This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Centre Forwards
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
dreamwaverider London 02 Mar 22 3.00am |
|
|
Will be interesting to see what happens this summer. Looks like all four of our strikers could move on. Plus Eze. None of them can hold down a place in the team, probably because they aren’t quite good enough. However PV seems to be squeezing out the best from them. His rotation seems to be working well. Must be an advantage all4 strikers and PV have French as their first language.
|
sprites Auckland 02 Mar 22 3.45am |
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I don't recall anyone saying he is the saviour he is just above average which goes to show how poor the others CFs are, Mateta is the best of a bad bunch, why would PV choose him above the others, unless you think PV is Clueless
He's not. Nowhere near. End of. Let's move on...everyone's getting sick of us.
|
cardiff eagle 02 Mar 22 6.23am |
|
|
At the beginning of the seasons Benteke and Edouard started together and actually looked decent as a partnership. Then PV never started them again.
Benteke is the only player who can win the ball in the air or hold up play. Edouard is only player who can finish. Mateta, for all his height rarely wins a battle but does work hard and tbf isn’t afraid to shoot and that creates chances for us (against Watford scored because he shot, last night his shot meant kouyate scored). So I’d like to see a return of the benteke edouard (or mateta) partnership against teams worse than us (like Stoke and Burnley).
|
PatrickA London 02 Mar 22 8.32am |
|
|
For much of this season the central striker has had Zaha and Ayew either side of him. Neither are adept at picking out the striker in the penalty area with passes or crosses. Zaha often plays with his head down and looks to cut in and look for shooting opportunities. Ayew undoes his hard work when in good crossing positions by not looking up and finding a teammate. He invariably hits the first defender or finds the keeper. For the Stoke goal yesterday Sawyers got past Hughes on the byline, looked up and picked out his teammate to slot in the goal. Edouard did this for the Mateta goal v Norwich, Olise for Gallagher's goal v Man City but examples are few and far between. With Olise increasingly getting starts I hope the service to the striker improves. It's a thankless task expecting Zaha or Ayew, for all their other attributes, to put the ball on a plate for the striker from wide positions.
|
taylors lovechild 02 Mar 22 10.12am |
|
|
The commentary pointed out something which surprised me last night, (until Leicester beat Burnley) we were the highest scoring team in the PL outside the top 6. Imagine what we could do if one of our strikers could start scoring more regularly!
|
YT Oxford 02 Mar 22 2.38pm |
|
Originally posted by viveasheagle
Just on the Benteke thread i do think he might be a square peg in a round hole under Viera. Our formation and style under Viera is not unlike Liverpool's and one of the early things Klopp did was move on Benteke. There are teams he will be better suited to Burnley been one that springs to mind.
"Hello honky-tonks!"
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)
|
PatrickA London 06 Mar 22 8.01am |
|
|
In theory Benteke and Edouard should be ahead of Mateta in the pecking order. Benteke has a better pedigree, more experience and is better in the air and hold up play. Edouard has better control,quicker feet and looks to be the better footballer. But are they more effective than Mateta? If you watch the first goal yesterday Mateta laid the ball off to Gallagher near the half way line and then turned and bust a gut to run forty yards to get to the penalty area where he converted Zaha's cross. For his deflected goal v Watford, Mateta was facing the wrong way but turned and shot instantly rather than attempting to lay it off or try some intricate footwork to work an opportunity. For the Kouyate goal v Stoke when Zaha got the ball on the right most of the players burst to the near post, but Mateta took a couple of steps back to make space for himself to receive a pass for a shot which he scuffed, but it lead to the goal. These are game changing moments, which ungainly as Mateta is, one has to take into consideration. He's by no means the finished article but I'm warming to him. Benteke hasn't the mobility to play the required role and Edouard so far has shown a tendency to disappear from games, although it's early days and I'm sure he can improve.
|
Teddy Eagle 06 Mar 22 8.14am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
In theory Benteke and Edouard should be ahead of Mateta in the pecking order. Benteke has a better pedigree, more experience and is better in the air and hold up play. Edouard has better control,quicker feet and looks to be the better footballer. But are they more effective than Mateta? If you watch the first goal yesterday Mateta laid the ball off to Gallagher near the half way line and then turned and bust a gut to run forty yards to get to the penalty area where he converted Zaha's cross. For his deflected goal v Watford, Mateta was facing the wrong way but turned and shot instantly rather than attempting to lay it off or try some intricate footwork to work an opportunity. For the Kouyate goal v Stoke when Zaha got the ball on the right most of the players burst to the near post, but Mateta took a couple of steps back to make space for himself to receive a pass for a shot which he scuffed, but it lead to the goal. These are game changing moments, which ungainly as Mateta is, one has to take into consideration. He's by no means the finished article but I'm warming to him. Benteke hasn't the mobility to play the required role and Edouard so far has shown a tendency to disappear from games, although it's early days and I'm sure he can improve.
Mateta seems to have that bit of selfishness, or to be kinder he takes responsibility for shooting, needed for a goal scorer - if a shot is on he takes it. When Clive Allen was at Tottenham he would shoot from the corner flag but he got 49 goals one season. I think you’re right about Eduoard; he’s good running with the ball. Maybe the contrast with Mateta could make a good partnership.
|
dreamwaverider London 06 Mar 22 8.29am |
|
|
When Benteke came on yesterday it sadly exposed his shortcomings. He has no energy. He is very slow and lacks control on the ball. He doesn’t fit into the fast moving high press game we now pursue. This will surely be his last season with us. I’m sure in a different league at his age he could maybe squeeze a couple more seasons. But he has fallen noticeably short of the Premier pace which to be honest he hasn’t had since his Villa days.
|
southnorwoodhill 06 Mar 22 9.36am |
|
|
Apart from one season (his first) Benteke has taken plenty from the club and given nothing in return. Held the club back with his over-inflated fee and wages. As all can see, when he comes on for 15 minutes he still can't be bothered to put in a shift. He'll be gone soon, and we have more than adequate replacements. Mateta has that nuisance factor, and is also working hard for the team. He's deserved his goals, because he makes the effort to get into the box at the right time, a scrappy goal is still a goal, just like yesterday, goalscorer's instinct. He's young and with good coaching can only improve. I think Mateta and Eduoard would make a good combo, but PV doesn't want to play 4-4-2, so it's difficult to comment.
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 06 Mar 22 9.44am |
|
|
Mateta is fitting into the style of play more and more and is a lot more difficult to knock off the ball, unlike Tekkers and Edouard. Although I see a place for Edouard when the ball is at his feet in the box.
You could see against Wolves Mateta links up well with players around him and you can see the other players like him.
|
MrRobbo Chaldon 06 Mar 22 10.29am |
|
|
Really impressive performance from Mateta yesterday. Movement was great, linked up nicely, shot when given half a chance.
Watching his goal back, his movement and desire is actually quite impressive. wins the header, and then peels off wanting Connor to go long to him, Wilf gets in and then JP sprints across the defender to make the move to the front post.
I know it sounds simple, but without the movement, Wilf's cross is picked up by the keeper.
|
EaglesEaglesEagles 06 Mar 22 11.00am |
|
|
As well as being a decent passer when laying off to the midfield Mateta has become the best at pressing amongst the strikers. This effective pressure on the opposition when in possession was clear in both the Wolves and Watford wins.
I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.
|
Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 06 Mar 22 11.08am |
|
|
The opening post i put on was and is still spot on
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
|
Robk 06 Mar 22 11.13am |
|
|
Funny isn’t it...all those who said he should be sent back to Mainz have gone a little quiet...wonder why.... Dougie has done a great job and got him for a steal of a price if he continues to knock them in....
|
Palace Old Geezer Midhurst 06 Mar 22 11.15am |
|
|
Crikey! I keep finding myself agreeing with you this morning.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.
|
EddieMac 06 Mar 22 11.51am |
|
Originally posted by Robk
Funny isn’t it...all those who said he should be sent back to Mainz have gone a little quiet...wonder why.... Dougie has done a great job and got him for a steal of a price if he continues to knock them in....
There’s is nothing funny about it. He was woeful and even the people who see him every day in training were close to ending his deal. It wasn’t just fans moaning.
Fair play to the chap he has turned things around and is now our main striker. He is not perfect but over all he is out best option as a CF.
|
mileend East London 06 Mar 22 12.23pm |
|
|
The pundits seem to be settling on a description of Mateta as 'awkward' or 'leggy' or 'giving the defenders a problem' - I doubt many see him as an exceptional talent, or what to make of him.
But what I quite like about Mateta is that he really believes he can and will score.. While Benteke really doesn't give me the impression he thinks he will ever hit the back of the net.
|
southnorwoodhill 06 Mar 22 12.33pm |
|
Originally posted by mileend
The pundits seem to be settling on a description of Mateta as 'awkward' or 'leggy' or 'giving the defenders a problem' - I doubt many see him as an exceptional talent, or what to make of him.
But what I quite like about Mateta is that he really believes he can and will score.. While Benteke really doesn't give me the impression he thinks he will ever hit the back of the net.
Would Benteke have laid the ball off centre park and then sprinted to the box to be on the end of something? Highly unlikely. Put in the work and get rewarded! Also his sprint opened up the pitch for Wilf (who worked hard himself) and the CG pass.
|
Nicholas91 The Democratic Republic of Kent 06 Mar 22 12.35pm |
|
Originally posted by mileend
The pundits seem to be settling on a description of Mateta as 'awkward' or 'leggy' or 'giving the defenders a problem' - I doubt many see him as an exceptional talent, or what to make of him.
But what I quite like about Mateta is that he really believes he can and will score.. While Benteke really doesn't give me the impression he thinks he will ever hit the back of the net.
I thoroughly agree.
Benteke has something to offer but his behaviour in front of goal reminds me of that song with the line ‘to reach the unreachable star’. Mateta acts as though he is owed a goal, which is a huge difference.
One defence for Big Ben may be however his pregame briefing has gone far beyond ‘just stick it in the back over the net’ in years past, hence his mentality/approach may have altered.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!
|