This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
You should worry about the longer term consequences of complete intolerance of views that don't suit certain narratives. Intolerance so bad that people cannot function effectively once tainted. How many others have been treated in a totally intolerant way? I've no idea what this has to do with me or my post.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I've no idea what this has to do with me or my post. You changed your mind on Rowling, can you now see this has happened/is happening to others? That was the point.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
You changed your mind on Rowling, can you now see this has happened/is happening to others? That was the point. I've never denied it happens to others, so yes I can. I'm fairly sure in this thread alone I've referenced the lecturer who lost her job.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
You should worry about the longer term consequences of complete intolerance of views that don't suit certain narratives. Intolerance so bad that people cannot function effectively once tainted. How many others have been treated in a totally intolerant way?
But yes, take the monument issue was instance. The principled stance would be to acknowledge history and create room for sensible discussion rather than silence it or damage it. One interesting aspect of this statue now, is that it still exists, and has even more monetary and historical value than it ever did. Much like in the US with the confederate monuments, most of which which erected well after the fact as a thumb in the eye to black people, this action was a thumb in the eye in the other direction,. As is life.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
You should worry about the longer term consequences of complete intolerance of views that don't suit certain narratives. Intolerance so bad that people cannot function effectively once tainted. How many others have been treated in a totally intolerant way? Also, there are certainly issues with social media networks cherry picking what stays and what goes. They actually create a more and more polarised environment that people feel the need to opt into in such a binary fashion, then act like there is a problem with the behaviour of their users. They have helped craft how utterly uncompromising, one dimensional and 'wish list' both the considerable minority of those on the left and right have become in their view of life and society.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Yeah, it's called changing your opinion based on new information - you should give it a try some time. If you read the thread, you'll see there were some interesting examples shared by other posters, and I was advised on how her involvement in the films is very different to an ordinary author - I already acknowledged I'm no real fan of the franchise, so this was news to me. It was a good exchange, not ruined by someone posting the same one-liners on repeat with no interest in discussion. Refreshing. Oh really? I don't think Rowling ever had anything to answer for. What you mean is that you and others jumped on a band waggon, and now you are feeling a bit stupid. All power to her for expressing an opinion held by the vast majority of ordinary people. Time to put the blue haired loons in their place.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I just wonder how many “cancel Rowling” activists have children, in particular daughters. This has already happened in several branches of Primark - a shop beloved of pubescent/pre-pubescent girls with communal changing rooms - one was actually masturbating (with his 'femail' p****, of course)
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Oh really? I don't think Rowling ever had anything to answer for. What you mean is that you and others jumped on a band waggon, and now you are feeling a bit stupid. All power to her for expressing an opinion held by the vast majority of ordinary people. Time to put the blue haired loons in their place. What bandwagon did I jump on?
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Oh really? I don't think Rowling ever had anything to answer for. All power to her for expressing an opinion held by the vast majority of ordinary people. Time to put the blue haired loons in their place. He's made perfectly reasonable point and a rare as hens teeth take on HOL. Someone who has looked at their view on a topic and adjusted it based on taking on board different perspective. If you're going to chastise someone as 'stupid' for doing something that exists on another planet from your conduct (thinking beyond ones own perpetually stuck, self interest) then that's s sad state of affairs. You're literally berating someone for showing a positive quality.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I just wonder how many “cancel Rowling” activists have children, in particular daughters. JK Rowing should be able to say what she likes; she's a reasonable woman not hate filled as she is portrayed by some. Beyond activists and tweeting twits, I don't really see any indication that most trans types are particularly enraged by her outlook of wanting to ensure that the rights and safety of biological women aren't lost to the point of assuming someones sex based on their appearance is somehow laughably crime of the century.
I do see this as being 'somewhat' contrived and media driven, because if a male to female who looked exactly like a female went into a womens toilet they would not be judged as a danger, (even if their biological sex was known). People would not imagine that they're perpetually on the verge of sexual assault. Should someone like Blaire White be forced to use a mens toilet for instance? There would likely be more danger in that, than using a womens loo. I'm not sure there are enough trans people that we look at this issue in a reasoned light, as we seem very keen on 'blaming them' for perverted behaviour that would happen regardless and rarely has anything to do with them at all anyway. Just attempting to thread a needle on 'one of those' topics. A nod towards different positions and outlooks would seem to add some value. If of course that means much here nowadays. Edited by BlueJay (07 Jan 2022 7.43pm)
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Fecking hell. No wonder I'm attracted to traditionalism. Oh for the days when blokes dressing up as tarts was all for a bit of a laugh....and what people got up to behind their own doors was for them. It's a relevant point to raise, as I say what bathroom should someone like Blaire White use? Would it seem odd for her to go into the mens room? More sensible a womans? Perhaps people should have to effectively have to have some kind of medical confirmation based on their identity, appearance etc rather than 'self identifying'. The obvious answer would I suppose be a unisex toilet that anyone can use. Who knows. Different perspectives help to reach conclusions. People like her don't exist solely to be mocked and shut away outside of whatever physical oh so traditional interest you might have with them. They may also occasionally also need to take a piss while out. Edited by BlueJay (07 Jan 2022 8.09pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
It's a relevant point to raise, as I say what bathroom should someone like Blaire White use? Would it seem odd for her to go into the mens room? More sensible a womans? Perhaps people should have to effectively have to have some kind of medical confirmation based on their identity, appearance etc rather than 'self identifying'. The obvious answer would I suppose be a unisex toilet that anyone can use. Who knows. Different perspectives help to reach conclusions. People like her don't exist solely to be mocked and shut away outside of whatever physical oh so traditional interest you might have with them. They may also occasionally also need to take a piss while out. Edited by BlueJay (07 Jan 2022 8.09pm) Forgive me...I'm on a couple of cans at the moment so my posts are shorter and to the point. Blaire White is a man who looks like a woman. In my view it should be male facilities.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I just wonder how many “cancel Rowling” activists have children, in particular daughters. I haven't followed this thread, as I consider it all a bit silly, and just an opportunity for people to get onto their soap boxes and bang drums. Change happens. Society evolves. When things swing too far then they will swing back until a sensible position, acceptable to most, is found. But for a moment let's assume that anyone was stupid enough to attempt what you suggest, who would likely attract so much attention they would spend time contemplating their stupidity at her Majesty's pleasure. I don't though for a moment dimmish the impact on any child witnessing such a disgusting act. However, just for a moment consider the reverse situation, which is probably much more likely. Imagine someone who sincerely believes that, although born with male genitalia, they are psychologically female. They act, look and dress like a female. It's only part of their body which isn't. Which toilet should they use? I can imagine your "Jane's" workmates being really understanding of them hitching their dress up to have a pee at a urinal. Surely it's all about using common sense and judging on what people do, rather than trying to make hard and fast rules?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
It's a relevant point to raise, as I say what bathroom should someone like Blaire White use? Would it seem odd for her to go into the mens room? More sensible a womans? Perhaps people should have to effectively have to have some kind of medical confirmation based on their identity, appearance etc rather than 'self identifying'. The obvious answer would I suppose be a unisex toilet that anyone can use. Who knows. Different perspectives help to reach conclusions. People like her don't exist solely to be mocked and shut away outside of whatever physical oh so traditional interest you might have with them. They may also occasionally also need to take a piss while out. Edited by BlueJay (07 Jan 2022 8.09pm) In the University here, there are men's and lady's toilets, then what were the disabled loos are now also the gender neutral loos.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
In the University here, there are men's and lady's toilets, then what were the disabled loos are now also the gender neutral loos. Sounds sensible enough. In tonnes of pubs and restaurant there are basically non descript individual toilets. Always have been.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I haven't followed this thread, as I consider it all a bit silly, and just an opportunity for people to get onto their soap boxes and bang drums. Change happens. Society evolves. When things swing too far then they will swing back until a sensible position, acceptable to most, is found. But for a moment let's assume that anyone was stupid enough to attempt what you suggest, who would likely attract so much attention they would spend time contemplating their stupidity at her Majesty's pleasure. I don't though for a moment dimmish the impact on any child witnessing such a disgusting act. However, just for a moment consider the reverse situation, which is probably much more likely. Imagine someone who sincerely believes that, although born with male genitalia, they are psychologically female. They act, look and dress like a female. It's only part of their body which isn't. Which toilet should they use? I can imagine your "Jane's" workmates being really understanding of them hitching their dress up to have a pee at a urinal. Surely it's all about using common sense and judging on what people do, rather than trying to make hard and fast rules? These are the genuine transgender people who will usually go on to have gender reassignment surgery, following all the usual hormone therapy that will give them, outwardly, a greater appearance of being female. These are actually quite well accepted in 'female' spaces by women, are never seen as a threat and will generally be left in peace to use changing rooms, lavatories etc without being challenged. It's the hairy arsed, bearded blokes that put on a frock and say that today they are women that real women object to and who, according to reported instances are the real threat to women in what should be their safe spaces.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by becky
These are the genuine transgender people who will usually go on to have gender reassignment surgery, following all the usual hormone therapy that will give them, outwardly, a greater appearance of being female. These are actually quite well accepted in 'female' spaces by women, are never seen as a threat and will generally be left in peace to use changing rooms, lavatories etc without being challenged. It's the hairy arsed, bearded blokes that put on a frock and say that today they are women that real women object to and who, according to reported instances are the real threat to women in what should be their safe spaces. Here here, absolutely bang on. If it looks like a bloke, has balls and a dick I don’t care what it says it is, it’s still a bloke and should not be allowed in womens dressing rooms or toilets. It’s obscene to think otherwise.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by becky
These are the genuine transgender people who will usually go on to have gender reassignment surgery, following all the usual hormone therapy that will give them, outwardly, a greater appearance of being female. These are actually quite well accepted in 'female' spaces by women, are never seen as a threat and will generally be left in peace to use changing rooms, lavatories etc without being challenged. It's the hairy arsed, bearded blokes that put on a frock and say that today they are women that real women object to and who, according to reported instances are the real threat to women in what should be their safe spaces. Yeah, this sounds perfectly fair to me. In whatever walk of life if someone is decent, well intentioned and its clear what they're all about that goes a long way. I'm not sure how best to view it, appearance wise perhaps, maybe proof of transitioning, or whatever. As you say that is a totally different situation than this modern idea that people can access spaces by mentally deciding that they're this or that with absolutely no outside or medical indication of it being anything other than a decision they've made there and then. Edited by BlueJay (07 Jan 2022 9.30pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.