You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 9 dead in USA Church Shooting.
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

9 dead in USA Church Shooting.


Page 6 of 14 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Stirlingsays Flag 21 Jun 15 11.25pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm

Some replies...

We aren't talking about 1949 and commonwealth immigration in this post. Also what parliament do is often not in the interests of the working class here.

I wasn't aware of that, perhaps because I haven't read the whole thread. Parliament's job, by the way, is not to serve the interests of the working classes. It's to serve the interests of the entire country, rich and poor alike. I think the implicit suggestion that immigration is particularly harmful to the working classes probably explains the rise of proto-working class neo-Nazi organisations like the National Front. Not something any of us should welcome.

So to speak of too many immigrants creates the 'National Front'. So I suppose this would mean that the far right didn't exist in the country before ....What was your year? 1949.
It's just a simplistic and silly comment of which your post was littered with.

You obviously don't really understand why these groups exist and wish to put them down to a simplistic narrative.

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm

Plus the numbers from the era are absolutely nothing compared to the numbers since 97....Which is obviously what we are talking about.

It wasn't obvious to me (and I'm not sure you can break a historical timeline into convenient parts capable of being analysed in isolation from the rest anyway. With regard to a rise in numbers since 1997 I don't know but I will take it on faith you are right.

Damn right you can.....Here's a suggestion....Maybe know what you're talking about....It might actually help.


Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm

Immigrants who come here in reasonable numbers, work hard and integrate are not a problem.

How generous of you. Dare I say spoken like a working class racist?

Oh dear.

You compare me to a racist? Well, if you are going to start name calling I'm going to compare you to a stupid scrumbag. We can continue along that vein if you wish or you can grow up. I would prefer not to use word insults.

For the record, I don't condone racism and I don't consider myself a racist. I consider an attempt to call me one a personal insult.

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm

This country, being an island, is partly built upon immigration and to be English itself is to be often a mixture of nations.

Often but not always? What you are doesn't change. The western world is now generally multi-cultural and multi-national. It doesn't matter whether your an island or a continent or anything in between.

Really? Where do you live, London? There are many parts of the country that aren't multi-cultural.

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm

Also, someone can become English or British over time and I'm ok with that.....If their allegiance is here then I welcome them happily.

Again, how generous of you. I'm sure it comes as a relief to the immigrant community that over time and with good behaviour, there's a constituency of people like you willing to give them the benefit of the doubt. The trouble is, we welcome immigrants with passports regardless of an allegiance test so like it or not, they've become English whether they meet that standard or not. To suggest otherwise implies you think some Brits are "purer" or more British than others. Let's not go there, eh? It's a rocky road.

'More pure' what a ridiculous way of describing allegiance. These are your words not mine and I disown your description: ridiculous and simplistic caricature.

I also find your description of this nation being ok with immigrants with British passports not having an allegiance as bulls***. As usual you don't know what you're talking about.

When you become British you have to swear an oath of allegiance...It goes like this:

'I... swear by Almighty God that, on becoming a British citizen, I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth the Second, Her Heirs and Successors according to law'.

The British government does care and again you don't know what you're talking about.


Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm

The left have given us these problems and now we should 'look at ourselves'.....Nonsense.

Seriously?...you really think huge and complex social issues can be dismissed with a wave of the hand in the direction of blaming the left. No bloody wonder things don't change.

I wasn't aware that I was summing up the whole issue. I was simply reacting to your statement that we need to look at ourselves. The reality is that the left's previous support of multi-culturalism has compounded integration and social issues.

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm

If someone is against the British state or is British but wishes they weren't they should be given free plane tickets to the country of their choice. I don't think we need them.

What about those who have a legitimate grievance but want to stay and change the British state for the better, rather than run off home. There's a lot about England I don't like and I've had many opportunities to live elsewhere. But I come home because I want to make my country better; not give up on it and slope off somewhere else. I admire those who stay in the face of prejudice. They're paying a high price for rewards that eventually people like you and I will benefit from when society does become a fairer, better, and less prejudiced place. And it will. It may take a long time, but we'll get there.

If they didn't have allegiance I would give them the free tickets and put them on the plane. Obviously there are exceptions to this (short visas, students, economic immigrants, dual citizenship, children raised abroad etc) but as a general idea for British passport holders I think its fair enough. As for being 'political radicals' wishing to change the state it wouldn't make any difference to me.

We have plenty of people who wish to change many things about Britain who still have allegiance to it...Most of us wish to change things....This isn't about wanting rid of people who wish for a better system....But I'd get rid of fifth columnists full stop.

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm

No special revisions of British society should be made for any group within it......This is Britain, you take the rough with the smooth or you can always bugger off.

No. Where you find rough you try to change things for the better. A healthy society is in a constant state of self-examination and revision. It's not static and f*** off if you don't like it. That's what hallmarks a democracy which, thank God, we are.


Whose better is that? Your better sounds like my worse. You aren't changing jack mate.

Judging by the election this country is pretty heavily against your ideology. There are far far more people here willing to work against your mindset than for it.

Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Jun 2015 11.32pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Jun 15 5.36am

So to speak of too many immigrants creates the 'National Front'.

To speak (or openly complain) of too many immigrants results in the creation of "extremist groups" including the National Front, yes. At least in part.

So I suppose this would mean that the far right didn't exist in the country before ....What was your year? 1949.

That's adding 2 and 2 to make 5. I didn't say or imply there was no far right before 1949. I merely commented on the rise of a certain type of group after that year. The far right, by the way, have many motives beyond racism, social and economic.

It's just a simplistic and silly comment of which your post was littered with.

You obviously don't really understand why these groups exist and wish to put them down to a simplistic narrative.

Possibly, And you don't?

Plus the numbers from the era are absolutely nothing compared to the numbers since 97....Which is obviously what we are talking about.

Damn right you can.....Here's a suggestion....Maybe know what you're talking about....It might actually help.

I won't respond to opinion followed by personal attack.

Well, if you are going to start name calling I'm going to compare you to a stupid scrumbag. We can continue along that vein if you wish or you can grow up. I would prefer not to use word insults.

But you just did call me a stupid scumbag, or words to that effect. See above. It doesn't particularly offend me, but pot, kettle.

Really? Where do you live, London? There are many parts of the country that aren't multi-cultural.

Rural Northants. In a village with three farms and zero commercial establishments. Not even a pub. The local towns are less multicultural than London (where I grew up) but multicultural nonetheless. I can assure you my kids school is populated with all creeds and colours, and so much the better.

'More pure' what a ridiculous way of describing allegiance. These are your words not mine and I disown your description: ridiculous and simplistic caricature.

Yes, they are my words and yes, they may be simplistic. But that was where reading what you wrote took me. I didn't dream them up in response to nothing. Which, perhaps, shows that if you play with fire, you risk getting burned.

The British government does care and again you don't know what you're talking about.

I would say swearing an oath which some, doubtless, view as simply the price of passport is evidence only of a very high level of caring. If you present an oath and leave it at that, you won't engender a lot of allegiance. Nonetheless, I concede your point to some extent.

The reality is that the left's previous support of multi-culturalism has compounded integration and social issues.

But in two posts you've gone from "the left has given us these problems" (quote) to "the left has compounded these problems." Those are two very different statements. Which is your view?

If they didn't have allegiance I would give them the free tickets and put them on the plane.

Is allegiance the by-product of swearing an oath, or it something that develops over time? Here, I think you are being simplistic. At the time one emigrates (I've sort of been in that situation myself), one does so because one is attracted to the country to which one is moving and wants to feel allegiance. Over time, reality can erode the initial intent. I think immigrants start from the point allegiance. Part of the duty of a successful nation is to build on that, rather than destroy it.

We have plenty of people who wish to change many things about Britain who still have allegiance to it...Most of us wish to change things....This isn't about wanting rid of people who wish for a better system....But I'd get rid of fifth columnists full stop.

Now who's being Utopian? But you are right; I think we would both support this statement, though we'd get there in opposing ways.

Whose better is that? Your better sounds like my worse. You aren't changing jack mate.

On the contrary, in this instance both our "betters" is a safe country with no fifth columnists and a population dedicated to the betterment of all. Again, we agree on the destination but disagree on the route there (I think.)

Judging by the election this country is pretty heavily against your ideology. There are far far more people here willing to work against your mindset than for it.

