You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR at its worst
November 22 2026 7.23pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

VAR at its worst


Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 11 Mar 21 8.25pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Last night's latest VAR faux-pas really takes the biscuit.

The VAR match centre said: "The on-field referee felt that Alex McCarthy got a slight touch on the ball, and VAR couldn't see anything to disprove that."

If it can't do that, what possible use is it?

As for last nights VAR howler.

If VAR isn’t going to give a penalty in that instance, then obviously we might as well not have it and get back to enjoying the game and the excitement we used to have before it’s introduction.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 13 Mar 21 10.18pm

I thought VAR was taken to a new level at today’s game.

VARing a possible offside leading to a VAR penalty decision. In effect VARing a VAR.

Honestly what has our game become. Such a sorry state of affairs. The enjoyment of football has gone. Found myself far more gripped by the Afghanistan vs Zimbabwe Test match on ‘Freesport’ (don’t even know what that channel is) this morning than I did the Palace match.

RIP football

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 19 Mar 21 7.20am

Originally posted by steeleye20

Last night's latest VAR faux-pas really takes the biscuit.

The VAR match centre said: "The on-field referee felt that Alex McCarthy got a slight touch on the ball, and VAR couldn't see anything to disprove that."

If it can't do that, what possible use is it?

Interesting article in yesterday’s paper adding some detail as to what happened in the Man City / Southampton Phil Foden non penalty incident.

[Link]

It is an utter farce.

Scott Parker’s interview embedded in the article also sums up how many feel about VAR and how it is removing the excitement and making the game too ‘sterile’.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 26 Apr 21 11.15am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

'Top 50 Comedy VAR Decisions', coming to E4 June.

Another absolutely appalling VAR decision / intervention with the Balbuena sending off for West Ham in their game against Chelsea.

Quite possibly one of the most ridiculous red cards ever issued.

[Link]

I’m looking forward to the news that the sending off has been overturned and that Peter Bankes (VAR) and Chris Kavanagh (Referee) will not be officiating again.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Apr 21 11.45am

Red card for me.

If one of our players had been the victim of a contact high on the leg delivered with force, our supporters would have lacerated and pilloried the referee for not sending off the perpetrator.

I accept that others will disagree but I will not be persuaded to change my opinion.

Edited by Willo (26 Apr 2021 11.46am)

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 26 Apr 21 11.46am

Being a tad old school I preferred the game without VAR.

When it was first introduced I was prepared to accept the arguments for eliminating areas of doubt and helping referees to retrospectively take consistent action against obvious foul play they'd missed.

But last night's dreadful VAR interventions and subsequent decisions have cemented my beliefs that the whole process needs a thorough overhaul.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 26 Apr 21 11.59am

Originally posted by Willo

Red card for me.

If one of our players had been the victim of a contact high on the leg delivered with force, our supporters would have lacerated and pilloried the referee for not sending off the perpetrator.

I accept that others will disagree but I will not be persuaded to change my opinion.

Edited by Willo (26 Apr 2021 11.46am)

You are right, I totally disagree with you! Played the ball fairly, then made contact, which could not be avoided

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 26 Apr 21 12.11pm

Red card for me also.

The ref perfectly positioned to see that this was not just a follow through but a deliberate deviation.

Full marks to the ref.


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Apr 21 12.12pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

You are right, I totally disagree with you! Played the ball fairly, then made contact, which could not be avoided

If that was a Craig Dawson v Wilfried Zaha, I suspect many of our supporters would have deemed a "Red" appropriate !!!!

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 26 Apr 21 2.37pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Red card for me also.

The ref perfectly positioned to see that this was not just a follow through but a deliberate deviation.

Full marks to the ref.


I haven’t yet seen one pundit, reporter, commentator or ex pro share your view. In fact I have to agree with David Moyes and others who have stated that the decision could only have been made by someone who has never played the game.

Btw, the (perfectly positioned) ref didn’t give it. He was told by the VAR to subsequently go and look at the monitor.

There was no deviation. The follow through made by Balbuena was a perfectly natural one and anyone who has played the game would say the same.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 26 Apr 21 2.39pm

Originally posted by Willo

If that was a Craig Dawson v Wilfried Zaha, I suspect many of our supporters would have deemed a "Red" appropriate !!!!

Replacing Chilwell for Zaha (or any other of our players for that matter) wouldn’t change the fact that it wasn’t even a foul, never mind a red card.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 26 Apr 21 3.13pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

I haven’t yet seen one pundit, reporter, commentator or ex pro share your view. In fact I have to agree with David Moyes and others who have stated that the decision could only have been made by someone who has never played the game.

Btw, the (perfectly positioned) ref didn’t give it. He was told by the VAR to subsequently go and look at the monitor.

There was no deviation. The follow through made by Balbuena was a perfectly natural one and anyone who has played the game would say the same.

They would be wrong.

Backward pressure rubbing on the calf, that is not a natural follow through.

Deliberate, cynical, clever, but got caught out.

Pundits, especially Lineker, should go to spec-savers.


 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 26 Apr 21 3.38pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

They would be wrong.

Backward pressure rubbing on the calf, that is not a natural follow through.

Deliberate, cynical, clever, but got caught out.

Pundits, especially Lineker, should go to spec-savers.


Sorry it was a natural follow through. Not sure where you get the backward pressure rubbing down the calf. He had got the ball cleanly with a perfectly timed tackle. Players are always going to get caught during tackling. This is the sort of decision that will eradicate tackling. Wouldn’t be surprised if red overturned imo

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 26 Apr 21 4.01pm

Well let's see if there is an appeal and what it brings.

I have just reviewed it again and to me B does more than follow though and forces into the back of the leg, but it is not an easy spot.

The other incident I felt was a natural follow through.

Sakho last year, for example, a natural follow through.

The ref, after consulting the monitor, looks very clear in his mind.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 26 Apr 21 4.20pm

All tackles look bad in slow motion. It was a very harsh sending off. Having won the ball comfortably before the other player got even close he was doing nothing other than following through on a natural path. I agree with those who say it wasn't even a foul.

There appears to be lots of decisions these days which are contrary to what everyone knows is correct who has played the game. Another classic was a players foot being taken out and jammed against the ball which is a foul but is not given because it looks like the ball has travelled on the path it would take if it was a clean tackle.

 

deleted 25 Flag 26 Apr 21 7.27pm

Luke Shaw handballed in the area and adverted the ball reaching a Leeds player in a clear scoring position

Made no effort to get out of the way and the ball was not diverted into him.

Was a definite penalty and potential red card. VAR was supposed to root out bias but MU still getting the decisions

Edited by Vincehair (26 Apr 2021 7.28pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 27 Apr 21 8.17am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

All tackles look bad in slow motion. It was a very harsh sending off. Having won the ball comfortably before the other player got even close he was doing nothing other than following through on a natural path. I agree with those who say it wasn't even a foul.

There appears to be lots of decisions these days which are contrary to what everyone knows is correct who has played the game. Another classic was a players foot being taken out and jammed against the ball which is a foul but is not given because it looks like the ball has travelled on the path it would take if it was a clean tackle.

This

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 27 Apr 21 1.41pm

The pundits said Leicester goal was a hand ball last night. I didn't see the replay - what did everyone else think?

 


Red and Blue Army!

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 27 Apr 21 1.49pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

The pundits said Leicester goal was a hand ball last night. I didn't see the replay - what did everyone else think?

Hand ball, hand ball, hand ball, HAND BALL...... Sorry, we are the wrong team to get that decision. VAR is licensed cheating.

Actually I have no idea as I didn't see the incident, but you get my drift.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 27 Apr 21 1.55pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

The pundits said Leicester goal was a hand ball last night. I didn't see the replay - what did everyone else think?

From what I saw it looked from one angle that it had hit his hand but then when viewed from another (behind the player) it clearly hit the inside of his thigh and was a good 12 inches away from his hand.

It was just one misleading camera angle that looked like a handball but it was quickly ruled out when viewed from other angles.

 

Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR at its worst