You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic
November 22 2026 1.07pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rhian Brewster (rumour) (LOCKED)


Page 5 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Spiderman Flag Horsham 18 Sep 20 2.11pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

what concerns me a little is that our track record of developing young strikers of late isn't that good - Bamford, Sorloth, Gayle to a certain extent. Hope I'm wrong if we do get someone like him in.

Yes to a certain extent but Bamford obviously thought he was too good for us, I suspect Sorloth and agent are bad eggs and Gayle while a great natural finisher, had little else to his game imo and may have had off field issues. So possibly the club could do little with them, who knows

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 18 Sep 20 6.32pm

It giving new players an opportunity that concerns me.
I Promised myself I was going to give Roy the benefit of the doubt to start this season off - but let’s face it he’s not been that great at trying something new/different.
Don’t think the same applies for Wilder - Really hope Brewster choses to come to us though.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 19 Sep 20 10.09pm

Originally posted by topcat

I can't see anyone agreeing to buying Brewster for £25 million with a £35 million option for them to buy him back. The risk outweighs the potential profit. The buy-back needs to be at least double the transfer fee.

He looks to have great potential though.

I'd prefer a £25m with a guaranteed profit, if they chose to take him back, over paying a £5m loan for a developing player.

You need to be very good to play for Liverpool these days. If they chose to buy him back, he'd need to be in the top 10%. Or, of course, they buy back as a squad player with resale value. There's still always the chance they chose not to take up their entitlement, like Chelsea did with Ake.

In terms of a future fee being 'double', possibly it's more likely the £25m is cheap, on the basis that there is a buy back option.

 

mattteo Flag 20 Sep 20 9.18pm

Originally posted by topcat

I can't see anyone agreeing to buying Brewster for £25 million with a £35 million option for them to buy him back. The risk outweighs the potential profit. The buy-back needs to be at least double the transfer fee.

He looks to have great potential though.

Totally agree with this. A club like Palace can't be pushed around. If you pay 25 million on a 19 year old player and he score 25 goals in 2 seasons, it should be club's right to ask 100 million for him.

 

thechaddyboy Flag Peterborough 20 Sep 20 9.38pm

As well as the 'buy back / sell on clause' maybe write a refund clause into the contract too, if he stiffs after one season like Benteke or becomes an injury liability like Sakho we can get a full refund, we've give the scouse lot far too much in recent years, can't say it's been VFM to be honest

 


Red & Blue since 73'

the.universal 20 Sep 20 9.45pm

Let’s not get too excited. He could be the next Dominic Solanke.

 


Vive le Roy!

ger20 Flag London 20 Sep 20 9.56pm

Thiago Alcantra cost Liverpool £25 million how is this kid worth almost the same

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Sep 20 10.15pm

Originally posted by ger20

Thiago Alcantra cost Liverpool £25 million how is this kid worth almost the same

[/u
It's about age, future prospects/future potential worth and position.

If this kid develops into a good Prem league striker we can benefit in two ways, firstly through his goals and secondly, should we want/need to sell, by his future increased value. How much profit will depend on the terms of any buy-back or sell-on clauses. Strikers tend to cost more than players in other positions for obvious reasons.

As for Thiago, he's unlikely to be worth any more than £25m in any future sale because of his age (29 last April). You might ask, is AWB worth twice as much as Thiago? If so why?

 

taylors lovechild Flag 21 Sep 20 8.59am

If we pay 20m it's because of his potential, not because he's proved he's worth that so we are taking the risk while Liverpool get instant cash. Unless the buy back is significantly higher than what Liverpool sell him to us for then it seems heavily weighted in their favour: they don't need him right now, but they don't want to risk a situation where he proves he is a top class striker and they have to pay insane sums to get him back. We on the other hand would either end up with a striker who might not prove to be worth 20m+, or he does and then we lose him with little profit.

I know this is all stating the obvious, but I hope if we get him then (as others have said) the buy back is at least double what we pay for him and that we don't have an insane sell-on included in the deal. After all, if he was already a cert to be top class then Liverpool would not be selling.

Edited by taylors lovechild (21 Sep 2020 8.59am)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Sep 20 9.03am

As others have said Liverpool are trying to structure the deal so that we take all of the risk and if he develops they can buy him back on the cheap.

I have no idea if he is any good but we need to tell Liverpool that as we are taking a risk on potential the money / buy back needs to reflect this.

Or we go for Grant at Huddersfield.

 


One more point

Petereagle Flag Brockley 21 Sep 20 9.05am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

If we pay 20m it's because of his potential, not because he's proved he's worth that so we are taking the risk while Liverpool get instant cash. Unless the buy back is significantly higher than what Liverpool sell him to us for then it seems heavily weighted in their favour: they don't need him right now, but they don't want to risk a situation where he proves he is a top class striker and they have to pay insane sums to get him back. We on the other hand would either end up with a striker who might not prove to be worth 20m+, or he does and then we lose him with little profit.

I know this is all stating the obvious, but I hope if we get him then (as others have said) the buy back is at least double what we pay for him and that we don't have an insane sell-on included in the deal. After all, if he was already a cert to be top class then Liverpool would not be selling.

Edited by taylors lovechild (21 Sep 2020 8.59am)


[Link]
Palace have done really well this transfer window so far and I am confident this will continue, crossing fingers and toes!

 

SurbsEagle Flag 21 Sep 20 9.15am

I really don't understand this one. £20m for someone who has played 26 professional games? This has to be one of the biggest risks the club has taken on a player by a long way..? Especially when you look at what £20m players other clubs are buying

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Sep 20 9.52am

Originally posted by ger20

Thiago Alcantra cost Liverpool £25 million how is this kid worth almost the same

Age

Liverpool stable

English

Proven in Chapionship

England youth

Striker

Very good

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Sep 20 9.59am

Originally posted by SurbsEagle

I really don't understand this one. £20m for someone who has played 26 professional games? This has to be one of the biggest risks the club has taken on a player by a long way..? Especially when you look at what £20m players other clubs are buying

I am not saying you, but this site is full of those (not without some justification) criticising the club's buying record of old crocks discarded by bigger clubs, leaving an ageing squad who are just off pace and vulnerable to long term injury.

We have now pushed X players through from our own academy, have acquired 5 from elsewhere, have bought Eze, Ferguson and may be looking to add Downes and a young CB; and now we are seeking an England youth striker to add to the depth of the squad and reduce the average age. If you include the move to a cat 1 academy, you might argue that this is the sort of risk this club has been crying out for.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Sep 20 10.05am

Originally posted by silvertop


I am not saying you, but this site is full of those (not without some justification) criticising the club's buying record of old crocks discarded by bigger clubs, leaving an ageing squad who are just off pace and vulnerable to long term injury.

We have now pushed X players through from our own academy, have acquired 5 from elsewhere, have bought Eze, Ferguson and may be looking to add Downes and a young CB; and now we are seeking an England youth striker to add to the depth of the squad and reduce the average age. If you include the move to a cat 1 academy, you might argue that this is the sort of risk this club has been crying out for.

I don't think that anyone is criticizing the potential purchase of this young striker but it's the likely terms of the deal that people seem to be wary of

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 21 Sep 20 10.09am

Originally posted by silvertop

Age

Liverpool stable

English

Proven in Chapionship

England youth

Striker

Very good

However you could add we always end up being shafted by Liverpool in the transfer market.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Sep 20 10.13am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle


However you could add we always end up being shafted by Liverpool in the transfer market.

That's hardly Liverpool's fault as they don't force us to buy their players. Surely if anyone is at fault it must be our own team

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 21 Sep 20 10.23am

I wasn't saying it was Liverpool's fault, just an observation.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 21 Sep 20 10.45am

Originally posted by silvertop

I am not saying you, but this site is full of those (not without some justification) criticising the club's buying record of old crocks discarded by bigger clubs, leaving an ageing squad who are just off pace and vulnerable to long term injury.

We have now pushed X players through from our own academy, have acquired 5 from elsewhere, have bought Eze, Ferguson and may be looking to add Downes and a young CB; and now we are seeking an England youth striker to add to the depth of the squad and reduce the average age. If you include the move to a cat 1 academy, you might argue that this is the sort of risk this club has been crying out for.

[Link]

If we pull this off, this will perhaps be the clincher in moving Palace on from perennial PL strugglers to an established PL club with great potential and knocking on the door of top six finishes, or am I just dreaming?

[Link]

 

SurbsEagle Flag 21 Sep 20 10.56am

Originally posted by silvertop

I am not saying you, but this site is full of those (not without some justification) criticising the club's buying record of old crocks discarded by bigger clubs, leaving an ageing squad who are just off pace and vulnerable to long term injury.

We have now pushed X players through from our own academy, have acquired 5 from elsewhere, have bought Eze, Ferguson and may be looking to add Downes and a young CB; and now we are seeking an England youth striker to add to the depth of the squad and reduce the average age. If you include the move to a cat 1 academy, you might argue that this is the sort of risk this club has been crying out for.

Personally for me, I think the club has handled our business in the Premier League perfectly. Have said for a few years now, even when people on this site were asking for Roy and Dougie's/SP's heads. They invested in the current 1st team with some large purchases that won't have the same sell on value, but it established us as a premier league club. Use the time that bought us to invest in the stadium and training facilities, allowing us to become a larger club that will appeal to more players and fans. Then invest in youth so that we have a conveyor belt of talent potentially coming through.

I just personally don't judge £20m for someone who has extremely limited track record as a good deal. Why not spend £20m on someone like Batshuayi who will hold our front line for 4-5 years and then use that time to invest in a young (cheaper) striker and bring them up through the youth ranks. For me, I just don't get it but appreciate others will have differing opinions to me. And I am fully open to Brewster and the club proving me wrong!


Edited by SurbsEagle (21 Sep 2020 10.56am)

 

Page 5 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic