This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You may abhor 'these vermin' but you speak up for what they want.....the restriction of free speech. I believe you are well intentioned but just wrong.....appeasement just doesn't work.....giving a little is never enough for ideological (religiously extreme) people. I agree that freedom of speech should be protected, but I just see this type of speech as freedom to insult. If you have a debate or disagreement with someone then that's acceptable. If you insult someone then what they'll do is unpredictable. Laugh, retort, flounce, swerve you permanently or give you a thump.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Not going to go back or suck it up they? And there is a major problem. The radicalised I mean. I agree with we respect country's culture when we travel, apart from football, Crete, Falaraki, Majorca etc, but there's a lot of fear of punishment as well as respect as travelling Brits. In the UK it's a prison full of radical elements of Islam. Hardly putting them off. Well capitulation is not an option so I would say that all other options must remain on the table. There is certainly no room for negotiating. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (16 Jul 2016 10.25am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Well capitulation is not an option so I would say that all other options must remain on the table. There is certainly no room for negotiating. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (16 Jul 2016 10.25am) No room for negotiation. That is for certain. Capitulation shouldn't be an option either.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I agree that freedom of speech should be protected, but I just see this type of speech as freedom to insult. If you have a debate or disagreement with someone then that's acceptable. If you insult someone then what they'll do is unpredictable. Laugh, retort, flounce, swerve you permanently or give you a thump. Apart of freedom of speech is the freedom to insult......think about it....Freedom of speech couldn't work any other way. The fact that someone feels insulted or feels their religion is insulted means nothing as regards western values. What is correctly restricted is incitement to violence or hatred. In your world, we wouldn't have 'the life of Brian'.....Indeed we wouldn't have modern science or technology as we wouldn't have had the enlightenment. There was a hell of a lot of insulted religious people back when that was happening.....they responded violently too.......Should we have stopped? As I say....well intentioned, just wrong.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Apart of freedom of speech is the freedom to insult......think about it....Freedom of speech couldn't work any other way. The fact that someone feels insulted or feels their religion is insulted means nothing as regards western values. What is correctly restricted is incitement to violence or hatred. In your world, we wouldn't have 'the life of Brian'.....Indeed we wouldn't have modern science or technology as we wouldn't have had the enlightenment. There was a hell of a lot of insulted religious people back when that was happening.....they responded violently too.......Should we have stopped? As I say....well intentioned, just wrong. I wouldn't miss the Life of Brian, not my thing, but I get the logic and your point. And there are other religious satire that's funny. Bans on publishing theories of evolution would be a huge loss to us all, apart from those in denial. I just couldn't accept it if one of mine was innocently murdered following a warning over an insult that was ignored.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I wouldn't miss the Life of Brian, not my thing, but I get the logic and your point. And there are other religious satire that's funny. Bans on publishing theories of evolution would be a huge loss to us all, apart from those in denial. I just couldn't accept it if one of mine was innocently murdered following a warning over an insult that was ignored. It's admirable that you can see the logic is another's argument. Many just can't be bothered. I agree in many circumstances to heed a warning is sensible.....However, when it comes to free speech...that's a non negotiable. It's has helped to get us here.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It's admirable that you can see the logic is another's argument. Many just can't be bothered. It's has helped to get us here. Doesn't stop you feeling dejected with the 2 sides and situation. As I said, medieval beliefs and modern societies aren't compatible, but they're here, and here they wills stay in my prediction, not necessarily my desire. Lucky I have no reason to go to France or Belgium. Others do, but you're probably safer now in Paris or Nice.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I wouldn't miss the Life of Brian, not my thing, but I get the logic and your point. And there are other religious satire that's funny. Bans on publishing theories of evolution would be a huge loss to us all, apart from those in denial. I just couldn't accept it if one of mine was innocently murdered following a warning over an insult that was ignored. I don't think we can elevate certain belief systems beyond criticism just because we are scared of the consequences. We should all play by the same rules and if that was understood it would never reach a point where some think it acceptable to lose their minds over such things. I'm not encouraging the goading of this or that belief system, so I get your point, but people should learn to appreciate that their response should be in the form of a discussion, not violence.
|
|
|
I have to wonder if shock and grief may soon turn to anger in this case. I'm not French but am really angry about this myself.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
So do you think that continuing with controversial drawings for a quick laugh was worth it when they were warned of what would happen, and did? I'm saying tolerate that images of Muhammed are forbidden. Is it really such an uncomfortable change in their society? It is worth it. We have freedom of speech and in no way should we change our rights and freedoms to accommodate others because they are violent. If they don't like our laws and customs there are plenty of Islamic countries where they would feel more comfortable.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DivingIsNotGood
I think it's an absolute DISGRACE how all media outlets are saying this is an isil terror attack. Nothing to do with those isis scum. I don't think we know all of this murderer's affiliations yet. I suspect the French police are probably making sure no-one else is involved at present.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Doesn't stop you feeling dejected with the 2 sides and situation. As I said, medieval beliefs and modern societies aren't compatible, but they're here, and here they wills stay in my prediction, not necessarily my desire. Lucky I have no reason to go to France or Belgium. Others do, but you're probably safer now in Paris or Nice. You're saying that the pragmatic stance to take would be heeding their 'warnings' about our interpretation of Islam. I understand that, and its tempting. However, there is so much wrong with that. Firstly, the islamic extremists will have 'won'. Secondly, you're altering ('de-facto'
When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop... |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by on me shed son
It is worth it. We have freedom of speech and in no way should we change our rights and freedoms to accommodate others because they are violent. If they don't like our laws and customs there are plenty of Islamic countries where they would feel more comfortable. Freedom of speech doesn't mean the right to offend and incite people, because you can. Free Speech without consequences for what is being said, is absurdly stupid, and it only protects individuals rights from the authority of state and law. It doesn't protect you, for example, from lying in court. It has very real limitations. Incitement is one of those. The irony of the Hebdo cartoons is that they actually had artistic merit, and used images to criticise Islamist extremists, whilst showing Islam in a positive light. There are those who routinely abuse the concept of 'freedom of speech' to disrupt and pursue other less noble political agendas. The regular US Prophet Cartoon Competitions, aren't about free speech, they're about hate and inciting hate. These aren't occasional events either...
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by We are goin up!
You do not respond to threats by changing your culture. That is the terrorists winning. It is OUR culture, if they don't like it fine. But don't try and "Islamify" ours. Our women wouldn't dream of going to Saudi Arabia and waltzing around in a bikini by day and getting pished in short skirts by night. We have been incredibly accepting as a society, but enough is enough. The people are sick of it, and they are going to speak at the ballot box, namely Brexit and the Front Nationale in France. Voters aren't stupid, they know when they've been screwed over and won't put up with it. Well except of course there is no relationship between the EU membership, and terrorism from Islamic sources, and its almost as if a number of them have been duped into believing that a Brexit will have any impact at all on UK security or culture. Arguably, I'd say a lot of people may actually have screwed themselves over, at least individually, by voting to leave the EU, especially if they're talking about terrorism. Also, Islam to an extent is a part of our culture, about 4% of the country is made up of British Muslims, it would be absurd to imagine that they could have no influence on British Society, anymore than any other group. The idea of British Democracy is the ideal of representation and inclusion, of all legitimate participants in the democratic process of society, culture etc.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Maybe not the best example, given the number of local authorities that banned it being shown, or gave it a ridiculous 18 certificate in an attempt to make it a failure. But I agree the separation of church and state is as essential in application to all religions. The state must remain secular and concerned with facts, not with the pursuit of faith, as a means of governance. I think that's as true for Islam as for Christianity. Indeed its interesting that the more secular Middle Eastern countries, were also the most progressive.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Freedom of speech doesn't mean the right to offend and incite people, because you can. Free Speech without consequences for what is being said, is absurdly stupid, and it only protects individuals rights from the authority of state and law. It doesn't protect you, for example, from lying in court. It has very real limitations. Incitement is one of those. The irony of the Hebdo cartoons is that they actually had artistic merit, and used images to criticise Islamist extremists, whilst showing Islam in a positive light. There are those who routinely abuse the concept of 'freedom of speech' to disrupt and pursue other less noble political agendas. The regular US Prophet Cartoon Competitions, aren't about free speech, they're about hate and inciting hate. These aren't occasional events either... It's all very well to discuss the limits of free speech and the abuse of said but this kind of intellectual discussion just hides the reality. This is really a choice between the better of two evils. I know which side I'm on. There is no reasonable comparison between the two.
|
|
|
I think this about sums it up....
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.