This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
You are right, but it completely mystifies me why you are unhappy about it. Harris and Blitzer are INVESTORS. It says that on the tin. It's what they do. They have never, ever pretended to be anything else. And we (Palace) were more than happy to have them invest in us at a time when we needed investment. They did us a favour (buying in) and we've done them a favour (as the value of the club has increased). Everybody won. That's how it's supposed to be. The investor benefits from a shrewd investment and good management. The business benefits from the investment. What the hell is there to be unhappy about? And how can they be "all wrong for football" when, since they invested, almost everything that has happened at Palace has been good? Do you think fans make better owners than serious investors? Do you want Simon Jordan or Mark Goldberg back? Sorry to be blunt, but you statements strike me as nonsensical. We may never have warmed to Harris and Blitzer but we have absolutely nothing to excoriate them for. Quite agree. They haven't been sugar daddies but truthfully I'd get pretty uncomfortable should Palace turn into a sugar daddy club. I'd be more than happy if they were replaced - if need be - like for like with experienced sports investors who would follow their lead in supporting the club financially in the background to allow the club to grow sustainably. It's not exactly the Palace way but steady incremental growth rather attracts me! We will learn more I guess when the next set of accounts come out but I very much suspect that we have done alright through H and B in the past couple of seasons with cash being injected to support us through COVID and at a time when the squad value was minimal.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
Quite agree. They haven't been sugar daddies but truthfully I'd get pretty uncomfortable should Palace turn into a sugar daddy club. I'd be more than happy if they were replaced - if need be - like for like with experienced sports investors who would follow their lead in supporting the club financially in the background to allow the club to grow sustainably. It's not exactly the Palace way but steady incremental growth rather attracts me! We will learn more I guess when the next set of accounts come out but I very much suspect that we have done alright through H and B in the past couple of seasons with cash being injected to support us through COVID and at a time when the squad value was minimal. Well said, Oomph. I was genuinely starting to despair and wonder if there was any common sense or understanding at all in the world of football fans. I sometimes think they are totally ignorant of even the most basic principles of running a sound business and genuinely believe that a fly-by-night, over-leveraged sugar daddy is the route to the promised land. You'd think by now, based on recent experience alone, that Palace supporters above all others would have figured out that road leads to self-destruction. We should be celebrating what Harris and Blitzer have done to stabilise and develop the club. Instead, some are criticising them for what amounts to not being Simon Jordan. It's just utter madness. Can you imagine being deeply unhappy about having a successful, responsible investor? No, you can't. Nor can I.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
You are right, but it completely mystifies me why you are unhappy about it. Harris and Blitzer are INVESTORS. It says that on the tin. It's what they do. They have never, ever pretended to be anything else. And we (Palace) were more than happy to have them invest in us at a time when we needed investment. They did us a favour (buying in) and we've done them a favour (as the value of the club has increased). Everybody won. That's how it's supposed to be. The investor benefits from a shrewd investment and good management. The business benefits from the investment. What the hell is there to be unhappy about? And how can they be "all wrong for football" when, since they invested, almost everything that has happened at Palace has been good? Do you think fans make better owners than serious investors? Do you want Simon Jordan or Mark Goldberg back? Sorry to be blunt, but you statements strike me as nonsensical. We may never have warmed to Harris and Blitzer but we have absolutely nothing to excoriate them for. syd, as often happens reading your posts, you have shown me the light and clarified the situation in my head. When you look at it as you have, it all makes sense. As I said, I had been chewing on it and hadn’t got there.
|
|
|
Still, if we did get some filthy lucre a new 50,000 stadium would be nice. Or even a new stand or two or three.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Still, if we did get some filthy lucre a new 50,000 stadium would be nice. Or even a new stand or two or three. Who knows? Maybe it’s our turn for some billionaire money. Most of the parties bidding for Chelsea won’t be successful.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Still, if we did get some filthy lucre a new 50,000 stadium would be nice. Or even a new stand or two or three. Just been trying to work out the time scale for three new stands. Think 2050 seems about right factoring in marginally greater efficiency for stands 2 and 3. Edit: bit ambitious on second thoughts - that’s more like 2 stands Edited by Omph (30 Mar 2022 6.44pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Still, if we did get some filthy lucre a new 50,000 stadium would be nice. Or even a new stand or two or three. I think this is the Holy Grail BUT the question isn't would it be nice (obviously, absent of context it would be) BUT what price would the nice come in at? Nice is wonderful, but it's not free of cost or responsibility. If we got those things from Harris and Blitzer it would be (or would have been) wonderful because a). they could afford to do it without leverage, and b). we know they'd do it in a responsible way because they've proven to be responsible investors. If, say, their Chelsea bid didn't go through and for whatever reason they decided to go "all in" on Palace, that'd be cause to break out the champagne. Abramovich was "nice" for Chelsea because he could afford to what he did. Glazer hasn't been nice for Man Utd because even though he's supported a large transfer budget, he's leveraged the club to do it and they're paying a high price for that. The danger is that we that we get all you describe above, everyone starts popping the corks, but the source of it is Simon Jordan/Mark Goldberg version 2. And I fear football supporters being what they are, would just celebrate. No one would ask questions about the provenance of the investor, they'd just see a couple of new players and a new stand and think mannah from heaven had arrived. Two years later, when we're back in administration, they'd claim never to have seen it coming. The thing for me with any investor who buys into Palace is that first and foremost, I want to know that they have a track record of successfully running businesses over a long period of time. Not a single, quick high-value success (a la Jordan or Goldberg) but real, demonstrable, serious pedigree. Then, I want to know that they're sufficiently capitalised to run the club for a long-ish period of time; not just spend money one summer or one season. That means they need to be pretty high net worth (not just rich). Personally, I want investors in Palace to be COMPETENT INVESTORS. I want them to be brilliant at what they do (supporting and running a business). I couldn't give a toss if they're Palace fans or not because as we all know the last time we were owned by someone passionate about the club (before Parish), we ended up in administration. And the same the time before that. Of course, if the competent investors are also passionate about Palace so much the better but you can't always have your cake and eat it. At the end of the day, more than anything else I want Palace to exist. So the first litmus test I apply to any prospective owner/investor is "are they likely to run the club in a manner that ensures that is the case?" "Are they likely to make us more successful on the pitch" comes a distant second. Plus, if they run the club in a way that provides a satisfactory answer to the first question, sooner or later a satisfactory answer to the second question is likely to follow. As Harris and Blitzer have proved. Look at where the club is now.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
Just been trying to work out the time scale for three new stands. Think 2050 seems about right factoring in marginally greater efficiency for stands 2 and 3. Edit: bit ambitious on second thoughts - that’s more like 2 stands Edited by Omph (30 Mar 2022 6.44pm) I think the Old Stand rebuild is probably the elephant in the room for Parish (and Textor) right now and a Catch 22 situation. They can't increase the value of their investment without building it but building it (because of the diversion of the limited funds it requires) threatens the security of the underlying investment because there's no doubt that funds earmarked to strengthen the team would be diminished by the build. In a way, whatever now happens with Harris and Blitzer is probably a line in the sand and forces the issue. The opportunity to bring in a new investor is also an opportunity to fire up the stadium plan. That's one reason I have reservations about Textor (and as I said earlier, I also see many positives). Whatever else he is, he's not going to fund the new stand. What we really need is someone to buy Harris and Blitser's shares who's able to do that or take us a long way towards it, yet who's still happy to be a minority owner in the club. That's probably wishful thinking. As I've said before, I don't think Harris and Blitzer can be criticised because we have no right to expect them to do anything they haven't done but I would allow that it's disappointing that they haven't found more passion for the club over the past three to five years and found themselves wanting to commit more. They had no obligation to do so and we have no right to expect them to, but it's still disappointing that they haven't been inspired by Palace in the way that all of us are. They could have been legends and really built something but they've chosen, as is their right, just to be competent investors applying a proven and conservative business model instead.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
I think the Old Stand rebuild is probably the elephant in the room for Parish (and Textor) right now and a Catch 22 situation. They can't increase the value of their investment without building it but building it (because of the diversion of the limited funds it requires) threatens the security of the underlying investment because there's no doubt that funds earmarked to strengthen the team would be diminished by the build. In a way, whatever now happens with Harris and Blitzer is probably a line in the sand and forces the issue. The opportunity to bring in a new investor is also an opportunity to fire up the stadium plan. That's one reason I have reservations about Textor (and as I said earlier, I also see many positives). Whatever else he is, he's not going to fund the new stand. What we really need is someone to buy Harris and Blitser's shares who's able to do that or take us a long way towards it, yet who's still happy to be a minority owner in the club. That's probably wishful thinking. As I've said before, I don't think Harris and Blitzer can be criticised because we have no right to expect them to do anything they haven't done but I would allow that it's disappointing that they haven't found more passion for the club over the past three to five years and found themselves wanting to commit more. They had no obligation to do so and we have no right to expect them to, but it's still disappointing that they haven't been inspired by Palace in the way that all of us are. They could have been legends and really built something but they've chosen, as is their right, just to be competent investors applying a proven and conservative business model instead. Nothing to disagree with there. I'm fully in line with you and Doom (just above). There are any number of permutations fo what could happen next - itself quite worrying! - and as you say the investment in the stand is an issue. Looked at optimistically the need to set aside so much cash for the stand is a bonus as makes the club attractive as a long-term investment and not as a get rich quick scheme! One way in which the current situation could (bold undermined) work in the club's favour is that the sale of the H and B shares might be close to something below true market value simply given that sale will be on almost fire sale terms with H and B unable to hold out for the most favourable result. Looked at like that potential investors might (bold underlined again) be able to push more money into the club as they got the shares themselves on favourable terms. The other point is this whole scenario rather points out the delicate balance of power in the ownership with so much power in the hands of the minority owner, How many investors are there out there who are willing to spend a very significant chunk of money to become "sleeping partners"? I'd assume that that most investors looking to spend a 9 figure sum would be wanting outright control. That makes me nervous for what I think are understandable historic reasons. If we are talking about groups of people as opposed to individuals to come on board then the limiting factor is the potential investors may be less prepared to pump money into the club itself (as opposed to spending it on the share holding) as they will have less control of the direction of the club. It's a tricky balance. In all very much hope H and B fail to get Chelsea.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I also have some memory of B&H money being ring-fenced for the stand development or was that never the case? If it was it would have been ring fenced externally otherwise it would have shown up in the accounts
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
If it was it would have been ring fenced externally otherwise it would have shown up in the accounts I have no idea whether true or not but if there was a contractual commitment to ring-fence a sum for the stand, it would presumably be in an escrow account.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Not sure if this appears elsewhere (apologies if so) but an interesting take on things
I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals. |
|
|
Originally posted by trapperjohn
Not sure if this appears elsewhere (apologies if so) but an interesting take on things Interesting quote that isn't true:- "Both Textor and Parish have first refusal on their shares and both have the funds to take them on." Whilst Textor may have sufficient wealth to buy the shares I doubt that Parish does
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Interesting quote that isn't true:- "Both Textor and Parish have first refusal on their shares and both have the funds to take them on." Whilst Textor may have sufficient wealth to buy the shares I doubt that Parish does
Edited by dreamwaverider (03 Apr 2022 9.22am) Edited by dreamwaverider (03 Apr 2022 9.27am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Edited by dreamwaverider (03 Apr 2022 9.22am) Edited by dreamwaverider (03 Apr 2022 9.27am) Agreed all round. Textor worries me a bit. Clearly he loves the game if you look at how he's looking to invest - not just here but in Brazil, Belgium and potentially Portugal. But unless I'm missing something all this investment is really quite recent. The Boafogo venture in Brazil looks fairly speculative to me almost as if he's a bit of a dreamer. He even apparently has a preferred method of play I'd be more comfortable if he was in it simply for the money to be honest!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
Agreed all round. Textor worries me a bit. Clearly he loves the game if you look at how he's looking to invest - not just here but in Brazil, Belgium and potentially Portugal. But unless I'm missing something all this investment is really quite recent. The Boafogo venture in Brazil looks fairly speculative to me almost as if he's a bit of a dreamer. He even apparently has a preferred method of play I'd be more comfortable if he was in it simply for the money to be honest! Like you I do worry about what Textor is doing and how he is doing it.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.