You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Effects of Austerity Cuts part 58
November 21 2026 11.34pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Effects of Austerity Cuts part 58


Page 6 of 15 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
npn Flag Crowborough 11 Feb 15 9.50am

Quote crystal balls at 11 Feb 2015 8.29am

Quote npn at 11 Feb 2015 8.19am

Quote moylerg at 11 Feb 2015 7.51am

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2015 7.47am

260,000 people a year adding to the population is hardly "statistically insignificant".


Statistics tend to look at overall percentages, part of the whole, and at 0.5%, it is close to statistically insignificant. He is correct in that and many other of his statements. A great article.


But that's an annual figure.
0.5% may be a small figure, but over 10 years that's 5%, and growing constantly.

You may believe imigration is beneficial, which is fine, but you can't realistically claim it's insignificant

An annual figure, in the sense that it occurred in a 12 month period, but it is not a fixed figure; in future growth may be at a higher or lower rate. Over 10 years it is impossible to predict.

Incidentally, the world population is growing at a faster rate than 0.5% annually, why should the UK be exempt from that? People have to live somewhere, and the majority of those coming to the UK tend to be better educated on average than those remaining in their homelands.

There are positives to people coming to the UK, though sections of the media choose to only look at (and exaggerate) the downside.


I agree, which is why I said you can argue that the imigration is beneficial. My only objection was to the claim that imigration numbers are insignificant - they are not, and it just perpetuates the 'head-in-the-sand' and 'we-will-not-discuss-it-for-fear-of-accusations-of-racism' attitudes which make the situtaion far worse than it needs to be.

Frank, honest, and open discussion is required, of both the benefits and the drawbacks. That discussion may very well come to the conclusion that the numbers are sustainable, or even that they could be increased, but avoiding the discussion helps nobody. Personally, I'm all for imigration when it comprises skilled people, and I favour a points based system, but that's a different debate

 

TheJudge Flag 11 Feb 15 6.42pm

Quote npn at 11 Feb 2015 9.50am

Quote crystal balls at 11 Feb 2015 8.29am

Quote npn at 11 Feb 2015 8.19am

Quote moylerg at 11 Feb 2015 7.51am

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2015 7.47am

260,000 people a year adding to the population is hardly "statistically insignificant".


Statistics tend to look at overall percentages, part of the whole, and at 0.5%, it is close to statistically insignificant. He is correct in that and many other of his statements. A great article.


But that's an annual figure.
0.5% may be a small figure, but over 10 years that's 5%, and growing constantly.

You may believe imigration is beneficial, which is fine, but you can't realistically claim it's insignificant

An annual figure, in the sense that it occurred in a 12 month period, but it is not a fixed figure; in future growth may be at a higher or lower rate. Over 10 years it is impossible to predict.

Incidentally, the world population is growing at a faster rate than 0.5% annually, why should the UK be exempt from that? People have to live somewhere, and the majority of those coming to the UK tend to be better educated on average than those remaining in their homelands.

There are positives to people coming to the UK, though sections of the media choose to only look at (and exaggerate) the downside.


I agree, which is why I said you can argue that the imigration is beneficial. My only objection was to the claim that imigration numbers are insignificant - they are not, and it just perpetuates the 'head-in-the-sand' and 'we-will-not-discuss-it-for-fear-of-accusations-of-racism' attitudes which make the situtaion far worse than it needs to be.

Frank, honest, and open discussion is required, of both the benefits and the drawbacks. That discussion may very well come to the conclusion that the numbers are sustainable, or even that they could be increased, but avoiding the discussion helps nobody. Personally, I'm all for imigration when it comprises skilled people, and I favour a points based system, but that's a different debate


Are you new to the internet ?

 

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 11 Feb 15 6.53pm

Quote npn at 11 Feb 2015 9.50am

Quote crystal balls at 11 Feb 2015 8.29am

Quote npn at 11 Feb 2015 8.19am

Quote moylerg at 11 Feb 2015 7.51am

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2015 7.47am

260,000 people a year adding to the population is hardly "statistically insignificant".


Statistics tend to look at overall percentages, part of the whole, and at 0.5%, it is close to statistically insignificant. He is correct in that and many other of his statements. A great article.


But that's an annual figure.
0.5% may be a small figure, but over 10 years that's 5%, and growing constantly.

You may believe imigration is beneficial, which is fine, but you can't realistically claim it's insignificant

An annual figure, in the sense that it occurred in a 12 month period, but it is not a fixed figure; in future growth may be at a higher or lower rate. Over 10 years it is impossible to predict.

Incidentally, the world population is growing at a faster rate than 0.5% annually, why should the UK be exempt from that? People have to live somewhere, and the majority of those coming to the UK tend to be better educated on average than those remaining in their homelands.

There are positives to people coming to the UK, though sections of the media choose to only look at (and exaggerate) the downside.


I agree, which is why I said you can argue that the imigration is beneficial. My only objection was to the claim that imigration numbers are insignificant - they are not, and it just perpetuates the 'head-in-the-sand' and 'we-will-not-discuss-it-for-fear-of-accusations-of-racism' attitudes which make the situtaion far worse than it needs to be.

Frank, honest, and open discussion is required, of both the benefits and the drawbacks. That discussion may very well come to the conclusion that the numbers are sustainable, or even that they could be increased, but avoiding the discussion helps nobody. Personally, I'm all for imigration when it comprises skilled people, and I favour a points based system, but that's a different debate

Significant yes to you or I, but In statistical terms, they are insignificant. What that really means is that in terms of numbers in the population they are not that high. That said, in terms of the economic contribution, extremely positive overall. The issue is surely that when someone knows of an immigrant claiming benefits, then they all are! I live in Birmingham, having lived in Perth WA for almost 4-years, and it is such a mixed race city to come back to, it was a shock at first! How many are immigrants, and of what generation, who knows! The fact is that typically immigrants serve the UK well and have for the last century and more. My in laws are immigrants, from India in the 50s. Worked in iron foundries post wartime and worked hard for themselves and the country. Different times now, differing immigrant nationalities, but, the same potential work ethic.

Edited by moylerg (11 Feb 2015 6.54pm)

 


Most certainly not European.

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 Mar 15 7.11pm

[Link]

400,000 to be denied adult education due to cuts according to this...

 

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 17 Mar 15 7.54pm

It has become a standard thing to say that immigration is economically a good thng and that we are better off as a result of immgration over the last 15-20 years. Really?
The number of foreign born people has risen from 3 to 7 million in that time. Well that is not a bad experiment - if there were economic advantages they should now be readily apparent. They are not. Even the most liberal economists say that the economic benefits are marginal at best. What they cannot Inclde in their sums, because they are unknowns, is the impact of illegal workers on the job market and the impact of a shadow population on services, housing, schools, hospitals and prisons. No one can calculate the impact on the economy of those millions who send much of their earnings abroad rather than recycle wealth into our economy. Even if there were a marginal economic benefit it is more than offset by the social tensions and risks to our security.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

johnfirewall Flag 17 Mar 15 9.07pm

His carer had probably just departed from a 3 second visit after placing a boiled egg in his hand for his lunch. (True story and I'm not even sure the egg was boiled)

 

Dweeb Flag East London 18 Mar 15 2.01am

It is notable that no one from teh government is denying that 60% of teh cuts are yet to come.

So if you think things are bad now just wait...

 


Taking the bungy jump since 1964. Never to see John Jackson in a shirt again

Sorry to see Lee Hills go, did we ever see Alex Marrow? We did January 2013

General Flag 18 Mar 15 8.51am

Electrical industry changed/screwed by these amazingly hard working/sneaky people. Go from earning good money to struggling to find work that is not somehow influenced by the ways these workers accept payment (umbrella/self employed) and/or conditions.
No trouble Il wear them 15 quid work boots for a year why do u want them comfortable ones. I can work 7-7 for no overtime pay thanks boss I have no reason to go home and see wife/kids they back home. Weekends yes Il work both days for standard pay! Maybe I expect too much..should be thankful I have a job!
Basically they are great for owners/governments.
Only thing u can do Is employ them and reap the benefits...dont worry about morals

Oh and this is exactly what the people above us want. Dont question the politicians/bankers who screw us over billions or shag boys go for the poor bozo

Propaganda in full effect congrats to the rulers of our life n world u done great

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 9.08am

Quote npn at 11 Feb 2015 8.19am

Quote moylerg at 11 Feb 2015 7.51am

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2015 7.47am

260,000 people a year adding to the population is hardly "statistically insignificant".


Statistics tend to look at overall percentages, part of the whole, and at 0.5%, it is close to statistically insignificant. He is correct in that and many other of his statements. A great article.


But that's an annual figure.
0.5% may be a small figure, but over 10 years that's 5%, and growing constantly.

You may believe imigration is beneficial, which is fine, but you can't realistically claim it's insignificant

You need to determine the percentage of population growth that is generated by immigration.

Even over 10 years, its not 5%, its still 0.5%, it doesn't increase as a percentage just because its x10 it remains fixed at 0.5% of the sum.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

npn Flag Crowborough 18 Mar 15 9.16am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 9.08am

Quote npn at 11 Feb 2015 8.19am

Quote moylerg at 11 Feb 2015 7.51am

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2015 7.47am

260,000 people a year adding to the population is hardly "statistically insignificant".


Statistics tend to look at overall percentages, part of the whole, and at 0.5%, it is close to statistically insignificant. He is correct in that and many other of his statements. A great article.


But that's an annual figure.
0.5% may be a small figure, but over 10 years that's 5%, and growing constantly.

You may believe imigration is beneficial, which is fine, but you can't realistically claim it's insignificant

You need to determine the percentage of population growth that is generated by immigration.

Even over 10 years, its not 5%, its still 0.5%, it doesn't increase as a percentage just because its x10 it remains fixed at 0.5% of the sum.



260,000 a year are down to immigration (no idea if those figures are accurate).

In 10 years (comparatively the blink of an eye), that's 2.6 million. Nobody in their right mind could possibly claim that 2.6 million is a "statistically insignificant" figure, regardless of the population growth from non-immigration sources.

As I said, you can argue that it's beneficial, which is fine (but a seperate argument) but you can't just claim the figures are insignificant and ignore them. That sort of approach is precisely what led to the rise of UKIP - "don't talk about it or you're a racist"

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 9.20am

Quote Catfish at 17 Mar 2015 7.54pm

It has become a standard thing to say that immigration is economically a good thng and that we are better off as a result of immgration over the last 15-20 years. Really?
The number of foreign born people has risen from 3 to 7 million in that time. Well that is not a bad experiment - if there were economic advantages they should now be readily apparent. They are not. Even the most liberal economists say that the economic benefits are marginal at best. What they cannot Inclde in their sums, because they are unknowns, is the impact of illegal workers on the job market and the impact of a shadow population on services, housing, schools, hospitals and prisons. No one can calculate the impact on the economy of those millions who send much of their earnings abroad rather than recycle wealth into our economy. Even if there were a marginal economic benefit it is more than offset by the social tensions and risks to our security.

Technically, better off, in terms of macro-economic picture, doesn't actually mean everything is bright and rosy, just that realistically those 'at the top are better off as a result', there are many different ways to determine success, and ecconmic benefit has a null real world value for most people, because the benefit they personally see on a micro scale is minimal.

Realistically, the problem of 'immigration' stems not so much from the fact of migration, but from the 'economic situation' prior to the impact of the 'crunch' European migration wasn't an issue, people generally found it a positive experience, as they migrants typically filled vacancies that 'upper working class and middle class' citizens didn't want to have to do, and did it affordably.

Post crunch, the contraction has affected those two very media significant demographics, as they've found themselves squeezed by the competition for jobs from migration, as employers looking to reduce operation costs, have passed on that cost to their workers, and government spending cuts have had a big impact on people working in government contract and mid level civil service facing roles.

Meanwhile the working classes, typically working alongside those migrant workers, find themselves increasing squeezed towards the underclasses, by rising costs, and an accessable cheap labour force.

Consequently, these people have come to see migration workers in a different light, and a convenient scapegoat for blame (in reality those migrant workers are in the same situation more or less), and rather than looking at the economic failures in state, that have essentially benefitted corporate UK over the population, the focus has become about 'foreigners being to blame for everything' - a very traditional scape goat rolled out in times of economic constriction and downturn.

The reality is that some very poor economic decisions, both in finance, corporate and government resulted in a situation, which increasingly has become blamed not on those responsible, but a minority of its victims.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 9.25am

Quote npn at 18 Mar 2015 9.16am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 9.08am

Quote npn at 11 Feb 2015 8.19am

Quote moylerg at 11 Feb 2015 7.51am

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2015 7.47am

260,000 people a year adding to the population is hardly "statistically insignificant".


Statistics tend to look at overall percentages, part of the whole, and at 0.5%, it is close to statistically insignificant. He is correct in that and many other of his statements. A great article.


But that's an annual figure.
0.5% may be a small figure, but over 10 years that's 5%, and growing constantly.

You may believe imigration is beneficial, which is fine, but you can't realistically claim it's insignificant

You need to determine the percentage of population growth that is generated by immigration.

Even over 10 years, its not 5%, its still 0.5%, it doesn't increase as a percentage just because its x10 it remains fixed at 0.5% of the sum.



260,000 a year are down to immigration (no idea if those figures are accurate).

In 10 years (comparatively the blink of an eye), that's 2.6 million. Nobody in their right mind could possibly claim that 2.6 million is a "statistically insignificant" figure, regardless of the population growth from non-immigration sources.

As I said, you can argue that it's beneficial, which is fine (but a seperate argument) but you can't just claim the figures are insignificant and ignore them. That sort of approach is precisely what led to the rise of UKIP - "don't talk about it or you're a racist"

Except of course it is, if its a 0.5% factor of the whole. Even at 5%, that would mean that 95% of the 'factor or problem' occurs elsewhere, so it would only be significant if 95% of the other factors fell below the 5% margin.

You might as well be arguing the 5 is a bigger number than 95.

Statistical relevancy is an objective measurement, determined in line with mathematics. As such only someone not in their right mind would argue that a statistically insignificant factor is significant.

This is why in statistical based science, you tend to argue with the methodology of determining significance rather than the results of the statistical analysis.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 9.28am

Quote npn at 18 Mar 2015 9.16am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 9.08am

Quote npn at 11 Feb 2015 8.19am

Quote moylerg at 11 Feb 2015 7.51am

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2015 7.47am

260,000 people a year adding to the population is hardly "statistically insignificant".


Statistics tend to look at overall percentages, part of the whole, and at 0.5%, it is close to statistically insignificant. He is correct in that and many other of his statements. A great article.


But that's an annual figure.
0.5% may be a small figure, but over 10 years that's 5%, and growing constantly.

You may believe imigration is beneficial, which is fine, but you can't realistically claim it's insignificant

You need to determine the percentage of population growth that is generated by immigration.

Even over 10 years, its not 5%, its still 0.5%, it doesn't increase as a percentage just because its x10 it remains fixed at 0.5% of the sum.



260,000 a year are down to immigration (no idea if those figures are accurate).

In 10 years (comparatively the blink of an eye), that's 2.6 million. Nobody in their right mind could possibly claim that 2.6 million is a "statistically insignificant" figure, regardless of the population growth from non-immigration sources.

As I said, you can argue that it's beneficial, which is fine (but a seperate argument) but you can't just claim the figures are insignificant and ignore them. That sort of approach is precisely what led to the rise of UKIP - "don't talk about it or you're a racist"

If 0.5% of population growth is down to migration, then its an insignificant factor. It would arguably be more relevant, in terms of talking about the impact of population size, to focus on a factor that control of would implement a more significant result.

Unless of course you can statistically determine that a 0.5% factor is a significant factor (ie that 95% of all other factors fall below the 0.5% ratio).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

npn Flag Crowborough 18 Mar 15 9.40am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 9.25am

Quote npn at 18 Mar 2015 9.16am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 9.08am

Quote npn at 11 Feb 2015 8.19am

Quote moylerg at 11 Feb 2015 7.51am

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2015 7.47am

260,000 people a year adding to the population is hardly "statistically insignificant".


Statistics tend to look at overall percentages, part of the whole, and at 0.5%, it is close to statistically insignificant. He is correct in that and many other of his statements. A great article.


But that's an annual figure.
0.5% may be a small figure, but over 10 years that's 5%, and growing constantly.

You may believe imigration is beneficial, which is fine, but you can't realistically claim it's insignificant

You need to determine the percentage of population growth that is generated by immigration.

Even over 10 years, its not 5%, its still 0.5%, it doesn't increase as a percentage just because its x10 it remains fixed at 0.5% of the sum.



260,000 a year are down to immigration (no idea if those figures are accurate).

In 10 years (comparatively the blink of an eye), that's 2.6 million. Nobody in their right mind could possibly claim that 2.6 million is a "statistically insignificant" figure, regardless of the population growth from non-immigration sources.

As I said, you can argue that it's beneficial, which is fine (but a seperate argument) but you can't just claim the figures are insignificant and ignore them. That sort of approach is precisely what led to the rise of UKIP - "don't talk about it or you're a racist"

Except of course it is, if its a 0.5% factor of the whole. Even at 5%, that would mean that 95% of the 'factor or problem' occurs elsewhere, so it would only be significant if 95% of the other factors fell below the 5% margin.

You might as well be arguing the 5 is a bigger number than 95.

Statistical relevancy is an objective measurement, determined in line with mathematics. As such only someone not in their right mind would argue that a statistically insignificant factor is significant.

This is why in statistical based science, you tend to argue with the methodology of determining significance rather than the results of the statistical analysis.



And that's where "lies, damned lies, and statistics" comes into play. Of course the vast majority of popuylation growth is down to birth rate of those already here, and statistically there is also a much higher birth rate among immigrant (and particularly third world immigrant) families.

But hey, let's just ignore it!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 9.51am

Quote npn at 18 Mar 2015 9.40am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 9.25am

Quote npn at 18 Mar 2015 9.16am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 9.08am

Quote npn at 11 Feb 2015 8.19am

Quote moylerg at 11 Feb 2015 7.51am

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2015 7.47am

260,000 people a year adding to the population is hardly "statistically insignificant".


Statistics tend to look at overall percentages, part of the whole, and at 0.5%, it is close to statistically insignificant. He is correct in that and many other of his statements. A great article.


But that's an annual figure.
0.5% may be a small figure, but over 10 years that's 5%, and growing constantly.

You may believe imigration is beneficial, which is fine, but you can't realistically claim it's insignificant

You need to determine the percentage of population growth that is generated by immigration.

Even over 10 years, its not 5%, its still 0.5%, it doesn't increase as a percentage just because its x10 it remains fixed at 0.5% of the sum.



260,000 a year are down to immigration (no idea if those figures are accurate).

In 10 years (comparatively the blink of an eye), that's 2.6 million. Nobody in their right mind could possibly claim that 2.6 million is a "statistically insignificant" figure, regardless of the population growth from non-immigration sources.

As I said, you can argue that it's beneficial, which is fine (but a seperate argument) but you can't just claim the figures are insignificant and ignore them. That sort of approach is precisely what led to the rise of UKIP - "don't talk about it or you're a racist"

Except of course it is, if its a 0.5% factor of the whole. Even at 5%, that would mean that 95% of the 'factor or problem' occurs elsewhere, so it would only be significant if 95% of the other factors fell below the 5% margin.

You might as well be arguing the 5 is a bigger number than 95.

Statistical relevancy is an objective measurement, determined in line with mathematics. As such only someone not in their right mind would argue that a statistically insignificant factor is significant.

This is why in statistical based science, you tend to argue with the methodology of determining significance rather than the results of the statistical analysis.



And that's where "lies, damned lies, and statistics" comes into play. Of course the vast majority of popuylation growth is down to birth rate of those already here, and statistically there is also a much higher birth rate among immigrant (and particularly third world immigrant) families.

But hey, let's just ignore it!

See, you've already realized that it isn't a relevant factor, and that cultural factors on birth rates is itself a more relevant area to focus on.

Interestingly the most relevant determanent of higher than average birth rates, isn't ethnic, its economic factors and education. Poverty seems to be linked with higher birth rates, far more than culture or ethnicity.

So I'd start there, rather than blaming working migrants and immigration.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

npn Flag Crowborough 18 Mar 15 9.57am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 9.51am

Quote npn at 18 Mar 2015 9.40am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 9.25am

Quote npn at 18 Mar 2015 9.16am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 9.08am

Quote npn at 11 Feb 2015 8.19am

Quote moylerg at 11 Feb 2015 7.51am

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2015 7.47am

260,000 people a year adding to the population is hardly "statistically insignificant".


Statistics tend to look at overall percentages, part of the whole, and at 0.5%, it is close to statistically insignificant. He is correct in that and many other of his statements. A great article.


But that's an annual figure.
0.5% may be a small figure, but over 10 years that's 5%, and growing constantly.

You may believe imigration is beneficial, which is fine, but you can't realistically claim it's insignificant

You need to determine the percentage of population growth that is generated by immigration.

Even over 10 years, its not 5%, its still 0.5%, it doesn't increase as a percentage just because its x10 it remains fixed at 0.5% of the sum.



260,000 a year are down to immigration (no idea if those figures are accurate).

In 10 years (comparatively the blink of an eye), that's 2.6 million. Nobody in their right mind could possibly claim that 2.6 million is a "statistically insignificant" figure, regardless of the population growth from non-immigration sources.

As I said, you can argue that it's beneficial, which is fine (but a seperate argument) but you can't just claim the figures are insignificant and ignore them. That sort of approach is precisely what led to the rise of UKIP - "don't talk about it or you're a racist"

Except of course it is, if its a 0.5% factor of the whole. Even at 5%, that would mean that 95% of the 'factor or problem' occurs elsewhere, so it would only be significant if 95% of the other factors fell below the 5% margin.

You might as well be arguing the 5 is a bigger number than 95.

Statistical relevancy is an objective measurement, determined in line with mathematics. As such only someone not in their right mind would argue that a statistically insignificant factor is significant.

This is why in statistical based science, you tend to argue with the methodology of determining significance rather than the results of the statistical analysis.



And that's where "lies, damned lies, and statistics" comes into play. Of course the vast majority of popuylation growth is down to birth rate of those already here, and statistically there is also a much higher birth rate among immigrant (and particularly third world immigrant) families.

But hey, let's just ignore it!

See, you've already realized that it isn't a relevant factor, and that cultural factors on birth rates is itself a more relevant area to focus on.

Interestingly the most relevant determanent of higher than average birth rates, isn't ethnic, its economic factors and education. Poverty seems to be linked with higher birth rates, far more than culture or ethnicity.

So I'd start there, rather than blaming working migrants and immigration.



Don't think antyone was 'blaming' anything. There you go again with your "if you talk about immigration you're blaming immigrants"

Jesus, you may as well work for UKIP!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 10.04am

I volunteer as a carer for UKIP Policy makers....

Yeah blame isn't a very neutral term. But I did mean it in terms of determining a consequence or responsibility.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Mar 15 10.40pm

[Link]

Well done Dave and Nick

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 19 Mar 15 10.50pm

Quote nickgusset at 19 Mar 2015 10.40pm

[Link]

Well done Dave and Nick


Oh Dear !!

 


Pro USA & Israel

kersal Flag London 19 Mar 15 11.26pm

Quote npn at 18 Mar 2015 9.57am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 9.51am

Quote npn at 18 Mar 2015 9.40am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 9.25am

Quote npn at 18 Mar 2015 9.16am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 9.08am

Quote npn at 11 Feb 2015 8.19am

Quote moylerg at 11 Feb 2015 7.51am

Quote Catfish at 11 Feb 2015 7.47am

260,000 people a year adding to the population is hardly "statistically insignificant".


Statistics tend to look at overall percentages, part of the whole, and at 0.5%, it is close to statistically insignificant. He is correct in that and many other of his statements. A great article.


But that's an annual figure.
0.5% may be a small figure, but over 10 years that's 5%, and growing constantly.

You may believe imigration is beneficial, which is fine, but you can't realistically claim it's insignificant

You need to determine the percentage of population growth that is generated by immigration.

Even over 10 years, its not 5%, its still 0.5%, it doesn't increase as a percentage just because its x10 it remains fixed at 0.5% of the sum.



260,000 a year are down to immigration (no idea if those figures are accurate).

In 10 years (comparatively the blink of an eye), that's 2.6 million. Nobody in their right mind could possibly claim that 2.6 million is a "statistically insignificant" figure, regardless of the population growth from non-immigration sources.

As I said, you can argue that it's beneficial, which is fine (but a seperate argument) but you can't just claim the figures are insignificant and ignore them. That sort of approach is precisely what led to the rise of UKIP - "don't talk about it or you're a racist"

Except of course it is, if its a 0.5% factor of the whole. Even at 5%, that would mean that 95% of the 'factor or problem' occurs elsewhere, so it would only be significant if 95% of the other factors fell below the 5% margin.

You might as well be arguing the 5 is a bigger number than 95.

Statistical relevancy is an objective measurement, determined in line with mathematics. As such only someone not in their right mind would argue that a statistically insignificant factor is significant.

This is why in statistical based science, you tend to argue with the methodology of determining significance rather than the results of the statistical analysis.



And that's where "lies, damned lies, and statistics" comes into play. Of course the vast majority of popuylation growth is down to birth rate of those already here, and statistically there is also a much higher birth rate among immigrant (and particularly third world immigrant) families.

But hey, let's just ignore it!

See, you've already realized that it isn't a relevant factor, and that cultural factors on birth rates is itself a more relevant area to focus on.

Interestingly the most relevant determanent of higher than average birth rates, isn't ethnic, its economic factors and education. Poverty seems to be linked with higher birth rates, far more than culture or ethnicity.

So I'd start there, rather than blaming working migrants and immigration.



Don't think antyone was 'blaming' anything. There you go again with your "if you talk about immigration you're blaming immigrants"

Jesus, you may as well work for UKIP!

What's the big deal about the population growth by the way? Since 2000, UK's population growth has been less than 0.7% per annum on average. US grows easily above 1%. Emerging markets grow 2-3% and this is considered a normal rate. Developed nations grow at anywhere between 0.5-1.5% and the UK is at the lower half.

Some population growth is a very healthy thing; it expands all markets.

No government would be alarmed by a population growth of less than 1% - no well-functioning government should be. If a politician uses this argument to make a point about immigration policies and immigrants, please know that it's nothing but propaganda.

There may be other very real concerns about immigration, but this is not one of them.

 

Page 6 of 15 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Effects of Austerity Cuts part 58