You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Worst Penalty Decision Of The Season !!!
November 16 2026 10.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Worst Penalty Decision Of The Season !!!


Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Inapickle Flag South West 11 Dec 16 1.55pm

Originally posted by peterg

Willo's problem is that he won't ever admit that the ref made an out-and-out mistake. I am a qualified cricket umpire and I know I have made decisions that were just wrong and could not even be justified - and which gave me sleepless nights! Cricket umpires have bad games, so do refs, and yesterday's ref had a shocker - three out of four pen calls wrong.

Willo defends him on the first Benteke decision on the grounds he might have thought the defender got a foot to the ball first. Well, the defender clearly didn't, and the ref got that totally wrong.

On the Snodgrass call, he clearly didn't see what had happened, otherwise he wouldn't have called a pen. Since he didn't see what happened, it means he guessed, which is utterly wrong. If you didn't see it you can't call it.

In his zealous defence of all refs everywhere, Willo never deals with the psychology of officiating, or analyses why mistakes are made. He poses as a refereeing expert but never deals with these vital factors. I went on umpiring courses where umpires of the stature of Billy Bowden admitted he made mistakes - but went on to say that the vital thing is understand why you made the mistake and learn from that.

Willo is not interested in that kind of analysis or what can be learned from yesterday's abysmal refereeing performance. All he does is defend refs right or wrong.

..there lies the problem doesn't it, nothing more nothing less and it has nothing to do with Willo whether the ref gets it right or wrong, Willo is just saying that the refs always believe they are getting every decision right every time, they are up for scrutiny after every performance from their own professions so none of them want to go and make bad mistakes that will reduce their popularity, nobody alive wants that.

 

Inapickle Flag South West 11 Dec 16 2.00pm

Originally posted by Willo

One cannot say for certain this is the case as one doesn't have the exact view the referee has of the incident.

..I think they should wear cameras on their head, perhaps then they will get help.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 16 2.01pm

Originally posted by Inapickle

..Willo is just coming from the same angle as the refs are and his hands are just as tied for our amusement ..and it should be amusement, no need for anyone to get nasty.

No I'm not toeing any "Party line".

All I do is to try and see it from a referee's standpoint and try to understand why on occasions they make decisions not universally approved.

People have accused me of never admitting that referees make mistakes but this is simply not the case as you will see in this debate.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 11 Dec 16 2.11pm

Agree the game is too fast now for consistent refereeing. Need video ref for all penalty calls. Wont slow the game down, it takes a minute or so for the penalty to be set up, plenty of time to review the video. Perhaps one team review when pen not given like in test cricket.

 

Inapickle Flag South West 11 Dec 16 2.32pm

Originally posted by Willo

No I'm not toeing any "Party line".

All I do is to try and see it from a referee's standpoint and try to understand why on occasions they make decisions not universally approved.

People have accused me of never admitting that referees make mistakes but this is simply not the case as you will see in this debate.

..I do understand where you are coming from, my term for hands tied wasn't for you ..but for the refs.

Edited by Inapickle (11 Dec 2016 2.33pm)

 

Inapickle Flag South West 11 Dec 16 2.53pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Agree the game is too fast now for consistent refereeing. Need video ref for all penalty calls. Wont slow the game down, it takes a minute or so for the penalty to be set up, plenty of time to review the video. Perhaps one team review when pen not given like in test cricket.

..it will more or less be instant, well within 15 seconds, many believe it will lead to nothing to talk about after a game but I'd rather talk about how the right decisions made a entertaining game instead of a nasty torrid affair, the moan.city and chelsea game would have been solved instantly after the first incident and the game wouldn't have become a farce in regards to players behaviour and play acting.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 11 Dec 16 3.02pm

Originally posted by Willo

To be honest, I'm not really interested debating with you when you refer to me as "Trollo".

Still avoiding the question I see!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 16 3.04pm

Originally posted by the silurian

Still avoiding the question I see!

I have no idea as to what question you are referring to.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 11 Dec 16 3.11pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have no idea as to what question you are referring to.

Yes you do.....the question was" do you think the referee erred in awarding a penalty (Snodgrass dive)???

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 16 3.16pm

Originally posted by the silurian

Yes you do.....the question was" do you think the referee erred in awarding a penalty (Snodgrass dive)???

If you examine this thread you will see that I have answered this question.

To save you the trouble, I can only re-iterate that it is universally accepted that Hull were fortunate to be awarded the penalty.Hope this answers your question.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 11 Dec 16 3.46pm

Originally posted by Willo

If you examine this thread you will see that I have answered this question.

To save you the trouble, I can only re-iterate that it is universally accepted that Hull were fortunate to be awarded the penalty.Hope this answers your question.

Suppose it's a near as I'm gonna get, Willo almost admits ( without actually saying so) that the ref f***ed up yesterday!

Edited by the silurian (11 Dec 2016 4.08pm)

 

peterg Flag Anerley 11 Dec 16 8.11pm

Originally posted by Willo

No I'm not toeing any "Party line".

All I do is to try and see it from a referee's standpoint and try to understand why on occasions they make decisions not universally approved.

People have accused me of never admitting that referees make mistakes but this is simply not the case as you will see in this debate.

why on occasions they make decisions not universally approved.

We are not talking about decisions that are not universally approved, which is setting the bar very low. We are talking about decisions that are 100% wrong and which everyone can see are wrong. Like yesterday.

 


The right place at the right time

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 16 8.16pm

Originally posted by peterg

why on occasions they make decisions not universally approved.

We are not talking about decisions that are not universally approved, which is setting the bar very low. We are talking about decisions that are 100% wrong and which everyone can see are wrong. Like yesterday.

By "Universally approved" I meant that decisions that are generally accepted to have been made in error.Once can therefore deduce that those considered 100% incorrect can enter this category.

 

chateauferret Flag 11 Dec 16 8.18pm

Originally posted by peterg

why on occasions they make decisions not universally approved.

We are not talking about decisions that are not universally approved, which is setting the bar very low. We are talking about decisions that are 100% wrong and which everyone can see are wrong. Like yesterday.

Decisions universally conemned, I think he means - even Snodgrass admitted the decision was wrong and so did his manager, in a roundabout mealy-mouthed and quite embarrassed-sounding kind of way.

This standard of refereeing is not just unfortunate, not just bad luck, not just swings and roundabouts. It's totally f****** unacceptable.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 11 Dec 16 8.18pm

Originally posted by Willo

By "Universally approved" I meant that decisions that are generally accepted to have been made in error.Once can therefore deduce that those considered 100% incorrect can enter this category.

And the two Benteke penalty calls?

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 16 8.24pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch


And the two Benteke penalty calls?

If you would be so kind as to review my posts on this thread you will see that I have passed comment on the incident when Benteke went down and felt he should have had a penalty.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 11 Dec 16 8.41pm

Originally posted by Willo

If you would be so kind as to review my posts on this thread you will see that I have passed comment on the incident when Benteke went down and felt he should have had a penalty.

And when Dawson? Was clinging on for dear life?

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 16 8.46pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

And when Dawson? Was clinging on for dear life?

Not aware of this so cannot comment.

 

Inapickle Flag South West 11 Dec 16 8.51pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

And when Dawson? Was clinging on for dear life?

..bit like that Watford game wasn't it at home when they decided to make us an example of handling/pushing in the box, was it Jedinak? these decisions are very hit and miss and the only way to sort them is by having another ref sat in a room away from influence with an earpiece.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 11 Dec 16 9.03pm

Originally posted by Willo

Not aware of this so cannot comment.

Why, were you out making a cup of tea at the time it happened? If so, I suppose you're right to say you can't comment.

 

Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Worst Penalty Decision Of The Season !!!