Quote Penge Eagle at 13 Apr 2013 2.55pm
Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 10.22pm
Quote chris123 at 12 Apr 2013 9.15pm
Quote Penge Eagle at 12 Apr 2013 9.05pm
Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 9.02pm
Quote Penge Eagle at 12 Apr 2013 8.41pm
Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 7.27pm
Quote Penge Eagle at 12 Apr 2013 5.22pm
Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 12.29am
WhiteHorse hasn't been on for a while, was he really a senile Thatch?
I notice in the Daily Mirror that of all the council homes sold off, one third are being rented out by private landlords...Probably for a lot more than council rent would cost!!!
Edited by nickgusset (12 Apr 2013 12.31am)
Again, you are simply parroting what the likes of Owen Jones says.
Please explain in a bit more detail how landlords are profiteering or the "Probably for a lot more than council rent would cost!" bit.
I asked Owen Jones about this through twitter and he didn't get back to me, funnily enough!
Edited by Penge Eagle (12 Apr 2013 5.23pm)
I was merelysharing the Daily Mirrors story, I haven't read what Owen Jones wrote, although he did touch upon housing benefit being paid directly to unscrupulous landlords (not into the pockets of the inhabitants) during his excellent speech at the NUT conference.
If you repeat anything in a paper, may I accuse you of 'parroting' Littlejohn.
Once again Penge, you resort to personal digs rather than countering the argument. Do you have evidence against the fact that a third of sold off council houses are owned by private landlords? If you do, I'd be more than happy to read it.
Sorry Nick, I fail to see any personal insult there.
Why are you quoting a story to score points without being aware of the facts of the actual story?
I said you [in the case of this Mirror link] and "the likes of Owen Jones" as I've heard it so many times before and it's rubbish. By you quoting that Mirror story, you clearly agree with it. "Greedy landlords" is regularly trotted out by left wing commentators and politicians.
I am really interested to know how landlords who provide a service for the population profiteer on vulnerable people or are unscrupulousness.
I genuinely don't understand your point about landlords. Is it because they earn money and are therefore evil?
I'm not arguing over housing stock, but the issue about landlords.
For your information, housing benefit IS paid directly to the tenant unless they ask otherwise. Owen Jones said different at the NUT jolly, so it must be true? You are parroting what he said.
Edited by Penge Eagle (12 Apr 2013 8.49pm)
I was paraphrasing, not saying word for word.
Landlords are profiting out of your taxes, did you know that the son of the housing minister at the time of the council house sell off has a portfolio of over 40 ex council houses?
"Landlords are profiting out of your taxes". I just don't understand what is wrong with that? The State gives money to the private sector all of the time...
Do you have a problem with landlords?
Edited by Penge Eagle (12 Apr 2013 9.07pm
Landlord's are inherently risk takers. We have had two major property slumps in my memory. In the SE property prices may be fairly stable at the moment, but elsewhere they are not. If you are prepared to invest, take on risk and provide a service, what is wrong with those that get right making a profit?
I don't have a problem with landlords per se.
One and a half million council houses were sold off at up to 50% of their value. 1/3 of these houses are now owned by private landlords, fair play to private landlords if that is their way of making money. However the rent they are charging is way above what the council rent would have been.
In the vast majority of cases, the houses are being rented back to people who would have, had there been enough, been renting off of the council. As tax payers, we are paying a lot of the (now inflated when compared to council)rent through housing benefit.
Rents have increased by 36% in the last few years- now whether this is partly because landlords know they are onto a good thing because they know they have a guaranteed income from benefit tenants is debatable but not unlikely-I know there are other reasons, supply/demand etc-(a hangover from the original sold off housing stock not being replaced)
So as tax payers, we are paying a great deal more to support those who need housing benefit in order to provide a profit for individuals rather than to a council who could use the money for other projects-building more houses, fixing the facking pothole in the road, keeping libraries open etc etc.
That is where my beef lies.
Edited by nickgusset (12 Apr 2013 10.24pm)
I'm glad you had overnight to research your point since. 
You say: "However the rent they are charging is way above what the council rent would have been."
Landlords do not get paid any more letting out to the local council as they would a private individual. In fact, many council schemes give the landlord LESS money but tie to a rental guarantee scheme and the landlord has to spend more money to bring it up to council standards.
It doesn't affect the tenant as the rent is still covered.
OBVIOUSLY, if the council owned the property themselves then it would be cheaper for them instead of renting off a landlord.
But that is not the landlord's fault!!
It's down to a shortage of housing stock after Maggie (rightly) enabled people to buy their council home and the social housing was not replaced by her or in the 30 years since by Labour governments. Coupled with a rising population and more divorces that makes supply even more scare. It's got nothing to do with landlords renting out accommodation.
The rent is market value!
Anyway, you could argue that a council paying a landlord rent works out much cheaper than the cost of building and maintaining thousands of homes in the medium term.
I find it incredible that you are concerned about value for money for the tax payer all of a sudden! Only when a private individual has the opportunity to earn some money, then it's not fair! You forget that many landlords don't make any money or have lost thousands - so they are not all "profiteering". Many don't like the fact tenants get the housing because tenants have run off with the money or trashed the place.
From a moral perspective, only genuine cases should get housing benefit and the frauds should not which should in turn free up cash for fixing the potholes etc. The landlords are irrelevant as they are simply providing a service.
Edited by Penge Eagle (13 Apr 2013 2.57pm)
The market value of rents is high due to a lack of social housing. Although it must be said there's a fair few thousand second homes that lay empty. If I had my way, unless 2nd homes were rented out rather than laying empty, the owners should be taxed to the hilt. Same with holiday homes that lay empty for half the year. If these were rented out it would drive rents down.
As for my sudden concern for the tax payer! I've always been concerned for the tax payer, I want value for my taxes. At the moment I'm not getting it, especially as rents are so high, ergo housing benefit payments are higher.
There are dodgy landlords milking the system, just as there are honest ones making a living.
From a moral perspective, I think you should focus your ire on tax dodgers and avoiders. They rob the system of far more money than benefit fraudsters.