You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread
November 20 2026 3.05pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Benteke thread


Page 64 of 166 < 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 >
Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 05 Apr 18 6.56am

Originally posted by boo909


I think we're way past this now, sad to say. I've been rooting for him for so long now but it's just not happening. I have no problem at all with his game apart from the fact he can't score to save his life anymore, if it's a confidence thing, I honestly don't think dropping him can make it any worse, there's even a small chance of forcing him, psychologically, to prove himself. I think he's a good player, the rest of his game is excellent, his assists, his defensive play can be remarkably good and I'm not at all one of the people on here that thinks he's lazy or doesn't care about the club (one of the more ridiculous opinions on here). But he's our striker, he should be scoring goals, at the very least hitting the target and he's not unfortunately.

Saying that though, I think in hindsight he should have been dropped earlier in the season, at this point it is a risk with what he brings to the team in other areas. So should he be dropped for Sørloth? Your guess is as good as mine but I really think we should be looking to move him on at the end if the season. As I said earlier in this thread, despite how much he's paid, he must be f***ing hating his job at the moment, I'd love to see him go somewhere else and start scoring his arse off (even if it causes us problems next season) but it's just not happening here, for whatever reason.

I was more making the point that dropping him to play with no recognised centre forward wouldn't be a risk worth taking.

If Sorloth looked fully fit and reliable of body, that's an altogether trickier proposition and on balance I too would drop Benteke in that scenario.

If I were Palace, I'd train the bollocks off Benteke in the summer and go on a pre-season tour like Coppell used to do where we're going to win every game 8- 9- 10- nil and he's going to remember the feeling of scoring goals.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 05 Apr 18 7.58am

Originally posted by boo909

Saying that though, I think in hindsight he should have been dropped earlier in the season, at this point it is a risk with what he brings to the team in other areas.

You mean earlier in the season when he was injured?

The problem is that we don’t have cover, which is an absolute schoolboy error, so we are relying on Benteke. Sign a pacy striker or a player to sit just behind Benteke and see how we do then. I mean, most managers have a plan B to fall back on, if not a plan C - we don’t even have a plan A up front at the moment.

We are going to stay up, but we need to make sure we work hard to give our manager something to work with next year. We can’t keep relying on the mercurial talents of an xperienced manager to dig us out of the mess that some other manager has got us into every season.

If we do that, and Benteke still isn’t performing then I will slate him. Whilst we are telegraphing our tactics up front from the start of the season, I think the blame lays elsewhere.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 05 Apr 18 8.43am

Originally posted by dp

You mean earlier in the season when he was injured?

The problem is that we don’t have cover, which is an absolute schoolboy error, so we are relying on Benteke. Sign a pacy striker or a player to sit just behind Benteke and see how we do then. I mean, most managers have a plan B to fall back on, if not a plan C - we don’t even have a plan A up front at the moment.

We are going to stay up, but we need to make sure we work hard to give our manager something to work with next year. We can’t keep relying on the mercurial talents of an xperienced manager to dig us out of the mess that some other manager has got us into every season.

If we do that, and Benteke still isn’t performing then I will slate him. Whilst we are telegraphing our tactics up front from the start of the season, I think the blame lays elsewhere.

He was injured and suspended, but still played a lot of games. We coped as mentioned in previous posts, we played Andros and Wilf up front to great affect....

 

npn Flag Crowborough 05 Apr 18 9.02am

Originally posted by spartakev2

These are all strikers from top 10 teams, how does he compare to strikers in the bottom 6..

That's a fair enough distinction, but I didn't grab them at random, I took the list of the top 10 in terms of "big chances missed" according to the premier league stats page. I suspect most strikers from bottom 6 sides don't have a great number of chances to miss!

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 05 Apr 18 9.12am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

He was injured and suspended, but still played a lot of games. We coped as mentioned in previous posts, we played Andros and Wilf up front to great affect....

The only game that worked with was the chelsea game. The other games we tried that it didn't work very well at all....

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards andyachtie Flag Monte Giberto 05 Apr 18 9.28am

He is top of the league......

[Link]

Originally posted by npn

That's a fair enough distinction, but I didn't grab them at random, I took the list of the top 10 in terms of "big chances missed" according to the premier league stats page. I suspect most strikers from bottom 6 sides don't have a great number of chances to miss!

 

jimboslice Flag New Addington 05 Apr 18 11.00am

I don't post a lot on here, but feel this needs to be said.

It is not a simple case of sell him, don't sell him.

As mentioned his game is fantastic everywhere except finding the back of the net.

If I was Roy I'd be putting him through more drills based around finishing and getting him back to where he was last season with us and three seasons ago with Villa.

He has the ability, just not the mindset at the moment.

But I regret to say, like the De Boer situation. How long is too long...

The fact of the matter is, he is prem quality and he suits our play-style. I can't think of a replacement who would do his job better for his price-tag and wage bill. If you can I am all ears.

Unfortunately all we have is an unproven giant from Iceland who has come in for a big price and you guessed it, he is injured just like the other 50 percent of our first team. Don't get me wrong, I have big hopes for Sorloth, he looks fantastic from what I have seen so far. But he has something to prove. Benteke proved it last in many seasons prior.

Edited by jimboslice (05 Apr 2018 11.03am)

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 05 Apr 18 11.07am

Originally posted by jimboslice

I don't post a lot on here, but feel this needs to be said.

It is not a simple case of sell him, don't sell him.

As mentioned his game is fantastic everywhere except finding the back of the net.

If I was Roy I'd be putting him through more drills based around finishing and getting him back to where he was last season with us and three seasons ago with Villa.

He has the ability, just not the mindset at the moment.

But I regret to say, like the De Boer situation. How long is too long...

The fact of the matter is, he is prem quality and he suits our play-style. I can't think of a replacement who would do his job better for his price-tag and wage bill. If you can I am all ears.

Unfortunately all we have is an unproven giant from Iceland who has come in for a big price and you guessed it, he is injured just like the other 50 percent of our first team. Don't get me wrong, I have big hopes for Sorloth, he looks fantastic from what I have seen so far. But he has something to prove. Benteke proved it last in many seasons prior.

Edited by jimboslice (05 Apr 2018 11.03am)

You are only as good as your last goal. He 'would' have been dropped by now by Palace if we had an alternative and HAS been dropped by Belgium. He has scored 2 goals all season. I would say he still has a lot to prove. Also I do not buy Martiniez' comments about Palace not delivering the service for Benteke. If that was the only issue why drop him, surely the Belgian national squad would have no such issues.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 05 Apr 18 11.48am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

You are only as good as your last goal. He 'would' have been dropped by now by Palace if we had an alternative and HAS been dropped by Belgium. He has scored 2 goals all season. I would say he still has a lot to prove. Also I do not buy Martiniez' comments about Palace not delivering the service for Benteke. If that was the only issue why drop him, surely the Belgian national squad would have no such issues.

The service thing is a red herring. As mentioned earlier, he has missed more "big chances" than anyone else in the division (yeah, I know, lies, damned lies, and statistics). If he'd scored even half of these good chances, he'd be on 11-13 goals, and we wouldn't be having this conversation.

His confidence is shot, but how you rectify that is anyone's guess. As you say, though, his impact aside from goal-scoring is decent, and we certainly don't have anyone better available

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 05 Apr 18 12.25pm

It should say EandalittlebitWPL anyway shouldn't it?

Agree, I long for Division one! Had a discussion lately with a non football person who struggled to understand how Premier was above Championship..... And League 2 is the 4rd tier, please explain!?

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

The EPL? You sound like a Johnny come lately tourist fan using this acronym. No offence intended but it just grinds my gears. It’s what the news anchors in non footballing countries call our beloved football league.

 

Username Flag Horsham 05 Apr 18 12.29pm

Originally posted by npn

The service thing is a red herring. As mentioned earlier, he has missed more "big chances" than anyone else in the division (yeah, I know, lies, damned lies, and statistics). If he'd scored even half of these good chances, he'd be on 11-13 goals, and we wouldn't be having this conversation.

His confidence is shot, but how you rectify that is anyone's guess. As you say, though, his impact aside from goal-scoring is decent, and we certainly don't have anyone better available

I think both things are true. He's missed chances he should have scored, but the service hasn't been as good as last year, or the same as last year.

I've mentioned it before, but if you look at the goals he did score last year, many of them were from us getting early balls into the box, allowing Benteke to get in between two defenders. Think of Boro or Everton away last year.

That's where his goals against Leicester and West Ham came from as well, and where he has come closest with chances, the header against Utd for example.

It's something we haven't done as much this season. Yes, he should still have scored more goals, but it doesn't mean that we aren't necessarily playing to what we know his strengths are.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 05 Apr 18 1.10pm

Originally posted by dp

You mean earlier in the season when he was injured?

The problem is that we don’t have cover, which is an absolute schoolboy error, so we are relying on Benteke. Sign a pacy striker or a player to sit just behind Benteke and see how we do then. I mean, most managers have a plan B to fall back on, if not a plan C - we don’t even have a plan A up front at the moment.

We are going to stay up, but we need to make sure we work hard to give our manager something to work with next year. We can’t keep relying on the mercurial talents of an xperienced manager to dig us out of the mess that some other manager has got us into every season.

If we do that, and Benteke still isn’t performing then I will slate him. Whilst we are telegraphing our tactics up front from the start of the season, I think the blame lays elsewhere.

Good point. Kill 2 birds with one stone, versatile striker who can take Tekkers place if need be or play with him if he can get some sort of form going. In relation to selling, be very surprised to find a buyer and get half of what we payed back. Admittedly we would save a shed load on wages. As mentioned getting a replacement won't be easy as where are the 10-15 goals a season strikers ?

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

chateauferret Flag 05 Apr 18 1.31pm

Originally posted by OhthisbloodyPC


For tis written in the stars. Willo hath delivered the word of truth

Dilly dilly.

 


============
The Ferret
============

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 05 Apr 18 1.36pm

Originally posted by Username

I think both things are true. He's missed chances he should have scored, but the service hasn't been as good as last year, or the same as last year.

I've mentioned it before, but if you look at the goals he did score last year, many of them were from us getting early balls into the box, allowing Benteke to get in between two defenders. Think of Boro or Everton away last year.

That's where his goals against Leicester and West Ham came from as well, and where he has come closest with chances, the header against Utd for example.

It's something we haven't done as much this season. Yes, he should still have scored more goals, but it doesn't mean that we aren't necessarily playing to what we know his strengths are.


We were getting balls in earlier last season because sam put townsend on the left and wilf on the right - their natural sides. Townsend rarely puts an early cross on because he always has to cut inside onto his left foot, something defenders are well aware of. Put him on the left and benteke would immediately get better service.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 05 Apr 18 1.41pm

Originally posted by spartakev2


We were getting balls in earlier last season because sam put townsend on the left and wilf on the right - their natural sides. Townsend rarely puts an early cross on because he always has to cut inside onto his left foot, something defenders are well aware of. Put him on the left and benteke would immediately get better service.

Very good point - Roy has got that aspect very wrong indeed

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 05 Apr 18 1.59pm

Oh well - sounds like he may now also be injured for Bournemouth so those who do not wish him to play will be able to see how we fare without him.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 05 Apr 18 2.22pm

Originally posted by jimboslice

Unfortunately all we have is an unproven giant from Iceland who has come in for a big price and you guessed it, he is injured just like the other 50 percent of our first team. Don't get me wrong, I have big hopes for Sorloth, he looks fantastic from what I have seen so far. But he has something to prove. Benteke proved it last in many seasons prior.


Iceland? Or is that a reference to where Sørloth shops?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

AERO Flag 05 Apr 18 2.30pm

Dire wolf, Can’t be much worse blessing in disguise trust me .

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 05 Apr 18 3.02pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

The EPL? You sound like a Johnny come lately tourist fan using this acronym. No offence intended but it just grinds my gears. It’s what the news anchors in non footballing countries call our beloved football league.

None taken ! yeah, i use that to wind up a couple of chelsea pals at work when they try and wind me up about relegation and winning nothing ever, i say im happy to just stay in the epl, and how city are the best team ever, a credit to the epl, they bite every time!

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 07 Apr 18 6.50pm

no Benteke today, and yet our attacking performance was pretty good.

please keep him on the bench Roy.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Page 64 of 166 < 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread