You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine
November 22 2026 2.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Israel / Palestine


Page 59 of 80 < 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 >
nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 03 Aug 14 3.34pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 03 Aug 2014 3.21pm

The arguments on this thread are a pretty good indicator of why peace in the Middle East is so difficult to attain.

Very little subtlety


Ironically put.

 

davidpercival Flag Croydon 03 Aug 14 3.36pm

First of all, Israel said they were attacking Gaza because Hamas was involved in murdering three boys from the (illegal) settlements in the west Bank. This was despite the fact that they have shown no evidence for it and that the major Palestinian group in the West Bank is Fatah.
Because of this unsupported claim they then re-arrested hundreds of Hamas supporters who had been released as part of a previous agreement. Israel says taking one of their soldiers captive is reason to bomb thousands of people whereas Palestinians are not supposed to do anything about thousands of prisoner being held by Israel.

Then they said they had to carry on bombing and rocketing Gaza because some rockets were being fired into Israel in protest at the arrests in defiance of the agreement which had been made.

Then they said they had to carry on bombing because of "terror tunnels". although there was no indication they had been used before Israel started this latest war.

Then they said they had to carry on bombing because Hamas had captured one of their soldiers (although they themselves had captured thousands of Palestinians over the last few years and said any action in response was terrorism). Obama and Cameron came on the tele and said how disgraceful it was that the soldier had been captured (even though all they had got to go on was Israel had said it had happened and Hamas said it had not).

Then they admitted that the soldier wasn't captured at all but had been killed in action, as Hamas had said all along. Did they say sorry to all the people they had killed on the basis of a lie on their part? Did Obama and Cameron apologise to the Palestians? No, and no.

All that has happened is that Israel has bombed yet another school with thousands of refugees in it again today (that is after several other similar events, including bombing hospitals).

The only solution is for the blockade and the occupation to end. Otherwise this conflict will continue because it is based on people fighting huge injustice, and nobody will be able to convince them they should just be quiet and let Israel carry on their exploitation (including their natural resourses as the previous poster said).

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 03 Aug 14 4.04pm

Interesting that a couple of posts have mentioned gas reserves eh Stirling

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 03 Aug 14 4.13pm

Quote davidpercival at 03 Aug 2014 3.36pm

First of all, Israel said they were attacking Gaza because Hamas was involved in murdering three boys from the (illegal) settlements in the west Bank. This was despite the fact that they have shown no evidence for it and that the major Palestinian group in the West Bank is Fatah.
Because of this unsupported claim they then re-arrested hundreds of Hamas supporters who had been released as part of a previous agreement. Israel says taking one of their soldiers captive is reason to bomb thousands of people whereas Palestinians are not supposed to do anything about thousands of prisoner being held by Israel.

Then they said they had to carry on bombing and rocketing Gaza because some rockets were being fired into Israel in protest at the arrests in defiance of the agreement which had been made.

Then they said they had to carry on bombing because of "terror tunnels". although there was no indication they had been used before Israel started this latest war.

Then they said they had to carry on bombing because Hamas had captured one of their soldiers (although they themselves had captured thousands of Palestinians over the last few years and said any action in response was terrorism). Obama and Cameron came on the tele and said how disgraceful it was that the soldier had been captured (even though all they had got to go on was Israel had said it had happened and Hamas said it had not).

Then they admitted that the soldier wasn't captured at all but had been killed in action, as Hamas had said all along. Did they say sorry to all the people they had killed on the basis of a lie on their part? Did Obama and Cameron apologise to the Palestians? No, and no.

All that has happened is that Israel has bombed yet another school with thousands of refugees in it again today (that is after several other similar events, including bombing hospitals).

The only solution is for the blockade and the occupation to end. Otherwise this conflict will continue because it is based on people fighting huge injustice, and nobody will be able to convince them they should just be quiet and let Israel carry on their exploitation (including their natural resourses as the previous poster said).

Good post, excellently put.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Palacetinian Flag Surrey Fam 03 Aug 14 4.31pm

The lead piece in Today's Mail explains what the people are facing in Gaza without electricity and the virtual collapse of the hospital system.

