You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hodgson has to go


Page 6 of 18 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
EddieMac Flag 13 Jan 19 5.04pm

6 wins from 18 games to basically stay in this league again this year. I reckon we will get that plus a few more. We are not going to be pushing for top 6 anytime soon so a close to mid table finish should be satisfactory for all involved.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 13 Jan 19 5.18pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Get a grip anyone that thinks Hodgson should be sacked. There are very fine margins in football and unfortunately our finishing has been woeful all season hence the lack of points.

Sakho missed an open goal against Newcastle.
Zaha and Mccarturs misses against Watford.
Only a couple of examples of where we should have scored and won games.
If we scored half the sitters we missed then we would be sitting comfortably around mid table place and Hodgson would be the best thing since sliced pan.
Meyer doesn't start because at this present moment he is not good enough.
We will not get relegated this season but will finish comfortably around 11th-14th which is about our level at this moment.

So what you point out suggests that this should be the absolute focus in training, no? That and delivering a decent set piece. All Zaha had to do was to lightly chip the keeper, it's a goal. Panic stations ahoy!

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 13 Jan 19 5.45pm


Originally posted by Cucking Funt

And here we are, folks. Back in Pantwet City. Again.

I have been wetting myself for 2 years now, and s*** myself on more than one occasion. I take it you recognise how f***ing bad we have been at home?!


 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 13 Jan 19 5.49pm

No the point is games are lost due to fine margines. Luck good or bad does play its part. Roy is a fair minded pragmatic manager. We have a commited squad of players who are doing their dammest to win matches. Nobody likes loosing but its isn't becasue Roy or the squad arn't fully committed to doing their best.

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

So what you point out suggests that this should be the absolute focus in training, no? That and delivering a decent set piece. All Zaha had to do was to lightly chip the keeper, it's a goal. Panic stations ahoy!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 13 Jan 19 6.17pm

Originally posted by johnmcormick8

No the point is games are lost due to fine margines. Luck good or bad does play its part. Roy is a fair minded pragmatic manager. We have a commited squad of players who are doing their dammest to win matches. Nobody likes loosing but its isn't becasue Roy or the squad arn't fully committed to doing their best.

I beg to disagree. Starting with 3 defensive mids at home is a sin in my eyes, an then to think Wilf is a centre forward is just plain ignorance and stubbornness. There were options on the bench. Did see his reply when asked whether he thought if Wickham made a difference in the previous game. Go and have a look and watch the body language, well shifty. Not sure what is going on, but I do know that Hodgson is well past his sell by date.

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 13 Jan 19 6.29pm

Roy doesn't feel Wickham improves are chances of winning a game.He made that quite clear,although I think he is worth starting to see if he can make a difffernce Roy doesn't so I would suggest his days are numbered. The three at the back is Roy's pattern of play again we ani't going to change him or it. So sack Roy errrr no who is any beter has the experince in the Prem?

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I beg to disagree. Starting with 3 defensive mids at home is a sin in my eyes, an then to think Wilf is a centre forward is just plain ignorance and stubbornness. There were options on the bench. Did see his reply when asked whether he thought if Wickham made a difference in the previous game. Go and have a look and watch the body language, well shifty. Not sure what is going on, but I do know that Hodgson is well past his sell by date.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 13 Jan 19 6.30pm

He is dream employee for SP so no way he would be fired and if he did want to leave SP would be begging for him to stay.

How this guy keeps praising scouting and puts up with no funds is shocking and if he beliefs what he is saying to media he really is past it.

Who would replace him say he does tomorrow? I can't think of any one that would want to come here.

I said this before let him retire end of the season but he wont I can see him seeing out the new 2 year deal he signed which means if he is backed in the summer then goes the next season we could be in same mess player wise as before new manager not liking players wanting new ones which means need to spend which SP does want to do.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

EddieMac Flag 13 Jan 19 6.39pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

So what you point out suggests that this should be the absolute focus in training, no? That and delivering a decent set piece. All Zaha had to do was to lightly chip the keeper, it's a goal. Panic stations ahoy!

Yeah, im sure they should have training sessions on tapping a ball home into an empty net from 2 yards.

No manager can control players missing open goals. The fact of the matter is, our style of football and tactics are creatong endless chances but the players are mising them.

So that is not Roy's fault.

 

MR200% Flag 13 Jan 19 6.39pm

I understand that we have to grind results out, but at least under Pulis I always thought we would. Now it maybe Hodgson's tactics, but I also feel that the players had more spirit and belief in their abilities.I feel under Hodgson, they just don't buy into his tactical approach, and don't enjoy playing his way.

Have to say watching Palace at home over the last full calendar year has been very depressing and a complete contrast to the previous three years

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 13 Jan 19 6.41pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

He is dream employee for SP so no way he would be fired and if he did want to leave SP would be begging for him to stay.

How this guy keeps praising scouting and puts up with no funds is shocking and if he beliefs what he is saying to media he really is past it.

Who would replace him say he does tomorrow? I can't think of any one that would want to come here.

I said this before let him retire end of the season but he wont I can see him seeing out the new 2 year deal he signed which means if he is backed in the summer then goes the next season we could be in same mess player wise as before new manager not liking players wanting new ones which means need to spend which SP does want to do.

I agree, I doubt anyone would like to come here and work with Parish, unless they've got £££ in their eyes - i.e. get the boot and earn a few million. A pity, because we have a good enough team to do well.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Jan 19 6.42pm

Hodgson performed a miracle last season keeping us up against all the odds.We really were prime relegation candidates and we ended up in a respectable 11th place.

At the present time, we aren't in the relegation zone and there is a small buffer between ourselves and the team in 18th place.Whilst of course supporters are in despair about certain matters,not least the strength in forward areas and our abject home form, Hodgson still has credit in the bank for what he has achieved and he will not be going anywhere soon.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 13 Jan 19 7.07pm

Originally posted by Willo

Hodgson performed a miracle last season keeping us up against all the odds.We really were prime relegation candidates and we ended up in a respectable 11th place.

At the present time, we aren't in the relegation zone and there is a small buffer between ourselves and the team in 18th place.Whilst of course supporters are in despair about certain matters,not least the strength in forward areas and our abject home form, Hodgson still has credit in the bank for what he has achieved and he will not be going anywhere soon.

What he needs is a slice of luck, like Wan Bissaka last year, but a forward.

Zaha is brilliant but an air-head, can't score for toffee.

No Manager can force anyone to score, he is probably tearing his hair out.

 

PatrickA Flag London 13 Jan 19 8.23pm

I understand the goodwill to Hodgson for his achievement last season and it’s understandable and commendable that people are tolerant and patient with him.
It’s also true that we have a good chance of staying up this season.
However, the central point is that the dearth of home wins and goals this season is not just down to lack of a striker or bad luck.
We have lacked creativity, flair and vision in attack and it’s valid to ask questions of Hodgson in this regard.
People refer ‘20 chances’ per game but this has not been the case for the vast majority of games.
Playing people in wrong positions, poor set pieces, failure to get players in the box when on the attack.
I’m not saying he is a bad manager but I don’t believe he is getting the best out of the squad.

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 13 Jan 19 8.32pm

The squad is not doing RH justice by missing so many chances, it's not his fault that they seem to be so incompetent at finding the back of the net.
We are actually playing pretty good football at the moment it's just our lack of a finish that is letting us down.

 

mentalpalacefan Flag Ashford 13 Jan 19 8.39pm

You can’t blame the manager when our senior players are creating and missing sitters

 

McPalace Flag Carshalton Village 13 Jan 19 9.35pm

I worry that all is well in the dressing room
The team appears to have lost their confidence

 

mentalpalacefan Flag Ashford 13 Jan 19 9.42pm

Yesterday wasn’t about confidence we just got to convert chances 2 yards from the goal

 

jeeagles Flag 13 Jan 19 10.03pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

What he needs is a slice of luck, like Wan Bissaka last year, but a forward.

Zaha is brilliant but an air-head, can't score for toffee.

No Manager can force anyone to score, he is probably tearing his hair out.

I disagree with those who think Hodgson performed a miracle. Pulis performed miracle based on our starting league position and players. In Pardew's first season he did a great job coming in after Warnock to keep us up. BFS did a good job, but spent about £45M plus had £30M Sakho on loan.

Roy had 34 games and one of our best squads to turn it around last year, basically all he needed to do is not play 3 at the back. It was a good job, but we'd already avoided relegation 4 seasons on the trot. It's not like it was an impossible task with the players we have.

Like Pardew, he seems to have run out of ideas. Unfortunately, these managers have a limited shelf live before they get found out.

 

Numbers Man Flag Tulse Hill 13 Jan 19 11.11pm

RH’s is very poor. Recently his negative approach to the Chelsea game and the poor home form in general. Yesterday was a typical example. We didn’t do that badly up to their equaliser but it seem to knock the stuffing out the team. Substitutions should have been made at this point. One of the strikers should have been changed for a mid field player. We were overrun in mid field from this point onwards. Wickham should have been brought on instead of Benteke because he had had a couple of games already.
The other point was the way Watford always got five or six players in and around the box. We had on occasions only one or two!

 

jerryleeboy Flag Warden Bay 13 Jan 19 11.22pm

Roy’s stubbornness to change is costing us

No subs, no starting xl change, playing Wilf at centre forward when we have strikers on the bench...Wilf and Andros are so much better on the wings.....continually playing Hennessey when guaita is so obviously the better keeper...yesterday, need a goal, takes off striker, brings on def mid, leaves two strikers on bench...the list is endless...we can’t blame Roy for our lack of goals of course, our finishing is woeful....what we can blame him for is his unwillingness to change anything, his lack of belief in anyone apart from the usual starting xl...maybe not now, but he has to go if we are to advance

 


Loud n Proud since '76.

Page 6 of 18 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go