You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Minimum wage
November 21 2026 10.14pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Minimum wage


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
cryrst Flag The garden of England 01 Oct 20 7.06pm

This is creating issues now. Companies are looking for younger employees to save money. Lots of mortgage payers and older people are being swerved so companies can employ younger and pay less.
In effect the people with more commitments are suffering because of this rule. Just an observation as I never believed it to be a good policy.

 

dorking Flag 01 Oct 20 7.21pm

My Mrs used to work at a WHSmiths. They only wanted to employ teenagers at the weekends because it was cheaper wages cost.

Fairly often, one of the weekend staff would let them down (usually on a Sunday morning when hungover) and they'd have to quickly get my wife to cover the hours.

They never wanted to pay her for those hours though, because she was more expensive than the kids, so they'd give her a day off in the middle of the following week instead the cheapskates.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 01 Oct 20 8.20pm

Originally posted by dorking

My Mrs used to work at a WHSmiths. They only wanted to employ teenagers at the weekends because it was cheaper wages cost.

Fairly often, one of the weekend staff would let them down (usually on a Sunday morning when hungover) and they'd have to quickly get my wife to cover the hours.

They never wanted to pay her for those hours though, because she was more expensive than the kids, so they'd give her a day off in the middle of the following week instead the cheapskates.

My point exactly dorking. People with real commitments ( majority of youngsters have less) are being left on the shelf because of the minimum wage. This present situation could well have happened naturally with a cyclical recession. This is a little artificial but shows the failure in setting a minimum hourly rate. Many as I've said before could prove their value and get raises but now they are stuffed with this law. Equality doesnt always create the best outcome.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 01 Oct 20 9.21pm

Originally posted by cryrst

This is creating issues now. Companies are looking for younger employees to save money. Lots of mortgage payers and older people are being swerved so companies can employ younger and pay less.
In effect the people with more commitments are suffering because of this rule. Just an observation as I never believed it to be a good policy.

I very broadly agree with this. However, the problem, as usual, is that it was not thought through. There are hundreds of thousands of small businesses which should be excluded from the minimum wage/living wage rules (under a certain amount of employees perhaps, or profit margin), and restrictions put on the larger buisnesses/corporations to pay appropriate age groups at different rates and employ quotas of age groups. It could be achieved by using a percentage system.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

cryrst Flag The garden of England 01 Oct 20 10.15pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3562077]

I very broadly agree with this. However, the problem, as usual, is that it was not thought through. There are hundreds of thousands of small businesses which should be excluded from the minimum wage/living wage rules (under a certain amount of employees perhaps, or profit margin), and restrictions put on the larger buisnesses/corporations to pay appropriate age groups at different rates and employ quotas of age groups. It could be achieved by using a percentage system.

The books would be cooked somewhat as potentially profit/loss etc can all be offset against a rule.
(Not sure if that's worded correctly tbh)
It was bought in by labour in 1999 but it was a party policy back in 1986 under kinnock. How long do you need? Raab wanted it re looked at but was shouted down by the virtue signallers and here we are during a recession watching over 25s struggle for work. It was always going to draw a line and now that line is by a sharpie pen.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 01 Oct 20 10.18pm

Maybe they should scrap all working rights, and advertise jobs on a rising scale, so start at £1 an hour, if they don"t fill the vacancy put it up to £2 an hour, and so on, that way they will fill vacancies at around £5 per hour i would imagine, some cheaper, especially when people cant afford to eat, its a win win for businessmen everywhere and the unemployment figures would stay low!

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 01 Oct 20 10.27pm

Scrap unions and workers rights, sick pay could go for starters as if you"re not well enough to work you are in breach of contract! We need to re-educate the general public- holidays are a luxuary- so is a hot meal every day- we have become spoiled to be fair- back in the day a holiday was picking hops in kent for a long weekend-or apples- a working holiday! The zero hours contract idea is also an excellent idea- why should your boss pay you all day if he can just ring you at 5 in the morning and tell you theres an hour work for you at 8am, then pop back at 4 pm for a second hour, he dont need you inbetween so why let you take a whole 10 hours pay for 2 hours work? This economic downturn is going to bring in lots of working changes so we might as well get used to these practices, just live off the memories!

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Oct 20 10.50pm

You had me with the first post Croydon, then it all went horribly wrong. The idea of rising wages until you find someone willing to take the job Is not as daft as it sounds.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 01 Oct 20 11.02pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You had me with the first post Croydon, then it all went horribly wrong. The idea of rising wages until you find someone willing to take the job Is not as daft as it sounds.

I thank you! It could well work, obviously not great for the working man but they seem to hate workers rights anyway so might as well bite the bullet and go back to the middle ages! I really do feel with zero hours contracts and the economic crash coming, anything is possible, never think "that" could never happen, it could, and probably will! I do feel for the youngsters starting out, if s*** really happens at least we can choose to drink ourselves to death, over a few years, but the young can"t afford to even do that!

