You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 50 of 91 < 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 >
Ian-VI Flag Vicenza 19 Jan 20 10.30am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I predicted a City win, with two late goals. Glad to say I was wrong about the result, but the late goals are a cause for concern. Roy's habit of no subs or late subs or the wrong late subs is something he should look at.
Ayew was knackered and Pierrick should have come on.
Still, a great result.

No disrespect to you, but this is exactly the difference from a normal person and a football manager. Not even at amateur level you will find a manager who plays an absolute beginner at the topic moment of the match away against a much stronger team.

 


The best footie management game: [Link]

southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Jan 20 11.13am

Originally posted by Ian-VI

No disrespect to you, but this is exactly the difference from a normal person and a football manager. Not even at amateur level you will find a manager who plays an absolute beginner at the topic moment of the match away against a much stronger team.

None taken. Comments regarding Roy's substitution criteria, coupled with a lack of chances for youth, are common on this board.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 19 Jan 20 11.48am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Why are they ?

We were playing one of the best teams in Europe, away from home, and after defending heroically conceded to one of the best strikers in the world.

Why should Pierrick have come on ? We needed someone with physical presence to hold the ball up, not an inexperienced rookie.

I'm glad you somehow found it in yourself to acknowledge it was a great result, must have been hard for someone that likes to otherwise just post in a negative way

Agreed but I am surprised he put Wickham on when he did. Tosun didn’t look as tired as Ayew so if he was going to make any sub I thought a better choice would have been Ward for Ayew who was by that point playing almost a defensive midfield role anyway.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 19 Jan 20 11.52am

Originally posted by silvertop

8 points and +5 goals over same time last year.

My only concerns are with obstacles to infrastructure development and Roy's advanced age.

I will yell and whinge when watching a match but truthfully I can have no complaints about what is happening on the pitch

Nail. Head. It ain’t pretty but it’s damn effective for scraping draws and one win in three average which is all you need in this league to stay up.

 

blackheatheagle Flag Beckenham 19 Jan 20 12.11pm

Originally posted by silvertop

8 points and +5 goals over same time last year.

My only concerns are with obstacles to infrastructure development and Roy's advanced age.

I will yell and whinge when watching a match but truthfully I can have no complaints about what is happening on the pitch

The other + is that no losing pattern to teams which is mid-table or at second half of the table (excluding Newcastle)

Now we seem untouchable against such teams which was not the case last year.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 19 Jan 20 1.04pm

Looks like our transfer structure with Dougie at the helm is starting to bear fruit. Yesssss!

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 19 Jan 20 1.19pm

Finally understood (bit dense) why there are two vey distinct groups on here. Roy has been very very consistent duriing his tenure at Palace. He is a safe pair of hands (which is why I have always been a fan) however he will never take any risks. He will not experiment with players and it's only when we have an injury crisis that he has been forced to bring in a new player and they have all done really well:- AWB, Riedewald and Tosun yesterday are clear examples. This exasperates many fans who want to see other players given more of a chance. Finally, after three years I have to agree with them. Must be worth risking one or two, to at worst improve their value or maybe unearth a new gem.

 

Den1923 Flag 19 Jan 20 1.19pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Looks like our transfer structure with Dougie at the helm is starting to bear fruit. Yesssss!

Not exactly with one short term loan and a couple of unproven Scottish youngsters, hardly what Roy was seeking and asking Tosun excepted!

 

Adamoc123 Flag Ennis 19 Jan 20 1.28pm

My only major worry right now (other than injury crisis) is the average age of our players, across the board we have a pretty old squad and with the squad being threadbare it means that these players have to run out every single game and it's clear they tire in the last 15/20 mins, one of the main reasons I feel we concede so many late on, and also why we have so much injuries throughout the season, without much action to bring in a younger class of squad players over the next 2/3 transfer windows it'd only get drastically worse so I'm hoping we look to getting in a few younger legs to blood into the squad and mingle with the more experienced players sooner rather than too late.

 


The First 90 Minutes Are The Most Important!

silvertop Flag Portishead 19 Jan 20 5.34pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Finally understood (bit dense) why there are two vey distinct groups on here. Roy has been very very consistent duriing his tenure at Palace. He is a safe pair of hands (which is why I have always been a fan) however he will never take any risks. He will not experiment with players and it's only when we have an injury crisis that he has been forced to bring in a new player and they have all done really well:- AWB, Riedewald and Tosun yesterday are clear examples. This exasperates many fans who want to see other players given more of a chance. Finally, after three years I have to agree with them. Must be worth risking one or two, to at worst improve their value or maybe unearth a new gem.

Had a chat on this topic with my barber who used to play non league. He cuts the hair of a Bristol city player. They have chopped and changed the team to allow rotation and set the team to fit the opposition so everyone gets a chance and there is no burn out. The players hate it and are unsettled. The results show.

Apparently players don't need a rest? I know news to me too. The level of fitness as well as high tech pre and post match support mean playing 40 plus matches is well within the modern players ability.

Make changes where it isn't working. If it is working - and i fail to see how it isn't working at palace - don't change it absent injury and an obvious loss of form.

Dowie Pulis and now Hodgson have all achieved success with settled teams. The loss of playing time for those not making the first XI is more than offset by the enhanced esprit de Corp of a unified team.

Apparently.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Jan 20 6.23pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Had a chat on this topic with my barber who used to play non league. He cuts the hair of a Bristol city player. They have chopped and changed the team to allow rotation and set the team to fit the opposition so everyone gets a chance and there is no burn out. The players hate it and are unsettled. The results show.

Apparently players don't need a rest? I know news to me too. The level of fitness as well as high tech pre and post match support mean playing 40 plus matches is well within the modern players ability.

Make changes where it isn't working. If it is working - and i fail to see how it isn't working at palace - don't change it absent injury and an obvious loss of form.

Dowie Pulis and now Hodgson have all achieved success with settled teams. The loss of playing time for those not making the first XI is more than offset by the enhanced esprit de Corp of a unified team.

Apparently.

Pretty sure there’s an in between. The modern game isn’t playing the same players every week for 80 mins and the rest being rusty and then proving that they’re not worthy of playing. Nobody has suggested tinkering, just phasing players in more. You never know, we may not get 6-7 or more key injuries all at once, then, like I say, throwing rusty players in, with other rusty players at the same time.

There’s also being more easily read by managers with the same players all the time. Don’t forget that for once we’ve had decisions go for us this season for a change, which has been a sizeable points and league position advantage, or we would be battling lower and biting our nails more. I’m feeling more relaxed this season though, as long as we’re not still quite short with our tough run in.


Edited by Rudi Hedman (19 Jan 2020 6.27pm)

 


COYP

Painter Flag Croydon 19 Jan 20 7.53pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

None taken. Comments regarding Roy's substitution criteria, coupled with a lack of chances for youth, are common on this board.

Roy as common with every manager picks their team and use their subs to get the best result possible. Pep has one of the talented youngsters in Foden and rarely uses him now for years, he doesn't feel the need to use youngsters for the sake of it.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 19 Jan 20 8.32pm

Originally posted by blackheatheagle

The other + is that no losing pattern to teams which is mid-table or at second half of the table (excluding Newcastle)

Now we seem untouchable against such teams which was not the case last year.

..and that was a result very much against the run of play, I noticed we allowed Man.C also far too much space to head in their second goal and although we defended quite brilliantly as we also did against Newcastle silly mistakes in picking up the opposition can still very easily bite us on the arse come the end of the season and I'm not going to mention Kelly's horror against Southampton ..lost two points and allowed a huge confidence boost to both Ings and his team mates instead of doing the opposite with just ten mins to go. The table is becoming scarily congested below us and it could only take two defeats for us to visit the bog.

 

redandblue4life Flag Auckland city ! 21 Jan 20 9.26pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Spend some @£&KING Money &#128176; ' by bexleydave

So bloody frustrating we need some real quality in the centre of the park ....... and other areas !!!! Getting fed up now with these owners the have not improved the squad for ages ........

 

redandblue4life Flag Auckland city ! 21 Jan 20 9.29pm

It’s a JOKE spend some money where has it all gone !!

 

Dave91131 Flag 21 Jan 20 10.28pm

So we're basically two thirds of the way through the season.

We're 4 points off 5th, have the 6th best defence in the league (only 1 goal more conceded than both Manchester clubs), have only conceded more than 2 goals once in the league all season, and home form has improved relative to recent seasons.

Yes I know we're 19th out of 20 for goals scored with only 22, but almost half the teams in the league have scored less than 30.

I don't think it's that bad guys. We're CPFC!

 

jeeagles Flag 21 Jan 20 10.41pm

Looking at all our results this year. I think we've been awful, but very lucky.

We've had an extrodinaty amount of last minute goals and a fair few reds against us.

The only convincing win we've had this season is Burnley away.

Looking at our last 10 fixtures.

Southampton (L)
City (D) last min
Arsenal (D) 10 men
Derby (L)
Norwich (D) last min
Southampton (D)
West Ham (W) last min
Newcastle (L)
Brighton (D)
Watford (D)

That's 9 points from a possible 27 and knocked out of the cup to a lower league team. Out of the teams in that list, only 1 is above 9th place. We havent scored first in any of those games, 4 of the points we won in the last minute and 1 against a side with 10 men.

The more I look into this season the more frightening it seems.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 21 Jan 20 10.59pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Looking at all our results this year. I think we've been awful, but very lucky.

We've had an extrodinaty amount of last minute goals and a fair few reds against us.

The only convincing win we've had this season is Burnley away.

Looking at our last 10 fixtures.

Southampton (L)
City (D) last min
Arsenal (D) 10 men
Derby (L)
Norwich (D) last min
Southampton (D)
West Ham (W) last min
Newcastle (L)
Brighton (D)
Watford (D)

That's 9 points from a possible 27 and knocked out of the cup to a lower league team. Out of the teams in that list, only 1 is above 9th place. We havent scored first in any of those games, 4 of the points we won in the last minute and 1 against a side with 10 men.

The more I look into this season the more frightening it seems.

Brighton fans are frightened and have reason to be so, we don't.

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 21 Jan 20 11.26pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Looking at all our results this year. I think we've been awful, but very lucky.

We've had an extrodinaty amount of last minute goals and a fair few reds against us.

The only convincing win we've had this season is Burnley away.

Looking at our last 10 fixtures.

Southampton (L)
City (D) last min
Arsenal (D) 10 men
Derby (L)
Norwich (D) last min
Southampton (D)
West Ham (W) last min
Newcastle (L)
Brighton (D)
Watford (D)

That's 9 points from a possible 27 and knocked out of the cup to a lower league team. Out of the teams in that list, only 1 is above 9th place. We havent scored first in any of those games, 4 of the points we won in the last minute and 1 against a side with 10 men.

The more I look into this season the more frightening it seems.

And despite all that I keep reading on this site how wonderful Roy is and how we're so lucky to have him. I beg to differ.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 21 Jan 20 11.36pm

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

And despite all that I keep reading on this site how wonderful Roy is and how we're so lucky to have him. I beg to differ.

Can you imagine anyone doing better with the squad we currently have? Watching Southampton tonight I was trying to imagine our players passing like theirs were and just ended up laughing. We've got a team that's no good for anything but Roy's functional style - and the worrying thing is that we're paying the players a ton for it, not developing any young players, and have an ageing squad. Our time in this league is ticking away unless recruitment is sorted.

 

Page 50 of 91 < 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread