This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Common ownership of energy water and rail is an absolute must. Why do the tories see privatisations, in the face of all their failures, as their preference? Privatisation is the God that failed. Rotten services, sky-high prices, zero investment, absent foreign owners, naked profiteering, highest taxes and borrowing since WW2 to keep them in clover. The taxpayer ultimately picks up the tab for all their failures, not them. The problem is that nationalised industries are usually even worse.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Common ownership of energy water and rail is an absolute must. Why do the tories see privatisations, in the face of all their failures, as their preference? Privatisation is the God that failed. Rotten services, sky-high prices, zero investment, absent foreign owners, naked profiteering, highest taxes and borrowing since WW2 to keep them in clover. The taxpayer ultimately picks up the tab for all their failures, not them. So who pays if a nationalised service fails ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Why do the tories see privatisations, in the face of all their failures, as their preference? Privatisation is the God that failed. Rotten services, sky-high prices, zero investment, absent foreign owners, naked profiteering, highest taxes and borrowing since WW2 to keep them in clover. The taxpayer ultimately picks up the tab for all their failures, not them. Whilst the utilities may have been privatised under the Tories it was the traditional Labour supporters who snaffled the shares in the offerings then subsequently sold out when offered large profits
|
|
| footythoughts |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
The problem is that nationalised industries are usually even worse. The nationalised rail network runs like clockwork in many European countries and is actually affortable. In this country we tend to privatise gains and socialise loses. In fact that almost always happens.
|
|
| footythoughts |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Whilst the utilities may have been privatised under the Tories it was the traditional Labour supporters who snaffled the shares in the offerings then subsequently sold out when offered large profits I remember when the Post office was privatised. Big investors got first dogs and the man on the street (regardless of politics) had a limit of a few K they could vuy. That's more in line with what actually happens during privatisation.
|
|
|
Originally posted by footythoughts
The nationalised rail network runs like clockwork in many European countries and is actually affortable. In this country we tend to privatise gains and socialise loses. In fact that almost always happens. I'm old enough to remember when the railways here were nationalised and they ran more like a sun-dial than clockwork.
|
|
| footythoughts |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
I'm old enough to remember when the railways here were nationalised and they ran more like a sun-dial than clockwork. Certainly the railway here has struggled at times. The beeching cuts, unpopular the the time, would be a good example of that. My point is that many countries do get nationalisation right and at it's most effective it's often more effective as can be seen in other countries. The problem I suppose often may be that governments that wish to privatise have the tools to let nationalised industries fail, and it's a big of a cash windfall in the moment. A significant failing of our politics is that no government thinks beyond four years, or you can even argue beyond election years.
|
|
|
Originally posted by footythoughts
A significant failing of our politics is that no government thinks beyond four years, or you can even argue beyond election years.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by footythoughts
Certainly the railway here has struggled at times. The beeching cuts, unpopular the the time, would be a good example of that. My point is that many countries do get nationalisation right and at it's most effective it's often more effective as can be seen in other countries. The problem I suppose often may be that governments that wish to privatise have the tools to let nationalised industries fail, and it's a big of a cash windfall in the moment. A significant failing of our politics is that no government thinks beyond four years, or you can even argue beyond election years. Now 5k (five thousand pounds) for a season ticket to travel 35 miles, and a monthly visa £875, never thought I'd pine for British Rail. Privatisation has turned out to be a profiteering racket, the whole point of it, that it would be more efficient, more investment and less costly, is all b****x. A further raft of across the board increases today will hit hard-pressed Brits, I don't know how we tolerate, or can afford them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Now 5k (five thousand pounds) for a season ticket to travel 35 miles, and a monthly visa £875, never thought I'd pine for British Rail. Privatisation has turned out to be a profiteering racket, the whole point of it, that it would be more efficient, more investment and less costly, is all b****x. A further raft of across the board increases today will hit hard-pressed Brits, I don't know how we tolerate, or can afford them. Can't remember the last time I used a train.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Now 5k (five thousand pounds) for a season ticket to travel 35 miles, and a monthly visa £875, never thought I'd pine for British Rail. Privatisation has turned out to be a profiteering racket, the whole point of it, that it would be more efficient, more investment and less costly, is all b****x. A further raft of across the board increases today will hit hard-pressed Brits, I don't know how we tolerate, or can afford them. If we are destroying the planet with uk emissions then all public transport should be free shouldn’t it. Pay the companies costs plus 10% then they can pay the dividends and the service will be perfect. I’m applying for PM
|
|
| footythoughts |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Very true, it's all strung together soundbites and soon forgotten promises.
|
|
| footythoughts |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Can't remember the last time I used a train. It if was priced along the lines of many of our european neigbours it would be something people just did rather than needed to think about or get a loan out for Edited by footythoughts (01 Apr 2023 4.20pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
We have never really had the 'left', we are still semi-feudal. Many of our institutions – monarchy, landed aristocracy, House of Lords, deeply ingrained class system, Oxbridge, private schools – rule us and are now obsolete elsewhere. These are indicators of a forelock-pulling worldview that persists, certainly in my generation. The French had a genuine revolution, we never did, it explains the difference they naturally rebel against authority, the British not so, and cannot change their system in elections. And you know what happens with revolutions. You end up back where you started. There cannot be and never will be a system where everybody is equal. Get over it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Now 5k (five thousand pounds) for a season ticket to travel 35 miles, and a monthly visa £875, never thought I'd pine for British Rail. Privatisation has turned out to be a profiteering racket, the whole point of it, that it would be more efficient, more investment and less costly, is all b****x. A further raft of across the board increases today will hit hard-pressed Brits, I don't know how we tolerate, or can afford them.
Living in France, we often take the train to CDG airport......90 minutes journey, first class tickets, bar and snack service and ALWAYS on time (if it says 9.20 its ALWAYS at 9.20, not within 15 minutes like English trains) so taking the train is a no brainer, especially as it costs us 12 quid each, if only UK trains were like that.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
We have never really had the 'left', we are still semi-feudal. Many of our institutions – monarchy, landed aristocracy, House of Lords, deeply ingrained class system, Oxbridge, private schools – rule us and are now obsolete elsewhere. These are indicators of a forelock-pulling worldview that persists, certainly in my generation. The French had a genuine revolution, we never did, it explains the difference they naturally rebel against authority, the British not so, and cannot change their system in elections. As usual, we were ahead of our time, and had our Revolution in the 1640s - complete with beheading the Monarch. The result was of course a dictator who had more power than the deposed - a familiar pattern. Edited by georgenorman (02 Apr 2023 6.45pm)
|
|
|
They will stop at nothing. I’m beginning to wonder how they can win in 2024 as they score so many own goals it’s laughable
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.