This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Then you side slightly with MP/Lord whatever his name was on this one, but even so, would you agree with me that the far more important issue is what she says rather than how she says it? You do seem to miss my point. You can speak how the hell you like in real life, but like the Lord I want someone (who's on that BBC gravy train too) to put a bit of effort in her articulation if she is broadcasting to the nation. And like I said earlier, I don't actually think what she says to be that much informative either.
|
|
|
Apologies if my memory is crap & I am wrong - But going back quite a few years I seem to remember Janet St Porter & Elaine Chase arriving on our screens, & thinking that they only got their break(s) on TV because of ITV- with the way that they spoke they weren't in the BBC mould at the time. Originally posted by Slimey Toad
You do seem to miss my point. You can speak how the hell you like in real life, but like the Lord I want someone (who's on that BBC gravy train too) to put a bit of effort in her articulation if she is broadcasting to the nation. And like I said earlier, I don't actually think what she says to be that much informative either.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
You do seem to miss my point. You can speak how the hell you like in real life, but like the Lord I want someone (who's on that BBC gravy train too) to put a bit of effort in her articulation if she is broadcasting to the nation. And like I said earlier, I don't actually think what she says to be that much informative either. I understood your point, and to be fair you made it a little better than Lord so-and-so did. To me, I don't really mind how someone speaks in any walk of life, including if they don't change for work or being on the telly (within reason) if what they are saying makes sense and has value. Or a least, it isn't as important to me as it is to you. I do wonder where accent meets elocution though. Scott's view was (apparently) that dropping her Gs was partly a feature of her accent. Not so sure about that myself. There are plenty of strong regional accents on tv and most don't seem to preclude decent pronunciation. I've been called common-sounding on and off all my life (at least, when I wasn't in the company of my native friends and family in Croydon / South London), but also had my articulacy noted along the way. No reason you can't have both, and neither adds up to anything of value if you're talking nonsense!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
Apologies if my memory is crap & I am wrong - But going back quite a few years I seem to remember Janet St Porter & Elaine Chase arriving on our screens, & thinking that they only got their break(s) on TV because of ITV- with the way that they spoke they weren't in the BBC mould at the time. But Street Porter was articulate in her toothy London Brogue, and anyway she was involved in Yoof TV. As for Lorraine Chase (I think that who you are referring to) - Lu'on Airport
|
|
|
I knew my memory was fading fast - lol Originally posted by Slimey Toad
But Street Porter was articulate in her toothy London Brogue, and anyway she was involved in Yoof TV. As for Lorraine Chase (I think that who you are referring to) - Lu'on Airport
|
|
|
In the same way we are entitled to expect a professional footballer to be able to kick a ball, it's not unreasonable to expect a professional commentator to enunciate.
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Yannick selassie
Lol did you not read how bitter and dismissive the original post about Henry was? The general consensus seemed to agree with me and the OP literally called Henry “just an arrogant bully” who was not world class..I mean does that not sound like a twisted bitter opinion of someone who’s just out to hate..all I did was suggest he’s chasing the dragon as in a smack head...was not overly aggressive but did list attributes as to back up my reasoning that Henry was as good as everyone said he was... But I’m just a troublemaker aren’t I haha doesn’t matter if the original post was inflammatory and aggressive or not I was there to start trouble ok mate Someone please tell me what was so inflammatory or outrageous about my first comment on this post to have someone draw his sword at me and tell me my opinion was invalid and disgraceful just because I dared to suggest black players might have a difference experience..is the the English football lads alliance page am I on the wrong forum or what? I know there are a few Yaxley-Lennon minions on here but cor blimey I didn’t realise they were so sensitive and fragile The pack mentality I’m seeing on this forum is really infantile yet unsurprising as there is safety in numbers and the internet is a safe space for people with strong outdated convictions that lack substance- daily mail readers etc And just to let you know I’ve been reading this forum for around ten years probably a bit more so not new here at all and been watching palace since my first game at selhurst millwall 1994 I was there at Leicester Claridge I was there when hopkin curled one I was there for Lombardo and at Sasha curcic’s protests I was at Liverpool in the league cup featuring Julian grey etc...I was standing on the advertising boards at Stockport when dougie scored and he ran to me to celebrate and hence been there at too many poignant moments over the last twenty years than I could mention..I even walked for an hour and a half to see Trevor Francis punch kolinko in his nose on a cold Tuesday night against Bradford..I’ve got stripes and pedigree and hundreds and hundreds of games on the holmesdale and Arthur wait so I’ve got every right to be here as much as anyone before you question my position again sorry for turning up and having an opinion maybe I’ll just keep it to myself and let the old timers talk trash about whatever they like unchallenged...proper sad little community good post - For accuracy it was Julian Gray. The Francis punch was early in the season, so probably not that cold. Just saying, not having a go. Edited by palace99 (10 Aug 2021 4.22pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
But Street Porter was articulate in her toothy London Brogue, and anyway she was involved in Yoof TV. As for Lorraine Chase (I think that who you are referring to) - Lu'on Airport Not that long ago someone liked me to Jacob Rees-Mogg but alas I cannot match him for intelligence,articulacy and charm.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Not that long ago someone liked me to Jacob Rees-Mogg but alas I cannot match him for intelligence,articulacy and charm.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
Guffaws aloud in 'Chez Willo'.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Robert Heenan
I've heard from very good honest folks that apparently Sol Campbell was very much interested in taking over as manager at Crystal Palace and was left very dissapointed that he was overlooked in favour of Patrick Vieira Sol hasn't made it any secret regarding his desire to be a top class manager
|
|
|
Janet If I remember correctly she was actually the Head of Youth TV and was a very smart operator
|
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
Quite impressive how quickly this thread has managed to move onto the topic of Janet Street Porter... To have an idea of the extent to which race plays a factor, you'd need access to applicant lists which neither those claiming race is a factor nor those denouncing it have. However, I think it would be fair to say that a black player may be less likely to take their badges if the black players who took them 5 years before them aren't getting jobs, which creates a self-fulfilling prophecy. I wouldn't say any issue is due to racists running football clubs, more a long running perpetuation of 'I need a safe manager who has experience - what are Allardyce, Warnock, Hodgson etc. doing?'. The Rooney Rule may break that way of thinking, maybe something else would. I don't think Palace can be accused of having an issue here. There's a good chance we'll have a black manager put out a team of 10 black outfield players at some point this year. Jairo Eze Schlupp Ayew Benteke Zaha That's without Olise, Mateta, Ferguson, and many of the academy. It's laughable when people talk about racism in football. You get jobs on merit, and if you are a winner, you will definitely get a chance. Did anyone notice how keen Twitter were to tell that most of the racist tweets during the Euros came from England?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It's laughable when people talk about racism in football. You get jobs on merit, and if you are a winner, you will definitely get a chance. Did anyone notice how keen Twitter were to tell that most of the racist tweets during the Euros came from England? Exactly this, they make up 3% of the population yet I think 40% of Premier league footballers are black, they are hugely overrepresented in football but it's a competitive sport, they get there on merit so I've got no problem, every match on tv now always has a black pundit, again no problem but like my south American friend says, they've been hugely influential in our league, where is the outcry for more representation of South Americans on punditry, apart from poyet who you see every now and then I can't think of any other.
|
|
|
Regarding Sol, I would advise that Sol tries maybe to join the likes of PV training staff or equivalent to get back into the game ? Good luck to him .
|
|
|
Originally posted by Surrey Hills
Regarding Sol, I would advise that Sol tries maybe to join the likes of PV training staff or equivalent to get back into the game ? Good luck to him .
|
|
|
Originally posted by rikz
Exactly this, they make up 3% of the population yet I think 40% of Premier league footballers are black, they are hugely overrepresented in football but it's a competitive sport, they get there on merit so I've got no problem, every match on tv now always has a black pundit, again no problem but like my south American friend says, they've been hugely influential in our league, where is the outcry for more representation of South Americans on punditry, apart from poyet who you see every now and then I can't think of any other. I reckon Sol is probably a bit of an arse but doesn’t that often go with the territory? Takes an ego to think you can manage. And a lot more. People to believe in you and decide you’re worth taking a punt on. Easy to make the case someone isn’t worth it on an individual level. The question racism in football is worth reflecting on in the context of your point- if 40% of players are black why so little representation in management and coaching?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It's laughable when people talk about racism in football. You get jobs on merit, and if you are a winner, you will definitely get a chance. Did anyone notice how keen Twitter were to tell that most of the racist tweets during the Euros came from England? The Police person leading the investigation, has said of the nearly 700 tweets/msgs etc, over 500 came from Asia & most of those where what they call 'bots'. 27 ip addresses were identified in the UK, 11 people arrested, 2 where white. This has been reported on BBC & various sites but not with shouty headlines.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
The Police person leading the investigation, has said of the nearly 700 tweets/msgs etc, over 500 came from Asia & most of those where what they call 'bots'. 27 ip addresses were identified in the UK, 11 people arrested, 2 where white. This has been reported on BBC & various sites but not with shouty headlines. Do you have a link to those reports you can share please?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.