You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread
November 21 2026 12.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Holmesdale Fanatics thread


Page 64 of 122 < 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 18 10.28am

Originally posted by djp

For me if I was asked to move so the HF could take a position behind the goal I would do it as they are a tremendous asset to the Club at home and away games. All supporters are one may say but sometimes we all need to make small compromises for the sake of some cause or other. The HF, like the Crystals and the Eagle, when possible (!), are what fans like to see at Selhurst. Long may they all continue
If the Club had made vague commitments or hints to the HF then they should have followed it through.

When I read several people say shift blocks I admittedly didn’t like it initially but I’d do it and put up with it for a while.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 18 10.44am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

And if you don’t get your way when you want it, you walk? So tell me, Rudi, in what way is the HF currently acting with the “what you can do for your club not what the club can do for you” philosophy?

This is the very problem with this whole saga. It’s 6 of 1 and half a dozen of the other. And it’s become something thay directly undermines the original (good natured) intention.

That’s the issue I take, the failure in foresight. That’s on the HF. I’m not denying Parish has handled this poorly. But with all the facts presented in front of us, with a statement from either side. The HF have to take at least 50% responsibility for the current s*** show.

You can’t have it both ways.

I’d say the HF have done a hell of a lot for the good of the club. Often much more than the vast majority of the ground. Sure the club have assisted them but to just throw the accusation that the HF are not doing it for the good of the club is quite unfair.

If they didn’t move out of block B Parish and nobody would’ve taken any notice of them whatsoever, but now they have, and a solution is possible. You cannot tell me that starting over again would mean all pre-Prem season ticket holders wouldn’t get a decent seat, starting with the 23 year club, then at some point the pre and then post Dowie Prem ST holders.

Really it now boils down to stubbornness and the club don’t want to bother. And I am not really pro HF at all. The flags can do one at 3pm and some of their personal songs can go IMO as can 20 minutes of ‘We’re the boys from SE 25’ but the atmosphere must not go or we’ve made one hell of a feck up. And if anyone’s principles that can be addressed or absorbed with a workable solution play a part in this disappearing then we really will have lost something valuable and can have no complaints being just a nothing special small club you pass on the train.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (05 Sep 2018 10.45am)

 


COYP

youngpalacefan111 Flag 05 Sep 18 10.48am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I’d say the HF have done a hell of a lot for the good of the club. Often much more than the vast majority of the ground. Sure the club have assisted them but to just throw the accusation that the HF are not doing it for the good of the club is quite unfair.

If they didn’t move out of block B Parish and nobody would’ve taken any notice of them whatsoever, but now they have, and a solution is possible. You cannot tell me that starting over again would mean all pre-Prem season ticket holders wouldn’t get a decent seat, starting with the 23 year club, then at some point the pre and then post Dowie Prem ST holders.

Really it now boils down to stubbornness and the club don’t want to bother. And I am not really pro HF at all. The flags can do one at 3pm and some of their personal songs can go IMO as can 20 minutes of ‘We’re the boys from SE 25’ but the atmosphere must not go or we’ve made one hell of a feck up. And if anyone’s principles that can be addressed or absorbed with a workable solution play a part in this disappearing then we really will have lost something valuable and can have no complaints being just a nothing special small club you pass on the train.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (05 Sep 2018 10.45am)


when have we ever not been a nothing special small club? In my lifetime thats all we've been and I still love the club. 100 people jumping up and down singing don't make the club.

 

Aray Flag South London 05 Sep 18 10.48am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The point it’s making is Parish to work with them to bring them back rather than the p1ss poor blame game club statement. Whatever solution is found, returning to block b for 1 season if needs be which is probably the only solution considering their proposal, do fvck it something compared to absolutely nothing.

I sit with mates in the Main stand and believe me without the HF trying to get the oldies around me going is hard work. Parish needs to work with the HF. Whoever is in charge of comms needs shooting. Wasn't his business in marketing?!

 

Beastie Flag 05 Sep 18 10.55am

Originally posted by youngpalacefan111

when have we ever not been a nothing special small club? In my lifetime thats all we've been and I still love the club. 100 people jumping up and down singing don't make the club.

To outsiders, the atmosphere is/was something that set us apart.

 

youngpalacefan111 Flag 05 Sep 18 11.10am

Originally posted by Beastie

To outsiders, the atmosphere is/was something that set us apart.

And some outsiders thought the "ultras" were daft, with the drum beating and black hoodies. I personally liked what they did for our club but if they have decided to leave so be it I'm siding with the club.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 05 Sep 18 11.16am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I’m 23 and opposed to it. And that’s not opposed to the vision, I think the end goal that they want would be f***ing amazing at Selhurst. I’m opposed to the idea that they are able to implement it without consent from the people who’s seats they want.

The minute that happens, you are literally telling supporters of all generations that effectively, unless you bang a drum and sing loud, your support is less valued. That can’t be right. It just can’t be, however old you are.

They have to get consent, and non influenced/pressurised consent at that.

Indeed. On reading the HF statement, it was apparent to me that they used the word 'inclusive', when they clearly want an 'exclusive' area of the stadium.

The implementation of 'safe standing' areas should sort this 5hlt out.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Beastie Flag 05 Sep 18 11.16am

Originally posted by youngpalacefan111

And some outsiders thought the "ultras" were daft, with the drum beating and black hoodies. I personally liked what they did for our club but if they have decided to leave so be it I'm siding with the club.

Yeah, why put any thought into it.

Edited by Beastie (05 Sep 2018 11.18am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 18 11.20am

Originally posted by youngpalacefan111


when have we ever not been a nothing special small club? In my lifetime thats all we've been and I still love the club. 100 people jumping up and down singing don't make the club.

You can look forward to the family enclosure next to the tunnel being the noisiest part of the stadium then with 7 year old squeaky voices shouting out Eagles while you and everyone around you politely claps about 5 times a match over the rustling of sweet packets, because that’s what it used to be, before the late ‘80s, and was again when the Holmesdale stand went up, apocrine promotion campaigns, or the HF shaking it up. Sad.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 18 11.29am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Indeed. On reading the HF statement, it was apparent to me that they used the word 'inclusive', when they clearly want an 'exclusive' area of the stadium.

The implementation of 'safe standing' areas should sort this 5hlt out.

Unless some silent standers want to have their standing tickets slap bang in the centre.

Nobody so far can tell me that the E block and 23 year old club won’t have the pick of the lower tier with this proposal. You can even go as far as pretty much every season ticket holder up to Freedman and Holloway would be happy or at the worst content with this proposal. This is probably the saddest part of this aged stubbornness that’s part of the problem. Resistance to change and for some it’ll be just pure objection to the HF in general.

As it’s bern explained on the BBS, a part of the atmosphere struggling to return to all seater stadia is the same generation of people sat in the same seats, content with the status quo. Oh well. We always kill our selves off somehow and this is probably it. It’s just come in a completely different guise this time. It’s just harder to experience with the internet. Before you could just forget it apart from when reminded by rival fans and you think of what could’ve and should’ve been. A few people’s principles over the club will mean little when that time comes, yet could’ve been avoided by selecting a seat from about 5,000 or however many there are. Sad.

 


COYP

bicycle repair man 05 Sep 18 11.37am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

What if some in E block still can’t leave that precious seat?

Indeed that seat is precious.
But I am sure when the new stand is open there will be plenty more seats available in the Holmesdale.
Many lower Holmesdale dwellers,like myself, will be flocking to the modern new stand,with it's better facilities and more leg room.
Then ideally the lower Holmesdale will be made a legitimate standing area.

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 05 Sep 18 11.50am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

If our atmosphere remains dead then we could test this out if we’re in another one of our April and May relegation battles. That’ll settle it. If we get relegated the HF can have half of block E, the back of block E really won’t be able to see, the main stand mightvget put on hold and we can return to being that middle class club and 13,000 supporters that accepts disappointment but tuts at those noisy twerps who’ve now taken over the front and Parish only cares about cutting the club’s cloth.

In the HF position in block B the fact that they stood effected very few people. If they are moved to block E they effect a lot more.

This will have quite a few effects. The most serious will be the club will either have to close area or insist on people sitting. I think the licensing authority will act on the increased risk and this will effect planning for new stand at best more stringent conditions at worst it is refused. You can also forget about a safe standing trial being allowed.

I think everyone wants a solution to problem that is amicable however the HF by deciding not to renew their allocation have made this difficult if not virtually impossible. The best I can see is the HF getting back the allocation in Block B as some is unsold and the club may be able to satisfy the needs of the new season ticket holders elsewhere in ground.

In short the club have very little to gain by allocating block E to standing supporters but much to lose. Personally I would like to see a Safe Standing trial in Block B but this is probably 2 years away. This will be the HF chance to increase the vocal support

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 18 11.52am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

Indeed that seat is precious.
But I am sure when the new stand is open there will be plenty more seats available in the Holmesdale.
Many lower Holmesdale dwellers,like myself, will be flocking to the modern new stand,with it's better facilities and more leg room.
Then ideally the lower Holmesdale will be made a legitimate standing area.

Or the club could make an effort now, the E club and 23 year club move 2 blocks to the side next season and we keep and create something really precious. More precious than someone’s view that’ll be very good anyway with the pick 5,000+ seats.

 


COYP

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 05 Sep 18 11.59am

I don't really know why this lot are still floating about, you can't just ask people to give them your seats. End of.

If they really supported the club as much as they did, then they would still be waving the flags and singing for the whole 90 as the did before. It doesn't matter where you sit.

 

Leftfield Flag Camberley 05 Sep 18 12.51pm

I very rarely post as I prefer to lurk & read others opinions but this is one subject I feel passionately enough about to bother to join in. I'm 57 and have been going to SP since I was a young lad living in Beulah Hill, so I've seen 50 years worth of ups & downs at Palace.

We've always had a mixed fan base with the middle classes from the Surrey suburbs complemented by the rougher tougher London lads & it seems the arguments pretty much are defined by which tribe you come from

I'm actually normally thought of as middle class, but when it comes to football, I don't want to sit there clapping politely, I want to get involved in the whole matchday atmosphere (like it was in the 70's for example). This isn't Rugby or cricket, this is football & that should mean showing some bloody passion !!

To use a musical analogy we have one group wanting it to be like Glyndbourne & the others wanting it to be like going to a Prodigy Gig........and I'm a big Prodigy fan so you can see which appeals to me

To my mind there's plenty of places to sit quietly and appreciate a good bit of play with a smattering of applause but traditionally behind the goal on the Holmesdale terrace (or at the back of the Arfur) were the places to make some noise

I just cannot see why people would want Palace to go back to the bad old days before the HF got involved. We have recently got a reputation for being the loudest home support in the PL & that made me bloody proud of my club & my fellow fans

Back in the seventies when we were all packed onto the terraces it was relatively easy to get a chant going as we just moved to the most vocal area behind the goal, but now with seating it's so much harder. I mainly stand at the back of the Arfur with the other older lads and at least there we can make some noise, but in more open Holmesdale it's much much harder to get the songs going without a singing section being organised.

I can see why the HF want it to be allocated centrally as that would get people joining in from both sides & hopefully from the upper tier too.

Is it really that big a deal for some people to shuffle along a bit if they really just want to sit and "support" their club silently ?

Surely even those that don't want to sing and chant miss the passion that that engenders ?

God help us if we end up like most of the other London clubs with their sterile stadia & lack of noise

I for one am embarrassed at how bad the atmosphere has been this season & how others now see us as a set of supporters who without the HF are as quiet as the rest

It's not just the HF that want to inject some passion to supporting our beloved club, there's thousands of others like me I'm sure but until safe standing is introduced we've got to do something to make it easier for those of us who want to make plenty of noise & getting a central singing section has to be the answer

 

Username Flag Horsham 05 Sep 18 1.06pm

Originally posted by Leftfield

I very rarely post as I prefer to lurk & read others opinions but this is one subject I feel passionately enough about to bother to join in. I'm 57 and have been going to SP since I was a young lad living in Beulah Hill, so I've seen 50 years worth of ups & downs at Palace.

We've always had a mixed fan base with the middle classes from the Surrey suburbs complemented by the rougher tougher London lads & it seems the arguments pretty much are defined by which tribe you come from

I'm actually normally thought of as middle class, but when it comes to football, I don't want to sit there clapping politely, I want to get involved in the whole matchday atmosphere (like it was in the 70's for example). This isn't Rugby or cricket, this is football & that should mean showing some bloody passion !!

To use a musical analogy we have one group wanting it to be like Glyndbourne & the others wanting it to be like going to a Prodigy Gig........and I'm a big Prodigy fan so you can see which appeals to me

To my mind there's plenty of places to sit quietly and appreciate a good bit of play with a smattering of applause but traditionally behind the goal on the Holmesdale terrace (or at the back of the Arfur) were the places to make some noise

I just cannot see why people would want Palace to go back to the bad old days before the HF got involved. We have recently got a reputation for being the loudest home support in the PL & that made me bloody proud of my club & my fellow fans

Back in the seventies when we were all packed onto the terraces it was relatively easy to get a chant going as we just moved to the most vocal area behind the goal, but now with seating it's so much harder. I mainly stand at the back of the Arfur with the other older lads and at least there we can make some noise, but in more open Holmesdale it's much much harder to get the songs going without a singing section being organised.

I can see why the HF want it to be allocated centrally as that would get people joining in from both sides & hopefully from the upper tier too.

Is it really that big a deal for some people to shuffle along a bit if they really just want to sit and "support" their club silently ?

Surely even those that don't want to sing and chant miss the passion that that engenders ?

God help us if we end up like most of the other London clubs with their sterile stadia & lack of noise

I for one am embarrassed at how bad the atmosphere has been this season & how others now see us as a set of supporters who without the HF are as quiet as the rest

It's not just the HF that want to inject some passion to supporting our beloved club, there's thousands of others like me I'm sure but until safe standing is introduced we've got to do something to make it easier for those of us who want to make plenty of noise & getting a central singing section has to be the answer

I haven't seen a single person suggest this.

Plenty have said they would, ultimately, support the singing section but that it should (as the club suggested) be done when the new stand is built as it will be MUCH easier.

There have also been plenty of comments about the HF's decision to leave as an overreaction, but that is completely separate to the issue of a standing section in general.

It's also nowhere near as simple as a few people 'shuffling along a little bit.'

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 05 Sep 18 1.12pm

and i first went to Palace in the 1980's, as a schoolboy. I remember how scary it was when Palace scored in the Holmesdale, as the crowd surge swept you off your feet like a tsunami, and carried you over the advertising hoardings onto the playing area.

the fact is we have a mixed bag of supporters, and football is slightly different to the days of the 70's and 80's.

Safe standing is obviously not far off, according to Spurs. can't we all just take a step back and sort things properly for when SS is introduced ? It really would be a fck of a lot easier

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Bangell Flag Oxford 05 Sep 18 1.13pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

and i first went to Palace in the 1980's, as a schoolboy. I remember how scary it was when Palace scored in the Holmesdale, as the crowd surge swept you off your feet like a tsunami, and carried you over the advertising hoardings onto the playing area.

the fact is we have a mixed bag of supporters, and football is slightly different to the days of the 70's and 80's.

Safe standing is obviously not far off, according to Spurs. can't we all just take a step back and sort things properly for when SS is introduced ? It really would be a fck of a lot easier

This sounds like a bad excuse by a pitch invader

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 18 1.24pm

Originally posted by Username

I haven't seen a single person suggest this.

Plenty have said they would, ultimately, support the singing section but that it should (as the club suggested) be done when the new stand is built as it will be MUCH easier.

There have also been plenty of comments about the HF's decision to leave as an overreaction, but that is completely separate to the issue of a standing section in general.

It's also nowhere near as simple as a few people 'shuffling along a little bit.'

Easier when the new stand is done, yes. When’s that? 5 years?

It is possible, next season, it’s just hard work.

Those long term season ticket holders will be able to just shuffle along or choose a great view because they’ll have 95% of the lower tier to choose from.

 


COYP

Isley46 Flag Sanderstead 05 Sep 18 1.28pm

Originally posted by Leftfield


I can see why the HF want it to be allocated centrally as that would get people joining in from both sides & hopefully from the upper tier too.

Have followed this thread with great interest but part of me still thinks that moving to the centre of the Holmesdale still has something to do with credibility and exposure - Can't truly be seen as an 'ultra' supporters group if you are positioned out of the way by the corner flag....especially by other clubs 'ultra' factions who are mostly positioned behind the goal in a centre stage positions.

 

Page 64 of 122 < 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread