This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
It will remain a handball offence if a player scores accidentally with their hand or arm, or uses their hand or arm directly before scoring. So it is a partial climb-down As RH says, handball should be deliberate. I wholeheartedly agree. What with our current anti-football and the excitement nullifying VAR, I’m likely to watch lower league and non league games once crowds can return. I’ll still renew mine and my sons season ticket, to support the club, but I’m not subjecting him to the s***e served up at home against the likes of Brighton, Newcastle, Liverpool, Burnley and Fulham...especially when VAR then destroys any of the excitement were we to actually score a goal, as it searches for 2 minutes to find a way of disallowing it.
|
|
|
Some new ideas and a discussion of VAR:
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Last night's latest VAR faux-pas really takes the biscuit. The VAR match centre said: "The on-field referee felt that Alex McCarthy got a slight touch on the ball, and VAR couldn't see anything to disprove that." Haven't seen the incident but have read about it. VAR has been a total car crash. The fact you can't celebrate goals has destroyed the best part of football. Football decisions are too subjective and I can never see it working. Tennis and cricket are great as the rules are very black and white, as is goaline technology. I don't watch football anymore (unless its Palace) because I just get wound up with the constant over analysis of every incident. I don't know anyone personally who likes VAR and I'm just surprised there isn't more of a movement to scrap it from the game.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Haven't seen the incident but have read about it. VAR has been a total car crash. The fact you can't celebrate goals has destroyed the best part of football. Football decisions are too subjective and I can never see it working. Tennis and cricket are great as the rules are very black and white, as is goaline technology. I don't watch football anymore (unless its Palace) because I just get wound up with the constant over analysis of every incident. I don't know anyone personally who likes VAR and I'm just surprised there isn't more of a movement to scrap it from the game. Apparently there’s an online petition to scrap VAR. Adrian Durham spoke about it last night on Talksport.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eritheagle
Apparently there’s an online petition to scrap VAR. Adrian Durham spoke about it last night on Talksport. Even if by some remote chance VAR is no longer deployed, it will always be mentioned ; IE Under VAR that would have been offside,a foul etc etc.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
I watched the game and it definitely looked like a penalty to me. Pep thinks VAR decisions never go their way, and after seeing the debacle last night I have some sympathy with him. Many VAR decisions are dubious, but the one aspect I really struggle with is offside when it's by a fingertip or elbow. I'm in the 'let's see daylight' camp. As many have said on here already, VAR is taking the thrill of the moment out of the game. Great shame. There are those who have complained about 'Subjectivity' in relation to VAR but the Offside ruling as adjudged by VAR is objective, it is either proved offside or onside, yet there are still those who are not content with the application of VAR in this respect.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
There are those who have complained about 'Subjectivity' in relation to VAR but the Offside ruling as adjudged by VAR is objective, it is either proved offside or onside, yet there are still those who are not content with the application of VAR in this respect. I agree that offside is a clear rule where subjectivity doesn't come into it, however, we all know the technology at present isn't 100% accurate, so it can't work in its current form. All this arm being offside is a total nonsense and leaves everyone waiting around to possibly do a half celebration. Fouls and handballs will always divide opinion, so lets just stick with the referees original decision and move on. It worked fine before. You will get decisions go far/against you which even themselves out over time. In my opinion, the linesman are pretty good any get 90% of decision correct anyway. I'm not averse to there being a pitch side referee who can overrule a really poor decision - i.e. one that can be seen clearly is an error in one 5 second replay. Not one which requires 2 minutes of slow mo replays from 3 angles to spot a 'clear and obvious error'
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
There are those who have complained about 'Subjectivity' in relation to VAR but the Offside ruling as adjudged by VAR is objective, it is either proved offside or onside, yet there are still those who are not content with the application of VAR in this respect. I understand the objectivity of VAR in the context of the offside rule in particular. I would just prefer daylight to be the object rather than a fingertip. For certain there would be less decisions needing to be referred for judgement if that we're the case. As I said in my last post, the aspect most of us dislike is the period of deliberation before we can cheer or boo.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
I understand the objectivity of VAR in the context of the offside rule in particular. I would just prefer daylight to be the object rather than a fingertip. For certain there would be less decisions needing to be referred for judgement if that we're the case. As I said in my last post, the aspect most of us dislike is the period of deliberation before we can cheer or boo. My view,for what it is worth, is there would still be debate about the fine margins of 'Daylight'.The devil always lies in the detail! Forget all this Onside/Offside adjudication.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
My view,for what it is worth, is there would still be debate about the fine margins of 'Daylight'.The devil always lies in the detail! Forget all this Onside/Offside adjudication. Why not simply say a player to be offside must have the whole of his body in front of the last defender.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Why not simply say a player to be offside must have the whole of his body in front of the last defender. Perhaps there will be a debate if part of the heel was adjudged to have been in line with the last defender! Fine margins once more! Just revert back to the old days when Assistant Referees used to get a very high percentage of the calls right, there is no delaying the raising of the flag and referees can simply stop the game to consult a pitch monitor in respect of penalties and red cards with no VAR chirping in their ears. !!!! Indeed goals will be scored which might have been 'Chalked off' by VAR but life is not perfect,VAR is not perfect !!!! I thought I would run this idea up the flagpole and see who salutes it !!!! Edited by Willo (11 Mar 2021 12.12pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Perhaps there will be a debate if part of the heel was adjudged to have been in line with the last defender! Fine margins once more! Just revert back to the old days when Assistant Referees used to get a very high percentage of the calls right, there is no delaying the raising of the flag and referees can simply stop the game to consult a pitch monitor in respect of penalties and red cards with no VAR chirping in their ears. !!!! Indeed goals will be scored which might have been 'Chalked off' by VAR but life is not perfect,VAR is not perfect !!!! I thought I would run this idea up the flagpole and see who salutes it !!!! Edited by Willo (11 Mar 2021 12.12pm) Funnily enough, I think you and I are 'on the same page' as they say. I too was about to suggest a novel new way to deal with this issue. A referree. He could make an instant decision, blow his whistle, players would happily accept his ruling and we'd all get on with game.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
VAR can be a fantastic tool, but referees need their heads banging together over the meaning of 'clear and obvious'. Put simply, they shouldn't be allowed more than ~20 seconds of viewing time and that's only to make sure the best angle gets checked. If they can't make a decision in ~20 seconds, it's evidently not obvious. The point at which a line needs to be slowly shifted back and forth to hit an exact point to make an offside decision, it's evidently not obvious, so just get on with the game. VAR should only ever be in place to deal with the El Hadji Diouf dives, the Aubameyang tackle on Meyer last year - not to turn football into a science. "Clear and obvious" is also a subjective judgement call so open to controversy.
|
|
|
'Top 50 Comedy VAR Decisions', coming to E4 June.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
"Clear and obvious" is also a subjective judgement call so open to controversy. It's subjective, but I think the standard should be so high as to make that subjectiveness fairly obsolete. If it takes more than ~20 seconds of looking at it, I don't think the decision is clearly and obviously wrong. The tool is there to prevent scandals, not to re-referee the game. Take the Soucek red card at Fulham. It evidently wasn't clearly and obviously wrong because it got overturned. That's a referee lowering the decision-making standard. Take the goal Bamford scored against us - is any Palace fan up in arms had that goal been given? The penalty appeal we had at Villa was exactly right. Referee was asked to look at it (not sure why), I myself am thinking 'you could give it, but I'm not up in arms if we don't get it' and the referee rightly said it's not clear and obvious.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
I agree that offside is a clear rule where subjectivity doesn't come into it, however, we all know the technology at present isn't 100% accurate, so it can't work in its current form. All this arm being offside is a total nonsense and leaves everyone waiting around to possibly do a half celebration. Fouls and handballs will always divide opinion, so lets just stick with the referees original decision and move on. It worked fine before. You will get decisions go far/against you which even themselves out over time. In my opinion, the linesman are pretty good any get 90% of decision correct anyway. I'm not averse to there being a pitch side referee who can overrule a really poor decision - i.e. one that can be seen clearly is an error in one 5 second replay. Not one which requires 2 minutes of slow mo replays from 3 angles to spot a 'clear and obvious error' Wholeheartedly agree. It has already been shown that there is a +/- 14cm ‘margin of error’ due to freeze frame technology. Then there is the subjectivity of the Video Assistant Referee in Shockley Park to decide when the ball is played and then where to draw the lines (Bamford v Palace being the classic example of a huge error). VAR just isn’t fit for purpose to adjudicate on marginal offsides. Not only this but the ludicrous situation we now have, where the assistant referees don’t flag until sometimes almost 40 seconds after the ‘offside’ is another aspect ruining the game as people don’t seem to play on with the same conviction or intensity, knowing or wondering if it is going to be given offside in another minute or so. Someone is also going to be seriously injured in one of the phases of play, for absolutely no reason and when the Assistant Referee could’ve easily flagged for offside, as of old. There will be a huge law-suit and quite rightly so!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.