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 01 Oct 20 11.13pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

I thank you! It could well work, obviously not great for the working man but they seem to hate workers rights anyway so might as well bite the bullet and go back to the middle ages! I really do feel with zero hours contracts and the economic crash coming, anything is possible, never think "that" could never happen, it could, and probably will! I do feel for the youngsters starting out, if s*** really happens at least we can choose to drink ourselves to death, over a few years, but the young can"t afford to even do that!


The problem is that when workers rights were stronger, your socialist union friends took the piss and this is where we ended up as a result.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 01 Oct 20 11.20pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger


The problem is that when workers rights were stronger, your socialist union friends took the piss and this is where we ended up as a result.

I think the aslef drivers on 50k plus would disagree hrolf, whats good for the goose?

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 02 Oct 20 12.08am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger


The problem is that when workers rights were stronger, your socialist union friends took the piss and this is where we ended up as a result.

This is why I agree with the op. Broadly. Like all rules, they get abused. For the benefit of some, but to the detriment of most.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 02 Oct 20 12.10am

Originally posted by croydon proud

I think the aslef drivers on 50k plus would disagree hrolf, whats good for the goose?

And this is why. 50kpa to drive in a straight line ffs!

Cabbies should earn more.....

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (02 Oct 2020 12.11am)

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 02 Oct 20 12.11am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3562105]

And this is why. 50kpa to drive ffs!

Do you resent their 50 k then? What about a banker sitting in a nice office in the city, do you value him at 50k?

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 02 Oct 20 12.14am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3562105]

And this is why. 50kpa to drive in a straight line ffs!

Cabbies should earn more.....

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (02 Oct 2020 12.11am)

Sorry - only saw first line and not even the straight line bit, but yes, cabbies are hard done by in comparison!

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 02 Oct 20 12.24am

Originally posted by croydon proud

Sorry - only saw first line and not even the straight line bit, but yes, cabbies are hard done by in comparison!

It's ok. People don't deserve more for where they work, but what they do. Somebody who has spent years learning to become a surgeon so that they can save lives is more important than the person who removes the dirty scalpels and the cleaning staff that clear up the mess. But should they be paid the same?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 02 Oct 20 12.26am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3562109]

It's ok. People don't deserve more for where they work, but what they do. Somebody who has spent years learning to become a surgeon so that they can save lives is more important than the person who removes the dirty scalpels and the cleaning staff that clear up the mess. But should they be paid the same?

edit I'll add they are equally important

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 02 Oct 20 12.42am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3562110]

edit I'll add they are equally important

Yeah, the person who has trained longer and studied harder like the surgeon should get more than the run of the mill jobs you can get off the street with no qualifications, i think those jobs are paid at the minimum now anyway, you couldn"t really pay them less in theory- but i wouldn"t bank on it not happening in the current environment. I have no problem with surgeons and the like getting top dollar, if you go in to the car park at mayday - croydon uni - you see lots of top cars parked up, thats the staff car park, and i doubt it"s the cleaners or nurses!

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 Oct 20 4.18am

My whole point wasnt to separate jobs for importance. It was that there is now no room to negotiate. Firms have taken the 'minimum' to mean the actual. All on the same rate, good and bad.
As for the banker, he is in the private sector which is different to the state sector. The private side makes the money to pay for the state side. Pure economics and if he makes millions for his bosses he gets rewarded accordingly. This minimum wage affects across all sectors, and both sides, state and private.
The unions do a job for their members but have you seen the salaries they get. Wow it puts them in the top 10%. How would that make you feel at the present. None of them were furloughed or layed off I dont think. Good for their time but now a bit too big for their boots.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 Oct 20 8.03am

Originally posted by croydon proud

I thank you! It could well work, obviously not great for the working man but they seem to hate workers rights anyway so might as well bite the bullet and go back to the middle ages! I really do feel with zero hours contracts and the economic crash coming, anything is possible, never think "that" could never happen, it could, and probably will! I do feel for the youngsters starting out, if s*** really happens at least we can choose to drink ourselves to death, over a few years, but the young can"t afford to even do that!

My son applied for several jobs a couple of years ago, when he finished Uni ( including Sports Direct! that’s how desperate he was), as he was able to work any days/hours they all seemed keen until they found out he was over 21 and he heard no more. He obtained a job last year at Thorpe Park but was paid less than £8 ph. Enjoyed the job so was willing to go again completed 1 training day but in view of Covid was not required and missed out on being furloughed by a couple of days. Applied for farm work/ supermarkets earlier this year, heard nothing.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Minimum wage