You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 4.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 67 of 91 < 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 >
Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 03 Feb 20 1.38am

Originally posted by PatrickA


I’m not totally anti-Hodgson.
In the past when fixtures didn’t clash with Palace I occasionally watched Hodgson’s Fulham.
He did a fine job there and they were quite entertaining to watch.
I also think he did a very good job in his first year at Palace.
This season I don’t admire his work, certainly from an attacking standpoint.
With the same squad as Hodgson has here I doubt say Rodgers or even Wilder would set up each game so defensively.
We have a good squad, albeit unbalanced in some respects.
I’m not saying he’s a bad manager but I do cringe when I hear him acclaimed as our greatest manager merely through keeping us up.
Pulls , for example,had a far inferior squad to work with.
Coppell built a team from nothing and took us from the Championship to third in the equivalent of the Premier League and the Cup Final.
People can feel free to disagree but I’m just trying to introduce some balance.

We appear this way because we fail to make the most of the opportunities we create, Benteke created for himself the perfect opportunity to score on 48' and mis*** the ball harmlessly into Henderson arms, should've at least forced a corner and a bit of excitement back in his direction from the crowd ..because this is what he desperately needs.

Not Hodgsons fault the faults of our attackers.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 03 Feb 20 1.41am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

knowing us...it will be on saturday against everton.

I reckon so.

 

Wilbraham413 Flag 03 Feb 20 4.44am

The bottom line is we are one of the worst teams in the league at home. We almost never win at home, almost never score at home.

Given that abject futility for two years now, you would expect a rational manager to try something, anything, different.

Say Roy went crazy, and started Riedewald, Meyer, Kouyate, Pierrick, in place of Luka, Benteke, McCarthy, McArthur.

What would the worst possible outcome have been? We would lose the match to Sheffield? Well we lost anyway, never came close to scoring a goal, and we lose every home match anyway. So WTF is the difference?

I'm sick to death of watching the same failure over and over. That is 100% on Roy.

If he ever tried different lineups or tactics, and nothing worked, then ok, you can blame SP and Freedman for the roster. Failing with the same thing over and over makes me question what value Roy is bringing to us at the moment.

Any of us can predict the lineups at this point, and we all know our only "strategy": Play for 0-0 the entire game, and hope for a lucky goal, usually from Zaha doing it all alone. The team doesn't seem to play hard, doesn't do well at set pieces. So what exactly are we paying Roy for?

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 03 Feb 20 5.34am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

The bottom line is we are one of the worst teams in the league at home. We almost never win at home, almost never score at home.

Given that abject futility for two years now, you would expect a rational manager to try something, anything, different.

Say Roy went crazy, and started Riedewald, Meyer, Kouyate, Pierrick, in place of Luka, Benteke, McCarthy, McArthur.

What would the worst possible outcome have been? We would lose the match to Sheffield? Well we lost anyway, never came close to scoring a goal, and we lose every home match anyway. So WTF is the difference?

I'm sick to death of watching the same failure over and over. That is 100% on Roy.

If he ever tried different lineups or tactics, and nothing worked, then ok, you can blame SP and Freedman for the roster. Failing with the same thing over and over makes me question what value Roy is bringing to us at the moment.

Any of us can predict the lineups at this point, and we all know our only "strategy": Play for 0-0 the entire game, and hope for a lucky goal, usually from Zaha doing it all alone. The team doesn't seem to play hard, doesn't do well at set pieces. So what exactly are we paying Roy for?

seconded. if you have any doubt of roy's limitations as a good modern manager, just look at how he has handled the matches were we have ended up with a one man advantage when the scoreline was 0-0. what did genius roy tweak? yep, you guessed it, NUFFING! in fact we ended up being more under pressure from the man down team as they made tweaks to compensate for their numerical disadvantage!

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 03 Feb 20 6.36am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

The bottom line is we are one of the worst teams in the league at home. We almost never win at home, almost never score at home.

Given that abject futility for two years now, you would expect a rational manager to try something, anything, different.

Say Roy went crazy, and started Riedewald, Meyer, Kouyate, Pierrick, in place of Luka, Benteke, McCarthy, McArthur.

What would the worst possible outcome have been? We would lose the match to Sheffield? Well we lost anyway, never came close to scoring a goal, and we lose every home match anyway. So WTF is the difference?

I'm sick to death of watching the same failure over and over. That is 100% on Roy.

If he ever tried different lineups or tactics, and nothing worked, then ok, you can blame SP and Freedman for the roster. Failing with the same thing over and over makes me question what value Roy is bringing to us at the moment.

Any of us can predict the lineups at this point, and we all know our only "strategy": Play for 0-0 the entire game, and hope for a lucky goal, usually from Zaha doing it all alone. The team doesn't seem to play hard, doesn't do well at set pieces. So what exactly are we paying Roy for?


me too, second that. It is easy to be an armchair manager, but seeing the same negative line up game after game - u know what u get even before kick-off.
Would also like to see the likes of Riedewald, Meyer and that young kid in starting line.
What do we have to lose?

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 03 Feb 20 7.48am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

The bottom line is we are one of the worst teams in the league at home. We almost never win at home, almost never score at home.

Given that abject futility for two years now, you would expect a rational manager to try something, anything, different.

Say Roy went crazy, and started Riedewald, Meyer, Kouyate, Pierrick, in place of Luka, Benteke, McCarthy, McArthur.

What would the worst possible outcome have been? We would lose the match to Sheffield? Well we lost anyway, never came close to scoring a goal, and we lose every home match anyway. So WTF is the difference?

I'm sick to death of watching the same failure over and over. That is 100% on Roy.

If he ever tried different lineups or tactics, and nothing worked, then ok, you can blame SP and Freedman for the roster. Failing with the same thing over and over makes me question what value Roy is bringing to us at the moment.

Any of us can predict the lineups at this point, and we all know our only "strategy": Play for 0-0 the entire game, and hope for a lucky goal, usually from Zaha doing it all alone. The team doesn't seem to play hard, doesn't do well at set pieces. So what exactly are we paying Roy for?

Agree 100%. This is the cold fact of the matter, yet the RH apologists still find excuses for him. Good post!

 

jeeagles Flag 03 Feb 20 8.34am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

No. Sahko was on loan under Big Sam and signed before Hodgson arrived.

That aside, he still inherited £25m Sakho and £10m Reidewald just before he arrived. Even though he's refused to play Reidewald

He also inherited the £45m worth of players BFS signed in the form of PVA, Schlupp and Luca.

We've not really made any sales under Roy either, Pardew sold Bolasie, Gayle, Jedi, and FFS. That probably came to £50m combined. Admittedly selling Murrey was a mistake, but at the time it was selling an aging player who hadn't played in 2 years for £6m. Most people on here would probably sell Wickham or Benteke for the same.

Roy's probably had the best squad available to any palace manager since the premiership began.

 

HerneBayPalace Flag Herne Bay 03 Feb 20 8.41am

Homes games including last season up until now :

Games Played = 32
Goals Scored = 29
Goals Conceded = 36
Wins = 9
Draws = 9
Loses = 14

It always makes me laugh on the radio during the week ahead of the fixtures "X are away to Palace, Selhurst is always a tough place to go" - it is honestly the easiest ffs.

I honestly dread homes games, as we are just fairly useless and lack any plan B. We all know Meyer for McArthur is happening after 65 mins these days and that's about it.

We can pick the team for next week now, as Roy has no imagination or trust in other players.

Saturday was always the biggest away banker of the weekend on anyone's accumulator.

9 wins in 32 at home...

Just feels like we are sleepwalking towards relegation either this season or next.

I feel for Roy at times, but he also lacks the ability to recognise when changes are needed. Perhaps we could give the Townsend and Zaha front two another whirl to freshen it up, giving us Ayew and Benteke off the bench, just anything would do that is different !

We also can't play Ayew and Benteke if we only have two stikers, as we have nothing off the bench to change it.

If we miss the one or two chances we create per game, then we lose as other teams take theirs. It is turning out to be as simple as that.

I just wish we were proactive rather than reactive.

 

jeeagles Flag 03 Feb 20 8.46am

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

seconded. if you have any doubt of roy's limitations as a good modern manager, just look at how he has handled the matches were we have ended up with a one man advantage when the scoreline was 0-0. what did genius roy tweak? yep, you guessed it, NUFFING! in fact we ended up being more under pressure from the man down team as they made tweaks to compensate for their numerical disadvantage!

