You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why are we in this mess?
November 16 2026 8.34am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why are we in this mess?


Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Midlands Eagle Flag 03 Oct 17 7.52am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

ME how much cash have the Americans actually put in ?

We won't know until the latest accounts are out but in addition there are the sums that they paid to the existing shareholders to buy out their shares

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 03 Oct 17 8.04am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I think it's more a case of when you're new in a job, and a job with limited resources you need to remember a few things. great starting point

You cannot just decide you don't want these players gone and they're replaced instantly. pivotal to our predicament. Who wants to buy shjt players from Palace ? Players out of their depth would much rather run down their lucrative contracts before going to a League 1 club. Do any good players want to come to Palace, with the very real threat of being in the Championship next season ?

You need to call on them during the time you might need them to perform for you at times and indeed attract interest. This was evident with Kelly and Ward. It's because of Frank's arrogance, idiocy and then naivety towards the mammoth task in the premier league that this happened. His personality was brought into question ages ago if anyone bothers to remember. Stubbornness was definitely raised, meaning his way, whatever. Well that matches with how players he would need were treated one day and then selected for league games days later. Then dumped, then more players used. Chungy anyone?

Do you think his management of Luca was successful? All pre season in a back 3 we were never going to be able to afford? Similar with Ward?

Frank approached this job in the way he'd approach Ajax again or any club in any small league or probably Man Utd because in his mind he was already Van Gaal.

Huddersfield was a disgrace and Swansea was again playing with our club for his own promotion.
Huddersfield was shocking on many , many levels. A shambles on the pitch, which left Palace supporters and the HOL fanatics shocked into silence. Having Huddersfield sing "Where's your fantastic support ?", met with a resounding silence from Palace fans

It was never a good feeling with him and I'm not surprised it wasn't just results that got him fired. Shame it wasn't 70 days sooner when the alarm bells got louder than they already were.
I'm glad it's not my money being gambled, like it has in recent seasons. Hoping lessons are learned. This season could end in disaster, but we still have time to save this

Edited by Rudi Hedman (02 Oct 2017 4.41pm)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

djmobi Flag Oxford 03 Oct 17 8.05am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

So with all the multitudes of cock ups we have had to bare over the last 5 seasons,we have created history and stayed in the top flight.
So if the fault is at the Top so must the credit be.
Well done Parish for keeping us there,in the Top 20.

Perfect Example

 

djmobi Flag Oxford 03 Oct 17 8.12am

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Agreed he's made mistakes, but haven't you made any in your business and will you sack yourself like many are saying Parish should do?

I don't remember asking him to sack himself..... I'm simply pointing out that as the boss... He is to blame. I won't sack myself when I make mistakes because it's my business and I of course would not expect SP to do that either.

Just because other people want him to sack himself and I have a negative opinion about him does not mean I agree with them.

He is at fault.... People that don't believe that are simply wrong. It's his football team so he can carry on doing whatever he wants..... That's the way it works and there is nothing any of us can do about it.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 03 Oct 17 8.26am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

So with all the multitudes of cock ups we have had to bare over the last 5 seasons,we have created history and stayed in the top flight.
So if the fault is at the Top so must the credit be.
Well done Parish for keeping us there,in the Top 20.

Hi Al, absolutely right. Steve Parish has overseen 5 consecutive years in the Prem and we aren't saddled with the massive debts that other clubs have. I think he should get the credit for that.

Underneath those headlines though, I think his decision making has been consistently flawed over the last two years.

I won't bother repeating what both myself and others have been saying, but the club is in a mess at the moment, the majority of it seemingly avoidable. And that's what hurts the most.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 03 Oct 17 8.47am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Hi Al, absolutely right. Steve Parish has overseen 5 consecutive years in the Prem and we aren't saddled with the massive debts that other clubs have. I think he should get the credit for that.

Underneath those headlines though, I think his decision making has been consistently flawed over the last two years.

I won't bother repeating what both myself and others have been saying, but the club is in a mess at the moment, the majority of it seemingly avoidable. And that's what hurts the most.

Hi Neillo,
Hope your well

Agreed,I was just looking back at when we had two strikers up front.
Swansea away last season.November.
5-4 Connor got injured.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

The Dolphin Flag 03 Oct 17 9.08am

Apparently Dyche was interviewed and wanted the job and was gobsmacked he didn't get it.
Wish he had!!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Oct 17 9.37am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Excellent point.

Parish's experience is not something I'd get rid of......Who is going to buy his shares? How do we know that what would replace him is going to be better?

Edited by Stirlingsays (03 Oct 2017 6.16am)

I wouldn't want to get rid of his experience but I would his tendency to do the unexpected, the stupid and illogical and the repeats of gross negligence in trying to be more clever than than the competition out there.

Parish is responsible for this and it was unnecessary. His stewardship and the luck that certain managers were out of work or in Pardew and Holloway, willing to leave their posts, got us so far. Then crept in the misguided cr@p and repeated mistakes and taking liberties in the league. Something frank was sacked for, which is ironic. Frank writes off the first 3 games and is sacked. Parish does it every season because he thinks he can do what others can't pull off, and won't have a squad ready to prepare for the real start of the season and not Parish's preferred start. Now we're still not ready. P1ss p1ss poor. But he's ''not going to apologise for try trying to improve this football club'' by having 1 striker in the richest league in the world and the money available. So that's alright then. It wasn't an error before because it didn't result in relegation. As I say. Gross negligence.

I know there were more reasons for Frank's sacking but it still makes you think.


Edited by Rudi Hedman (03 Oct 2017 9.56am)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Oct 17 9.42am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

So with all the multitudes of cock ups we have had to bare over the last 5 seasons,we have created history and stayed in the top flight.
So if the fault is at the Top so must the credit be.
Well done Parish for keeping us there,in the Top 20.

We've been lucky certain managers were out of work or willing to come. When the best are here they don't leave anything undone that'll leave us vulnerable. If parish had his way he'd buy every player required at 10.59pm on deadline day. And the managers who've succeeded were when there wasn't any choice. Even Holloway and Pardew were practically begging to get away and in here.

As soon as Parish had a choice he made the wrong left field one.

He's good at keeping a tight ship or overseeing everything but not football. Turning into a liability.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Oct 17 9.47am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Apparently Dyche was interviewed and wanted the job and was gobsmacked he didn't get it.
Wish he had!!

Better to ignore managers with premier league experience and especially one who will more than likely respect all the points on offer. Now looks even more stupid than it did then. Wtf was my reaction when it was eventually Frank and not one of the others.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Oct 17 10.34am

Perhaps there is no simple explanation as to our current plight and is probably an array of factors.

That said, I cannot help thinking about our transfer activity in recent seasons.It is players who win games irrespective of the systems played and our overall squad is totally lacking in PL quality.

Just look at some of our options in midfield - Lee,Sako,Mutch.Even Cabaye and Puncheon have been off the pace and don't offer too much.McArthur has had his injury problems and is struggling to recreate his previous form.

Up front - For a few seasons now our transfer activity has been dire - Remy,Bamford,Adebayor,Sanogo,Ameobi etc etc.Furthemore the likes of Campbell and Gayle have not shown they can do it in the PL.And look at the options now !!!!

So overall, one can point figures at our recruitment and probably this is the prime reason why we are in the mire.


Edited by Willo (03 Oct 2017 10.49am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Oct 17 10.56am

Recruitment is a serious issue, but so was extending Pardew, keeping him on, and embarking on that 'expansive' football, along with the already made 'transition' excuse. The team hadn't really changed enough to do that, and also we'd sold Bolasie, which I'm not criticising but affects this change in strategy. Not only that but we didn't recruit a bad left back or def mid. We just didn't sign any. Just a past it Flamini who hadn't played for ages. And what did we do this season with striker? The same. All of that Pardew project was after a 5 month struggle to get a couple of wins.

Then there's the Frank experience. Did we not have a near escape with Sam and announce a limited budget?

Yes Willo, recruitment should be a lot better and go beyond the panini album and actually start about at least half a year before they may move on, preferably earlier. Not 10.59pm on deadline day.

Recruitment and strategy/planning and indeed lack of plus manager selection/extensions and agreements/changes in team strategy are why we're here. Specifically now it's Frank and Benteke with nobody to step in or challenge his place.

Shambles in other words and those responsible deserve the relegation to learn. We don't deserve it, especially when you see it unfold and watch us take 6 weeks waiting for Southampton to choose our manager after we don't hire Dyche, and log on to find all we've bought is Riederwald and 2 loans. Navigated into relegation. But it was okay, everyone uses Skype these days, even when there's emergency issues in an organisation. I can see every large company not sending in their top ball breaker and instead talking over a screen in fvcking Skype. Silly me.

 


COYP

Painter Flag Croydon 03 Oct 17 11.04am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Apparently Dyche was interviewed and wanted the job and was gobsmacked he didn't get it.
Wish he had!!

Source of your post to validate. As apparently does sound convincing.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Oct 17 11.40am

To summarise why we're in this mess:

2 appalling summers regarding recruitment (leaving specialist positions without back up until the last day, or not at all).

2 appalling summers regarding manager extension, selection, football tactics agreements, trust, believing in interview BS, not stepping in when alarm bells must've rung loud etc.

That's where we've gone wrong. Even if we hadn't gone wrong there we're still amongst the others at risk of relegation, so which begs the question, why take those risks with players not signed when we had the money, or tactical changes made after far from stable times just behind us.