Absolutely. But we're discussing ideology, not whose view is more popular.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

TheJudge Flag 22 Jun 15 8.27am

The trouble with ideology is that it often tries to uphold the rights of one group at the expense of another.
This is a simple clash of cultures with one refusing to integrate with he other while clinging on to medieval ideas.
I am proud to say that I will not tolerate disgusting treatment of women and the promotion of ignorance. Ideology is all very well in an ideal world, but that does not and never will exist. Sometimes you have to choose sides. Do you want to uphold all the progress we have made in the Western culture or allow it to be eroded by religious insanity ?

 

reborn 22 Jun 15 8.36am

All credit to the relatives and members of this church for their incredible reaction.

This is the Christian faith in action.

Hate, no not for us.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 8.37am

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 10.34pm

Quote beagle at 21 Jun 2015 9.36pm

Depends what the 'special revisions' the OP is referring to, doesn't it?

If a 'special revision' was that, lets say, 'Sharia Law' was permitted within certain sections of the community then I'd agree with the OP. One law for one people. Not a mix and match. To mind that would be the antithesis of democracy.


Yes, I see where you're coming from though the example you give is more nuanced and interesting that it at first appears because democracy isn't straightforward. Suppose, as you suggest, Sharia Law was permitted in a segment of society that welcomed it and chose willingly to adhere to it while the remainder of society was unaffected (as would probably be the case in the unlikely event that Sharia Law was ever to permitted at all). That, surely, far from being the antithesis of democracy would represent democracy in a highly evolved state; two antithetical frameworks operating peacefully alongside each other.

Don't get me wrong I am not advocating the above or trying to be Utopian, just making the point that these arguments run deeper than they appear. Ditto the question of "one law for all people." I haven't thought that one through and I suspect you're right; at least with regard to maintaining certain standards that is a pre-requisite for any governable society but still, there remains room to debate the point. Does democracy require the subjugation of all to a single rule of law, or is choice permissible so long as nothing is administered by force on someone who doesn't want it?

I don't know. The comments above are just food for thought.

Right, so stoning to death of adulterous women in Bradford football ground, throwing gay people off the roof of Bradford Town Hall, hanging people from cranes in Bradford city square? I know legaleagle will disapprove, but I would probably consider moving house if I lived in Bradford.

 

suicideatselhurst Flag crawley 22 Jun 15 8.42am

Quote reborn at 22 Jun 2015 8.36am

All credit to the relatives and members of this church for their incredible reaction.

This is the Christian faith in action.

Hate, no not for us.


Its nice to see someone keeping on track with the orginal post about 9 senseless murders in a church, which as been hi-jacked into a debate about muslims ????

 


Theres someone in my head ... But its not me

X/Box game Tag bazcpfc1961, clan (HMS)

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Jun 15 8.48am

The trouble with ideology is that it often tries to uphold the rights of one group at the expense of another.

But that, surely, is true of both "good" ideologies and "bad" ideologies. I think you have to separate beliefs from their imposition. An ideology, remember, is only theoretical. It's how it's then imposed which is political. I would agree that all ideologies do, in reality, tend to become politicised but the question is still worth asking whether that has to be the case. Probably, the answer is "yes" but it remains a pity that we seem unable to accommodate multiple, contrasting beliefs.

One other interesting case study is provided by America where there are far more immigrant groups and, thus, contrasting belief systems than in the UK. Why is that some of these population groups are almost perfectly and generally successfully assimilated into US society (South East Asians for example) without sacrificing their regional dogmas while other sub-groups (black Americans) seem to be so poorly assimilated? This would seem to argue against the reality that different ideologies and social cohesion are mutually exclusive.

This is a simple clash of cultures with one refusing to integrate with he other while clinging on to medieval ideas.

While I know what you are saying and I may not even disagree on a personal level, that sort of use of pejoratives isn't going to help anyone.

I am proud to say that I will not tolerate disgusting treatment of women and the promotion of ignorance.

Nor will I. Though if we're talking about the promotion of ignorance, large swathes of the extremist British right are up there with Sharia Law enthusiasts when it comes to stupidity.

Ideology is all very well in an ideal world, but that does not and never will exist.

Political theory is created on paper for ideal worlds. It's application is where reality compromises theory. You start high to finish in the middle. So I think it's fine to be idealist in a discussion like this. Just my personal view.

Sometimes you have to choose sides. Do you want to uphold all the progress we have made in the Western culture or allow it to be eroded by religious insanity?

