You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic
November 22 2026 1.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rhian Brewster (rumour) (LOCKED)


Page 6 of 14 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 21 Sep 20 10.58am

He wants more game time. Here he will behind Ayew and Bats, unless he takes his likely limited opportunities and forces his way in through weight of goals.
I just can't see why he would come here unless Wilf is heading out the door.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Sep 20 11.17am

Originally posted by SurbsEagle

I think the club has handled our business in the Premier League perfectly.

I'm not sure that anyone (except Painter) would agree with you. Other descriptive terms like "adequately" may be more appropriate as you have obviously forgotten the times when we didn't bother to replace departing strikers or when defensive shortages meant having to use Jeffrey Schlupp as a central defender

The one thing that Parish seems to have in abundance is luck as a less lucky chairman would have had his club relegated with the past purchasing deficiencies

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Sep 20 11.27am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I'm not sure that anyone (except Painter) would agree with you. Other descriptive terms like "adequately" may be more appropriate as you have obviously forgotten the times when we didn't bother to replace departing strikers or when defensive shortages meant having to use Jeffrey Schlupp as a central defender

The one thing that Parish seems to have in abundance is luck as a less lucky chairman would have had his club relegated with the past purchasing deficiencies

Napoleon was urged to promote a general and snapped "yes yes I know he's brilliant but is he lucky?"

 


One more point

Putitout Flag Oxford 21 Sep 20 11.27am

My problem with this deal is not Brewster,s ability. But what seems to be the widely reported conditions Liverpool are putting in to it. A buy back. And a sell on. And £20 mill.
Talk about have your cake and eat it.

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 21 Sep 20 11.36am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

He wants more game time. Here he will behind Ayew and Bats, unless he takes his likely limited opportunities and forces his way in through weight of goals.
I just can't see why he would come here unless Wilf is heading out the door.

That’s exactly what I think. He’s never going to play every week, especially given Roy’s way of signing players and then leaving them on the bench which unfortunately means coming to us would be a bad move for him.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Sep 20 11.40am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

However you could add we always end up being shafted by Liverpool in the transfer market.

Do you know, the more I think about it, the more I am prepared to take a bit of a shafting from Liverpool if it means we have him for a few seasons and he is allowed to grow as a player for club and country rather than have his career destroyed - like many others - by pointlessly languishing in a big club's reserves.

That said, I do appreciate this is not my money and I will not personally be in receipt of said scouse shaft.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Sep 20 11.43am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

He wants more game time. Here he will behind Ayew and Bats, unless he takes his likely limited opportunities and forces his way in through weight of goals.
I just can't see why he would come here unless Wilf is heading out the door.

Injuries.

Remember who you support.

 

SurbsEagle Flag 21 Sep 20 11.58am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I'm not sure that anyone (except Painter) would agree with you. Other descriptive terms like "adequately" may be more appropriate as you have obviously forgotten the times when we didn't bother to replace departing strikers or when defensive shortages meant having to use Jeffrey Schlupp as a central defender

The one thing that Parish seems to have in abundance is luck as a less lucky chairman would have had his club relegated with the past purchasing deficiencies

You can't do that. When things go bad it's because the chairman was not up to the job, when things go good it's because he is lucky. No, it's because he has taken this club from the brink of non-existence to an established premier league club which will have (hopefully soon) an improved stadium, top category rated academy and a decent first team squad. All the while, managing to balance the books fairly well.
Also, given the evidence that we are still in the Premier League, we clearly didn't need to replace the departed/injured players at that time. Yes, we needed to eventually replace these players but as we currently stand, we have multiple players for each position in the squad and still have money to spend.

At some point, the negative palace fans will have to admit that he has done a decent job with our club. Like it or not...

 

elky30 Flag Clapham 21 Sep 20 12.17pm

Sky Sports have confirmed we have made a bid.
19 mil + 6 in add ons
Buy back of 37 for Liverpool!