 


COYP

Diagonal Flag 03 Oct 17 11.48am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Recruitment is a serious issue, but so was extending Pardew, keeping him on, and embarking on that 'expansive' football, along with the already made 'transition' excuse. The team hadn't really changed enough to do that, and also we'd sold Bolasie, which I'm not criticising but affects this change in strategy. Not only that but we didn't recruit a bad left back or def mid. We just didn't sign any. Just a past it Flamini who hadn't played for ages. And what did we do this season with striker? The same. All of that Pardew project was after a 5 month struggle to get a couple of wins.

Then there's the Frank experience. Did we not have a near escape with Sam and announce a limited budget?

Yes Willo, recruitment should be a lot better and go beyond the panini album and actually start about at least half a year before they may move on, preferably earlier. Not 10.59pm on deadline day.

Recruitment and strategy/planning and indeed lack of plus manager selection/extensions and agreements/changes in team strategy are why we're here. Specifically now it's Frank and Benteke with nobody to step in or challenge his place.

Shambles in other words and those responsible deserve the relegation to learn. We don't deserve it, especially when you see it unfold and watch us take 6 weeks waiting for Southampton to choose our manager after we don't hire Dyche, and log on to find all we've bought is Riederwald and 2 loans. Navigated into relegation. But it was okay, everyone uses Skype these days, even when there's emergency issues in an organisation. I can see every large company not sending in their top ball breaker and instead talking over a screen in fvcking Skype. Silly me.

I wholeheartedly agree. I think the word shambles is entirely accurate. And whilst I appreciate the special place that SP has in the hearts of us Palace fans, I'm fed up with his bluster around this catalogue of cock-ups.

It's just not good enough to continue saying 'Look, it's hurts me too. I love this club like every fan!'. We know that, SP. Nonetheless, we'd like some clear and sensible decision making please.

My heart sank when Da Silva went to Watford. Yes, he may have been a manager who was keen to provide a stage to move on to a bigger club, but in the turmoil of Sam resigning we just needed someone to ensure that the team had a backbone and would healthily consolidate its PL status.

I was disbelieving when De Boer's appointment was announced. At no point did I think that it was anything but an ambitious gambit born out of a lack of alternatives.

I'll be singing my heart out at Selhurst Park, but underneath it I'm very upset about the sorry stat we are in.

 


If only it were White, rather than Yellow!

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 03 Oct 17 11.55am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

To summarise why we're in this mess:

2 appalling summers regarding recruitment (leaving specialist positions without back up until the last day, or not at all).

2 appalling summers regarding manager extension, selection, football tactics agreements, trust, believing in interview BS, not stepping in when alarm bells must've rung loud etc.

That's where we've gone wrong. Even if we hadn't gone wrong there we're still amongst the others at risk of relegation, so which begs the question, why take those risks with players not signed when we had the money, or tactical changes made after far from stable times just behind us.

May I add Parish's over-reaching and lack of awareness as to the limits of his own ability a few years back in running a football club with one of the top 40 highest incomes in the world.

This for me is the biggest cock-up of all and self-inflicted.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 03 Oct 17 11.57am

I don't like the blame-game unless it has productive outcomes from the system, rather than individuals.

T'internet has put rumours into overdrive.

I just hope CPFC have the right people to get the club out of this. And that starts from the top, but goes all the way to the pitch.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 03 Oct 17 12.06pm

Originally posted by Diagonal

I wholeheartedly agree. I think the word shambles is entirely accurate. And whilst I appreciate the special place that SP has in the hearts of us Palace fans, I'm fed up with his bluster around this catalogue of cock-ups.

It's just not good enough to continue saying 'Look, it's hurts me too. I love this club like every fan!'. We know that, SP. Nonetheless, we'd like some clear and sensible decision making please.

My heart sank when Da Silva went to Watford. Yes, he may have been a manager who was keen to provide a stage to move on to a bigger club, but in the turmoil of Sam resigning we just needed someone to ensure that the team had a backbone and would healthily consolidate its PL status.

I was disbelieving when De Boer's appointment was announced. At no point did I think that it was anything but an ambitious gambit born out of a lack of alternatives.

I'll be singing my heart out at Selhurst Park, but underneath it I'm very upset about the sorry stat we are in.

I think your find Silva was always going to go to Watford.
From Sam resigning to Silva signing was a matter of days.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Dodger Lane Flag Merstham 03 Oct 17 12.07pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

May I add Parish's over-reaching and lack of awareness as to the limits of his own ability a few years back in running a football club with one of the top 40 highest incomes in the world.

This for me is the biggest cock-up of all and self-inflicted.

I agree with you whole heartedly

 


A Lie travels round the world quicker than a man can put his trousers on

[Link]

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 03 Oct 17 12.07pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Apparently Dyche was interviewed and wanted the job and was gobsmacked he didn't get it.
Wish he had!!

Apparently true or false ?

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why are we in this mess?