This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Matov
None of them Socialist. In fact, Soclialist is double speak. And the NSDAP, or as you might know it the Nazi's, only included the words 'Socialist' and 'Workers' for a laugh. The definition of irony and, as everybody knows, the Germans are world famous for their sense of humour. Ditto with the Bolsheviks. The REAL socialists would never actually include the word in the name because then it's not actually socialist. A bit like the modern day Conservative Party wants to conserve f*** all. And Labour would rather NONE of you actually went to work. As to the 'Lib Dems'....lets not even go there. And 2 plus 2 is not actually 4. Just in the same way that Eddie Izzard is in fact, when it suits, a lady. OK, so who were, or are, socialist countries?
|
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
please don't bore us with your ignorance of history. There are many discredited ideologies, including both of those mentioned above. and the Nazi's WERE socialists because both have been AntiSemitic violent cv.nts. Uncle Joe...Stalin was every bit as AntiSemitic and genocidal as the rest of them. Edited by PalazioVecchio (12 Nov 2023 9.45pm) Edited by PalazioVecchio (12 Nov 2023 9.53pm) You mean like social conservatives are socialists?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
OK, so who were, or are, socialist countries?
Because TRUE socialism has never been tried. Hence why you cannot berate Lefties just because countries have claimed to be socialist and then go on to murder millions of people and start global conflicts. All a cunning trick. And the laughs on YOU for even thinking it. In fact, it is a sign of being a NAZI (which is not socialist in any way, shape or form).
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You mean like social conservatives are socialists? Or like dogs are dogmatic or cats are caterers.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
The REAL socialists would never actually include the word in the name because then it's not actually socialist. A bit like the modern day Conservative Party wants to conserve f*** all. And Labour would rather NONE of you actually went to work. As to the 'Lib Dems'....lets not even go there. Sinn Féin....translates as 'we ourselves' The most multiculturalist party on the whole island. You may as well have called the party 'Siad ansin' Them lot over there. And funny enough, relevant to the OP, Sinn Fein are Socialist-Liberals.....who march up and down in military uniform, deny freedom of speech and could kneecap you if you question their wisdom. Sinn Fein...Palestine..the Catholic Party with a leader proudly photographed wearing a hijab. AntiSemitic. The Left is the new Fascists. Edited by PalazioVecchio (12 Nov 2023 10.17pm)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Because TRUE socialism has never been tried. Hence why you cannot berate Lefties just because countries have claimed to be socialist and then go on to murder millions of people and start global conflicts. All a cunning trick. And the laughs on YOU for even thinking it. In fact, it is a sign of being a NAZI (which is not socialist in any way, shape or form). We agree about something! Socialism is a very broad term. Broader even than Conservatism. Claiming your interpretation of it as the truth is as illogical as any religion claiming theirs is the only true god.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Or like dogs are dogmatic or cats are caterers. Pretty much!
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by inflikted
Speaking as someone with a master's degree in politics who studied radical political theory, I can tell you that is extremely oversimplified and limited view of it. Far Right politics involves highly performative nationalism, ostracising those deemed as "other" in a "them vs us" mentality, extreme social conservatism, desire for homogeny and hostility towards freedom of speech and protest if it opposes your views. Isn’t this, bar social conservatism, just a description of the left today? That’s also assuming multiculturalism (or the support for it) can be used in the place of nationalism, in its being highly performative and providing a common identity. Of course they’ve gone one further in not only being hostile to the freedom of speech but also pushing the forcible use of language (pronouns etc). It feels a bit similar to declaring that promoting or arguing the case for indigenous peoples is ‘far right’ but then supporting the case for Palestinians? Don’t these groups also have sincere hostility towards Jews just like the Nazis too? Or have I got that wrong? Genuine questions.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Isn’t this, bar social conservatism, just a description of the left today? That’s also assuming multiculturalism (or the support for it) can be used in the place of nationalism, in its being highly performative and providing a common identity. Of course they’ve gone one further in not only being hostile to the freedom of speech but also pushing the forcible use of language (pronouns etc). It feels a bit similar to declaring that promoting or arguing the case for indigenous peoples is ‘far right’ but then supporting the case for Palestinians? Don’t these groups also have sincere hostility towards Jews just like the Nazis too? Or have I got that wrong? Genuine questions. Nah it's very complicated but the far right should perhaps be better described as the authoritarian right - if you use political compass theory rather than the spectrum (or more embarrassingly, horseshoe theory which a few on here seem to subscribe to). Left and right are generally more for economic matters - the right favour total deregulation of markets and believe that the market will police itself (in its most extreme form advocating for trickle-down economics, the believe that wealth will naturally flow down the social order if those at the top get rich enough), along with non-intervention (or laissez-faire) approach to non-essential services (quite what is deemed non-essential varies as seen by the US view that healthcare is non-essential) - conversely, the economic left favours regulation of the markets to prevent abuse, state running of essential services, and government intervention to ensure that money reaches the lowest earners in society to prevent wealth getting hoarded at the top. Social attitudes *can* (but rarely does) fall into left/right too on matters relating to social change, as conservatives prefer to keep things as they are/were where as socially progressives advocate that change is good. However this isn't always the case, or it gets misinterpreted, as it is easily possible to be economically left wing yet socially conservative (see: China), or economically right wing yet socially liberal (see: America most of the time). Then we get to the authoritarian/libertarian split. The Authoritarians prefer authority and cultural hegemony (to the point of advocating unelected heads of state and governments) in order to ensure law and order in society. The extremety of which varies, with the utmost authoritarians delving into totalitarianism, which involves total control of the population in the name of protecting the peace (state intervention of society is a separate issue entirely to economic state intervention - see how the Nazis favoured private corporations and instead of nationalising them, just gave business owners incentives to support them). Libertarianism in the political compass involves opposing homogeny and promoting people over state for social matters. As such things can be authoritarian left, authoritarian right, liberterian left, libertarian right, centrist or anything in between. Examples of authoritarian left include the Communist Party of Russia and China (although China has embraced free market capitalism and drifted away from the left over time). Authoritarian right examples include the Nazis and most military dictatorships. Libertarian left generally encompasses the majority of anarchist groups (the First and Second Internationals were attempts at uniting anarchists and socialists due to shared opinions on many things, but both collapsed due to key irreconcilable differences) - although there are right wing anarchists like anarcho-capitalists - and most liberal left wing parties today such as the Green Party or modern progressive socialists. Libertarian right tends to involve the US libertarians who believe in total de-regulation and minimising the state to near nothing, or anarcho-capitalists who believe that the state is unnecessary because the capitalist system and free market will be able to meet all of society's needs. I'm really simplifying a lot of this otherwise I'll end up writing an entire book. PS Hitler himself wrote that he chose to call the Nazis national socialist because he wanted to co-opt the term to improve the "electability" of the party. He admitted he opposed socialism in all its forms but knew using the word would get support.
Milkshakes Against Fascism |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Internationalist interests....as can be seen in Ireland for example, are about radically changing a nation to suit their needs.
correct. And big money will always change a little place. To such an extent that it no longer matters who you vote for. Your votes carry no sway. Big money rules the day. All your local politicians are mere Waiters to the corporate boys. And the locals find themselves increasingly marginalised and outnumbered by newcomers. Culturally and ethnically replaced by something international. changing a Local identity into a cross between a Military Base, a Brothel, a Financial district, a gigantic Shopping centre, a Tourist town, a University town, a Soho/Chinatown, a retirement community etc. The native locals outnumbered ten to one. Mostly the locals are powerless and do nothing. Occasionally they balk against their Corporate oppressors and you get the Cuban Revolution. Las Vegas, Isle of Man, Bermuda, Ibiza, Hawaii, Venice.....now Ireland too. And London. Hypothetically, if a Far Right Ethnic Londoner party was born....say 'The Cockney Party' it wouldnt even matter anymore. Sadiq Khan would keep his job anyway. Which is another reason 'The Far Right' is little more than a few football hooligans howling at the moon on our streets. London has probably more supporters of Manchester United/Liverpool than all the smaller London clubs combined. Sadiq Khan is from Tooting and he supports Liverpool FC. Edited by PalazioVecchio (13 Nov 2023 9.14am)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
correct. And big money will always change a little place. To such an extent that it no longer matters who you vote for. Your votes carry no sway. Big money rules the day. All your local politicians are mere Waiters to the corporate boys. And the locals find themselves increasingly marginalised and outnumbered by newcomers. Culturally and ethnically replaced by something international. changing a Local identity into a cross between a Military Base, a Brothel, a Financial district, a gigantic Shopping centre, a Tourist town, a University town, a Soho/Chinatown, a retirement community etc. The native locals outnumbered ten to one. Mostly the locals are powerless and do nothing. Occasionally they balk against their Corporate oppressors and you get the Cuban Revolution. Las Vegas, Isle of Man, Bermuda, Ibiza, Hawaii, Venice.....now Ireland too. And London. Hypothetically, if a Far Right Ethnic Londoner party was born....say 'The Cockney Party' it wouldnt even matter anymore. Sadiq Khan would keep his job anyway. Which is another reason 'The Far Right' is little more than a few football hooligans howling at the moon on our streets. London has probably more supporters of Manchester United/Liverpool than all the smaller London clubs combined. Sadiq Khan is from Tooting and he supports Liverpool FC. Edited by PalazioVecchio (13 Nov 2023 9.14am) Because Ireland has a relatively small population size compared to England, around 5 to 6 million if I remember correctly that means that these changes become far more noticable far quicker. For anyone with any attachment to being Irish actually meaning anything to them it must be like death by a thousand cuts to watch your leaders sell out. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Nov 2023 9.52am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by inflikted
Nah it's very complicated but the far right should perhaps be better described as the authoritarian right - if you use political compass theory rather than the spectrum (or more embarrassingly, horseshoe theory which a few on here seem to subscribe to). Left and right are generally more for economic matters - the right favour total deregulation of markets and believe that the market will police itself (in its most extreme form advocating for trickle-down economics, the believe that wealth will naturally flow down the social order if those at the top get rich enough), along with non-intervention (or laissez-faire) approach to non-essential services (quite what is deemed non-essential varies as seen by the US view that healthcare is non-essential) - conversely, the economic left favours regulation of the markets to prevent abuse, state running of essential services, and government intervention to ensure that money reaches the lowest earners in society to prevent wealth getting hoarded at the top. Social attitudes *can* (but rarely does) fall into left/right too on matters relating to social change, as conservatives prefer to keep things as they are/were where as socially progressives advocate that change is good. However this isn't always the case, or it gets misinterpreted, as it is easily possible to be economically left wing yet socially conservative (see: China), or economically right wing yet socially liberal (see: America most of the time). Then we get to the authoritarian/libertarian split. The Authoritarians prefer authority and cultural hegemony (to the point of advocating unelected heads of state and governments) in order to ensure law and order in society. The extremety of which varies, with the utmost authoritarians delving into totalitarianism, which involves total control of the population in the name of protecting the peace (state intervention of society is a separate issue entirely to economic state intervention - see how the Nazis favoured private corporations and instead of nationalising them, just gave business owners incentives to support them). Libertarianism in the political compass involves opposing homogeny and promoting people over state for social matters. As such things can be authoritarian left, authoritarian right, liberterian left, libertarian right, centrist or anything in between. Examples of authoritarian left include the Communist Party of Russia and China (although China has embraced free market capitalism and drifted away from the left over time). Authoritarian right examples include the Nazis and most military dictatorships. Libertarian left generally encompasses the majority of anarchist groups (the First and Second Internationals were attempts at uniting anarchists and socialists due to shared opinions on many things, but both collapsed due to key irreconcilable differences) - although there are right wing anarchists like anarcho-capitalists - and most liberal left wing parties today such as the Green Party or modern progressive socialists. Libertarian right tends to involve the US libertarians who believe in total de-regulation and minimising the state to near nothing, or anarcho-capitalists who believe that the state is unnecessary because the capitalist system and free market will be able to meet all of society's needs. I'm really simplifying a lot of this otherwise I'll end up writing an entire book. PS Hitler himself wrote that he chose to call the Nazis national socialist because he wanted to co-opt the term to improve the "electability" of the party. He admitted he opposed socialism in all its forms but knew using the word would get support. So yes that mirrors a lot of my understanding (but with far better and accurate articulation than I could muster so kudos) however I have been making an underlying point. Neither the alleged 'far right' as we saw yesterday nor much of the loudest voices most prevalent in society, sometimes literally screaming these days, really fit well into binary political monikers of left/right. I would dare to suggest blokes fighting Police in the streets under the influence or those wanting to impose their totalitarian, radical, social thinking on the world aren't defined by their economic policies... not on the ground anyway. It's a sad state of affairs and one I have long feared, whereby the further to the so called 'left' society has drifted (I'm now using it as a blanket), the more this has begun resembling totalitarianism and the more extreme opposition it will provoke. The term 'silent majority' is one I also consider to be incorrectly employed as I would suggest it should be used to identify those who want neither factions of extremist thinking to be anywhere close to power and who staunchly oppose authoritarianism/totalitarianism. As it stands, we do have one of these groups dictating things unfortunately. The more they do, the more any opposing voice will be designated as 'far right' as this is the common tactic of any extremist thinking - to paint themselves as 'moderate' and any opposition as the extreme. If (big if) society begins to further oppose the authoritarian/totalitarian 'left', and the more they are told they are 'far right', the more resembling of this moniker they will become. Personally, I strongly dislike the current and evermore concerning zeitgeist. With the same emotion, I fear the uprising of an authoritarian right as an equal reaction to it's continued existence. What we saw over the weekend however was not this, although it may always be the early, very mild rumblings indicative of something to follow. It will just be a reaction to the initial action in any instance though. Edited by Nicholas91 (13 Nov 2023 11.08am)
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I predicted at the start of this thread that no one here would engage or admit to being far right. I was wrong about both. There has been one who has been honest enough to accept the epithet and lots of engagement. Unfortunately almost all of it a liturgy of denial blended with the usual insults. People never like to see themselves as extreme. They always believe they are part of the majority in the middle. However far right others see you as, you don’t as there are always others even more extreme than you. Then along comes someone with obvious specialist knowledge which causes a few worried responses. How do we counter this? They know their stuff. Deny? Insult? We cannot argue from strength. We have been rumbled. It’s quite amusing. Sad to witness but still amusing. You're entirely correct. This is the place of the far right. No one else welcome. The security services are monitoring.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
You're entirely correct. This is the place of the far right. No one else welcome. The security services are monitoring. Moreover the service monitors are securing and the secure monitors are servicing. It's a triple threat.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
So yes that mirrors a lot of my understanding (but with far better and accurate articulation than I could muster so kudos) however I have been making an underlying point. Neither the alleged 'far right' as we saw yesterday nor much of the loudest voices most prevalent in society, sometimes literally screaming these days, really fit well into binary political monikers of left/right. I would dare to suggest blokes fighting Police in the streets under the influence or those wanting to impose their totalitarian, radical, social thinking on the world aren't defined by their economic policies... not on the ground anyway. It's a sad state of affairs and one I have long feared, whereby the further to the so called 'left' society has drifted (I'm now using it as a blanket), the more this has begun resembling totalitarianism and the more extreme opposition it will provoke. The term 'silent majority' is one I also consider to be incorrectly employed as I would suggest it should be used to identify those who want neither factions of extremist thinking to be anywhere close to power and who staunchly oppose authoritarianism/totalitarianism. As it stands, we do have one of these groups dictating things unfortunately. The more they do, the more any opposing voice will be designated as 'far right' as this is the common tactic of any extremist thinking - to paint themselves as 'moderate' and any opposition as the extreme. If (big if) society begins to further oppose the authoritarian/totalitarian 'left', and the more they are told they are 'far right', the more resembling of this moniker they will become. Personally, I strongly dislike the current and evermore concerning zeitgeist. With the same emotion, I fear the uprising of an authoritarian right as an equal reaction to it's continued existence. What we saw over the weekend however was not this, although it may always be the early, very mild rumblings indicative of something to follow. It will just be a reaction to the initial action in any instance though. Edited by Nicholas91 (13 Nov 2023 11.08am) Perhaps another way to describe them would be the populist right, which is exactly what the government is right now. But to get into the nuances of populism is a whole different kettle of fish that I am not prepared to take on right now. I already did a 10k word dissertation on the rise of populism in western democracy, I'm not doing it again.
Milkshakes Against Fascism |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Because Ireland has a relatively small population size compared to England, around 5 to 6 million if I remember correctly that means that these changes become far more noticable far quicker. For anyone with any attachment to being Irish actually meaning anything to them it must be like death by a thousand cuts to watch your leaders sell out. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Nov 2023 9.52am) it has less to do with the size of our population, and everything to do with the size of our Welfare Payments. Employers cannot get locals to work for them. Certainly not for any minimum-wage jobs. So they must import a workforce. Added to the enormous numbers who arrive in and go straight onto the Longterm dole. This creates a housing crisis, and thus Irish University leavers all emigrate away....and you have the end of the historic Nation - replaced with something new. Double quick time. And lucrative jobs ? in Tech Giants......like the Premier League, its an international labour market. Only a very small proportion of those jobs go to irish candidates. Just like the tiny proportion of footballers at Palace who have Grandparents from SE25. Lucrative Public sector jobs ? see the link below. 1921 Partitioned Ireland into NI and ROI. Two different nations with different identities. Today its difficult to see much difference between the two. The same shops selling the same stuff with the same staff who never heard of Basil Fawlty. Edited by PalazioVecchio (13 Nov 2023 11.36am)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
You're entirely correct. This is the place of the far right. No one else welcome. The security services are monitoring. Not entirely correct. There are several opposition voices here speaking out for common sense. Somehow I doubt whether the security services pay any attention, although they might be monitoring any members who participate in the type of counter-protest we saw on Saturday.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.