This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by silvertop
very glad none of you gammons are in charge! A trope of a civilized society is how we treat our wrongdoers . That is not "lefty" thinking. That is Winston Churchill. This man was tried after a long process where all the factors were weighed up and an intelligent and proper judgment arrived at based on centuries of built up jurisprudence going back to the Romans. If the AG disagrees after reviewing everything the court viewed, then I will mend my view. Otherwise, the correct judgment even if the relatives of the victims are baying for blood. To me, life in a prison or life doped-up in a different, high walled institution? Similar cost, same outcome. If you Express-fed, frothing, rage-monsters don't like it, perhaps relocate to Alabama? You will be well received there. I'm not sure that you're talking about our society. When Churchill said that, he was talking about a totally different Britain. You think he would put up with this? He'd have the guy shot - no problem. He had several shot for less. Churchill would count it as an attack on Britain itself. So don't bother pontificating about Express readers or foaming at the mouth. Plenty of normal, average people all around you now, wouldn't care one iota if the guy was executed in public or if he accidentally dies in custody. People get angry - it's a normal emotion when faced with utter scum like this. Imagine this happened to one of your own - you'd shrug your shoulders and think - yeah poor sod with issues. You'd want actual punishment - not kid gloves.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
I'm not sure that you're talking about our society. When Churchill said that, he was talking about a totally different Britain. You think he would put up with this? He'd have the guy shot - no problem. He had several shot for less. Churchill would count it as an attack on Britain itself. So don't bother pontificating about Express readers or foaming at the mouth. Plenty of normal, average people all around you now, wouldn't care one iota if the guy was executed in public or if he accidentally dies in custody. People get angry - it's a normal emotion when faced with utter scum like this. Imagine this happened to one of your own - you'd shrug your shoulders and think - yeah poor sod with issues. You'd want actual punishment - not kid gloves. This argument has done the rounds but I will rehash it. The whole fabric of our penal system rests on the base of an arms length impartial "blind" arbiter determining the outcome and not those directly impacted. Of course if it were me and my family I would personally bury him alive. Which is precisely why I cannot criticise the victims' families. Too much hypocrisy. And it is precisely why punishment decisions should be far removed from the likes of me. However that point is incidental. If the court erred it deserves to be pulled up. Otherwise thank whatever you worship or respect that you live in a country with a well established rule of law and largely sensible albeit grossly underfunded judicial system
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
i think you have misquoted a relatively famous saying. "the measure of a civilisation is how it treats its elderly & vulnerable". and i am reading the vulnerable , in this case , to be miss Grace O'Malley Kumar. A defenceless teenager.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
This argument has done the rounds but I will rehash it. The whole fabric of our penal system rests on the base of an arms length impartial "blind" arbiter determining the outcome and not those directly impacted. Of course if it were me and my family I would personally bury him alive. Which is precisely why I cannot criticise the victims' families. Too much hypocrisy. And it is precisely why punishment decisions should be far removed from the likes of me. However that point is incidental. If the court erred it deserves to be pulled up. Otherwise thank whatever you worship or respect that you live in a country with a well established rule of law and largely sensible albeit grossly underfunded judicial system Fair enough.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
very glad none of you gammons are in charge! A trope of a civilized society is how we treat our wrongdoers . That is not "lefty" thinking. That is Winston Churchill. This man was tried after a long process where all the factors were weighed up and an intelligent and proper judgment arrived at based on centuries of built up jurisprudence going back to the Romans. If the AG disagrees after reviewing everything the court viewed, then I will mend my view. Otherwise, the correct judgment even if the relatives of the victims are baying for blood. To me, life in a prison or life doped-up in a different, high walled institution? Similar cost, same outcome. If you Express-fed, frothing, rage-monsters don't like it, perhaps relocate to Alabama? You will be well received there. What an unpleasant post. Of course the relatives are baying for blood. Perfectly justified and reasonable. If this man is going to be locked up for life, then a murder charge should have been delivered in this case. Those three poor souls were doing zero harm to anybody. Their killer was clearly of sound mind enough to murder a van driver and then try to turn his van into a weapon. For the families peace of mind a murder verdict, with the subsequent life sentence should have been sort no matter what.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
No he was of unsound mind, and his sick mind told him what to do. So diminished responsibility I think is correct. It's heart-breaking and unbearable I know, and the opportunities not taken must be investigated for the future. We don't want a society where people are put to death in barbaric fashion out of revenge like Alabama. Don't forget they have occasionally been wrong. Far more people have been killed by released murderers reoffending than by the execution of innocent people.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Far more people have been killed by released murderers reoffending than by the execution of innocent people. far more people have been killed by known family, friends & business associates,....... than ever by some random anonymous nutter with a machete.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
I was thinking that torture and execution with this new method could not only spread to other southern states prisons, but into American society. Neither is it a deterrent, Alabama will continue to have a murder a day. Of course, we get outraged who wouldn't, but torture and murder by the state? No thanks. Yet you are a great admirer of Soviet Russia.
|
|
|
No one should have to pay to keep this slime alive.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
No he was of unsound mind, and his sick mind told him what to do. So diminished responsibility I think is correct. It's heart-breaking and unbearable I know, and the opportunities not taken must be investigated for the future. We don't want a society where people are put to death in barbaric fashion out of revenge like Alabama. Don't forget they have occasionally been wrong. Japan get around that by restricting execution to certainties.....not convictions based upon probability. As this guy is on camera murdering people I'm more than happy for justice to be fast tracked.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
No he was of unsound mind, and his sick mind told him what to do. So diminished responsibility I think is correct. It's heart-breaking and unbearable I know, and the opportunities not taken must be investigated for the future. We don't want a society where people are put to death in barbaric fashion out of revenge like Alabama. Don't forget they have occasionally been wrong. Who is 'We' ??
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Japan get around that by restricting execution to certainties.....not convictions based upon probability. As this guy is on camera murdering people I'm more than happy for justice to be fast tracked. I totally agree in such circumstances.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
No he was of unsound mind, and his sick mind told him what to do. So diminished responsibility I think is correct. It's heart-breaking and unbearable I know, and the opportunities not taken must be investigated for the future. Don't forget they have occasionally been wrong. Nor do I. The problem is he is a hazard to everyone around him. So how are they protected? Keep him bound or drugged up? A painless death would surely be preferable to everyone including him.
I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Japan get around that by restricting execution to certainties.....not convictions based upon probability. As this guy is on camera murdering people I'm more than happy for justice to be fast tracked. Japan is an extremely measured society, crime is low and reoffending rates also low. They execute certain guilt for barbaric crimes. In the UK if there was a referendum and the result was affirmative parliament would never pass the legislation as MP's don't feel a need to do what their electors want as the electoral system doesn't give them enough incentive to do other than act or their own desires. The Swiss system is half way there but is only reactive to legislation already in effect Meantime we have people who do the most terrible things and then live out their lives at considerable expense to the taxpayer. Who could not support death for things like the killing of Lee Rigby. Last yougov poll was 50% against, 40% pro and 10% unsure in 2022 Don't confuse revenge with accountability Edited by HKOwen (27 Jan 2024 9.16am) Edited by HKOwen (27 Jan 2024 9.17am)
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Who could not support death for things like the killing of Lee Rigby.
Edited by HKOwen (27 Jan 2024 9.17am) Lots of Marxists would object, 'cos you is a racist' did one of the Lee Rigby killers give a speech at a 'Hope not hate' rally ? we have a photograph below of him participating at one of their rallies.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.