Roy's main aim seems to be to avoid embarrassment. He's like the teflon coated slopey shouldered project manager every office has. Spends his time not taking risks or sticking his head above the parapet and dodging any kind of responsibility. He can blame his failures on lack of transfers or injuries, when in reality he has one of our best squads and refuses to use some of the players we have signed for him.

Look at the difference between him and Southgate at England. In 2014 we limped out in the first round with Roy saying it was a hard group simply because Italy had a big reputation and Uruguay had a decent striker. Then constantly struggled against small opposition because he refused to attack them.

Southgate was constantly looking for any opportunities to make the england team and himself better. Against weaker teams like Paraguay he barely played a defence. Southgate isn't a great manager either but tries to evolve, his biggest mistake was probably not changing a winning team. Roy refuses to change a losing formula.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 03 Feb 20 8.50am

Originally posted by jeeagles

That aside, he still inherited £25m Sakho and £10m Reidewald just before he arrived. Even though he's refused to play Reidewald

He also inherited the £45m worth of players BFS signed in the form of PVA, Schlupp and Luca.

We've not really made any sales under Roy either, Pardew sold Bolasie, Gayle, Jedi, and FFS. That probably came to £50m combined. Admittedly selling Murrey was a mistake, but at the time it was selling an aging player who hadn't played in 2 years for £6m. Most people on here would probably sell Wickham or Benteke for the same.

Roy's probably had the best squad available to any palace manager since the premiership began.

Yes, these were my thoughts also. RH inherited some decent players, many of international standing. Why we play in the negative manner we do with the accompanying lack of goal threat only he can answer.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (03 Feb 2020 8.58am)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 03 Feb 20 8.54am

Originally posted by HerneBayPalace

It always makes me laugh on the radio during the week ahead of the fixtures "X are away to Palace, Selhurst is always a tough place to go"

They are probably referring to the traffic and parking

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 03 Feb 20 9.59am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Agree 100%. This is the cold fact of the matter, yet the RH apologists still find excuses for him. Good post!

The RH '' apologists '' need do nothing other than refer his critics to the facts - league positions attained , points won and the budget constraints he has to work with.

This thread has run it's course because it's the same old debate going around and around....I'm going to try and resist posting in it again !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

PatrickA Flag London 03 Feb 20 10.08am

Agreed.
Neither pro or anti Hodgson will ever be able convince the other of the merits of the other’s argument so it’s all pretty pointless to prolong the debate.
As an aside, there is a very good analysis by Dominic Fifield of the difficulties the whole club face in The Athletic this morning.
Can’t post a link but worth accessing if you get a chance.

 

cpj Flag Kent 03 Feb 20 10.35am

Jus been reading Roy's bizarre comments on why he let CW go on loan. Apparently now we have 3 centre forwards in Tosun (injured), Ayew and Benteke, CW would have struggled to get any game time with us. This depsite him scoring at Norwich and effectively forcing the equalizer at Man City. So he starts with Benteke who really cannot score a goal to save his life and has no forward on the bench.

Also his comments about Bowen - we were only ever interested in a loan from Hull with an option to buy later. What is going on at the club? Where has all the money gone that we can't buy anybody in the transfer window?

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 03 Feb 20 11.06am

My thoughts are as such:

We are 11th in the table and are 6 points clear of relegation. If you were offered that at the start of the season I think most would have taken it.

We clearly have financial restrictions and have a limited budget for squad investment. Why that is I don't know but that cannot be blamed on Roy.

We have had a crippling injury list for the last 2 months and we have been limping through that period and our form has deteriorated as a result.

Sheffield utd did to us what we have done to many others on the road. Sat back in the first half and showed a bit more ambition in the second half and knicked it. They are having a decent season and are no mugs.

Our form is a concern, but hopefully we can still be in this division next season. We will then have a summer transfer window to overhaul the squad (probably on the back of Zaha leaving). If we don't then I think we all know next season will be a battle to stay up once again.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 03 Feb 20 11.10am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

My thoughts are as such:

We are 11th in the table and are 6 points clear of relegation. If you were offered that at the start of the season I think most would have taken it.

We clearly have financial restrictions and have a limited budget for squad investment. Why that is I don't know but that cannot be blamed on Roy.

We have had a crippling injury list for the last 2 months and we have been limping through that period and our form has deteriorated as a result.

Sheffield utd did to us what we have done to many others on the road. Sat back in the first half and showed a bit more ambition in the second half and knicked it. They are having a decent season and are no mugs.

Our form is a concern, but hopefully we can still be in this division next season. We will then have a summer transfer window to overhaul the squad (probably on the back of Zaha leaving). If we don't then I think we all know next season will be a battle to stay up once again.

14th

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 03 Feb 20 11.30am

We're doing alright this season and should have enough about us to avoid getting dragged into a relegation scrap. The current structure is not sustainable though.

We've too many big earners on the books. I think we should try to offload Zaha (hopefully get £45m for him), Sakho and Benteke. Sakho and Big Ben simply don't justify their high salaries. Benteke has had enough chances and Sakho is behind Tompkins and Cahill and is too injury prone/much of a time bomb. Kelly and Dann and good back up.

The sale of these three will free up a lot of money for us to sign 4/5 younger players. Easier said than done of course.

The younger players like Meyer and Reidewald are the future so they need more game time to improve.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 03 Feb 20 11.44am

Originally posted by cpj

Jus been reading Roy's bizarre comments on why he let CW go on loan. Apparently now we have 3 centre forwards in Tosun (injured), Ayew and Benteke, CW would have struggled to get any game time with us. This depsite him scoring at Norwich and effectively forcing the equalizer at Man City. So he starts with Benteke who really cannot score a goal to save his life and has no forward on the bench.

Also his comments about Bowen - we were only ever interested in a loan from Hull with an option to buy later. What is going on at the club? Where has all the money gone that we can't buy anybody in the transfer window?

Couldn't agree more, and add that we don't even have a full 25 man squad - clearly a gap in thinking at the top.

 

Bud Flag 03 Feb 20 11.54am

I agree with some of your points but would question playing younger players please tell me when Roy has played a younger player from choice and not because he got no one else to play. Like everything in this world we have a sale by date sorry to say this Roy has got to that day.

Originally posted by Goal Machine

We're doing alright this season and should have enough about us to avoid getting dragged into a relegation scrap. The current structure is not sustainable though.

We've too many big earners on the books. I think we should try to offload Zaha (hopefully get £45m for him), Sakho and Benteke. Sakho and Big Ben simply don't justify their high salaries. Benteke has had enough chances and Sakho is behind Tompkins and Cahill and is too injury prone/much of a time bomb. Kelly and Dann and good back up.

The sale of these three will free up a lot of money for us to sign 4/5 younger players. Easier said than done of course.

The younger players like Meyer and Reidewald are the future so they need more game time to improve.

 

jeeagles Flag 03 Feb 20 12.00pm

Originally posted by HerneBayPalace

Homes games including last season up until now :

Games Played = 32
Goals Scored = 29
Goals Conceded = 36
Wins = 9
Draws = 9
Loses = 14

It always makes me laugh on the radio during the week ahead of the fixtures "X are away to Palace, Selhurst is always a tough place to go" - it is honestly the easiest ffs.

I honestly dread homes games, as we are just fairly useless and lack any plan B. We all know Meyer for McArthur is happening after 65 mins these days and that's about it.

We can pick the team for next week now, as Roy has no imagination or trust in other players.

Saturday was always the biggest away banker of the weekend on anyone's accumulator.

9 wins in 32 at home...

Just feels like we are sleepwalking towards relegation either this season or next.

I feel for Roy at times, but he also lacks the ability to recognise when changes are needed. Perhaps we could give the Townsend and Zaha front two another whirl to freshen it up, giving us Ayew and Benteke off the bench, just anything would do that is different !

We also can't play Ayew and Benteke if we only have two stikers, as we have nothing off the bench to change it.

If we miss the one or two chances we create per game, then we lose as other teams take theirs. It is turning out to be as simple as that.

I just wish we were proactive rather than reactive.

For season ticket holders that working out at about £100 a win and £30 a goal. Must be the worst value for money in the league

 

Page 67 of 91 < 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread