You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > A thread to itself - that challenge on De Bruyne
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

A thread to itself - that challenge on De Bruyne


Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
boo909 Flag Figeac 02 Jan 18 3.38pm

Originally posted by Medway Eagle

Can we put this one to bed and archive it now. A Badly timed tackle yes but no more than that. They happen all the time, Cant see the big deal, these happen all the time either accidently or in the heat of the moment, Hopefully Punch will recover his form and will get game time soon. No one at the club is more Palace than Punch. I am personally shocked at the vitriol against Punch from our own supporters far more than I am about the tackle. I could understand if it was City's forum but ours its a disgrace


Well said, I can't believe after such an amazing game of football that this is what people want to talk about.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 02 Jan 18 3.44pm

Originally posted by boo909


Well said, I can't believe after such an amazing game of football that this is what people want to talk about.

100% agree what a fantastic performance against possibly the best team in Europe, Came away proud of every single player including Punch

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 02 Jan 18 4.33pm

Wouldn’t be surprised if Puncheon gets charged with a second charge of assault after that one. Shocking tackle.

 

jimruss Flag Sidcup 02 Jan 18 4.45pm

I see KDB has a late fitness test to see if he can play tonight, I was worried his life support machine would be turned off.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 02 Jan 18 4.52pm

I've re-watched the tackle again. It's high and it's late, but it's not a studs up challenge. A bad tackle and I would only say it was a red if he was through on goal. The referee agreed and so did Poll when initially asked. I still think the OP was pretty obnoxious with their self-righteous post, which was probably more deserving of a red card

 

Glazier#1 Flag 02 Jan 18 5.13pm

Ok.

It's been very interesting to read so many comments on here on the subject.

As the OP, I have to say that my point was to see how our own supporters viewed the incident.

It is clear that many on here see absolutely no malice or danger in Punch's foul; most believe that it was the result of rustiness combined with a realisation that something had to be done, at all costs, to stop Citeh from breaking.

Having made the original comments, I have reviewed the incident over and over.

Yes, it is true that Punch is not and has never been known as a 'hatchet man' in the slightest over the years.

Yes, I accept that Jason's intention was not to injure KDB.

Yes, the fact is that our captain had only one thing on his mind at the time: stop City at all costs. I accept that many see this decision as 'run of the mill', 'taking one for the team'.

As it happens, that decision has caused great injury to himself and he is lucky (and it is only luck)that the injury to KDB wasn't as bad. The fact that this happened is because Punch lost his head, it would seem.
The term that is used to describe this sort of challenge is, usually, 'rash'.

Not premeditated or systematic, I accept, as some have described other 'assaults' on our players but rash, reckless and dangerous nonetheless.

Am I a turncoat expressing my opinion here?

It is clear that we have a jewel of our own at Palace and so many of us are heartily sick of what is meted out to him on a weekly basis. Many of us feel that these attacks on him do not get punished properly. I agree: it's a disgrace.

I love the game and hate it whenever I see talent smashed and destroyed illegally. I feel that if the game doesn't respond swiftly, fairly and consistently, then we all, as fans, suffer. No matter who is on the receiving end.

Old as I am, I still remember the great Pele walking off the pitch in the '66 World Cup, hobbling and in tears after the Bulgarians and others had been allowed to line up and to kick him to pieces under the eyes of the refs on duty. No doubt the Bulgarian and Portugese fans loved it but they were the only ones who did. I'm not saying that Punch or Palace are guilty of such cynicism, of course not but my point is about the illegal stifling of talent by those who can't live with it. Bad for our game.

Do I care more about Wilf and not about other players? If I'm honest, the answer is no. They do it to Wilf because they can't live with him, he's too good for them, as the saying goes. The same is true, I have to say, about De Bruyne and it is players like these that we watch the game for, isn't it? Or are we, in truth, only concerned about our own team winning, no matter what?

My hope is that all fans hate to see the guilty go unpunished, no matter who they play for. It's my opinion that Punch should have seen red for his recklessness. Does that make me a sky blue? Of course not.

I love the Palace. Always have done. I don't want to be taken over by some billionaire and be able to buy the league. Whatever we do, we do it our way. And yes, The lads did us proud against City as they have done so often in the past.

They have worked miracles after our disastrous start and Roy is, truly, a great manager in my opinion. One of ours, for sure. A gentleman (rare)and a coach of immense insight, talent and experience. We're lucky to have him, aren't we?

I'm sorry if I've come across as anti or disloyal. Not my intention at all.

I've expressed my opinion and I'm pleased I did.

Bumpy ride, though. Lol. 'Red Card' 'Obnoxious' 'Self righteous''Patronising'

Over and out.

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.15pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.19pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.21pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.23pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.25pm)

 

johnno42000 Flag 02 Jan 18 5.25pm

[Link]

I couldn't resist putting this in. The players today would be in therapy for years if they had to put up with this. The goalkeeper action from on 1:30 is funny. The cunning kick on 3:25 is a bit different as well. Yogi played in 2 of the matches against Racing Club and got sent off in the play off match.

Edited by johnno42000 (02 Jan 2018 5.26pm)

Edited by johnno42000 (02 Jan 2018 5.35pm)

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

taylors lovechild Flag 02 Jan 18 6.06pm

If only Puncheon had the chance to make five edits before submitting his challenge for consideration then I'm sure he wouldn't have taken the same action

 

Glazier#1 Flag 02 Jan 18 6.12pm

I doubt that Punch makes enough errors to warrant that.
I bet his fingers aren't as big as mine!

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 02 Jan 18 6.40pm

Unfortunately Luka has to share some of the blame for having his penalty saved by Emerson, the ball falling to KDB Citehs quickest player being looked after by our slowest player. The result being inevitable, I am not condoning what Punch did but given the circumstances I think most players would have stopped de Bruyne one way or another. As it happens Puncheon has come off second best and it seems KDB isn't too bad.
Nothing like kicking someone when they're down

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 02 Jan 18 6.48pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

If only Puncheon had the chance to make five edits before submitting his challenge for consideration then I'm sure he wouldn't have taken the same action

Glazier1 made his edits because he had made errors. Are you saying Punch knew he made an error? Many in here wouldn't agree with you. It has been suggested he had to be crocked to stop the attack, probably would make the league more open and interesting, Punch took one for the team. So no, Punch wouldn't have had to do it any other way.

 

Pikester Flag Worthing 02 Jan 18 6.53pm

I see far worse every week on MOTD.
It was naughty - a definite yellow but not the GBH suggested by some.

I'd never want to see players injured and the league is a better place for players like KDB but this was an attempt to stop an attack not kill the bloke.

Blown out of proportion.

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 02 Jan 18 6.58pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Ok.

It's been very interesting to read so many comments on here on the subject.

As the OP, I have to say that my point was to see how our own supporters viewed the incident.

It is clear that many on here see absolutely no malice or danger in Punch's foul; most believe that it was the result of rustiness combined with a realisation that something had to be done, at all costs, to stop Citeh from breaking.

Having made the original comments, I have reviewed the incident over and over.

Yes, it is true that Punch is not and has never been known as a 'hatchet man' in the slightest over the years.

Yes, I accept that Jason's intention was not to injure KDB.

Yes, the fact is that our captain had only one thing on his mind at the time: stop City at all costs. I accept that many see this decision as 'run of the mill', 'taking one for the team'.

As it happens, that decision has caused great injury to himself and he is lucky (and it is only luck)that the injury to KDB wasn't as bad. The fact that this happened is because Punch lost his head, it would seem.
The term that is used to describe this sort of challenge is, usually, 'rash'.

Not premeditated or systematic, I accept, as some have described other 'assaults' on our players but rash, reckless and dangerous nonetheless.

Am I a turncoat expressing my opinion here?

It is clear that we have a jewel of our own at Palace and so many of us are heartily sick of what is meted out to him on a weekly basis. Many of us feel that these attacks on him do not get punished properly. I agree: it's a disgrace.

I love the game and hate it whenever I see talent smashed and destroyed illegally. I feel that if the game doesn't respond swiftly, fairly and consistently, then we all, as fans, suffer. No matter who is on the receiving end.

Old as I am, I still remember the great Pele walking off the pitch in the '66 World Cup, hobbling and in tears after the Bulgarians and others had been allowed to line up and to kick him to pieces under the eyes of the refs on duty. No doubt the Bulgarian and Portugese fans loved it but they were the only ones who did. I'm not saying that Punch or Palace are guilty of such cynicism, of course not but my point is about the illegal stifling of talent by those who can't live with it. Bad for our game.

Do I care more about Wilf and not about other players? If I'm honest, the answer is no. They do it to Wilf because they can't live with him, he's too good for them, as the saying goes. The same is true, I have to say, about De Bruyne and it is players like these that we watch the game for, isn't it? Or are we, in truth, only concerned about our own team winning, no matter what?

My hope is that all fans hate to see the guilty go unpunished, no matter who they play for. It's my opinion that Punch should have seen red for his recklessness. Does that make me a sky blue? Of course not.

I love the Palace. Always have done. I don't want to be taken over by some billionaire and be able to buy the league. Whatever we do, we do it our way. And yes, The lads did us proud against City as they have done so often in the past.

They have worked miracles after our disastrous start and Roy is, truly, a great manager in my opinion. One of ours, for sure. A gentleman (rare)and a coach of immense insight, talent and experience. We're lucky to have him, aren't we?

I'm sorry if I've come across as anti or disloyal. Not my intention at all.

I've expressed my opinion and I'm pleased I did.

Bumpy ride, though. Lol. 'Red Card' 'Obnoxious' 'Self righteous''Patronising'

Over and out.

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.15pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.19pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.21pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.23pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.25pm)

I think you’re Willo.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 Jan 18 7.01pm

Just seen the city team at I've af the ground on SSN, and KDB is with them an looking fine. Wouldn't suprise me if he started.

 

Bullhorn76 Flag Darlington 02 Jan 18 7.04pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Just seen the city team at I've af the ground on SSN, and KDB is with them an looking fine. Wouldn't suprise me if he started.

He is starting tonight that was a really bad erm ‘injury’ wasn’t it ?

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 Jan 18 7.06pm

Suprise suprise he's playing tonight. Must have been a shocking tackle. ....

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 02 Jan 18 7.11pm

Ha ha. What a superman he must be, starting tonight after that terrible terrible tackle and putting two of ours out for the season in the process.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 02 Jan 18 8.09pm

Originally posted by cpfc1976

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Ok.

It's been very interesting to read so many comments on here on the subject.

As the OP, I have to say that my point was to see how our own supporters viewed the incident.

It is clear that many on here see absolutely no malice or danger in Punch's foul; most believe that it was the result of rustiness combined with a realisation that something had to be done, at all costs, to stop Citeh from breaking.

Having made the original comments, I have reviewed the incident over and over.

Yes, it is true that Punch is not and has never been known as a 'hatchet man' in the slightest over the years.

Yes, I accept that Jason's intention was not to injure KDB.

Yes, the fact is that our captain had only one thing on his mind at the time: stop City at all costs. I accept that many see this decision as 'run of the mill', 'taking one for the team'.

As it happens, that decision has caused great injury to himself and he is lucky (and it is only luck)that the injury to KDB wasn't as bad. The fact that this happened is because Punch lost his head, it would seem.
The term that is used to describe this sort of challenge is, usually, 'rash'.

Not premeditated or systematic, I accept, as some have described other 'assaults' on our players but rash, reckless and dangerous nonetheless.

Am I a turncoat expressing my opinion here?

It is clear that we have a jewel of our own at Palace and so many of us are heartily sick of what is meted out to him on a weekly basis. Many of us feel that these attacks on him do not get punished properly. I agree: it's a disgrace.

I love the game and hate it whenever I see talent smashed and destroyed illegally. I feel that if the game doesn't respond swiftly, fairly and consistently, then we all, as fans, suffer. No matter who is on the receiving end.

Old as I am, I still remember the great Pele walking off the pitch in the '66 World Cup, hobbling and in tears after the Bulgarians and others had been allowed to line up and to kick him to pieces under the eyes of the refs on duty. No doubt the Bulgarian and Portugese fans loved it but they were the only ones who did. I'm not saying that Punch or Palace are guilty of such cynicism, of course not but my point is about the illegal stifling of talent by those who can't live with it. Bad for our game.

Do I care more about Wilf and not about other players? If I'm honest, the answer is no. They do it to Wilf because they can't live with him, he's too good for them, as the saying goes. The same is true, I have to say, about De Bruyne and it is players like these that we watch the game for, isn't it? Or are we, in truth, only concerned about our own team winning, no matter what?

My hope is that all fans hate to see the guilty go unpunished, no matter who they play for. It's my opinion that Punch should have seen red for his recklessness. Does that make me a sky blue? Of course not.

I love the Palace. Always have done. I don't want to be taken over by some billionaire and be able to buy the league. Whatever we do, we do it our way. And yes, The lads did us proud against City as they have done so often in the past.

They have worked miracles after our disastrous start and Roy is, truly, a great manager in my opinion. One of ours, for sure. A gentleman (rare)and a coach of immense insight, talent and experience. We're lucky to have him, aren't we?

I'm sorry if I've come across as anti or disloyal. Not my intention at all.

I've expressed my opinion and I'm pleased I did.

Bumpy ride, though. Lol. 'Red Card' 'Obnoxious' 'Self righteous''Patronising'

Over and out.

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.15pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.19pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.21pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.23pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Jan 2018 5.25pm)

I think you’re Willo.


If you think I'm Willo, you need a check - up from the neck up.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 02 Jan 18 8.45pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1


If you think I'm Willo, you need a check - up from the neck up.

At least you get to enjoy favourite player at the expense of our club captain though eh. Nice one.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Glazier#1 Flag 02 Jan 18 9.47pm

Get a life.

Like I made the challenge.

Uncalled for.

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

At least you get to enjoy favourite player at the expense of our club captain though eh. Nice one.

 

Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > A thread to itself - that challenge on De Bruyne