[Link]

Even sane strong supporters of Israel have been pointing out that such a barbaric onslaught against a civilian population doesn't help Israel in the long run as it creates another generation of people with a grievance.

[Link]

 


Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Aug 14 4.40pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 03 Aug 2014 1.56pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 03 Aug 2014 12.34pm

There are some legitimate complaints about the route of the barrier.....But despite the claims of many people before it went up....It has bought down the number of suicide bombings in Israel significantly.

Those who argue against a barrier being there are arguing for increased death on the Israeli mainland.



Ludicrous - of course they are not. You really spout complete b******s. Not everyone has the limited vision you appear to possess.


That is the practical result of no barrier.

Again, provide rational argument rather than insults.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 03 Aug 14 4.40pm

Salutary reading

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (03 Aug 2014 4.40pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Aug 14 4.45pm

Quote Seth at 03 Aug 2014 2.53pm

Here's a surprise - Gaza has bn worth of gas deposits under it, and Israel faces an energy crisis. Surely there's no connection between these facts...is there? Would Israel really launch a massacre of innocent civilians, under the guise of destroying Hamas, merely to secure its energy supplies? You decide....

[Link]

I decided a while ago when Nick put the same argument forward.

The practical consequences of controlling Gaza's gas reserves (for Israel also have) make no sense.

They would have to take over control of Gaza to control the gas extraction.....Why do they need to do that when they along with Egypt control the border?

You can't sell what you can't export.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Aug 14 4.48pm

Quote legaleagle at 03 Aug 2014 4.40pm

Salutary reading

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (03 Aug 2014 4.40pm)

Good article.

The whole thing is pointless.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Palacetinian Flag Surrey Fam 03 Aug 14 4.52pm

Quote legaleagle at 03 Aug 2014 4.40pm

Salutary reading

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (03 Aug 2014 4.40pm)

Indeed. So is this...

VIEW FROM ISRAEL
It’s All Hamas’ Fault, Right Israel?
I’m no fan of Hamas, quite the contrary. But Israel’s attempt to put all the blame on Hamas is outrageous.
GIDEON LEVY

[Link]

 


Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 03 Aug 14 5.03pm

Quote Palacetinian at 03 Aug 2014 4.52pm

Quote legaleagle at 03 Aug 2014 4.40pm

Salutary reading

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (03 Aug 2014 4.40pm)

Indeed. So is this...

VIEW FROM ISRAEL
It’s All Hamas’ Fault, Right Israel?
I’m no fan of Hamas, quite the contrary. But Israel’s attempt to put all the blame on Hamas is outrageous.
GIDEON LEVY

[Link]


In the same vein:

Israel Provoked This War
It’s up to President Obama to stop it.
By HENRY SIEGMAN July 22, 2014

[Link]

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Palacetinian Flag Surrey Fam 03 Aug 14 5.25pm

Quote Seth at 03 Aug 2014 5.03pm

Quote Palacetinian at 03 Aug 2014 4.52pm

Quote legaleagle at 03 Aug 2014 4.40pm

Salutary reading

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (03 Aug 2014 4.40pm)

Indeed. So is this...

VIEW FROM ISRAEL
It’s All Hamas’ Fault, Right Israel?
I’m no fan of Hamas, quite the contrary. But Israel’s attempt to put all the blame on Hamas is outrageous.
GIDEON LEVY

[Link]


In the same vein:

Israel Provoked This War
It’s up to President Obama to stop it.
By HENRY SIEGMAN July 22, 2014

[Link]

Seth. The author also appears in this video - he is a former Zionist who now believes Israel needs to make peace and give Palestinians a homeland to end decades of enmity.

[Link]

Turns out he also is a visiting professor at London University's School of Oriental and African Studies, a college I know well.

 


Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 03 Aug 14 5.33pm

Quote Palacetinian at 03 Aug 2014 5.25pm

Quote Seth at 03 Aug 2014 5.03pm

Quote Palacetinian at 03 Aug 2014 4.52pm

Quote legaleagle at 03 Aug 2014 4.40pm

Salutary reading

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (03 Aug 2014 4.40pm)

Indeed. So is this...

VIEW FROM ISRAEL
It’s All Hamas’ Fault, Right Israel?
I’m no fan of Hamas, quite the contrary. But Israel’s attempt to put all the blame on Hamas is outrageous.
GIDEON LEVY

[Link]


In the same vein:

Israel Provoked This War
It’s up to President Obama to stop it.
By HENRY SIEGMAN July 22, 2014

[Link]

Seth. The author also appears in this video - he is a former Zionist who now believes Israel needs to make peace and give Palestinians a homeland to end decades of enmity.

[Link]

Turns out he also is a visiting professor at London University's School of Oriental and African Studies, a college I know well.


Yes mate, I found that piece from a link on facebook and read a little about Mr Siegman. People like him, who are able to see the truth despite years of thinking the opposite, give me hope where there seems to be little to be hoped for.

Thanks for the link to the video. Interesting viewing.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 03 Aug 14 5.34pm

Quote Palacetinian at 03 Aug 2014 4.31pm

The lead piece in Today's Mail explains what the people are facing in Gaza without electricity and the virtual collapse of the hospital system.

[Link]

Even sane strong supporters of Israel have been pointing out that such a barbaric onslaught against a civilian population doesn't help Israel in the long run as it creates another generation of people with a grievance.
[Link]


I do believe this is exactly what the extreme right in the Knesset want, have wanted and will always want and make damned sure they create the atmosphere for it to be so decade after decade.

It helps their fcked up cause and underpins their raison d'etre. To expand, exploit and subjugate with no quarter given.

Barbaric, criminal, dehumanising fascists.

Edited by Kermit8 (03 Aug 2014 5.38pm)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 03 Aug 14 6.33pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 03 Aug 2014 4.40pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 03 Aug 2014 1.56pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 03 Aug 2014 12.34pm

There are some legitimate complaints about the route of the barrier.....But despite the claims of many people before it went up....It has bought down the number of suicide bombings in Israel significantly.

Those who argue against a barrier being there are arguing for increased death on the Israeli mainland.



Ludicrous - of course they are not. You really spout complete b******s. Not everyone has the limited vision you appear to possess.


That is the practical result of no barrier.

Again, provide rational argument rather than insults.


That's hard, seeing as you provided no justification whatsoever for your sweeping and absurd generalisation in the first place. What exactly am I supposed to counter?

You made an unsupported allegation (again) which condemns anyone who disagrees with you as complicit in killings which is both stupid and offensive.

I think you confuse facts and sensible argument with you own, prejudiced and ignorant opinions which you spout, presumably in the innocent belief that only you know the real answers.

You appear not to understand that debate is not simply you mouthing your extremely narrow, prejudiced and inexperienced view of the world and expecting everyone will agree with you.

You bore me senseless but, if you post more nonsense, then of course I will counter it - not to try and persuade you as I do not believe you have the capacity to listen and learn, but to provide some semblance of balance and knock down some of your more outrageous opinions.


 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 03 Aug 14 6.39pm

Quote nickgusset at 03 Aug 2014 12.19am

Quote Stirlingsays at 02 Aug 2014 11.56pm

Quote nickgusset at 02 Aug 2014 11.49pm

Unless you stop saying you want our destruction, we will destroy you. Even if you do this, we will still control you anyway and will probably destroy your infrastructure or take your land piecemeal as we did in the days before Hamas.


So you regard events like Camp David and all those near misses as disingenuous from the Israelis?.....Even the left in Israel?

They mean nothing at the moment do they? You are talking of resolutions, great, but until one of the sides stops, it's meaningless.


Netanyahu must have been spoiling for a fight. Instead of waiting for an investigation, it was in, all guns blazing. The fact that it wasn't even Hamas that kidnapped the 3 teenagers seems to have passed them by.

At the moment, Hamas it would seem are going down with the ship. Dying defending their homeland. True spirit of St George (Palestinian) Rather die defending their country than subjugating and giving more of it up.
How many on here see dying, defending your country as heroic? Would you do the same if you were in Palestinian shoes?

Of course there will be resistance to the besiegement of Gaza and Palestine as a whole. The Israelis should expect that. There's always resistance among some of the population within occupied countries.


And the 'searching for the kidnapped soldier', resulted in dozens of civilian dead.

As it transpires, the soldier was most likely killed by one of those indiscriminate (ahem, 'targetted' bombing strikes by Israel, as he was identified from his DNA 'bits'.

Meanwhile, more Palestinian children/civilians and UN sanctuaries are blown up.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Aug 14 7.00pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 03 Aug 2014 6.33pm

That's hard, seeing as you provided no justification whatsoever for your sweeping and absurd generalisation in the first place. What exactly am I supposed to counter?

You made an unsupported allegation (again) which condemns anyone who disagrees with you as complicit in killings which is both stupid and offensive.

I think you confuse facts and sensible argument with you own, prejudiced and ignorant opinions which you spout, presumably in the innocent belief that only you know the real answers.

You appear not to understand that debate is not simply you mouthing your extremely narrow, prejudiced and inexperienced view of the world and expecting everyone will agree with you.

You bore me senseless but, if you post more nonsense, then of course I will counter it - not to try and persuade you as I do not believe you have the capacity to listen and learn, but to provide some semblance of balance and knock down some of your more outrageous opinions.


Hahahaha!

You are most welcome to oppose my views.

Again ignoring the amusing insults I looked to see what rationalisations you presented.

Unfortunately after reading through five paragraphs I didn't find one argument against the fact that not having the current barrier doesn't lead to more Israeli deaths.

You just ridicule my 'unsupported allegation'. Is it unsupported?

From September 2000 to mid-2005, hundreds of Palestinian suicide bombings and terrorist attacks against Israeli civilians killed more nearly 1,000 innocent people.

Since construction of the fence began, the number of attacks has declined by more than 90%.

I don't really think you know much about the issue you've replied on and instead you appear to have replied singularly for the purpose of insulting me.

Edited by Stirlingsays (03 Aug 2014 7.10pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 03 Aug 14 7.07pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 03 Aug 2014 7.00pm

Again ignoring the amusing insults I looked to see what renationalisation you presented.


I think bringing the railways back under state control would be a good idea.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Aug 14 7.09pm

Quote Seth at 03 Aug 2014 7.07pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 03 Aug 2014 7.00pm

Again ignoring the amusing insults I looked to see what renationalisation you presented.


I think bringing the railways back under state control would be a good idea.

Nice one Seth.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 03 Aug 14 7.14pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 03 Aug 2014 7.00pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 03 Aug 2014 6.33pm

That's hard, seeing as you provided no justification whatsoever for your sweeping and absurd generalisation in the first place. What exactly am I supposed to counter?

You made an unsupported allegation (again) which condemns anyone who disagrees with you as complicit in killings which is both stupid and offensive.

I think you confuse facts and sensible argument with you own, prejudiced and ignorant opinions which you spout, presumably in the innocent belief that only you know the real answers.

You appear not to understand that debate is not simply you mouthing your extremely narrow, prejudiced and inexperienced view of the world and expecting everyone will agree with you.

You bore me senseless but, if you post more nonsense, then of course I will counter it - not to try and persuade you as I do not believe you have the capacity to listen and learn, but to provide some semblance of balance and knock down some of your more outrageous opinions.


Hahahaha!

You are most welcome to oppose my views.

Again ignoring the amusing insults I looked to see what renationalisation you presented.

Unfortunately after reading through five paragraphs I didn't find one argument against the fact that not having the current barrier doesn't lead to more Israeli deaths.

You just ridicule my 'unsupported allegation'. Is it unsupported?

From September 2000 to mid-2005, hundreds of Palestinian suicide bombings and terrorist attacks against Israeli civilians killed more nearly 1,000 innocent people.

Since construction of the fence began, the number of attacks has declined by more than 90%.

I don't really think you know much about the issue you've replied on and instead you appear to have replied singularly for the purpose of insulting me.

Edited by Stirlingsays (03 Aug 2014 7.05pm)


Not insulting, its not worth it, but devaluing and undermining your prejudiced ignorance, absolutely. At least now you have felt obliged to provide some very simplistic statistics to support your blanket insult aimed at everyone who disagrees with you.

I do not claim to be an expert in the Israeli/Palestinian issue, hence my comments are largely much more circumspect and observational, rather than judgemental and over-simplistic prejudice.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Page 59 of 80 < 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine