people"! They determine what the people need and not what they want. If we don't like the results then we change them for others when we get the opportunity. 2 The Speaker also did his job. He protected the rights of Parliament and stood up for the back benchers. That he frustrated the government was obvious but that was their own fault as they attempted to over reach themselves and tried to sideline Parliament. It is Parliament is that is sovereign and not the government. No government, or PM, can do very much unless it can carry Parliament with it. Right now, with an 80 seat majority and a new bunch of compliant Tory MPs, that's easy but the fact remains. It's Parliament, and not the government, which is the ultimate authority. 1. Correct you will be. I have heard several distinguished MPs and constitutional experts define the role of an MP in far narrower terms that you put. MPs are expected to keep to any public statements they make during the election and to the manifesto they publicly endorse. Ken Clarke made it clear he would not vote for Brexit and I have no problem with that the voters knew what they were getting. Many other MPs simply lied to the voters especially around the 2017 GE when the issues around Brexit were well known at that stage so the argument that they changed their mind due to new information post GE was hogwash. Other than that your are correct MPs are free to vote on matters that are not central to the platform they were elected on or issues that arise post GE. You may disagree but as we an unwritten constitution the role is open to interpretation. However I think the bloodbath of the 2019 GE showed what the public thought of these liars they either stood down or were trounced I can't think of one MP who betrayed the voters that is still in Parliament.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
What your, or my, opinion is of any MP is irrelevant. When we elect them they then acquire the duty of their office. Don't like it? Then elect better MPs. This is the problem though. There are too many politicians being elected for reasons other than than their political expertise. For example those two parliamentary titans in north London, one of whom can’t put her shoes on the right feet and the other who thought Marie Antoinette won the Nobel Prize for Physics in 1903. These are the intellectual powerhouses who should have made the decision for us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
This is the problem though. There are too many politicians being elected for reasons other than than their political expertise. For example those two parliamentary titans in north London, one of whom can’t put her shoes on the right feet and the other who thought Marie Antoinette won the Nobel Prize for Physics in 1903. These are the intellectual powerhouses who should have made the decision for us. If they joined forces, and with their spelling skills, they could call themselves Lobotomy.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I will doubtless get criticised for repetition but you are yet another who doesn't understand the way our democracy actually works. MP's are not public servants. They are our elected representatives, sent to Parliament to decide things for us. Our sole task is to choose who we want to represent us. After that they make their own decisions. They don't "serve the will of the people"! They determine what the people need and not what they want. If we don't like the results then we change them for others when we get the opportunity. The Supreme Court simply did it's job. It was asked to rule on a matter of law and it did. If it had not been asked it would not have been involved in any way. The Speaker also did his job. He protected the rights of Parliament and stood up for the back benchers. That he frustrated the government was obvious but that was their own fault as they attempted to over reach themselves and tried to sideline Parliament. It is Parliament is that is sovereign and not the government. No government, or PM, can do very much unless it can carry Parliament with it. Right now, with an 80 seat majority and a new bunch of compliant Tory MPs, that's easy but the fact remains. It's Parliament, and not the government, which is the ultimate authority. You have repeated this many times. It doesn't make it any more correct. Think carefully about your statement, actually consider other viewpoints for a change. Take your argument - if MPs do not serve the public - then who exactly?
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I will doubtless get criticised for repetition but you are yet another who doesn't understand the way our democracy actually works. MP's are not public servants. They are our elected representatives, sent to Parliament to decide things for us. Our sole task is to choose who we want to represent us. After that they make their own decisions. They don't "serve the will of the people"! They determine what the people need and not what they want. If we don't like the results then we change them for others when we get the opportunity. The Supreme Court simply did it's job. It was asked to rule on a matter of law and it did. If it had not been asked it would not have been involved in any way. The Speaker also did his job. He protected the rights of Parliament and stood up for the back benchers. That he frustrated the government was obvious but that was their own fault as they attempted to over reach themselves and tried to sideline Parliament. It is Parliament is that is sovereign and not the government. No government, or PM, can do very much unless it can carry Parliament with it. Right now, with an 80 seat majority and a new bunch of compliant Tory MPs, that's easy but the fact remains. It's Parliament, and not the government, which is the ultimate authority. We have moved on and Brexit won. Waffle and disagree all you like. It makes no difference.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
You have repeated this many times. It doesn't make it any more correct. Think carefully about your statement, actually consider other viewpoints for a change. Take your argument - if MPs do not serve the public - then who exactly? Do you have a problem with the truth? Considering other viewpoints doesn't change the truth. It's not that I don't understand your viewpoint. It's just that it isn't true. The only reason I repeat it is because people like you continue to argue the point! MPs don't "serve" anybody. They "serve" the country's needs. Together they form our Parliament which is the sovereign power in the UK. We choose them so we can change them if they don't perform to our satisfaction so from that perspective alone they need to be mindful if their overriding priority is to keep a job. For those who put their duty above self interest (as those brave MPs did in the last Parliament) they will ignore any such pressure and concentrate on what they conclude is in the best interests of their constituents and the country as a whole. As I have repeatedly said our MPs are NOT delegates. They are our representatives and that fact completely changes what they must do and how they do it. The pity is that even some MPs don't actually understand this.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
We have moved on and Brexit won. Waffle and disagree all you like. It makes no difference. What I wrote had nothing to do with Brexit per se. It was merely the background event which could just as easily been something else. What makes no difference, for a while at least, is the 80 seat majority that Corbyn's stupidity handed to Johnson. With such a majority he can cope with quite a large rebellion and still do whatever he wants. I hear whispers that such a rebellion may well be brewing over the coming budget with a bunch of traditional Tories unhappy with the spend, spend spend largesse being thrown at the north by the Prince of Darkness (Dominic Cummings) who has taken control of the Treasury.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.