You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Flag
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Confederate Flag


Page 6 of 18 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Jul 14 4.12pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 14 Jul 2014 4.10pm

Quote doublesuited77 at 14 Jul 2014 2.30pm

Quote grump at 14 Jul 2014 2.24pm

Quote Mapletree at 14 Jul 2014 1.28pm

I can't believe this thread is still running, Adrian B is bang on.

It doesn't matter what is intended, what matters is the effect. I don't mind us upsetting one bloke by telling him not to fly it - if necessary - for the greater good. If this can be perceived as a racist statement it should not be flown. Full stop. The HF already suffers from a bit of a mixed review in some circles and other Ultras do have reputations for racism and intolerance. Don't take the risk.

Or maybe this doesn't matter as primarily it's only upsetting Americans who, of course, don't count. How racist is that attitude....

Edited by Mapletree (14 Jul 2014 1.29pm)


Sorry mate, it only upsets some Americans, I think you will find your attitude upsets quite a few as well.


It upsets more than just Americans. It upsets most people who have a knowledge of American history, myself included.

I remember a few years back, someone was flying a National Front flag in the Holmesdale. During the 2nd match, I saw the flag, it was removed since we dont want to be linked to racist extremist groups. I think the same logic should apply here.


It's quite an insult to call all the people who use the confederate flag as racist or lacking in history knowledge.

It represents much more than what you singluarly choose to recognise. Those who fail to recognise that give insult to those that don't.

If someone uses the flag to represent slavery or a far right group then yes.....tell them no thank you we don't want that here.

If someone waves it because they are southern American, anti government or whatever it is.....Then fair enough.


Agreed, but how do you stop American viewers from thinking it's being waved for the wrong reasons, even if is not.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Jul 14 4.26pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 4.12pm

Agreed, but how do you stop American viewers from thinking it's being waved for the wrong reasons, even if is not.


We can't......Sometimes they will be right and sometimes not.

It isn't really the biggest problem......Next time it's waved at Selhurst we should find out.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jul 2014 4.27pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Jul 14 4.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 14 Jul 2014 4.26pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 4.12pm

Agreed, but how do you stop American viewers from thinking it's being waved for the wrong reasons, even if is not.


We can't......Sometimes they will be right and sometimes not.

It isn't really the biggest problem......Next time it's waved at Selhurst we should find out.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jul 2014 4.27pm)


Are you happy for say 30% of American viewers (random figure I know) to think that Palace tolerate racist symbolism at their matches?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Jul 14 4.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 4.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 14 Jul 2014 4.26pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 4.12pm

Agreed, but how do you stop American viewers from thinking it's being waved for the wrong reasons, even if is not.


We can't......Sometimes they will be right and sometimes not.

It isn't really the biggest problem......Next time it's waved at Selhurst we should find out.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jul 2014 4.27pm)


Are you happy for say 30% of American viewers (random figure I know) to think that Palace tolerate racist symbolism at their matches?


I think to just regard it as a racism symbol is ill educated.....Millions of Americans watched Dukes of Hazard didn't they? I don't remember any slavers in that show.

The flag isn't just one thing as many would like to believe.....So I'm a bit non plussed to be honest.

If it's flown again, find out, and if the person's a twit chuck him out.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jul 2014 4.48pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Jul 14 4.52pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 14 Jul 2014 4.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 4.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 14 Jul 2014 4.26pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 4.12pm

Agreed, but how do you stop American viewers from thinking it's being waved for the wrong reasons, even if is not.


We can't......Sometimes they will be right and sometimes not.

It isn't really the biggest problem......Next time it's waved at Selhurst we should find out.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jul 2014 4.27pm)


Are you happy for say 30% of American viewers (random figure I know) to think that Palace tolerate racist symbolism at their matches?


I think to just regard it as a racism symbol is ill educated.....Millions of Americans watched Dukes of Hazard didn't they? I don't remember any slavers in that show.

The flag isn't just one thing as many would like to believe.....So I'm a bit non plussed to be honest.

If it's flown again, find out, and if the person's a twit chuck him out.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jul 2014 4.48pm)


Whilst I agree that it can mean different things to different people, the fact that it is in one sense construed as a symbol of white supremacy means that some will see it as that. To say that's their problem doesn't detract from the negative light it could put our club in.

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 14 Jul 14 4.54pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 4.12pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 14 Jul 2014 4.10pm

Quote doublesuited77 at 14 Jul 2014 2.30pm

Quote grump at 14 Jul 2014 2.24pm

Quote Mapletree at 14 Jul 2014 1.28pm

I can't believe this thread is still running, Adrian B is bang on.

It doesn't matter what is intended, what matters is the effect. I don't mind us upsetting one bloke by telling him not to fly it - if necessary - for the greater good. If this can be perceived as a racist statement it should not be flown. Full stop. The HF already suffers from a bit of a mixed review in some circles and other Ultras do have reputations for racism and intolerance. Don't take the risk.

Or maybe this doesn't matter as primarily it's only upsetting Americans who, of course, don't count. How racist is that attitude....

Edited by Mapletree (14 Jul 2014 1.29pm)


Sorry mate, it only upsets some Americans, I think you will find your attitude upsets quite a few as well.


It upsets more than just Americans. It upsets most people who have a knowledge of American history, myself included.

I remember a few years back, someone was flying a National Front flag in the Holmesdale. During the 2nd match, I saw the flag, it was removed since we dont want to be linked to racist extremist groups. I think the same logic should apply here.


It's quite an insult to call all the people who use the confederate flag as racist or lacking in history knowledge.

It represents much more than what you singluarly choose to recognise. Those who fail to recognise that give insult to those that don't.

If someone uses the flag to represent slavery or a far right group then yes.....tell them no thank you we don't want that here.

If someone waves it because they are southern American, anti government or whatever it is.....Then fair enough.


Agreed, but how do you stop American viewers from thinking it's being waved for the wrong reasons, even if is not.

You can't. Offence is taken, rather than given so there will always be someone, somewhere, that will find something that they don't like.
Flags will always stir up problems as they will mean something to one person and something else to another, generally neither group will accept the others view either.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

npn Flag Crowborough 14 Jul 14 5.21pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 14 Jul 2014 4.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 4.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 14 Jul 2014 4.26pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 4.12pm

Agreed, but how do you stop American viewers from thinking it's being waved for the wrong reasons, even if is not.


We can't......Sometimes they will be right and sometimes not.

It isn't really the biggest problem......Next time it's waved at Selhurst we should find out.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jul 2014 4.27pm)


Are you happy for say 30% of American viewers (random figure I know) to think that Palace tolerate racist symbolism at their matches?


I think to just regard it as a racism symbol is ill educated.....Millions of Americans watched Dukes of Hazard didn't they? I don't remember any slavers in that show.

The flag isn't just one thing as many would like to believe.....So I'm a bit non plussed to be honest.

If it's flown again, find out, and if the person's a twit chuck him out.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jul 2014 4.48pm)

I have no idea what the intent behind the flag is. The only person who knows that for sure is the person flying it (I rather suspect they just like the flag and it's red and blue), but there's a lot of simplification going on here - "supporter of the south" = "white supremacist"

Reminds me of the Simpsons episode where Apu is applying for US citizenship:

Proctor: All right, here's your last question. What was the cause of the Civil War?
Apu: Actually, there were numerous causes. Aside from the obvious schism between the abolitionists and the anti-abolitionists, there were economic factors, both domestic and inter--
Proctor: Wait, wait... just say slavery.
Apu: Slavery it is, sir.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Jul 14 5.25pm

Gotta love the hol. Who would've thought we'd discuss flag semantics...

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 14 Jul 14 7.04pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 5.25pm

Gotta love the hol. Who would've thought we'd discuss flag semantics...


We're not discussing semantics here. It's a straight forward question of whether we , as Palace supporters, are happy to see a flag that most regard as a racist flag in the Park. No semantics about that.

 

kersal Flag London 14 Jul 14 9.28pm

Dukes of Hazzard is a "satire" of rednecks done by one of the most sarcastic guys in America. The car's name is deliberately that of somebody who believed that white supremacy was God given. And there is even a scene in where they end up in a black neighborhood and the flag is not welcome. It's not about redneck pride, it's about redneck idiocy.

Also, just because an offensive symbol is used for sarcasm in a movie does not strip its meaning away and legitimizes it. If that were the case, dressing up similar to Hitler would not offend anybody because Chaplin made a movie called The Great Dictator - which is also funny. But hey, his name was Adenoid Hynkel, so it must be me who is offended by it and it is the racist in me that must see a resemblance to Hitler.

Or we can dress up as ghosts for Halloween and put pointy hats on. After all, Don Johnson was so funny in that costume in Django Unchained.

This "if you're offended it's your own weakness" argument is one of the most immature things I have ever heard. Then let's all wear Swastikas and walk in Tel Aviv. If they're offended, peh.

It's not semantics. It's the remembrance of a very bitter history not so long ago and pains that are still very much alive for many people. Symbol of heritage my a*s. It is heritage for Texas, heritage for Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia and South Carolina, where black people are still considered inferior. I've been in all of these states and lived in some. I know what I am talking about and I have seen the people who carry these "symbol of state rights" on their trucks.

If you had a close black American friend, I don't think you would be waving that flag around in his face.

I think whoever made that flag had absolutely no intent of racism, but I also believe it is not right to wave it when millions are watching in the US.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Jul 14 9.36pm

Quote adrian b at 14 Jul 2014 7.04pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 5.25pm

Gotta love the hol. Who would've thought we'd discuss flag semantics...


We're not discussing semantics here. It's a straight forward question of whether we , as Palace supporters, are happy to see a flag that most regard as a racist flag in the Park. No semantics about that.


Don't get me wrong,I agree with you in the fact that it can be seen as offensive, so is. I was alluding to different posters having different opinions on the flag.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 14 Jul 14 9.43pm

Quote adrian b at 14 Jul 2014 7.04pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 5.25pm

Gotta love the hol. Who would've thought we'd discuss flag semantics...


We're not discussing semantics here. It's a straight forward question of whether we , as Palace supporters, are happy to see a flag that most regard as a racist flag in the Park. No semantics about that.

Who says? Opinion is divided on here and there's no reason to believe that would not be the same generally. That may be through a lack of knowledge, it may be through own beliefs but one thing is clear from this discussion, it is far from a clear cut issue whatever an individuals personal opinion is.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

PsychoPaul Flag 14 Jul 14 9.46pm

Quote grump at 14 Jul 2014 2.56pm

I think the Union Jack is a far greater symbol of racism than the confederate southern cross.

My view exactly, the Union Flag drips blood of far more oppression. I don't want to see that being flown at Selhurst.


 

c_block_shedevil Flag London 14 Jul 14 9.50pm

Quote PsychoPaul at 14 Jul 2014 9.46pm

Quote grump at 14 Jul 2014 2.56pm

I think the Union Jack is a far greater symbol of racism than the confederate southern cross.

My view exactly, the Union Flag drips blood of far more oppression. I don't want to see that being flown at Selhurst.


Quite.

The flag has also been adopted by racist scum like the BNP.

Are the liberal bed-wetters pushing for this flag to be dropped?

 


I'm tough. I'm ambitious. I know exactly what I want. If that makes me a bitch, I'm OK with that.

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Jul 14 9.53pm

Quote c_block_shedevil at 14 Jul 2014 9.50pm

Quote PsychoPaul at 14 Jul 2014 9.46pm

Quote grump at 14 Jul 2014 2.56pm

I think the Union Jack is a far greater symbol of racism than the confederate southern cross.

My view exactly, the Union Flag drips blood of far more oppression. I don't want to see that being flown at Selhurst.


Quite.

The flag has also been adopted by racist scum like the BNP.

Are the liberal bed-wetters pushing for this flag to be dropped?

Bingo!

 

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Jul 14 10.18pm

Quote kersal at 14 Jul 2014 9.28pm

Dukes of Hazzard is a "satire" of rednecks done by one of the most sarcastic guys in America. The car's name is deliberately that of somebody who believed that white supremacy was God given. And there is even a scene in where they end up in a black neighborhood and the flag is not welcome. It's not about redneck pride, it's about redneck idiocy.

Also, just because an offensive symbol is used for sarcasm in a movie does not strip its meaning away and legitimizes it. If that were the case, dressing up similar to Hitler would not offend anybody because Chaplin made a movie called The Great Dictator - which is also funny. But hey, his name was Adenoid Hynkel, so it must be me who is offended by it and it is the racist in me that must see a resemblance to Hitler.

Or we can dress up as ghosts for Halloween and put pointy hats on. After all, Don Johnson was so funny in that costume in Django Unchained.

This "if you're offended it's your own weakness" argument is one of the most immature things I have ever heard. Then let's all wear Swastikas and walk in Tel Aviv. If they're offended, peh.

It's not semantics. It's the remembrance of a very bitter history not so long ago and pains that are still very much alive for many people. Symbol of heritage my a*s. It is heritage for Texas, heritage for Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia and South Carolina, where black people are still considered inferior. I've been in all of these states and lived in some. I know what I am talking about and I have seen the people who carry these "symbol of state rights" on their trucks.

If you had a close black American friend, I don't think you would be waving that flag around in his face.

I think whoever made that flag had absolutely no intent of racism, but I also believe it is not right to wave it when millions are watching in the US.


Calling the Dukes of Hazard a 'satire' is stretching things so far as to be risible.

Are you suggesting the main characters in that show are meant to be racists? I don't think you are, but they represent many Americans who identify with that flag for various reasons. They aren't all racists by any means and it's people like you regressing it back to racism all the time that are part of the problem.

I'll say it again, it represents different things to different people.

I couldn't give a monkey's uncle about the flag myself but I bulk at people like yourself telling others what symbol you think they can or can't wave.

If some idiot wants to wave the confederate flat in Harlem or the swastika amongst Jews that's their own stupid decision.

I support the freedom to express yourself.....If you are waving the flag as a symbol of oppression then that's a different issue...People have a right to confront you for it.......But if it's for dixie land or you're anti government then anyone telling you that it can't be waved are oppressing you....Not the other way around.

[Link]

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jul 2014 10.21pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

kersal Flag London 14 Jul 14 11.22pm

And I see you as part of the problem. Defending symbols that carry so much hate in them because it wasn't you or those close to you that experienced the suffering? A bit of empathy is what you need more of.

It's not about the intent of a symbol, it's about its potential recipients and its consequences for them. I wouldn't participate in this argument if our games were shown only in London and in fact cared much less when I saw it at Selhurst when we were all to ourselves - though it was always an eyesore to me.

The matches are shown in the US now and this means it's not liberal schmucks making a big deal out of nothing in England; it's our American audience and supporters that are offended and all I am trying to say is that I know that this flag is very much alive in its negative meanings in many parts of America. If you think they don't have a right to be offended, you really don't know anything about that side of the ocean.

Our flag is like unknowingly dressing up as kkk on halloween and knocking the door of a black household for trick and treat. No bad intent, but when our parents reminded us of the meaning of that costume, we would stop wearing it. It seems like you would find it ok as long as black neighbourhoods are avoided.

We are polar opposites on this matter. Let's disagree peacefully please.

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 15 Jul 14 8.33am

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 9.36pm

Quote adrian b at 14 Jul 2014 7.04pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 5.25pm

Gotta love the hol. Who would've thought we'd discuss flag semantics...


We're not discussing semantics here. It's a straight forward question of whether we , as Palace supporters, are happy to see a flag that most regard as a racist flag in the Park. No semantics about that.


Don't get me wrong,I agree with you in the fact that it can be seen as offensive, so is. I was alluding to different posters having different opinions on the flag.

What about the flag with the skull and crossbones displayed at Selhurst, This could be deemed as promoting Pirates. You have more chance of bumping into a pirate than a slave these days. People are far to quick to worry themselves silly about other people being offended by something that in truth they probably don't give a rats arse about.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 15 Jul 14 10.22am

Quote bubble wrap at 15 Jul 2014 8.33am

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 9.36pm

Quote adrian b at 14 Jul 2014 7.04pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 5.25pm

Gotta love the hol. Who would've thought we'd discuss flag semantics...


We're not discussing semantics here. It's a straight forward question of whether we , as Palace supporters, are happy to see a flag that most regard as a racist flag in the Park. No semantics about that.


Don't get me wrong,I agree with you in the fact that it can be seen as offensive, so is. I was alluding to different posters having different opinions on the flag.

What about the flag with the skull and crossbones displayed at Selhurst, This could be deemed as promoting Pirates. You have more chance of bumping into a pirate than a slave these days. People are far to quick to worry themselves silly about other people being offended by something that in truth they probably don't give a rats arse about.


People who are concerned about how others feel = liberal. People who don't care what others think = right wing.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 15 Jul 14 10.30am

Quote nickgusset at 15 Jul 2014 10.22am

People who are concerned about how others feel = liberal. People who don't care what others think = right wing.


Wouldn't stopping people from waving a flag be illiberal and a restriction of freedom and expression?

The right do care.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 6 of 18 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Flag