Of course...but were it only that simple. It's not whether or not I want to protect our culture from "religious insanity" (another unhelpful pejorative, even if true) but the best way to go about doing that. That is where we disagree; we share the same aim but are debating how to best achieve it.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

reborn 22 Jun 15 9.03am

Quote suicideatselhurst at 22 Jun 2015 8.42am

Quote reborn at 22 Jun 2015 8.36am

All credit to the relatives and members of this church for their incredible reaction.

This is the Christian faith in action.

Hate, no not for us.


Its nice to see someone keeping on track with the orginal post about 9 senseless murders in a church, which as been hi-jacked into a debate about muslims ????


LOL yes I was thinking that myself. How the hell did it go from a race hate monster killing some devout Christians (because they were black) , to debating Muslims?

Edited by reborn (22 Jun 2015 9.03am)

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 22 Jun 15 9.11am

Quote reborn at 22 Jun 2015 8.36am

All credit to the relatives and members of this church for their incredible reaction.

This is the Christian faith in action.

Hate, no not for us.


Gotta say - I was almightily impressed with them. Turning something so awfully negative into a positive. Great philosophy to have God or no God. Some think they a bit bonkers to have done it. I disagree. Also, it highlighted how wrong the killer was/is not only in his actions but also in his words. These were obviously good people. Not the demons he was trying to portray them us. A very sad but epic fail.

A lesson to all wannabe rabble-rousing hate mongers. Hitler made himself look a total ass and so will you.

Edited by Kermit8 (22 Jun 2015 9.17am)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


legaleagle Flag 22 Jun 15 9.13am

I think it was at the point below where a poster for some reason raised the "issue" of muslims in the UK:

Quote TheJudge at 21 Jun 2015 12.09pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.22am

Quote black eagle. at 20 Jun 2015 7.13pm

as you say ths country has it's fair share of nut jobs.

/quote]

I think this is an interesting point. Personally, I don't think the US has any more nut jobs than anywhere else. The difference is that their nut jobs have easy access to guns. Were that the case here, we'd have the same problem. That's why you have gun laws (or not, as the case may be.) Mental illness is pervasive in almost all industrialised societies. The right to bear arms isn't.


Sounds plausible, but have you been to the southern states or seen some of the comments on face book from the Bible belt ? For gun toting bigoted religious loons, the southern US rivals the middle east. And then they also have a gang culture which is not really the same here.
The biggest problem Britain faces is the ever increasing group of Muslims who refuse to integrate into British society. That needs to change. They need to stop listening to separatists and then we need to welcome them in to the fold.


 

legaleagle Flag 22 Jun 15 9.33am

Quote beagle at 21 Jun 2015 9.36pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm


No special revisions of British society should be made for any group within it......This is Britain, you take the rough with the smooth or you can always bugger off.

No. Where you find rough you try to change things for the better. A healthy society is in a constant state of self-examination and revision. It's not static and f*** off if you don't like it. That's what hallmarks a democracy which, thank God, we are.

Depends what the 'special revisions' the OP is referring to, doesn't it?

If a 'special revision' was that, lets say, 'Sharia Law' was permitted within certain sections of the community then I'd agree with the OP. One law for one people. Not a mix and match. To mind that would be the antithesis of democracy.


Apologies for veering away from the topic of the thread and back to other issues raised

There have in fact been separate courts here for different religious groups for hundreds of years,none of which prevent this country being seen as a liberal democracy.

Anglicans have various ecclesiastical courts.They may be limited nowadays in what they cover but nevertheless they are single religion-based courts.

The Jewish community have for a long time had "Beth Dins" which (provided both parties agree) determine matters such as conversion,property disputes and divorce and questions of religious doctrine.

The British, in significant parts of the British Empire, had a judicial system which included religious courts,including muslim-based ones.

Within the UK,there has been more than one legal system since the beginning (Scotland on the one hand/England & Wales on the other)with significant differences within them,including in determining matters of criminal law.

So,rather than being the antithesis of democracy,the UK democracy has survived perfectly OK in an environment where all do not live all the time under one precise set of laws/rules and there has long been a "mix and match".

Arguably,our adherence to the European Convention on Human Rights and the introduction of the Human Rights Act have been a step towards strengthening the existence of greater legal equivalence across the UK.

Apologies for veering off thread topic and hopefully now back to the terrible murders in the US.


 

suicideatselhurst Flag crawley 22 Jun 15 9.37am

Quote legaleagle at 22 Jun 2015 9.33am

Quote beagle at 21 Jun 2015 9.36pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm


No special revisions of British society should be made for any group within it......This is Britain, you take the rough with the smooth or you can always bugger off.

No. Where you find rough you try to change things for the better. A healthy society is in a constant state of self-examination and revision. It's not static and f*** off if you don't like it. That's what hallmarks a democracy which, thank God, we are.

Depends what the 'special revisions' the OP is referring to, doesn't it?

If a 'special revision' was that, lets say, 'Sharia Law' was permitted within certain sections of the community then I'd agree with the OP. One law for one people. Not a mix and match. To mind that would be the antithesis of democracy.


Apologies for veering away from the topic of the thread and back to other issues raised

There have in fact been separate courts here for different religious groups for hundreds of years,none of which prevent this country being seen as a liberal democracy.

Anglicans have various ecclesiastical courts.They may be limited nowadays in what they cover but nevertheless they are single religion-based courts.

The Jewish community have for a long time had "Beth Dins" which (provided both parties agree) determine matters such as conversion,property disputes and divorce and questions of religious doctrine.

The British, in significant parts of the British Empire, had a judicial system which included religious courts,including muslim-based ones.

Within the UK,there has been more than one legal system since the beginning (Scotland on the one hand/England & Wales on the other)with significant differences within them,including in determining matters of criminal law.

So,rather than being the antithesis of democracy,the UK democracy has survived perfectly OK in an environment where all do not live all the time under one precise set of laws/rules and there has long been a "mix and match".

Arguably,our adherence to the European Convention on Human Rights and the introduction of the Human Rights Act have been a step towards strengthening the existence of greater legal equivalence across the UK.

Apologies for veering off thread topic and hopefully now back to the terrible murders in the US.



Thanks only took 10 pages

 


Theres someone in my head ... But its not me

X/Box game Tag bazcpfc1961, clan (HMS)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 9.39am

Quote beagle at 21 Jun 2015 9.36pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm


No special revisions of British society should be made for any group within it......This is Britain, you take the rough with the smooth or you can always bugger off.

No. Where you find rough you try to change things for the better. A healthy society is in a constant state of self-examination and revision. It's not static and f*** off if you don't like it. That's what hallmarks a democracy which, thank God, we are.

Depends what the 'special revisions' the OP is referring to, doesn't it?

If a 'special revision' was that, lets say, 'Sharia Law' was permitted within certain sections of the community then I'd agree with the OP. One law for one people. Not a mix and match. To mind that would be the antithesis of democracy.


Of course the law in the UK is already different for Scots, Northern Irish and people from the Isle of Man. I'd be hesitant about incorporation of aspects of Sharia law more because not all Muslims want Sharia law, its massively open to interpretation and abuse and varies according to different Islamic faith.

That said, I also think that its many people also deliberately disrespect Islamic faith in a way that's deliberately antagonistic, for their own ends, and call it free speech / expression.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 9.47am

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 1.58pm

Quote TheJudge at 21 Jun 2015 12.09pm

Sounds plausible, but have you been to the southern states or seen some of the comments on face book from the Bible belt ? For gun toting bigoted religious loons, the southern US rivals the middle east. And then they also have a gang culture which is not really the same here.
The biggest problem Britain faces is the ever increasing group of Muslims who refuse to integrate into British society. That needs to change. They need to stop listening to separatists and then we need to welcome them in to the fold.

Yes, I lived in the States for almost a decade. Agree, in some ways (in their individual ferocity) US nut jobs do rival Middle Eastern loons but the comparison is still tenuous. For one thing, they're not nearly as coherently organised -- they're not acting under a single banner. For another, the actions (Roof being a case in point) are random rather than co-ordinated. Gang culture is pervasive and destructive but unrelated,; it's more to do with drugs and crime than political posturing.

With regard to Muslims who "refuse" to be integrated into British society, agree but only up to a point. Why would you want to integrate yourself into a society that's spent the better part of half a century acting prejudicially towards you? Although that in no way excuses violence, we've made a rod for our own back.s For years, we treated immigrants like second-class citizens and now we're surprised to find they've had enough and are fighting back. Is there a shortage of mirrors these days?

People will stop listening to separatists when they experience something that attracts them in the other direction. We won't solve the problem with anti-terrorist laws (although that may reduce the actual violence.) In the long-term, we'll change it by changing the very nature of society and creating something that everybody feels an equal part of.

Nor is radical Islam, it just gets presented that way more as a convenience, than anything else. Groups like Hezzbolah (arguably the most organized well equipped and trained radical Islamist group is diametrically opposed to groups like Al-Qaeda and IS, who themselves are rivals. Groups tend to be more divided than they appear as well. IS in Iraq and Syria tends to be a move convenient ally of other factions outside Syria and Iraq.

The Taliban have some allies in the NW province of Afghanistan, largely on the basis of the Drug Trade and convenience of a shared enemy (pakistan) but those groups co-operation tends to be driven by convenience.

Tribal lines tends to divide groups more in the 'Stan areas.

Certainly, Shia and Sunni groups don't associate (although they might share state allies and intelligence sources in say the Iranian government).

Association and communication does occur between the groups, usually as a result more of returning and surviving 'Mujahadeen' than anything else.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 9.55am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 9.39am

Quote beagle at 21 Jun 2015 9.36pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm


No special revisions of British society should be made for any group within it......This is Britain, you take the rough with the smooth or you can always bugger off.

No. Where you find rough you try to change things for the better. A healthy society is in a constant state of self-examination and revision. It's not static and f*** off if you don't like it. That's what hallmarks a democracy which, thank God, we are.

Depends what the 'special revisions' the OP is referring to, doesn't it?

If a 'special revision' was that, lets say, 'Sharia Law' was permitted within certain sections of the community then I'd agree with the OP. One law for one people. Not a mix and match. To mind that would be the antithesis of democracy.


Of course the law in the UK is already different for Scots, Northern Irish and people from the Isle of Man. I'd be hesitant about incorporation of aspects of Sharia law more because not all Muslims want Sharia law, its massively open to interpretation and abuse and varies according to different Islamic faith.

That said, I also think that its many people also deliberately disrespect Islamic faith in a way that's deliberately antagonistic, for their own ends, and call it free speech / expression.


They probably call expressing an opinion free speech, because that is what it is. I suppose you appreciate why cartoonist are killed and the likes of Rushdie have to go into hiding for exercising free speech. Why shouldn't people be free to 'disrespect' Islam - Jerry Springer, the Opera was free to disrespect Christianity.

 

reborn 22 Jun 15 9.55am

Quote Kermit8 at 22 Jun 2015 9.11am

Quote reborn at 22 Jun 2015 8.36am

All credit to the relatives and members of this church for their incredible reaction.

This is the Christian faith in action.

Hate, no not for us.


Gotta say - I was almightily impressed with them. Turning something so awfully negative into a positive. Great philosophy to have God or no God. Some think they a bit bonkers to have done it. I disagree. Also, it highlighted how wrong the killer was/is not only in his actions but also in his words. These were obviously good people. Not the demons he was trying to portray them us. A very sad but epic fail.

A lesson to all wannabe rabble-rousing hate mongers. Hitler made himself look a total ass and so will you.

Edited by Kermit8 (22 Jun 2015 9.17am)

Good post Kerm.

I know believing in Jesus is not a popular choice round these parts, but this is a potent example of where doing just that shows itself in a perfect light.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 9.58am

Quote reborn at 22 Jun 2015 9.55am

Quote Kermit8 at 22 Jun 2015 9.11am

Quote reborn at 22 Jun 2015 8.36am

All credit to the relatives and members of this church for their incredible reaction.

This is the Christian faith in action.

Hate, no not for us.


Gotta say - I was almightily impressed with them. Turning something so awfully negative into a positive. Great philosophy to have God or no God. Some think they a bit bonkers to have done it. I disagree. Also, it highlighted how wrong the killer was/is not only in his actions but also in his words. These were obviously good people. Not the demons he was trying to portray them us. A very sad but epic fail.

A lesson to all wannabe rabble-rousing hate mongers. Hitler made himself look a total ass and so will you.

Edited by Kermit8 (22 Jun 2015 9.17am)

Good post Kerm.

I know believing in Jesus is not a popular choice round these parts, but this is a potent example of where doing just that shows itself in a perfect light.

You think 'forgiving' these creatures makes it less likely that it will happen again?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 10.02am

Quote derben at 19 Jun 2015 11.12pm

Quote NickinOX at 19 Jun 2015 11.02pm

Here is the DoD's definition: "the calculated use of unlawful violence or threat of unlawful violence to inculcate fear; intended to coerce or to intimidate governments or societies in the pursuit of goals that are generally political, religious, or ideological.”

Note the use of the word unlawful, and also the intent of the violence.

This case looks like a text book definition of racist terrorism. He sought to spread fear and start a race war.

It is a very wide definition, a lot of riots would qualify. But in this case I guess he was motivated by racist/political ideas, so perhaps terrorism. Having said that, he is probably nuts as well.

In fairness, I'd say that most Islamic terrorists in the UK would fit into the probably 'disordered' if you viewed their actions objectively. The act of strapping on a bomb to kill people that have absolutely no capacity to fulfill your demands, and making long winded justifications, based on a minority interpretation of Islam, is arguably the act of a deeply irrational person.

This sits separately from the idea of those fighting in Iraq or Syria, where they plausibly can have hit the point of wanting an out, or an end, given that casualty rates among insurgent groups tend towards 75-90%, death or injury is almost unavoidable, long term.

But in the UK, its really a narcissistic act. The option to go and fight for Islam when it was Chechnya or the NW Alliance, or against Iran or in any of the Muslim insurgencies world wide, seems to have been ignored - So its because its the UK. When you look at a lot of these people, individually, rather than collectively, a lot display a number of factors similar to spree shooters.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 22 Jun 15 10.08am

Quote reborn at 22 Jun 2015 9.55am

Quote Kermit8 at 22 Jun 2015 9.11am

Quote reborn at 22 Jun 2015 8.36am

All credit to the relatives and members of this church for their incredible reaction.

This is the Christian faith in action.

Hate, no not for us.


Gotta say - I was almightily impressed with them. Turning something so awfully negative into a positive. Great philosophy to have God or no God. Some think they a bit bonkers to have done it. I disagree. Also, it highlighted how wrong the killer was/is not only in his actions but also in his words. These were obviously good people. Not the demons he was trying to portray them us. A very sad but epic fail.

A lesson to all wannabe rabble-rousing hate mongers. Hitler made himself look a total ass and so will you.

Edited by Kermit8 (22 Jun 2015 9.17am)

Good post Kerm.

I know believing in Jesus is not a popular choice round these parts, but this is a potent example of where doing just that shows itself in a perfect light.

You just can't see that "believing in Jesus" is a large part of the problem can you.
You don't have to believe in a fairytale to be a good person Reborn but there are an awful lot of lunatics in the world right now blaming their violent actions on deities.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 10.09am

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 9.55am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 9.39am

Quote beagle at 21 Jun 2015 9.36pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jun 2015 7.44pm


No special revisions of British society should be made for any group within it......This is Britain, you take the rough with the smooth or you can always bugger off.

No. Where you find rough you try to change things for the better. A healthy society is in a constant state of self-examination and revision. It's not static and f*** off if you don't like it. That's what hallmarks a democracy which, thank God, we are.

Depends what the 'special revisions' the OP is referring to, doesn't it?

If a 'special revision' was that, lets say, 'Sharia Law' was permitted within certain sections of the community then I'd agree with the OP. One law for one people. Not a mix and match. To mind that would be the antithesis of democracy.


Of course the law in the UK is already different for Scots, Northern Irish and people from the Isle of Man. I'd be hesitant about incorporation of aspects of Sharia law more because not all Muslims want Sharia law, its massively open to interpretation and abuse and varies according to different Islamic faith.

That said, I also think that its many people also deliberately disrespect Islamic faith in a way that's deliberately antagonistic, for their own ends, and call it free speech / expression.


They probably call expressing an opinion free speech, because that is what it is. I suppose you appreciate why cartoonist are killed and the likes of Rushdie have to go into hiding for exercising free speech. Why shouldn't people be free to 'disrespect' Islam - Jerry Springer, the Opera was free to disrespect Christianity.

Free speech isn't free of consequences. Rushdie, I feel somewhat sorry for, but I do feel less sympathy when its people who have persistently poked the snake with a stick, and then complained that its bitten them.

If you keep deliberately antagonizing people for your own ends, you shouldn't be too surprised if the crazy's among those people retaliate. Charlie Hebdo was notably targeted because its cartoons were specifically stating that the actions of Islamists were a disgrace and an insult to Islam, and the Prophet.

But if you keep insulting people, without reason, it shouldn't come as a great surprise when people get very upset with it.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 6 of 14 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 9 dead in USA Church Shooting.