You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ledley & McArthur
November 16 2026 11.44am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ledley & McArthur


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
MrCParrot Flag Taunton 18 Sep 16 11.14pm

They are looking untouchable at the moment
Both can go forward both can defend, absolutely rock solid
Unbreakable at the moment and first names on the team sheet
Cabeye better start challenging Punch or he ain't getting a game, and I never thought I'd be writing that!!!

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 18 Sep 16 11.18pm

Originally posted by MrCParrot

They are looking untouchable at the moment
Both can go forward both can defend, absolutely rock solid
Unbreakable at the moment and first names on the team sheet
Cabeye better start challenging Punch or he ain't getting a game, and I never thought I'd be writing that!!!

Parrot

Disagree. Cabaye is an upgrade on Ledley and will likely replace him when fit.

 


Most certainly not European.

palacer Flag Crystal Palace 18 Sep 16 11.23pm

Before now I would have agreed Cabaye is better. But today Ledley was great. The key is Mcarthur. Good to have him back .

 


People standing in the rain just to see their dream again. The Damned

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 18 Sep 16 11.26pm

Originally posted by moylerg

Disagree. Cabaye is an upgrade on Ledley and will likely replace him when fit.


Why and how ?

 

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 18 Sep 16 11.31pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC


Why and how ?

Seriously? Why? Cabaye has more craft, skill, vision and will play more as a play maker than Ledley. Ledley goes about his work well, but, is not a creative player. Unless I missed it, what did Ledley create today? He was steady but unspectacular, Cabaye will take us up another gear. How? When Pardew picks him

 


Most certainly not European.

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 19 Sep 16 2.27am

its McArthur thats the key here
Ledley is average
Flamini is better than both he and Cabaye

Edited by Croydonlad (19 Sep 2016 2.27am)

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 19 Sep 16 3.41am

Ledley average? Well, he played in Euro 2016 semifinal and was a very important member of the Welsh success. That is more than good enough for me - when Cabaye fit I would like the trio of MacA/Cabaye/Ledley covering the midfield.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 19 Sep 16 6.07am

MacLedley was always a strong m/f partnership. Personally I'd like to try Cabaye in a CAM role and leave those two as they are. I'd stick Puncheon on the bench when Cabaye is fit, but it's a good problem to have.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 19 Sep 16 6.11am

im pretty sure ledleys just keeping cabayes spot warm...hes doing a decent job tho and its nice to have the depth

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Elpis Flag In a pub 19 Sep 16 6.30am

Pardew will rotate his players to keep them fresh and on their toes .Cabaye brings his qualities to the side as does Ledley ,they are differet qualities but qualities all the same .

Why does puncheon come into this debate though. His offensive play makes him more irreplaceable than anyone at the moment bar none .

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 19 Sep 16 7.17am

Originally posted by moylerg
Disagree. Cabaye is an upgrade on Ledley and will likely replace him when fit.

Only on paper, Cabaye has to prove it on the pitch.
At the moment Ledley has upgraded himself through those euro performances and is the man.
Amazing that we have with Flamini, 4 superb defensive midfielders.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

citizensmudge Flag midlands 19 Sep 16 7.47am

Originally posted by MrCParrot

Only on paper, Cabaye has to prove it on the pitch.
At the moment Ledley has upgraded himself through those euro performances and is the man.
Amazing that we have with Flamini, 4 superb defensive midfielders.

Parrot

You remember the Spurs game Parrot? Cabaye replaced Ledley at half time and it changed the game massively because of Cabayes ability to get the team moving forward. Ledley and Cabaye are pretty well matched defensively but Cabaye offers a dimension offensively that Ledley just doesn't have in his locker. They will all be rotated Flamini included once hes matchfit but the big games will be JMac and Cabaye if everyones 100%.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 19 Sep 16 8.42am

Originally posted by citizensmudge

You remember the Spurs game Parrot? Cabaye replaced Ledley at half time and it changed the game massively because of Cabayes ability to get the team moving forward. Ledley and Cabaye are pretty well matched defensively but Cabaye offers a dimension offensively that Ledley just doesn't have in his locker. They will all be rotated Flamini included once hes matchfit but the big games will be JMac and Cabaye if everyones 100%.

I think Ledley is a better fit when Jimmy Mc is playing. Cabaye is clearly a better "footballer" but that is not the same as being the most suitable.

Ledley keeps the ball moving and moves around the pitch fulling in spaces when others go forward. He is a very good if often unspectacular player. Cabaye likes to slow it down and put his foot on the ball.

At Spurs, McArthur wasn't playing.

As a partnership, I would play Ledley & McArthur over Cabaye & McArthur.


 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 19 Sep 16 8.52am

Originally posted by Croydonlad

its McArthur thats the key here
Ledley is average
Flamini is better than both he and Cabaye

Edited by Croydonlad (19 Sep 2016 2.27am)

No he is not.

 


@sxp55555

Aray Flag South London 19 Sep 16 9.25am

When people say Cabaye puts his foot on the ball and slows it down id say that was because there was a lack passing options available - due to no movement off the ball.

We've now seen the impact of having a stronger team all round but that shouldn't cloud our judgement, our best central midfield pairing is still Cabaye & Mac - as it was last year when we weren't afflicted with injuries and bad form from key attacking players.

Ledley's Euros performance was good but far from spectacular. Once Ramsey got suspended the Wales midfield hardly fired. When Cabaye actually got a game he ran the French midfield - something Ledley will never be able to do.

 

wonder Flag Madrid 19 Sep 16 9.38am

jimmy mac n ledders will do well with townsend in the squad. they're not so great if all we want to do is run the ball into the corner flag!

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 19 Sep 16 9.44am

Originally posted by Aray

Ledley's Euros performance was good but far from spectacular. Once Ramsey got suspended the Wales midfield hardly fired. When Cabaye actually got a game he ran the French midfield - something Ledley will never be able to do.

Well quite, he is Welsh after all.

I am not anti-Cabaye, I happen to think he has been underrated by many Palace fans, I just happen ti think that as a partnership Mcledley works better.

Interesting that you mentioned Cabaye running the French midfield, he played one full game and two minutes of another.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Username Flag Horsham 19 Sep 16 9.46am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Well quite, he is Welsh after all.

I am not anti-Cabaye, I happen to think he has been underrated by many Palace fans, I just happen ti think that as a partnership Mcledley works better.

Interesting that you mentioned Cabaye running the French midfield, he played one full game and two minutes of another.

A fully fit Cabaye and a fully fit McArthur is our best pairing. People forget we haven't seen that since December.

There were periods yesterday where we got sloppy in midfield and could have done with Cabaye's control in there.

Biggest problem for me remains who plays with them. Punch was decent yesterday but he still slowed things down too much and we just don't seem to have anyone in there who can support Benteke.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

davehuggins Flag 19 Sep 16 9.50am

Mcarthur and Ledley together give us a solid unspectacular pairing in front of the back four. It is clear to me Mcarthur is a key player in our set up. Ledley does the simple things well and keeps player moving. When Cabaye is fit he is an upgrade on Ledley, but we are lucky to have Mcarthur & Ledley many other clubs would love them!!

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 19 Sep 16 10.03am

I thought our midfield was so fluid and the best I've seen it work for a long time. There seemed to be an understanding where each could push forward or drop back to cover which saw the extremes of Ledley being far forward whilst Punch dropped deep and both looked comfortable. Also Benteke dropping deep gave Stoke so much more movement to contend with and we pulled them quite out of shape at times.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ledley & McArthur