This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by DanH
Of course. Your massive mistake is thinking that the interest rate on bonds is variable - it's not, it's fixed. Debt now is very cheap. Interest rates will go up in the future and when they do further debt then will need to try and be contained. There is not a better method of fund raising right now then issuing further debt. I know bonds are fixed at the point of issue. That’s why they’re called ‘bonds’. Duh! Firstly though, the longer the bond, the higher the interest rate. In the meantime there’s still lots of borrowing, and you make containing that sound like a multiple choice answer, which if you get one term in government you’re lucky. Two if you’re a liar or not what you say you are or do exactly what you’d agree to. Please everyone now to be repaired by those in the future.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
MMR the latest macroeconomic fantasy. Blow the odd 500 millions on Rish's burger and chips and seemingly never pay for it. Have a new railway it is only 4 billions a mile could be useful one day and we won't be paying for it. 40% of the natural world lost since 1992. 20% of the world's deaths in 2018 related to fossil fuels. This pandemic could prove to be like a cold before the flu. MMT Also yes, in a way it is fantasy, but so is money, really, when you think about it. Any financial system is a fantasy. That said I totally agree with your sentiments - rather than finding ways to taper down our consumption we’re looking for ways to support it that are less damaging to the environment. Positive, but really not the right solution, and will also take far too long - time we don’t really have. I’m just explaining why focusing on debt piles is, under the current system anyway, a bit of a red herring
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Inflation is just another form of devaluation. Are you not being unrealistic in thinking this can be kept in check?....it plainly can't as it operates in cycles and economies like these have no wiggle room once the global system falters as it did only a while back. I am a bit of a broken record on this and other topics such as AI but I can’t help myself The financial system and economies do indeed operate in cycles but those cycles are often not solely related or even heavily influenced by government debt Usually stupidity and lax standards lead to the boom and bust cycles. The old human trait of recency bias and the hot hand fallacy will mean until something else runs our systems for us the same old cycle will continue. No one ever wants to stop the good times even if it’s the right thing to do - so everyone in the know simply waits until the whole thing fails, then the process starts all over again. The last crash was almost entirely down to lack of regulation, stupidity and more. If government debt was a real issue we’d all have gone bankrupt a long time ago. MMT just keeps more coming into the system indefinitely. Yes the debt pile grows but there’s no limit on injection to support it so it doesn’t really matter. Now to answer your point about some sort of reckoning - as long as the current system remains in place, unlikely. But it won’t be in place for ever - and at that point yeah, sure, serious issues. But it would take a lot more than debt to create that sort of event.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I am a bit of a broken record on this and other topics such as AI but I can’t help myself The financial system and economies do indeed operate in cycles but those cycles are often not solely related or even heavily influenced by government debt Usually stupidity and lax standards lead to the boom and bust cycles. The old human trait of recency bias and the hot hand fallacy will mean until something else runs our systems for us the same old cycle will continue. No one ever wants to stop the good times even if it’s the right thing to do - so everyone in the know simply waits until the whole thing fails, then the process starts all over again. The last crash was almost entirely down to lack of regulation, stupidity and more. If government debt was a real issue we’d all have gone bankrupt a long time ago. MMT just keeps more coming into the system indefinitely. Yes the debt pile grows but there’s no limit on injection to support it so it doesn’t really matter. Now to answer your point about some sort of reckoning - as long as the current system remains in place, unlikely. But it won’t be in place for ever - and at that point yeah, sure, serious issues. But it would take a lot more than debt to create that sort of event. From what I can tell the only way you can go on with increasing debt levels and not be affected negatively is if your GDP increases in lock step. Otherwise negative steps need to be taken....when that's mostly on the national level as in the past it's painful but can be mitigated. However we saw in 2008 how a global crises damaged economies and how it was denied by borrowing against the future. I don't agree with you on the debt because I think the sheer size of it becomes unsustainable and at the point creditors don't believe an economy is doing well enough then the dynamics change. I'd also say that 2008 was also in part down to 'over' regulation rather than under.....Clinton's regulation of forcing banks to hand out loans based on ethnicity regardless of solvency has been largely hidden from the story. So while I agree with you that under regulation encouraged too much risk taking encouraged by short term rather than hard nosed banking the reality is that ideological politics also contributed. So while you need regulation, an obvious is that it's worst than useless unless it's policy based upon common sense. Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2021 1.31pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
From what I can tell the only way you can go on with increasing debt levels and not be affected negatively is if your GDP increases in lock step. Otherwise negative steps need to be taken....when that's mostly on the national level as in the past it's painful but can be mitigated. However we saw in 2008 how a global crises damaged economies and how it was denied by borrowing against the future. I don't agree with you on the debt because I think the sheer size of it becomes unsustainable and at the point creditors don't believe an economy is doing well enough then the dynamics change. I'd also say that 2008 was also in part down to 'over' regulation rather than under.....Clinton's regulation of forcing banks to hand out loans based on ethnicity regardless of solvency has been largely hidden from the story. So while I agree with you that under regulation encouraged too much risk taking encouraged by short term rather than hard nosed banking the reality is that ideological politics also contributed. So while you need regulation, an obvious is that it's worst than useless unless it's policy based upon common sense. Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2021 1.31pm) Yep. The one thing in our favour is pretty much the world are in a similar position, only ours is one of the worst, and we seem okay with making it even worse now, and no doubt even more worse than other countries moving forward unless someone in power starts to take responsibility. Yes sure we’ll be alright for a while, but we’re storing up problems for the future, just like we’re good at, and it seems are okay to keep doing because we’re a nation of spenders, consumers, and self entitlement. MMT was fine for the last decade because inflation remained low so so did interest rates. If that isn’t the case then problems build, so to say it doesn’t really matter isn’t true, unless of course every country is in the same position I guess and inflation is left alone and so are interest rates. I don’t think I’ll ever be persuaded by the ‘it doesn’t really matter’ and ‘it’ll be okay’. Someone always pays for it. It’s whether they’re aware of it or not. Not only that, I don’t think it’s a very responsible or good grounding for younger generations to be in this mindset. The country and its people having no responsibility or issue with the handling of the country’s finances. Could be an interesting watch though. Edited by Rudi Hedman (26 Feb 2021 2.04pm)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
MMT Also yes, in a way it is fantasy, but so is money, really, when you think about it. Any financial system is a fantasy. That said I totally agree with your sentiments - rather than finding ways to taper down our consumption we’re looking for ways to support it that are less damaging to the environment. Positive, but really not the right solution, and will also take far too long - time we don’t really have. I’m just explaining why focusing on debt piles is, under the current system anyway, a bit of a red herring Do I have to focus on your piles?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Yep. The one thing in our favour is pretty much the world are in a similar position, only ours is one of the worst, and we seem okay with making it even worse now, and no doubt even more worse than other countries moving forward unless someone in power starts to take responsibility. Yes sure we’ll be alright for a while, but we’re storing up problems for the future, just like we’re good at, and it seems are okay to keep doing because we’re a nation of spenders, consumers, and self entitlement. MMT was fine for the last decade because inflation remained low so so did interest rates. If that isn’t the case then problems build, so to say it doesn’t really matter isn’t true, unless of course every country is in the same position I guess and inflation is left alone and so are interest rates. I don’t think I’ll ever be persuaded by the ‘it doesn’t really matter’ and ‘it’ll be okay’. Someone always pays for it. It’s whether they’re aware of it or not. Not only that, I don’t think it’s a very responsible or good grounding for younger generations to be in this mindset. The country and its people having no responsibility or issue with the handling of the country’s finances. Could be an interesting watch though. Edited by Rudi Hedman (26 Feb 2021 2.04pm) Aside from the debt it's compounded by the assumption that everything stays the same....nay not assumption, requirement. One of the problems is that we are talking about global finance....unless you're Japan or China the bounds of loyalty towards a nation don't interfere with the bottom line....Trump tried to reintroduce that with inducements but the elites hated him for it. Essentially they want the ability to move their money where it's most profitable to be. Now while America remains the centrepoint the truth is that via a collection of bad ideology and competition that centre has been moving for decades now. Once that reaches a critical mass the western economies are only going to travel one way, which is in relative terms less wealthy than they are now.....Bless, all the egalitarians and leftists with two cars and nice houses are going to face the reality of their beliefs. Once the elites learned that they could separate their wealth from their location....essentially they became disconnected from the wealth of their nation and became the disloyal fecks they are today. The officer no longer blows the whistle and goes over the top with the lads.....they blow the whistle and sit back in the trenches eating your tin of bully beef while taking pot shots at you. Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2021 2.23pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Lombardinho
Do I have to focus on your piles? Of facts? Sure. Go ahead
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Aside from the debt it's compounded by the assumption that everything stays the same....nay not assumption, requirement. One of the problems is that we are talking about global finance....unless you're Japan or China the bounds of loyalty towards a nation don't interfere with the bottom line....Trump tried to reintroduce that with inducements but the elites hated him for it. Essentially they want the ability to move their money where it's most profitable to be. Now while America remains the centrepoint the truth is that via a collection of bad ideology and competition that centre has been moving for decades now. Once that reaches a critical mass the western economies are only going to travel one way, which is in relative terms less wealthy than they are now.....Bless, all the egalitarians and leftists with two cars and nice houses are going to face the reality of their beliefs. Once the elites learned that they could separate their wealth from their location....essentially they became disconnected from the wealth of their nation and became the disloyal fecks they are today. The officer no longer blows the whistle and goes over the top with the lads.....they blow the whistle and sit back in the trenches eating your tin of bully beef while taking pot shots at you. Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2021 2.23pm) Yeah. Ceteris paribus to start off any article. They’re still in the exam hall or writing an essay. And not one generation should take one (decade or two) for the team. Well not that they know of.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
1. From what I can tell the only way you can go on with increasing debt levels and not be affected negatively is if your GDP increases in lock step. However we saw in 2008 how a global crises damaged economies and how it was denied by borrowing against the future. I don't agree with you on the debt because I think the sheer size of it becomes unsustainable and at the point creditors don't believe an economy is doing well enough then the dynamics change. 2. I'd also say that 2008 was also in part down to 'over' regulation rather than under.....Clinton's regulation of forcing banks to hand out loans based on ethnicity regardless of solvency has been largely hidden from the story. So while I agree with you that under regulation encouraged too much risk taking encouraged by short term rather than hard nosed banking the reality is that ideological politics also contributed. So while you need regulation, an obvious is that it's worst than useless unless it's policy based upon common sense. Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2021 1.31pm) Be warned, this reply is long and to most probably yawn inducing. But a subject of fascination to me due to it's inherent complexity, and currently unsolvable nature. 1. Sort of. Really bonds and inflation and actual 'stuff' are the big watch outs with MMT rather than GDP, debt or deficit – if you can't sell bonds inflation quickly runs out of control. If you can't trade 'stuff' anymore than any system is screwed. To be clear I'm not advocating for MMT, just explaining why according to MMT theorists and therefore to those who run most sovereign western economies, it's a bit of a red herring. MMT is literally built around the principle of 'deficit and debt is irrelevant as I can always print more money'. One thing I certainly can advocate for is that government debt and deficit should not be thought of in simple 'household' terms. Quoting from 'The Deficit myth'... "The essence of MMT is, “The federal government shouldn’t try to manage its budget ‘like a family sitting around the dinner table.’ We don’t need to tighten our belts with shared sacrifice and fiscal restraint … citizens should never be forced to suffer harsh austerity on the grounds that the government lacks the ability to pay for health care or pay benefits to retirees or the disabled.” "Thus, when we analyze MMT, we analyze it through the effect on real goods and services. Printing an extra trillion of a fiat currency does not directly increase or decrease real wealth. Rather, the impact of monetary policy is measured by the change in the total amount of goods and services, and the division of those real assets among different people." But, ultimately the summary makes sense to me... "The answer is that we do not know if MMT is correct. There is no consensus within economics on the impact of additional government deficit spending paid for by the creation of money... Consider what other fields would look like if they suffered similar gaps in consensus. For example, Aristotle argued that heavy objects fall faster than lighter objects. Many years later Galileo disagreed with Aristotle’s theory. In his famous Leaning Tower of Pisa experiment, Galileo found support for his theory that the falling speed is the same for different masses. When the objects are dropped in a vacuum, physicists now know that Galileo was right and Aristotle was wrong on this topic. Even during the period of dispute, however, both scientific theories agreed on the direction that an object would move. If natural scientists disagreed to the same extent as economists, some physicists would argue that an untethered bowling ball might float off a tower into the clouds. The secret shame of economics is that very little work focuses on the important issues of fiscal and monetary policy. Perhaps because these issues are so challenging, most economist have given up. Instead of working on fiscal and monetary policy, the field focuses on esoteric minutia. Without validated theories of the impact of MMT, we can make only weak inferences based on historical outcomes. It appears nearly certain that it is possible to print and spend so much that the real economy grinds to a halt. The relevant question is how much is too much and where are we today in this range of effects? Japan has followed MMT for longer than the US. The Japanese stock market is 50% below its level in 1989. The population of Japan is aging and shrinking. Decades of MMT in Japan correlate with stagnation and decline. Did MMT cause these Japanese problems? Again, no one knows, but still we wonder. In conclusion, what can we say about MMT? Money creates wealth only via its impact on real goods and services. When too much money is created, it decreases overall wealth by inhibiting economic cooperation. Economic theory is silent on whether the world has created the Goldilocks’ scenario of just the right amount of money, or too little or too much." ...like everything economic it's a massive experiment and no one knows whether it's the right approach or the wrong one because it's too hard to decipher. Too many non-monetary inputs and outcomes. So it's not as simplistic as saying 'we should spend within our means'. That could actually result in more inequality, worse performance, living standards etc. because it inhibits the positive effects of said expenditure. In short, it's more complex than saying 'the debt/deficit is high, therefore bad', or 'the debt/deficit is low, therefore good'. But it's the easiest thing to say, hence why most people say it. Discovering that actually it's not that simple and essentially unknowable would be destabilising to most I'd imagine, so they'd rather not think about it. That state of mind applies to a lot of things really. People would rather think there is certainty even if in reality there is none. See religion etc. 2. Agreed
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Aside from the debt it's compounded by the assumption that everything stays the same....nay not assumption, requirement. One of the problems is that we are talking about global finance....unless you're Japan or China the bounds of loyalty towards a nation don't interfere with the bottom line....Trump tried to reintroduce that with inducements but the elites hated him for it. Essentially they want the ability to move their money where it's most profitable to be. Now while America remains the centrepoint the truth is that via a collection of bad ideology and competition that centre has been moving for decades now. Once that reaches a critical mass the western economies are only going to travel one way, which is in relative terms less wealthy than they are now.....Bless, all the egalitarians and leftists with two cars and nice houses are going to face the reality of their beliefs. Once the elites learned that they could separate their wealth from their location....essentially they became disconnected from the wealth of their nation and became the disloyal fecks they are today. The officer no longer blows the whistle and goes over the top with the lads.....they blow the whistle and sit back in the trenches eating your tin of bully beef while taking pot shots at you. Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2021 2.23pm) Of course, but doesn't that apply to any system, monetary or otherwise, or for that matter, pretty much any situation? In fact you could argue MMT is actually pretty good at handling most changes in situation due to the fact it enables you to simply counteract it by printing more money. (Again, not advocating for it, just debating)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Of course, but doesn't that apply to any system, monetary or otherwise, or for that matter, pretty much any situation? In fact you could argue MMT is actually pretty good at handling most changes in situation due to the fact it enables you to simply counteract it by printing more money. (Again, not advocating for it, just debating) I have to agree with you it is fascinating. Let's just say that I hope this view that the plates can be kept in the air without consequence proves correct because I'd much rather be wrong about it. The shift in the balance of power though is down to western elite's shift in worldview rather than economics...short termism over the long....money over national loyalty. Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2021 3.30pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I have to agree with you it is fascinating. Let's just say that I hope this view that the plates can be kept in the air without consequence proves correct because I'd much rather be wrong about it. The shift in the balance of power though is down to western elite's shift in worldview rather than economics...short termism over the long....money over national loyalty.
Yep fair. Short-termism is the standard these days, I feel partly driven by the immediacy and transient nature of information and methods of delivery (eg. social networks). This excerpt from the reference was a source of great amusement. 'If natural scientists disagreed to the same extent as economists, some physicists would argue that an untethered bowling ball might float off a tower into the clouds.'
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Yep fair. Short-termism is the standard these days, I feel partly driven by the immediacy and transient nature of information and methods of delivery (eg. social networks). This excerpt from the reference was a source of great amusement. 'If natural scientists disagreed to the same extent as economists, some physicists would argue that an untethered bowling ball might float off a tower into the clouds.' Yes it’s a good one. If economists or economic analysts were right, they wouldn’t be economists or economic analysts.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Yep fair. Short-termism is the standard these days, I feel partly driven by the immediacy and transient nature of information and methods of delivery (eg. social networks). This excerpt from the reference was a source of great amusement. 'If natural scientists disagreed to the same extent as economists, some physicists would argue that an untethered bowling ball might float off a tower into the clouds.' You can go a long way as an economist without really being right about anything but by just being backed. Similar to teaching.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You can go a long way as an economist without really being right about anything but by just being backed. Similar to teaching. There is no right or wrong in economics, just schools of thought. Fascinating really. What I suspect is you go far if you just go along with the trendy current theory. A bit like all academic subjects these days.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
There is no right or wrong in economics, just schools of thought. Fascinating really. What I suspect is you go far if you just go along with the trendy current theory. A bit like all academic subjects these days. It's a fascinating subject. I loved studying it. You can never be 100% correct as inherently all economics really is is a study of human behaviour when it comes to exchanging value for goods and services. Human behaviour is not 100% predictable. You have rational and irrational behaviour, and where you can use data analysis and modelling to support an argument you always have to build in a margin of error. Edited by DanH (26 Feb 2021 4.32pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
It's a fascinating subject. I loved studying it. You can never be 100% correct as inherently all economics really is is a study of human behaviour when it comes to exchanging value for goods and services. Human behaviour is not 100% predictable. You have rational and irrational behaviour, and where you can use data analysis and modelling to support an argument you always have to build in a margin of error. Edited by DanH (26 Feb 2021 4.32pm) Interesting, I'm an Arts waster so don't know much about it. Have briefly studied Keynes, that's about it. I always thought being one of those powerful economists must be great. Just tell people what they want to hear and get paid loads.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Be warned, this reply is long and to most probably yawn inducing. But a subject of fascination to me due to it's inherent complexity, and currently unsolvable nature. 1. Sort of. Really bonds and inflation and actual 'stuff' are the big watch outs with MMT rather than GDP, debt or deficit – if you can't sell bonds inflation quickly runs out of control. If you can't trade 'stuff' anymore than any system is screwed. To be clear I'm not advocating for MMT, just explaining why according to MMT theorists and therefore to those who run most sovereign western economies, it's a bit of a red herring. MMT is literally built around the principle of 'deficit and debt is irrelevant as I can always print more money'. One thing I certainly can advocate for is that government debt and deficit should not be thought of in simple 'household' terms. Quoting from 'The Deficit myth'... "The essence of MMT is, “The federal government shouldn’t try to manage its budget ‘like a family sitting around the dinner table.’ We don’t need to tighten our belts with shared sacrifice and fiscal restraint … citizens should never be forced to suffer harsh austerity on the grounds that the government lacks the ability to pay for health care or pay benefits to retirees or the disabled.” "Thus, when we analyze MMT, we analyze it through the effect on real goods and services. Printing an extra trillion of a fiat currency does not directly increase or decrease real wealth. Rather, the impact of monetary policy is measured by the change in the total amount of goods and services, and the division of those real assets among different people." But, ultimately the summary makes sense to me... "The answer is that we do not know if MMT is correct. There is no consensus within economics on the impact of additional government deficit spending paid for by the creation of money... Consider what other fields would look like if they suffered similar gaps in consensus. For example, Aristotle argued that heavy objects fall faster than lighter objects. Many years later Galileo disagreed with Aristotle’s theory. In his famous Leaning Tower of Pisa experiment, Galileo found support for his theory that the falling speed is the same for different masses. When the objects are dropped in a vacuum, physicists now know that Galileo was right and Aristotle was wrong on this topic. Even during the period of dispute, however, both scientific theories agreed on the direction that an object would move. If natural scientists disagreed to the same extent as economists, some physicists would argue that an untethered bowling ball might float off a tower into the clouds. The secret shame of economics is that very little work focuses on the important issues of fiscal and monetary policy. Perhaps because these issues are so challenging, most economist have given up. Instead of working on fiscal and monetary policy, the field focuses on esoteric minutia. Without validated theories of the impact of MMT, we can make only weak inferences based on historical outcomes. It appears nearly certain that it is possible to print and spend so much that the real economy grinds to a halt. The relevant question is how much is too much and where are we today in this range of effects? Japan has followed MMT for longer than the US. The Japanese stock market is 50% below its level in 1989. The population of Japan is aging and shrinking. Decades of MMT in Japan correlate with stagnation and decline. Did MMT cause these Japanese problems? Again, no one knows, but still we wonder. In conclusion, what can we say about MMT? Money creates wealth only via its impact on real goods and services. When too much money is created, it decreases overall wealth by inhibiting economic cooperation. Economic theory is silent on whether the world has created the Goldilocks’ scenario of just the right amount of money, or too little or too much." ...like everything economic it's a massive experiment and no one knows whether it's the right approach or the wrong one because it's too hard to decipher. Too many non-monetary inputs and outcomes. So it's not as simplistic as saying 'we should spend within our means'. That could actually result in more inequality, worse performance, living standards etc. because it inhibits the positive effects of said expenditure. In short, it's more complex than saying 'the debt/deficit is high, therefore bad', or 'the debt/deficit is low, therefore good'. But it's the easiest thing to say, hence why most people say it. Discovering that actually it's not that simple and essentially unknowable would be destabilising to most I'd imagine, so they'd rather not think about it. That state of mind applies to a lot of things really. People would rather think there is certainty even if in reality there is none. See religion etc. 2. Agreed . Edited by cryrst (27 Feb 2021 5.32am)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.