This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by kuge
Yes, they may well be just a different barrel. I would agree entirely that at present Labour appear bereft of policies and ideas. It's a global condition in politics. Yesterday's election in Germany has brought about a balance of power that reflects the views of the population. The coalition that emerges will no doubt continue to govern Germany in a similar fashion to previous governments. mostly the public are not given a choice.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Good post IMO Labour being good at local level depends where you live, certainly not in Croydon Originally posted by CPFC1965
Tories are fascist scum etc is part and parcel of what the left what to present. Four failed elections have shown how ineffective they really are, especially outside of London. The Tories gave us Austerity they cried, and the truth was that they had mismanaged the economy so badly and brought us to the brink of bankruptcy and the possibility of having to apply for an IMF loan. 40 years ago, when the North was unionised, to not vote Labour was to be branded a scab, their rhetoric rang a bell. Now we're not, we're middle class, we've escaped the pits, we still have the same ideals of a progressive labour party but what we have seen is a return to the militant 70's. Labour lost the Red Wall because we voted to leave the EU, Corbyn and his acolytes chose to ignore us and WE voted NO. Labour treated their Northern membership with utter contempt, Rayner is nothing more than a Trade Union puppet who forgets she is a Manchester MP. I'll continue to vote Labour in the mayoral elections, because they know how to run regional systems and are competent at that level, but Nationally/Internationally I have grave doubts.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
I agree, give her as much air time as possible and fingers crossed make her leader. Not answering questions is common to all politicians. Originally posted by croydon proud
To be fair to Ange, it"s refreshing to see a politician speak the truth and be original at the same time! The amount of CON mp"s , being interviewed and not going anywhere near answering the question is frustrating to say the least! I wouldn"t give them the hot air time! More of the same please Angela , a refreshing change!
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Me too If there was another leadership election and she runs I will join Labour to vote for her. Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I actually hopes she takes over from Starmer. The rule changes are a complete two fingers to their membership. The leader of a party really should reflect it. Edited by HKOwen (28 Sep 2021 4.53am)
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I actually hopes she takes over from Starmer. The rule changes are a complete two fingers to their membership. The leader of a party really should reflect it. I have long suspected that you are not a true believer in representative democracy, and this confirms it. A party leader ought not simply reflect the current views of its paid up membership. They should lead them to a position where the Party can command enough votes from the electorate to actually achieve things, and not just blow hot air. Leaders should lead. In a representative democracy, they aren't followers. They aren't delegates, they are representatives, just as their MPs are. Their job is to try to give their membership what they need, and not what they want. The left of the Labour Party has long rejected this approach, and the consequences are obvious. Until such ideas are defeated, they will not regain power. As not having an effective opposition impacts us all, this is really important, even if you think having endless right wing Tory governments a good idea.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I have long suspected that you are not a true believer in representative democracy, and this confirms it. A party leader ought not simply reflect the current views of its paid up membership. They should lead them to a position where the Party can command enough votes from the electorate to actually achieve things, and not just blow hot air. Leaders should lead. In a representative democracy, they aren't followers. They aren't delegates, they are representatives, just as their MPs are. Their job is to try to give their membership what they need, and not what they want. The left of the Labour Party has long rejected this approach, and the consequences are obvious. Until such ideas are defeated, they will not regain power. As not having an effective opposition impacts us all, this is really important, even if you think having endless right wing Tory governments a good idea. Party members seem to be the biggest hindrance most MP's have. If you are willing to pay up then it's most likely you are on the extremes of the party and not part of the centrist majority. The issue for Party leaders is to try and get their membership to agree to what's best for the country, rather than just doing what the membership wants. In fairness, its not easy.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
Party members seem to be the biggest hindrance most MP's have. If you are willing to pay up then it's most likely you are on the extremes of the party and not part of the centrist majority. The issue for Party leaders is to try and get their membership to agree to what's best for the country, rather than just doing what the membership wants. In fairness, its not easy. Isn't the point of joining a political party that you want a particular style of politics? If there is a 'centrist majority' then why don't they create a centrist party and this giant majority can vote for them. Let Labour or indeed every party be the party that its rank and file paying supporters want it to be....not rich lobbyists and elites. As for your concern over extremism. Why would that matter? If a party is considered extreme then they won't win elections will they?
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
If there is a 'centrist majority' then why don't they create a centrist party and this giant majority can vote for them. Let Labour or indeed every party be the party that its rank and file paying supporters want it to be....not rich lobbyists and elites. As for your concern over extremism. Why would that matter? If a party is considered extreme then they won't win elections will they? Exactly no point in joining CND if the leadership wants to keep nukes. Because we have had a 2 party system for centuries the leadership tell the party members this is what you should believe in rather than listening to what the membership wants. I'm starting think that Labour splitting up would be a good idea for democracy. We can have a Blairite European socialist style party and Corbyn an Angela et al can go back to the SWP. They wont though because they know that a full on naked far left party will never get anywhere near power as the voters reject extremism at every election. That is why they have infiltrated the Labour party.
One more point |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Isn't the point of joining a political party that you want a particular style of politics? If there is a 'centrist majority' then why don't they create a centrist party and this giant majority can vote for them. Let Labour or indeed every party be the party that its rank and file paying supporters want it to be....not rich lobbyists and elites. As for your concern over extremism. Why would that matter? If a party is considered extreme then they won't win elections will they? There's been a centrist majority since at least 1997. That's why the "culture war" or "division in the Labour Party are a myth. Just a few disserdents with prehistoric ideas throwing trying to create a victim culture.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
There's been a centrist majority since at least 1997. That's why the "culture war" or "division in the Labour Party are a myth. Just a few disserdents with prehistoric ideas throwing trying to create a victim culture. The party rules allowed the party members the say, if it were just a few dissentients then they couldn't have got Corbyn elected over several 'Blairist' alternatives. If there were a centrist majority in the Labour party that wouldn't have happened. Now the party have changed it back and taken the deciding power away from the rank and file.....that's not 'centralist', that's elitist. For me I don't care what the party actually is....I have no axe to grind on that....I just think that the membership should have the leader they believe in....not lobbyists or rich elites. Then let the wider public choose, left, centre, right or whatever.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Exactly no point in joining CND if the leadership wants to keep nukes. Because we have had a 2 party system for centuries the leadership tell the party members this is what you should believe in rather than listening to what the membership wants. I'm starting think that Labour splitting up would be a good idea for democracy. We can have a Blairite European socialist style party and Corbyn an Angela et al can go back to the SWP. They wont though because they know that a full on naked far left party will never get anywhere near power as the voters reject extremism at every election. That is why they have infiltrated the Labour party. Agreed. In truth most people aren't that political and just wander through life trying to get through it....that's no criticism of them it's just how it's always been. So let them create a mainstream Labour party....Hell, call it New Labour or the Blair party and I'm sure they would be more popular. But instead they have gone back to block votes and elites (with their lobbyist democracy) over the memberships. Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Sep 2021 2.04pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Exactly no point in joining CND if the leadership wants to keep nukes. Because we have had a 2 party system for centuries the leadership tell the party members this is what you should believe in rather than listening to what the membership wants. I'm starting think that Labour splitting up would be a good idea for democracy. We can have a Blairite European socialist style party and Corbyn an Angela et al can go back to the SWP. They wont though because they know that a full on naked far left party will never get anywhere near power as the voters reject extremism at every election. That is why they have infiltrated the Labour party. It's another disingenuous response from Stirlingsays, where he's most likely to purposely misinterpreted the post rather than not reading what I said. The majority of the electorate are either centre right or centre left and support one or two major parties. The majority of party membership is made up of the nutters. Some are too extreme to even fit in with the nutters. They then tend to support the really mental parties, BNP, PA, Sargil's Old Labour, Respect etc. They tend to all follow an agenda stating the main parties don't represent the electorate. I agree that a UKIP for Labour Party would be a good way of dissasociating themselves with the weirdos.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
It's another disingenuous response from Stirlingsays, where he's most likely to purposely misinterpreted the post rather than not reading what I said. The majority of the electorate are either centre right or centre left and support one or two major parties. The majority of party membership is made up of the nutters. Some are too extreme to even fit in with the nutters. They then tend to support the really mental parties, BNP, PA, Sargil's Old Labour, Respect etc. They tend to all follow an agenda stating the main parties don't represent the electorate. I agree that a UKIP for Labour Party would be a good way of dissasociating themselves with the weirdos.
I wrote directly at you addressing this very point. 'As for your concern over extremism. Why would that matter? If a party is considered extreme then they won't win elections will they?' Yet I'm disingenuous? My points mainly concern how democracy should work within parties and avoiding elitist and block control. Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Sep 2021 2.21pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Exactly that, they're not in the least bit representative, because if you're a person/group/corporation of actual influence you simply need to make inroads on two fronts instead of one to get your way, while the best Joe Blow gets is a relative illusion of choice that comes to nothing. People are fine with the Punch and Judy aspects of politics and indeed play right into the jeering and cheering, but they don't ever quite realise that they too are part of the performance. A system that encourages a meaningful degree of compromise (possibly via proportional representation), and is representative of voters concerns and interests would be a better way forward but good luck ever getting that. Sure it's an approach that gets criticism too, but it's nuanced enough to be more in the hands of the people rather than corporations. Right now we really have just stumbled into a type of leadership where they only ever look out for their mates and the elderly (as the one voting block they want on side).
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The party rules allowed the party members the say, if it were just a few dissentients then they couldn't have got Corbyn elected over several 'Blairist' alternatives. If there were a centrist majority in the Labour party that wouldn't have happened. Now the party have changed it back and taken the deciding power away from the rank and file.....that's not 'centralist', that's elitist. For me I don't care what the party actually is....I have no axe to grind on that....I just think that the membership should have the leader they believe in....not lobbyists or rich elites. Then let the wider public choose, left, centre, right or whatever. It's not the least "elitist" for the leader to try to lead and steer his Party towards a position in which they can actually do things! It's actually a small elite of activists who are trying to control the destiny of the party against the interests of the bulk of passive, non-active, Labour leaning voters. This is a fight which has to be won. Initially within the Labour Party, but ultimately within all parties. If it is lost, we will all suffer.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Proportional representation is definitely more representative and a fairer reflection of actual votes. That said all the practical criticisms of it still stand, parties are broad churches as they are and pull in different directions anyway, but they are far more cohesive than government by proportional representation....which rarely agrees enough to get anything done. We could have more parties that reflect their voting base more accurately and then give them equal publicity so that their ideas reach the population equally.....even though the corporate media will obviously have favourites. I had some sympathy with Labour over how Corbyn was treated by the media (though Corbyn is fine with that being done to his opponents). The political access to the public shouldn't be controlled by corporations and restricted by social media companies. Those that care about democracy should have never allowed the situation as now to have developed.....but in reality it's a careerist gravy train for most of them. Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Sep 2021 4.02pm) Yes, people moan about this bias and that but Corbyn (not as though I was a fan anyway) received universally horrendous coverage that in no way represented the ideas he was seeking to stand for. It was similar to Sanders in the States really, where he was seen as a threat to power structures and the status quo to the extent that those with genuine power are united. The orchestrated 'shut out' that Sanders faced in both leadership contests (first by the DNC, second time everyone dropping out to back Biden to get him over the line) was laughable really. The PR point about parties getting things done is valid, but the other side of that is that is it always a good thing for parties to 'get things done' anyway rather than thrash out a compromise that is more modest. Education would be a good example of where parties perpetually 'stamp their mark' when they get into power and up end everything, when really it could be argued that giving the endless tinkering a miss for the most part isn't always the worst approach. I'd say that the area most parties should be able to get some agreement on, is investing in the future (whether infrastructure, energy and so on) as these always come back to bite us if we neglect them. The problem here is that political parties rarely look beyond the short term as they don't get the plaudits. The same with the general public often too if how they perceive things. If there's not in instant return on something it draws a lot of criticism, even though in just about any modern city or society, most of what we benefit from in the day to day isn't the result of short term thinking.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Yes, people moan about this bias and that but Corbyn (not as though I was a fan anyway) received universally horrendous coverage that in no way represented the ideas he was seeking to stand for. It was similar to Sanders in the States really, where he was seen as a threat to power structures and the status quo to the extent that those with genuine power are united. The orchestrated 'shut out' that Sanders faced in both leadership contests (first by the DNC, second time everyone dropping out to back Biden to get him over the line) was laughable really. The PR point about parties getting things done is valid, but the other side of that is that is it always a good thing for parties to 'get things done' anyway rather than thrash out a compromise that is more modest. Education would be a good example of where parties perpetually 'stamp their mark' when they get into power and up end everything, when really it could be argued that giving the endless tinkering a miss for the most part isn't always the worst approach. I'd say that the area most parties should be able to get some agreement on, is investing in the future (whether infrastructure, energy and so on) as these always come back to bite us if we neglect them. The problem here is that political parties rarely look beyond the short term as they don't get the plaudits. The same with the general public often too if how they perceive things. If there's not in instant return on something it draws a lot of criticism, even though in just about any modern city or society, most of what we benefit from in the day to day isn't the result of short term thinking. Yep, I think those are all good points. There is probably some version of PR that could counteract some of its negatives. Still, PR only partly and indirectly deals with the lobbying and corporate control of politics though. I think Obama had some good ideas on this when he was first chasing the presidency......while the various types of elites will always be important and powerful they have definitely acquired much more power than in the past....effectively being king makers and for the public 'restricted choice makers'. Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Sep 2021 7.57pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.