You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Spurs match thread
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Spurs match thread


Page 6 of 10 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
stancummins Flag 28 Oct 23 8.27am

Ultimately Roy has given himself a green pass to continue to pick the same starting 11 each week (unless Olise or Eze suddenly become available) his argument will be that he gave the bench warmers a chance last night and they were basically rubbish. Absolute crazy statement for him to make. I was never a supporter of him being re appointed the end of last season even though we had a good run against lesser opposition, and giving him another year extension was crazy. To set up for a Palace nil at home whether its against Spurs or Fulham or Forest lacks any ambition and flies against what Parish said pre match about Palace being an exciting place to be .At the moment its get 10 men behind the ball at all costs .It really is time for change and to give it a go and find a manager who is willing to do it

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 28 Oct 23 8.48am

We played well for a large proportion of the game and troubled their goal more than they did ours until they scored which then allowed them to take control. But there was little or no quality or cutting edge at the end of our attacks.

When we pressed (as we were encouraged to by the crowd) they picked us off and scored the second goal.

If we go toe to toe with the current line up against anyone half decent it will be really ugly.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (28 Oct 2023 8.50am)

 

dg1937 Flag 28 Oct 23 8.51am

Rak-Sakyi had a limited impact, in part, because whenever he got the ball in a promising position he was fouled (even though the ref didn’t give most of them). He needs to bulk up and get more upper body strength so he can shrug off some of these ‘robust’ challenges. Franca didn’t really get many opportunities and was a little anonymous I thought.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Oct 23 8.51am

Originally posted by stancummins

Ultimately Roy has given himself a green pass to continue to pick the same starting 11 each week (unless Olise or Eze suddenly become available) his argument will be that he gave the bench warmers a chance last night and they were basically rubbish. Absolute crazy statement for him to make. I was never a supporter of him being re appointed the end of last season even though we had a good run against lesser opposition, and giving him another year extension was crazy. To set up for a Palace nil at home whether its against Spurs or Fulham or Forest lacks any ambition and flies against what Parish said pre match about Palace being an exciting place to be .At the moment its get 10 men behind the ball at all costs .It really is time for change and to give it a go and find a manager who is willing to do it

This is an important point. Roy's supporters point to this period to illustrate what a fine attack minded manager Roy can be, but the cold fact is that up to that point PV had done all the hard work to maintain 12th place in a difficult run of games - Roy came in coincidentally just when we had to play the teams below us, and yes, new manager bounce ensured a happy end to the season.
This season reality is starting to bite, as Roy sticks to his tried and tested formula of negation first. it's all very predictable and I suppose one could make a thousand and one reasons either way, for or against, but anyone who expected some sort of renaissance under Roy I'm afraid to say you have deluded yourself.
I was actually in favour of Roy taking charge for another season, mainly because I'm a realist and there was no one else in the short space of time to appoint. Roy offered a safe short term solution and the likelihood of another season in the PL. Looking forward is another matter.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 28 Oct 23 8.58am

Originally posted by stancummins

Ultimately Roy has given himself a green pass to continue to pick the same starting 11 each week (unless Olise or Eze suddenly become available) his argument will be that he gave the bench warmers a chance last night and they were basically rubbish. Absolute crazy statement for him to make. I was never a supporter of him being re appointed the end of last season even though we had a good run against lesser opposition, and giving him another year extension was crazy. To set up for a Palace nil at home whether its against Spurs or Fulham or Forest lacks any ambition and flies against what Parish said pre match about Palace being an exciting place to be .At the moment its get 10 men behind the ball at all costs .It really is time for change and to give it a go and find a manager who is willing to do it

Im sure we will be 'giving it a go' when Eze and Olise are back .Roy will play the way that has the best chance of points and wasn't far off one last night . Going toe to toe with Spurs with the players we have available would have been a confidence sapping train wreck .
We now have a few games coming up where we should pick up points and I reckon most of us will be delighted to be mid table come the new year .With the return of our best players we will have a platform to push on and achieve the pre season forecast of a top ten finish

As for the interview if you don't want daft answers don't ask daft questions . I think Roy was just pointing out that our bench doesn't offer anything but fresh legs and that our starting 11 is as good as it gets .
If that upsets the players that came on then tough ,its professional sport and if they have anything about them will do something about it .

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 28 Oct 23 9.03am

Let’s not forget that Viera did not use Eze properly. Roy did. Other than that not much. Roy no good in the transfer market. Viera brought good young players in. Was pleased when Roy left first time around, needs to retire.

 

stancummins Flag 28 Oct 23 9.24am

I just remember the last half a season that Roy was in charge of when we were in lockdown and how dire and negative that was . Then we brought in PV and we had a new refreshing brand of football where we showed some ambition regardless of who was available . Now Roy is back it has gone right out of the window , and it has had a negative impact on the atmosphere in the stadium especially for the last three games , that is because the fans are getting nothing to get excited about, last night fans were booing spurs for playing back to and fro to the keeper when they were 2 0 up, they were doing nothing wrong it was down to us to go get the ball but the players were to frightened to break their lines and the front three kept looking at the bench to see what to do .The shackles need to come off

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 28 Oct 23 9.29am

Originally posted by CT Charlie

I feel like quite the contrarian.

1) Without Ebz and Olise, we earned 11 corners to 2 for Spurs.
2) We allowed the team at the top of the table, only 1 shot on target, while outshooting them 13 to 10.
3) We gave a handful of young, unproven attackers plenty of valuable, high-pressure minutes.
4) If you see Roy's comments about the young players IN CONTEXT, it doesn't sound hyper-critical. Overall, he sounded supportive and sympathetic to their situation.

If Roy is feeling peeved, it's because (like us fans) he wishes the club had shored up its defensive ranks this summer, and perhaps found some experienced depth in attack. Mostly, though, he's been dealt a harsh hand, missing our two most skilled players for a substantial part of the season to date.


I was with you until point four but disagree thereafter.

I'm not sure in what context the comments he made could be deemed supportive and sympathetic. It sounded to me very much like he was pinning the defeat on young, inexperienced players who came into the game when we were already losing.

Why he'd have a pop at them rather than our captain, who scored a dreadful own goal to put us behind and then was at 6s and 7s for the second goal, down his side, is beyond me.

And as for him wishing the club had invested more in the summer, he shouldn't have come out the day after the transfer window and said that us fans should be happy with our lot.

Ultimately the reason he is kept in charge is because he will grind out enough points to keep us up whilst putting zero pressure on the owners to spend. A new manager wouldn't put up with it.

Edited by Canterbury Palace (28 Oct 2023 9.29am)

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

PatrickA Flag London 28 Oct 23 9.31am

I watched Roy’s press conference and felt he was unduly harsh on the young players who came on.
The experienced players also didn’t play well after Spurs went two up and I thought the heads dropped until the brief rally at the end.
Why single out the youngsters?
At a more fundamental level it’s a failure of the club as by rights Rak Saki should be on loan at a Championship club , but our failure to recruit means he’s a bench warmer thrown on in games often when we’re behind in games and expected to be the game changer.
Ahamada is also only used when we fall behind.

What was evident to me yesterday was the lack of speed and energy in our team.
Hughes tries hard but hasn’t got the legs to play attacking midfield as he did yesterday.
I think to an extent Schlupp’s legs have gone and he seems unable to provide the thrust and make those driving runs which he did in the past.
Perhaps a case of age and injuries catching up.

With regard to Roy, he’s fine in terms of setting up a structure to contain teams , but once we fall behind he struggles.
His conservative instincts mean he worries about pushing forward and then going two goals down.
However, staying with the same pattern of play means you’ve no chance of equalising.
He doesn’t seem to have cracked this conundrum.
I’m not being too critical for him.
Without Olise, Eze and Zaha it’s necessary to have some realism about our lack of attacking threat.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 28 Oct 23 9.52am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I watched Roy’s press conference and felt he was unduly harsh on the young players who came on.
The experienced players also didn’t play well after Spurs went two up and I thought the heads dropped until the brief rally at the end.
Why single out the youngsters?
At a more fundamental level it’s a failure of the club as by rights Rak Saki should be on loan at a Championship club , but our failure to recruit means he’s a bench warmer thrown on in games often when we’re behind in games and expected to be the game changer.
Ahamada is also only used when we fall behind.

What was evident to me yesterday was the lack of speed and energy in our team.
Hughes tries hard but hasn’t got the legs to play attacking midfield as he did yesterday.
I think to an extent Schlupp’s legs have gone and he seems unable to provide the thrust and make those driving runs which he did in the past.
Perhaps a case of age and injuries catching up.

With regard to Roy, he’s fine in terms of setting up a structure to contain teams , but once we fall behind he struggles.
His conservative instincts mean he worries about pushing forward and then going two goals down.
However, staying with the same pattern of play means you’ve no chance of equalising.
He doesn’t seem to have cracked this conundrum.
I’m not being too critical for him.
Without Olise, Eze and Zaha it’s necessary to have some realism about our lack of attacking threat.

Agreed. At least we gave it a go for some of the game unlike last week where we just didn’t turn up. Desperately need a few positives like Olise &/or Eze coming back.

 

Oxford Don Flag North West of SP 28 Oct 23 9.54am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I watched Roy’s press conference and felt he was unduly harsh on the young players who came on.
The experienced players also didn’t play well after Spurs went two up and I thought the heads dropped until the brief rally at the end.
Why single out the youngsters?
At a more fundamental level it’s a failure of the club as by rights Rak Saki should be on loan at a Championship club , but our failure to recruit means he’s a bench warmer thrown on in games often when we’re behind in games and expected to be the game changer.
Ahamada is also only used when we fall behind.

What was evident to me yesterday was the lack of speed and energy in our team.
Hughes tries hard but hasn’t got the legs to play attacking midfield as he did yesterday.
I think to an extent Schlupp’s legs have gone and he seems unable to provide the thrust and make those driving runs which he did in the past.
Perhaps a case of age and injuries catching up.

With regard to Roy, he’s fine in terms of setting up a structure to contain teams , but once we fall behind he struggles.
His conservative instincts mean he worries about pushing forward and then going two goals down.
However, staying with the same pattern of play means you’ve no chance of equalising.
He doesn’t seem to have cracked this conundrum.
I’m not being too critical for him.
Without Olise, Eze and Zaha it’s necessary to have some realism about our lack of attacking threat.

Thoughtful and fair analysis Patrick.

For my part I really worry that what Roy said about the youngsters actually represents an underlying distrust of youth and also what message it sends them. If he - or the club generally - can't work out how to integrate promising but raw young talent into the squad what an earth is the point of the academy or buying in someone like Franca? They should be the future of the club and they need nurturing and support, not unconstructive criticism.

I hope Roy sits down with them on Monday and makes good any damage or otherwise we could lose them.

 


You can't change the way things are but you can change the way you are with the way things are.

Wright stuff Flag Bexley 28 Oct 23 9.59am

Disgraceful undermining any player it leads to disharmony in the squad & tends to ‘rollercoaster’.
Did not expect us to beat Spurs, however if we had some sort of an attack we would have won the game in the first half.
Blame the board, not Hodgson.
Both wing backs are not good enough, especially Ward.
The Midfield 3 are gritty & hardworking however are all CDM’s with no flair.
Palace should not have gone into the season relying on 2 players. Eze has been injured 3 times in 3 seasons, so I would hazard a guess will be plagued with injury in the future.
Will Olise return as before with after such an injury ?
Our best 3 players are the 2 centre backs & Goalkeeper. I suspect both CB’s will leave at the end of the season no matter how hard we try to keep them as they are probably the best in the league. Why stay at a club that seems to have no ambition & looks like we are just trying to stay in the division so the new stand can be built.
I’m disillusioned as previous writers. There is a long term vision, however you need to keep sight of the short term as well, otherwise we could find ourselves in the championship.
Need points in the next few games as the December fixtures are extremely difficult even if Eze & Olise are back.
Rant over!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Oct 23 10.07am

All teams have injuries.
Roy's answer is to double down and play even more negatively. And, when the opposition take the lead, do nothing because there's no contingency plan beyond holding for a 0-0. Start every game with players past their prime, leave subs too late, and lambast the substitutions for not rescuing the game that the past it players had lost.
A true professional, and never Roy's fault. We need to move on from this. I can envisage a time soon when our most gifted players will be thinking about a career elsewhere, as there's not much to be had with mere survival tactics playing negative football. And then it's back to square one. Of course this is the conundrum Parish has to seriously think about if he wishes to fill his 34000 seater stadium.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 28 Oct 23 10.07am

I wonder how many of the posters who in the run-up to the match said that they'd "bite your arm off for 0-0" are the same who are now bitterly compaining that Roy set the team up for a 0-0 draw, lacks ambition, etc., etc.

I'm certainly one of those arm biters, and I'm disappointed we didn't get the 0-0, but we gave it a very good go in the first half. Nobody has mentioned what seemed clear to me, that the Spurs players looked after the interval as if they'd had something unpleasant rammed up their posteriors. Son in particular was racing about like the proverbial blue-arsed fly. Under pressure from a very classy side, own goals happen.

 

SpyroCrystal 28 Oct 23 10.15am

We did our best, need Eze and Olise back. OG killed us

 


Big up the Palace!!!!

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 28 Oct 23 10.16am

I think it is very hard for any player to make an impact as an attacking player, and even harder for the younger players, JRS, Franca and Ahamada should start against start against Burnley, so we can see if when everyone is starting cold they perform

------Ayew
Franca-Ahamada-JRS

We are not losing much dropping Hughes, Schlupp and Edouard, they will be on the bench if needed.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Putitout Flag Oxford 28 Oct 23 10.27am

Lots of .Roy this, Roy that , Roy should have talk. But personally I don’t think he has any reason to feel overly excited by the young players on our bench. I get the feeling he knows this is his swan song, so why not confirm what he actually thinks.
We held Spurs very well until the own goal, only because of Roy’s tactics, with more quality we could have scored and possibly beaten them, but we don’t have that quality right now, it was there for all to see on three or four occasions. A forward line with Olise, Eze, and dare I say Wilf, could have won that game under Hodgson.
No matter how Hodgson voices it , our young substitutes are not good enough to improve us in most games. Spurs bring on the full armoury of international talent, as all the top half sides can do ,we bring on three kids trying to make their way in the game,and a has been to try and rescue a lost cause. Maybe he chose some wrong words, but he must be frustrated by the situation.
For me when it comes to wanting to compete in this league the young players are not good enough, certainly yet, and that’s what Hodgson is actually saying. Not to say they couldn’t be but more work needs doing away from the pressure of games like the last two..
In the over all losing to a good Spurs side is not the end of the world, what worries me is that without Eze, and Olise , we don’t look like we can score often enough to beat many top half sides . Outside of some clever stuff from Ayew, the rest were pedestrian , hard to know how a manager can alter that.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Oct 23 10.29am

It doesn't take long for the mob to start whining about Roy Hodgson.

He was right about our subs. Rak Saki is lightweight and I hope Franca was suffering first night nerves because he was appalling.


The fact is that we are suffering, as usual, from a lack of signings.

Our forwards are bang average, Joel Ward is 5 seasons past the point where we should have replaced him, we have no proper cover for Mitchell, and without Olise and Eze we are incapable of producing sustained pressure or have any pace or creativity at all in the midfield.

The squad cannot cope with injuries to key players, and Roy cannot be blamed for that. I do feel that he should have made substitutions after we went behind, but judging by the contribution from the subs, it would have made no difference anyway.
The bigger picture is that with players coming back, we be a lot better, but we do need to sign a left and right back and a striker.
For how many more windows will we be saying that?

 

rikz Flag Croydon 28 Oct 23 10.31am

I agree with Roy, rak sakyi is terrible, I dont know what people see when they watch him but he's nowhere near this level, send him on loan to the championship to continue to develop.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Oct 23 10.40am

Originally posted by Putitout

Lots of .Roy this, Roy that , Roy should have talk. But personally I don’t think he has any reason to feel overly excited by the young players on our bench. I get the feeling he knows this is his swan song, so why not confirm what he actually thinks.
We held Spurs very well until the own goal, only because of Roy’s tactics, with more quality we could have scored and possibly beaten them, but we don’t have that quality right now, it was there for all to see on three or four occasions. A forward line with Olise, Eze, and dare I say Wilf, could have won that game under Hodgson.
No matter how Hodgson voices it , our young substitutes are not good enough to improve us in most games. Spurs bring on the full armoury of international talent, as all the top half sides can do ,we bring on three kids trying to make their way in the game,and a has been to try and rescue a lost cause. Maybe he chose some wrong words, but he must be frustrated by the situation.
For me when it comes to wanting to compete in this league the young players are not good enough, certainly yet, and that’s what Hodgson is actually saying. Not to say they couldn’t be but more work needs doing away from the pressure of games like the last two..
In the over all losing to a good Spurs side is not the end of the world, what worries me is that without Eze, and Olise , we don’t look like we can score often enough to beat many top half sides . Outside of some clever stuff from Ayew, the rest were pedestrian , hard to know how a manager can alter that.

If this is the case why then did the club spend up to £25m on a relatively untried young Brazilian? How does the club expect Franca to exhibit his potential? I was thinking that Franca would be a starter pretty soon, but Roy has always shown preference to his favourites, and increasingly favourite duffers. Certainly Schlupp no longer brings anything to the party , and as for Ward, he's been Championship material for at least two seasons. Both are guaranteed starters under Roy. Up front Roy still gives Mateta the occasional game, despite him being total pony poo.
Easy to blame the subs, but Roy picks the team and devises the increasingly negative tactics. It really is like Groundhog Day round here.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (28 Oct 2023 10.47am)

 

Page 6 of 10 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Spurs match thread