This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You can think this is entirely organic if you wish, however I politely disagree. When it comes to famous individuals willing to be anti elite with big audiences...they are few and far between....and even if it's 1/12 the UK population that's much more than tune into say Sunak's videos. So I don't agree with your contention that people like him are ignored. I can point to the evidence of say how people like Lennon and various other public figures of the past were treated by intelligence and other services and they had no means of directly addressing the public through social media like they do today. There is a value in them damaging Brand as it serves as a warning for anti elite content in general.....which they look for restrict anyway they can. What exactly do they lose? Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Sep 2023 10.28pm) You misread I said it’s not 1/12 of the population. YouTube is international. His 6 million following also won’t be regular viewers, some will be bots, just like all youtubers. His actual UK based core following will be far lower than 6 million. And also a big majority of those will not be political, they’ll be people following him for advice about beating addiction etc. Overstating Again, you are over inflating his political relevance and impact simply because of your anti-elite beliefs And if you’re comparing brand to Lennon - or any other actually notable public political figures of the past you’ve lost the plot Brand is small fry. Maybe not in your world, but in the big wide one, he’s no longer as relevant or as visible as he once was. On ignored - he’s not even big enough to be ignored. Edited by SW19 CPFC (18 Sep 2023 10.53pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Since when did Brand’s YouTube channel put out information? Nothing he publishes there is information! It is devoted to misinformation and conspiracy theories. Something he is well known for in recent years. Only those unable to accept that Brand feeds them fuel for their own prejudices fail to recognise this. That they are now unwilling to contemplate that their hero might have more than just a controversial past, but an illegal one, is confirmation of their blindness to the obvious. In his defence, there are sometimes threads of rational critique that he’s always been capable of but these days a lot of it gets rapidly lost by veering off into (vastly more monetisable) rabbit holes. He’s also getting older so probably more bitter.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
You misread I said it’s not 1/12 of the population. YouTube is international. His 6 million following also won’t be regular viewers, some will be bots, just like all youtubers. His actual UK based core following will be far lower than 6 million. And also a big majority of those will not be political, they’ll be people following him for advice about beating addiction etc. Overstating Again, you are over inflating his political relevance and impact simply because of your anti-elite beliefs And if you’re comparing brand to Lennon - or any other actually notable public political figures of the past you’ve lost the plot Brand is small fry. Maybe not in your world, but in the big wide one, he’s no longer as relevant or as visible as he once was. On ignored - he’s not even big enough to be ignored. Edited by SW19 CPFC (18 Sep 2023 10.53pm) I think you are incorrect if you think Brand and his opinions aren't known by considerably more than you think. He's been a public figure for decades. Your views on his reach are purely conjecture. One minute I'm being told that Brand is making millions spreading lies and the next you're telling me he's irrelevant and makes no impact. I also once again stress that someone like Lennon did not have access to a platform like today. If you think that nothing is going on and it's all organic you are certainly entitled to your opinion. You think I'm over inflating his political relevance due to being anti-elite?....Well, I'm certainly anti neo liberal and low quality elites yeah....for sure....However, I'm not anti elites who are actually competent and have the best interests of those they rule over....but that's a side point. Once again I'll make the point that well known public figures who come out as anti elite are few and far between. The regular action taken against seemingly all of them tends towards my suspicions rather than yours. You think I've lost the plot? Perhaps or perhaps you are slightly naive and as I pointed out, the past reveals that projects against public figures have been a constant, not a fantasy. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Sep 2023 11.20pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I think you are incorrect if you think Brand and his opinions aren't known by considerably more than you think. He's been a public figure for decades. Your views on his reach are purely conjecture. One minute I'm being told that Brand is making millions spreading lies and the next you're telling me he's irrelevant and makes no impact. I also once again stress that someone like Lennon did not have access to a platform like today. If you think that nothing is going on and it's all organic you are certainly entitled to your opinion. You think I'm over inflating his political relevance due to being anti-elite?....Well, I'm certainly anti neo liberal and low quality elites yeah....for sure....However, I'm not anti elites who are actually competent and have the best interests of those they rule over....but that's a side point. Once again I'll make the point that well known public figures who come out as anti elite are few and far between. The regular action taken against seemingly all of them tends towards my suspicions rather than yours. You think I've lost the plot? Perhaps or perhaps you are slightly naive and as I pointed out, the past reveals that projects against public figures have been a constant, not a fantasy. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Sep 2023 11.20pm) You’re just over inflating his importance. He’s also only on your radar because of his recent pivot into right wing land. He’s always held the same political opinions and been far more visible to the general electorate (the ones that actually matter) than he is now. He has indeed been a public figure for decades and I can assure you that his reach was far wider at his peak then than it is now. Plenty of examples of prominent anti-establishment figures being taken down, or out even. I’m not naive to the obvious fact that shady s*** happens on the regular. However, he’s not prominent, he’s nowhere near the reach or relevance of Lennon, and I really dislike the narrative which is simply - ‘it must be the elites. No way any of this is credible’. It’s a very partisan position If he’d actually channeled all his looney addiction and general silliness over his career into doing more with the fleeting glimpses of what actually was on a lot of occasions valid and often well articulated political critique then we might be having a different conversation. But an Assange, a Lennon, a Snowden he most certainly is not and never will be. Nowhere near it. Edited by SW19 CPFC (18 Sep 2023 11.38pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
You’re just over inflating his importance. He’s also only on your radar because of his recent pivot into right wing land. He’s always held the same political opinions and been far more visible to the general electorate (the ones that actually matter) than he is now. He has indeed been a public figure for decades and I can assure you that his reach was far wider at his peak then than it is now. Plenty of examples of prominent anti-establishment figures being taken down, or out even. I’m not naive to the obvious fact that shady s*** happens on the regular. However, he’s not prominent, he’s nowhere near the reach or relevance of Lennon, and I really dislike the narrative which is simply - ‘it must be the elites. No way any of this is credible’. It’s a very partisan position If he’d actually channeled all his looney addiction and general silliness over his career into doing more with the fleeting glimpses of what actually was on a lot of occasions valid and often well articulated political critique then we might be having a different conversation. But an Assange, a Lennon, a Snowden he most certainly is not and never will be. Nowhere near it. Edited by SW19 CPFC (18 Sep 2023 11.38pm) Having watched his content I can assure you Brand is most definitely not right wing. Anti elite certainly....I like some of his opinions, like his focus on decentralisation as the better option... but I note that many on the left try to blanket everyone with the same labels (while complaining if anyone does the same to them). It's like a libertarian, you can be a right wing libertarian or a left wing one.....one is far less common today but they exist....An English Bill Maher type....A right wing one would be Peterson. If I had to 'label' Brand I'd probably call him that....a left wing libertarian. He's certainly not my guy...but I can respect him nevertheless. However, it's certainly true, that while not being the same thing that the right and libertarianism can agree on topics.....but that's no different to Labour agreeing with liberal democrats on their own sacred cows. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Sep 2023 11.56pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Having watched his content I can assure you Brand is most definitely not right wing. Anti elite certainly....I like some of his opinions, like his focus on decentralisation as the better option... but I note that many on the left try to blanket everyone with the same labels (while complaining if anyone does the same to them). It's like a libertarian, you can be a right wing libertarian or a left wing one.....one is far less common today but they exist....An English Bill Maher type....A right wing one would be Peterson. If I had to 'label' Brand I'd probably call him that....a left wing libertarian. He's certainly not my guy...but I can respect him nevertheless. However, it's certainly true, that while not being the same thing that the right and libertarianism can agree on topics.....but that's no different to Labour agreeing with liberal democrats on their own sacred cows. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Sep 2023 11.56pm) I never said he was right wing. He just appeals to that crowd these days and has adjusted his content accordingly to maximise monetisation. As I stated his political views have more or less stayed the same over time. So in that sense he’s been able to stay true to his political beliefs whilst adding other little flourishes to maximise returns. He’s not stupid.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I never said he was right wing. He just appeals to that crowd these days and has adjusted his content accordingly to maximise monetisation. As I stated his political views have more or less stayed the same over time. So in that sense he’s been able to stay true to his political beliefs whilst adding other little flourishes to maximise returns. He’s not stupid. Mmmm....one part of him has been. So you say that he's appealing to the right (without expressing actual right wing opinions) as a cynical ploy to make more money? In actual reality he makes libertarian arguments and appeals to anti elites. As you can see from many on the right on Hol....they aren't fans: It's a subset. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Sep 2023 2.10am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Mmmm....one part of him has been. So you say that he's appealing to the right (without expressing actual right wing opinions) as a cynical ploy to make more money? In actual reality he makes libertarian arguments and appeals to anti elites. As you can see from many on the right on Hol....they aren't fans: It's a subset.
Plus he is a kook. And is a literal nobody in terms of formulating policy. He parrots many themes and adds his own style to it. Grifting? Definitely a part of it. But worthy of all this effort? This is what I still don't get about this entire charade. He is yesterday's man. Many people on the Right despised him when he was at the height of his 'fame' (myself included) and pay him almost no heed now. But others might. With this exposure probably driving traffic to his online presence rather than driving them away. It is almost as though the mainstream, yet again, fail to understand how little they matter. Brand was not worth the effort. And yet now, the most talked about man in the UK.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Right. Done and dusted with this charade. Only conclusion I can reach is this down to pure vindictiveness. That back in his murkey past Brand managed to piss off somebody within media circles who has now risen to prominence and with the ability to try and do Brands legs. He ain't influential enough for any kind of 'Deep State' takedown. And he is not mainstream enough to warrant any kind of rational explanation for this level of effort. Emotive claims, which given the numbers of people who had to be interviewed to even come up with those, do not make a 90-minute expose on prime Saturday night TV. Leaving the possibility that somebody within the Media world hates Brand with a passion and has made it their life goal to try and bring him down because he slighted them a long time ago. Very Shakespearean. And very human, despite how pathetic it actually is. A dark part of my soul actually rather admires the need for vengeance. Edited by Matov (19 Sep 2023 8.02am) That's a surprise I never would have realised that the entertainment and media world is full of jealousy envy and resentment
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
IMHO Brand will say whatever he thinks will make him a pound. YouTube has suspended his account so he won't be earning anything from them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by becky
Two things that bother me about the claims..... 1) how many ordinary people still have the same mobile phone 10 years on? 2) How many ordinary people save messages from 10 years ago? It does seem slightly unusual that more than one person would keep texts for ten years.
|
|
|
Originally posted by becky
Two things that bother me about the claims..... 1) how many ordinary people still have the same mobile phone 10 years on? 2) How many ordinary people save messages from 10 years ago? A valid point.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Right. Done and dusted with this charade. Only conclusion I can reach is this down to pure vindictiveness. That back in his murkey past Brand managed to piss off somebody within media circles who has now risen to prominence and with the ability to try and do Brands legs. He ain't influential enough for any kind of 'Deep State' takedown. And he is not mainstream enough to warrant any kind of rational explanation for this level of effort. Emotive claims, which given the numbers of people who had to be interviewed to even come up with those, do not make a 90-minute expose on prime Saturday night TV. Leaving the possibility that somebody within the Media world hates Brand with a passion and has made it their life goal to try and bring him down because he slighted them a long time ago. Very Shakespearean. And very human, despite how pathetic it actually is. A dark part of my soul actually rather admires the need for vengeance. Edited by Matov (19 Sep 2023 8.02am) That you might regard this as “done and dusted” is a personal choice but one that is very unlikely to be a reality. It seems it is only at the beginning. Brand may well be a political nonentity but he represents an attitude that most find offensive at best and now potentially criminal. Exposing this attitude will serve as a warning to others that no matter how much time elapses their behaviour can be called to account. That alone makes this worthwhile. If it restricts others from abusing the vulnerable then it serves a purpose. Savile was never prosecuted, for obvious reasons, but no one disputes his crimes or excuses them. Brand may not be prosecuted because of a lack of admissible evidence, although there does seem some that could be. Does he deserve a free pass if he isn’t prosecuted? Will anyone doubt his behaviour was criminal? If Savile is universally now regarded as a sexual predator why would Brand not be? I know Savile abused children but Brand has been recorded as trying to assist him in that. If Savile matters then so does Brand. Especially as he is still here, pontificating, spreading misinformation and monetising prejudice. Those who abuse their power for sexual gratification, or in any other way, need to have their behaviour exposed. That applies to every walk of life, not just entertainment. In an ideal situation it needs to be done in a Court but sometimes the legal system is either inadequate or needs help. This seems such a case.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by becky
Two things that bother me about the claims..... 1) how many ordinary people still have the same mobile phone 10 years on? 2) How many ordinary people save messages from 10 years ago? Were they on actual phones or obtained by journalists from phone company records or via other means? I cannot remember my number 10 years ago, but deep in my pile of junk in my garage I could find my old Nokia. If I trawled back through old records I could probably unearth my number. It’s what investigative journalists do.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That you might regard this as “done and dusted” is a personal choice but one that is very unlikely to be a reality. It seems it is only at the beginning. Brand may well be a political nonentity but he represents an attitude that most find offensive at best and now potentially criminal. Exposing this attitude will serve as a warning to others that no matter how much time elapses their behaviour can be called to account. That alone makes this worthwhile. If it restricts others from abusing the vulnerable then it serves a purpose. Savile was never prosecuted, for obvious reasons, but no one disputes his crimes or excuses them. Brand may not be prosecuted because of a lack of admissible evidence, although there does seem some that could be. Does he deserve a free pass if he isn’t prosecuted? Will anyone doubt his behaviour was criminal? If Savile is universally now regarded as a sexual predator why would Brand not be? I know Savile abused children but Brand has been recorded as trying to assist him in that. If Savile matters then so does Brand. Especially as he is still here, pontificating, spreading misinformation and monetising prejudice. Those who abuse their power for sexual gratification, or in any other way, need to have their behaviour exposed. That applies to every walk of life, not just entertainment. In an ideal situation it needs to be done in a Court but sometimes the legal system is either inadequate or needs help. This seems such a case. That's for a court to decide. How would you like it if you were accused of not maintaining gas appliances as a landlord without it being proved in a court.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Were they on actual phones or obtained by journalists from phone company records or via other means? I cannot remember my number 10 years ago, but deep in my pile of junk in my garage I could find my old Nokia. If I trawled back through old records I could probably unearth my number. It’s what investigative journalists do. Do they also clutch at straws?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.