 

JohnB Flag 21 Sep 20 12.18pm

I'm doing some work with Liverpool at the moment and they're expecting him to move this week, early next week at the latest.

No idea if it's to us or not but was told we have been working on him for months. Who I'm speaking to have no idea about the details of any transfer in terms of buy backs etc as they would never be involved in that.

They have been analysing some centre backs which will come in as a result of him and one other going out. Likely to be Origi as the other out perm or Minamino on a loan out with a decent loan fee.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Sep 20 12.20pm

Originally posted by Putitout

My problem with this deal is not Brewster,s ability. But what seems to be the widely reported conditions Liverpool are putting in to it. A buy back. And a sell on. And £20 mill.
Talk about have your cake and eat it.

The problem is Liverpool are in a position to implement those conditions, we, unfortunately are one of many clubs that have to accept them , if we want up and coming prospects. As and when our Academy starts producing this may not be the case. Until then, I fear, we must suck it up

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 21 Sep 20 12.53pm

Originally posted by elky30

Sky Sports have confirmed we have made a bid.
19 mil + 6 in add ons
Buy back of 37 for Liverpool!

Not too sure about the buy-back but the offer sounds like a really good one, more than I was expecting. Can’t see anyone else going that high.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 21 Sep 20 12.59pm

Originally posted by elky30

Sky Sports have confirmed we have made a bid.
19 mil + 6 in add ons
Buy back of 37 for Liverpool!

Has the ingredients of a great deal all round although the buy back can be negotiated up to over £40m

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 21 Sep 20 1.00pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

Has the ingredients of a great deal all round although the buy back can be negotiated up to over £40m

Hopefully!

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Sep 20 1.04pm

Originally posted by SurbsEagle


You can't do that. When things go bad it's because the chairman was not up to the job, when things go good it's because he is lucky. No, it's because he has taken this club from the brink of non-existence to an established premier league club which will have (hopefully soon) an improved stadium, top category rated academy and a decent first team squad. All the while, managing to balance the books fairly well.
Also, given the evidence that we are still in the Premier League, we clearly didn't need to replace the departed/injured players at that time. Yes, we needed to eventually replace these players but as we currently stand, we have multiple players for each position in the squad and still have money to spend.

At some point, the negative palace fans will have to admit that he has done a decent job with our club. Like it or not...

I don't think that anyone will dispute the fact that he has done a decent job but your original post said "I think the club has handled our business in the Premier League perfectly" and it was the word "perfectly" that I was disputing and I most certainly dispute your phrase that "given the evidence that we are still in the Premier League, we clearly didn't need to replace the departed/injured players at that time" as many will agree that we scraped through the year that we had no fit strikers more by luck than by judgement

 

JohnB Flag 21 Sep 20 1.13pm

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

Not too sure about the buy-back but the offer sounds like a really good one, more than I was expecting. Can’t see anyone else going that high.

The buy back will have an expiration date, like Nathan Ake's one. We have to hope that at that point, Liverpool have other needs instead of upfront.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Sep 20 1.32pm

A buy back clause is terrible.

In affect, if he becomes a star he's not really our player.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

AERO Flag 21 Sep 20 1.39pm

But if he does well club do well ,and hopefully we can bring in our ownyoung talent along the way not ideal but like the idea

 

RASCAL Flag Purley 21 Sep 20 1.48pm

Parish has just put on his Twitter account that he has asked Sky to take down this bulletin as we haven't made a formal or informal bid....

 


Peace and stability

Cpfc1861 Flag 21 Sep 20 1.49pm

For those who don't understand a buy back clause doesn't mean we have to accept Liverpool bid it essentially means if we were to accept a bid for him from say arsenal in the future Liverpool would have the right to trigger a 37 million bid if they wished then it would be up to the player. Premier league rules forbid purchase and sale of player in the same window so its unlikely they will do this for extra money.

 

Page 6 of 14 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic