You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mateta
November 16 2026 2.16am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mateta


Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Kenteagle80 Flag Kent 30 Jan 24 10.31pm

For a team fighting to stay up under Hodgson style tactics I’d keep mateta until the summer.

If we get more injuries players like Ayew and mateta are gold dust.

His work rate and hold up play are superb

 

taylors lovechild Flag 30 Jan 24 10.43pm

Involved in all three goals, worked his socks off and knocked their keeper out. He's becoming a vital cog. There's no striker better...

 

stancummins Flag 30 Jan 24 10.56pm

Sorry i just dont get the enthusiasm for him, OK he held the ball up a bit tonight , but when the ball was flashing across the 6 yard box he was nowhere to be seen or running over the ball . He will not be a decent center forward all the time i have a hole in my rectal passage

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 30 Jan 24 11.21pm

JP good tonight. Just goes to show, if you play on the front foot and get players around him it makes a hell of a difference.

Edouard was his usual self, lightly jogging around for 15 minutes. Made me laugh that he got pulled back at one point, even though he is so slow with or without the ball. Clearly Sheff U had not done their homework.

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 30 Jan 24 11.23pm

He is the most improved player and starting to leverage his size and strength. Hold up play now very good, more mobile and starting to give defenders a hard time keeping him in check. Now, if only he can head the ball in the opponents box (his defensive heading seems better) and if only he can have that poacher instinct in the six yard box, he would be the real deal. I can't work out though why he doesn't seem to have much chemistry with the Eze, Olise and Ayew - so he gets marginalized. They see him every day in training, so draw your own conclusions.

 

Rogers the legend Flag Auckland 31 Jan 24 5.44am

I've got to say I was impressed with him tonight. I've watched him before and thought he was a total waste of space, but his hold up play has really come on. The ball doesn't ping off in all directions anymore, it actually sticks! He really bullied their CB's tonight. He's not the finished article yet, but given a bit more time with the right training / advice and I think he'll be half decent. Edouard how ever is the better finisher and probably better at link up play, but cant hold a ball up to save his life, and just seems to jog around rather than close people down, which doesn't fit in with our current team or style, a bit lazy in my view.

But fair play to the boy tonight he put in a decent shift.

 


It's not the size of the dog in the fight, but the size of the fight in the dog.

Archie Griffen

Hating Brighton since 1974

Robk Flag 31 Jan 24 7.07am

Had another really good game last night.. you can see he’s been working on his game..and he was unlucky not to score…

 

The Dolphin Flag 31 Jan 24 7.12am

I have always said that given time he can be what we are looking for.
He was very unselfish tonight - holding the ball up and passing to allow the Boy Wonders to do their thing.
He needs to get faster at then moving into the box but that will come.
He is an upgrade on Edouard in my opinion and always has been.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 31 Jan 24 7.37am

It all depends what we're looking for in a striker.

His performance as a target man last night, holding up play, bringing others into it, using his size and strength to unsettle defenders, was excellent.

However, there was more than one occasion where balls were delivered into the box and a forward with that striker's instinct would have been there to convert it. Most notably with the fantastic Olise cross in the second half that went right through the 6 yard area and nobody attacked it, I don't think he has that instinct.

I suppose my concern is that we don't score enough goals as it is and a front four of Ayew, Mateta, Olise and Eze contains two forward players who are more notable for their work ethic and defensive work in the opposition half than they are for their attacking ability.

That's quite a lot given that the team are already set up defensively. At the very least I think we need a poacher to compliment him.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

The Dolphin Flag 31 Jan 24 8.40am

I think that he does have that instinct - albeit he missed that one last night - but he has been asked to do a job right now and he was too deep on occasions when we would like to see him toe poking the ball in.
I hope Roy perseveres with him - I feel sure it will be worth it.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 31 Jan 24 9.33am

Another good game from JPM.

Feels like he is up for hte fight, understands his role and is playing it really well.

With goals coming from Eze and Olise there isn't the reliance on him to be scoring all the time.

Last night was a really good offensive performance and he was a big part of it

 

Fatherken Flag 31 Jan 24 9.41am

Yes he had a good game last night , but is still not of premiership standard and we should get rid ASAP

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 31 Jan 24 10.09am

Originally posted by Fatherken

Yes he had a good game last night , but is still not of premiership standard and we should get rid ASAP


Give us £50m so we can go and buy an upgrade. Meanwhile, Mateta is improving all the time now he has been given his first real run in the team - the whole of 6 league games (previous longest starting run was just 4 games). He also had the first cup game against Everton but was rested for the second one. If he keeps performing as he has been since the Citeh game then I would hope Hodgson will allow his run of starts to continue and we will finally get to see what he is capable of.

As has already been stated, Mateta was involved in all three of our goals last night. It wasn't just the Eze and Olise show.

Edited by doombear (31 Jan 2024 10.10am)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 31 Jan 24 10.21am

Originally posted by doombear


Give us £50m so we can go and buy an upgrade. Meanwhile, Mateta is improving all the time now he has been given his first real run in the team - the whole of 6 league games (previous longest starting run was just 4 games). He also had the first cup game against Everton but was rested for the second one. If he keeps performing as he has been since the Citeh game then I would hope Hodgson will allow his run of starts to continue and we will finally get to see what he is capable of.

As has already been stated, Mateta was involved in all three of our goals last night. It wasn't just the Eze and Olise show.

Edited by doombear (31 Jan 2024 10.10am)

We really need to teach him how to head the ball, he would then be international standard.

 

blackheatheagle Flag Beckenham 31 Jan 24 10.24am

I am not surprised with his performance. He shows up more when we are willing to attack and yesterday was one of them. For sure getting more minutes consistently is also a key. Not my cup of tea to criticize a player who plays only last 15 minutes occasionally.

I am very keen to see both him and Edouard on the field maybe at least when we fail to grab a score we want. If i am not mistaken, we did this against Wolves when he also shined. He is much more hard working than Edouard but Edouard`s goal instinct is also missed. (This offer is applicable when we are willing to attack especially at home games )

For eg i was really pissed off when Roy subbed him with Mateta on Everton game as i was keen to win the game, Roy was conservative and then they scored

 

Robk Flag 31 Jan 24 10.39am

We need his physicality against Brighton.. you saw how physical Luton were last night against them.. Brighton don’t like it !!

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 31 Jan 24 11.00am

Originally posted by Robk

We need his physicality against Brighton.. you saw how physical Luton were last night against them.. Brighton don’t like it !!

They don't like it up em Captain Mainwaring.

 


One more point

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 31 Jan 24 11.32am

He's just another Benteke.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 31 Jan 24 1.22pm

Last night was the best I've ever seen Mateta play, and he was no more than OK. He barely won a header all night but did hold the ball up pretty well.

We had tonnes of corners but even at 6'4" he got nowhere near any of them.

He managed to make one run in behind and flashed a shot over after Eze put him in, but otherwise didn't threaten at all.

He was nowhere to be found when crosses went in, which is probably the thing he should thrive on.

I don't want to see anyone seriously hurt of course, but when their goalie had to go off after colliding with Mateta I was as intrigued by the idea JPM might finally be punching his weight as I was concerned that bloody VAR would send him off. In the event, turns out Mateta went nowhere near the keeper, the keeper just slipped and flew into him, so not one to chalk up to some new-found aggression.

Ultimately, as poor a player as I think he is, I would apply the same approach to him as any other player: keep him unless we can sign a replacement who is better. It is madness to do otherwise.

That said, if anyone is actually offering cash money for him, it must be sorely tempting to the club even if we don't have a replacement available.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 31 Jan 24 2.29pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Last night was the best I've ever seen Mateta play, and he was no more than OK. He barely won a header all night but did hold the ball up pretty well.

We had tonnes of corners but even at 6'4" he got nowhere near any of them.

He managed to make one run in behind and flashed a shot over after Eze put him in, but otherwise didn't threaten at all.

He was nowhere to be found when crosses went in, which is probably the thing he should thrive on.

I don't want to see anyone seriously hurt of course, but when their goalie had to go off after colliding with Mateta I was as intrigued by the idea JPM might finally be punching his weight as I was concerned that bloody VAR would send him off. In the event, turns out Mateta went nowhere near the keeper, the keeper just slipped and flew into him, so not one to chalk up to some new-found aggression.

Ultimately, as poor a player as I think he is, I would apply the same approach to him as any other player: keep him unless we can sign a replacement who is better. It is madness to do otherwise.

That said, if anyone is actually offering cash money for him, it must be sorely tempting to the club even if we don't have a replacement available.

It seems his role is to be a focal point and hold the ball up, which he does quite well. He is a big guy and gives opposing CBs a hard time and occupied, creating space for Eze and Olise.

 

Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mateta